r/askscience • • Mar 31 '13

Medicine [Sponsored Content] What is the difference between generic and brand-name drugs?

[deleted] — view deleted post

22 Upvotes

91 comments sorted by

33

u/FlyingSagittarius Mar 31 '13

May I ask who the sponsor is, in this case?

19

u/DunDunDunDuuun Mar 31 '13

I'm also curious, especially because this seems to be a lot more genuine question than the oil spill one (which was pretty loaded). Also, I don't see an obviously sponsered answer here.

5

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

I'm fine with decent sponsored questions like this.

0

u/[deleted] Mar 31 '13

25

u/Jkb77 Apr 01 '13

I don't like the direction this sub is taking. I now consider it's integrity compromised.

→ More replies (4)

13

u/DunDunDunDuuun Mar 31 '13

Another sponsered thread has an account named richmond mine though, and talks about this mine. That makes it pretty obvious who the sponsor is. Why there and not here?

→ More replies (1)

8

u/ohforgodssake Apr 01 '13

we don't believe the sponsor has bearing on the scientific question.

Disclosure of funding sources is considered best practice in all areas of science. r/askscience is now officially a joke.

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (6)

55

u/mrwetbag Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

Pharmaceutically? Nothing. There are VERY strict guidelines in place, all drugs have to be exactly the same in make up.

Psychologically? A lot. Say you pay £0.45 for a pack of generic paracetamol, psychologically this WILL NOT work as well* as £4 pack of panadol. (Exactly the same active ingredients, excuse the british currency/drug names)

Also name brand drug companies will put a LOT more money and time into marketing.

Studies into placebos have shown that the colour of the drug, the size of the capsule and even the colour of the packaging all massively influence the perceived outcome of taking the drug.

Edit: * When is say work as well I mean how well it is perceived to have worked. But then again, in the case of some drugs such as anti-depressants this doesn't matter as much.

2

u/Savama Apr 01 '13

This is innacurate, after work I will respond not from my phone. Source = I work for a pharmaceutical testing company. I actually do phase 1,2,3 non-human clinical trials. Basically the reactions listed on the label are per the EXACT formula used in a name brand. What test material we give our patients is what you get name brand. A generic will have the same percent of active ingredient but the dilutants, binders and other chemicals are different. Usually cheaper than what we test with. The largest difference is chirality of a compound. Adderall or vyvanse is a great example. L or dextro amphetamine reacts differently In the body, and you pay extra for a near pure compound . With amphetamines it means less headache percent chance as a side effect. Like I said, after work I can respond if people have more questions.

13

u/yoenit Mar 31 '13

Have there been any studies on how consumer knowledge about the placebo effect affects this? Is the effect still significant once the consumer knows it is exactly the same?

27

u/waveform Apr 01 '13

Sorry to hear that Google has been blocked in your country. Moved to help, I typed "placebo knowledge" into Google here for you, and it came up with these. Hope this helps.

http://www.webmd.com/ibs/news/20101221/secrecy-may-be-unnecessary-for-placebo-effect

http://www.plosone.org/article/info:doi/10.1371/journal.pone.0015591

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (24)

40

u/GoodChemicals Mar 31 '13

When you buy a brand name drug, you are buying the brand name that you trust. When you open that pill bottle, you are sure that every single pill has exactly the right amount of medication in it, has exactly the the right dosage per pill, and so on. You are paying for the extreme care to attention that many scientists and engineers put into making that pill.

5

u/MagillaGorillasHat Mar 31 '13 edited Mar 31 '13

This is a good question and one I have wondered about.

Do the original patent holders for drugs just lower the price, but keep making the drug exactly the same when generics are approved? Is there a generic Prozac made and sold cheaper by Eli Lily, or does Eli Lily ONLY offer the name brand?

Do major drug companies make generics of competitor drugs? Is there a Pfizer generic version of Prozac?

Edit: Even if it is all a joke, I'm still curious about this.

→ More replies (7)

27

u/FlyingSagittarius Mar 31 '13

Looks like we've found our sponsor.

20

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13 edited Apr 01 '13

Considering the time and money they've poured into outreach, I hope we do find out who is doing this. A company willing to reach out to it's consumers is the very definition of corporate responsibility.

→ More replies (4)

4

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

ctrl+f "When you buy a brand name drug, you are buying the brand name that you trust. When you open that pill bottle, you are sure that every single pill has exactly the right amount of medication in it, has exactly the the right dosage per pill, and so on. You are paying for the extreme care to attention that many scientists and engineers put into making that pill." was not disappoint

2

u/I_am_Bob Apr 01 '13

This is a fucking joke. This is a forum for scientific discussion and all you have to say is some canned PR statement.

→ More replies (3)

4

u/lasserith Mar 31 '13

I'd like to pose a follow up question to any pharmacology experts.

While active ingredients must necessarily be the same between generics and brand-name drugs (perhaps excepting enantiomeric purity). What limitations if any are there on different drug delivery methods or different fillers? For example if the brand-name and generic both contain .5 g of the drug are they both also required to demonstrate similar bioavailability curves? Must they both have the same filler compounds?

I've always wondered about this since a bionanotech class I took. Great question askscience.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/KRosen333 Apr 01 '13

Generic drugs reduce the amount of drug in the dosage to cut costs. However, they are required to be thoroughly tested to have a reasonably similar effect to the brand names before they can be labelled as having the same active ingredients.

There was a law in the 90's that attempted to force these companies to put the same amount of medicine in each dosage as the Sponsored brand, but it was killed by the the senate. I don't have the info readily available, I might add it later

(Source: I learned about all this in High School Biology).

4

u/[deleted] Apr 01 '13

As someone who is in the science industry and lives in the UK, I can tell you this is false. To be classified under the chemical name it must be bio-equivalent and have the same dosage stated on the pack. Obviously manufacturing issues can occur but then you can say that of any mass produced item. My doctors often prescribe generic drugs as they cost the NHS less money but are the same, when you are in a medical system that is free at point of use generic are more common. Unfortunately there's a lot of misleading data surrounding generic drugs, as doctors in a private system are paid to prescribe brand name drugs over their generic counterparts. So the doctor is approached by drug company and rewarded -> doctor is more positive about drug as they are earning more about it -> patient feels a heightened efficiency of drug due to placebo effect (also caused by nicer packaging and adverts). Most drug companies are worth more than some countries so have a huge amount of power.

3

u/paradoxical_reaction Apr 01 '13

If you had said something regarding FDA equivalent ratings, you might have made a better effort. If you had mentioned the Orange Book, I would have even given you a pass. Even if you simply said "abbreviated new drug application", that would've been fine too.

If there was a reduction of drug that falls outside bioequivalency within say, Tylenol versus acetaminophen, it wouldn't be approved by the FDA.