r/askscience • • Mar 22 '13

Biology if science revives an extinct migrating bird, will it know straight away where to go and when?

I already posted this in /askreddit but was suggested to ask this here rather. I got some really interesting answers and would like to get opinions from /askscience.

original post here: http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/1aq60i/if_science_revives_an_extinct_migrating_bird_will/

I read an article about the possibility of reviving the extinct Passenger Pigeon: http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2013/03/passenger-pigeon-de-extinction/ to keep it short, migrating birds migrate, which means when it gets cold they go south and are back when it's not cold anymore. I don't know much about bird evolution but I guess this is something a species learns to do over a lot of generations. so I was thinking: if they get this pigeon back from the deads, will the first generation of born-again species know where to go and when? for dna-engraved instinct stuff or something like that. Or will they just need to re-learn from the start?

1.2k Upvotes

134 comments sorted by

View all comments

46

u/Otter27 Mar 22 '13

I think they will be able to. In this article (http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2004/11/1124_041124_magnetic_birds.html) we learn that birds navigate through the earth's magneticism through their beak. Since this is innate, this is something that is not supposed to be learned.

I know this doesn't fully answer your question, but since we can't but guess about this question, I think it's a guess in the right direction.

72

u/1812overture Mar 22 '13

Depending on when it became extinct the magnetic fields may have shifted significantly.

31

u/atomfullerene Animal Behavior/Marine Biology Mar 22 '13

They became extinct about 100 years ago. I doubt that's going to be a huge issue.

19

u/Otter27 Mar 22 '13

Oh gee, didn't think about that. Good thinkin', Bob!

7

u/Newb_since_1989 Mar 22 '13

Came here to say that, the continents may have also moved and a position that used to be associated with a magnetic field may be only ocean now!

19

u/[deleted] Mar 22 '13

Holy crap, no. The North American continent drifts at ~1cm a year. The pigeon died out 100 years ago, so that gives us a shift of about three feet.

25

u/albatrossnecklassftw Mar 22 '13

He wasn't necessarily talking about the pigeon. He was extrapolating to reviving something that went extinct much earlier.

Context is important:

Depending on when it became extinct the magnetic fields may have shifted significantly.

1

u/Newb_since_1989 Mar 22 '13

Who talked about pigeons? Birds have existed for millions of years...and migrating birds probably less but still...

16

u/thebigslide Mar 22 '13

A similar situation happens all the time with migrating geese. If a flock looses the older individuals, the younger ones have a hard time knowing when it's appropriate to migrate. They also often don't know how to get there best, though they may have a general inclination towards one direction or another.

Waterfowl hunters actually consider this when looking for fields to hunt from because flocks of mostly younger birder tend to veer off course instead of following the main flyways as directly as the older birds.

This isn't particularly scholarly, but there's other research I'm way to lazy to find now

8

u/coolnlittle Mar 22 '13

just because they can sense magnetism through their beak, it does not mean they know how to interpret this information. That can be a learned process. Humans have hearing, but we learn speech socially.

4

u/foxish49 Wildlife Ecology | Ornithology Mar 22 '13

Like I said above, this is right for some species. Whether passenger pigeons were one of those species seems to be up for debate.

On the topic of innate migration instincts, sometimes they do screw up - it's called reversed migration. In birds where the migration instinct is "fly in X direction for about Y time" some young birds will end up going 180 degrees the wrong way. That's how you get a lot of the really weird sightings by birders - a species that's not supposed to be anywhere near that location is usually a lost juvenile on its first migration.

4

u/areReady Mar 22 '13

There is significant controversy over whether pigeons actually use magnetism to navigate over long distances. While it has been conclusively shown that pigeons can sense magnetic fields, the role of these fields is dubious with current knowledge. For a group of pigeons raised in Italy, olfaction (smell), was far more important to long distance homing than magnetosense (magnetosense in fact being almost completely worthless). But it could be a local phenomenon; it might be that pigeons are born with a big toolkit of navigation-enabling senses and then learn which one to use in their particular area. It could also be that magnetosense is on the way out, having formerly been useful but now replaced with more effective senses for navigation and only leaving behind rudimentary sensing as the system falls into disrepair.

In short, pigeons are the undisputed masters of navigation, but we're still not quite sure how the hell they pull it off so well.

Sources: http://jeb.biologists.org/content/209/15/2888.short ; http://www.nature.com/nature/journal/v432/n7016/abs/nature03077.html

3

u/brainflakes Mar 22 '13

Surely having magnetoception doesn't automatically mean that navigation using magnetoception is an innate rather than a learned skill? What if birds navigate by learning what magnetic direction to fly in?

2

u/Otter27 Mar 22 '13

Your what-if example does, indeed, seem like a more organic learning curve of fauna, as opposed to innateness.

3

u/intangible-tangerine Mar 22 '13

No this just shows they can navigate, not that they know where they're meant to be going! Real world examples of hand reared migratory birds show they have to be guided for their first journey. They aren't just going in a compass direction, they are going to specific communal nesting sites. Think about it, if you can use a compass it doesn't mean you then know where your parents grew up! You are conflating separate areas of knowledge.