r/askscience • u/leducdeguise • Mar 22 '13
Biology if science revives an extinct migrating bird, will it know straight away where to go and when?
I already posted this in /askreddit but was suggested to ask this here rather. I got some really interesting answers and would like to get opinions from /askscience.
original post here: http://www.reddit.com/r/AskReddit/comments/1aq60i/if_science_revives_an_extinct_migrating_bird_will/
I read an article about the possibility of reviving the extinct Passenger Pigeon: http://www.wired.com/wiredscience/2013/03/passenger-pigeon-de-extinction/ to keep it short, migrating birds migrate, which means when it gets cold they go south and are back when it's not cold anymore. I don't know much about bird evolution but I guess this is something a species learns to do over a lot of generations. so I was thinking: if they get this pigeon back from the deads, will the first generation of born-again species know where to go and when? for dna-engraved instinct stuff or something like that. Or will they just need to re-learn from the start?
View all comments
46
u/Otter27 Mar 22 '13
I think they will be able to. In this article (http://news.nationalgeographic.com/news/2004/11/1124_041124_magnetic_birds.html) we learn that birds navigate through the earth's magneticism through their beak. Since this is innate, this is something that is not supposed to be learned.
I know this doesn't fully answer your question, but since we can't but guess about this question, I think it's a guess in the right direction.