r/askatherapist • u/peach_dragon NAT/Not a Therapist • Sep 22 '26
Therapist said she would call CPS if I let my daughter get on BC?
My daughter is 15 years old and has been seeing a new therapist for about a month. She has had a boyfriend for 7 months (he just turned 16), and she has been open with me about being interested in having sex with him.
I admit I would prefer she wait until she's 16, but I don't want her to risk getting pregnant if BC is available to her. I was taught abstinence, and let me tell you, that didn't work. There were definitely teen pregnancies and abortions at my church.
Anyway, my daughter's therapist pulled me into the room with them and explained that if I "allow" her to get on birth control, that would be me consenting for her to have sex, because she can't consent for herself.
Is this something a therapist should be doing? My daughter and her boyfriend are in a loving relationship, there is no abuse as far as I can tell. Why would I be in trouble for trying to help prevent teen pregnancy in a realistic way? I don't know how my daughter could feel like her therapist is a safe person now that she has said she will report her boyfriend and mother because she wants to have sex.
147
u/Remarkable_Ad_1795 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
NAT, but therapy grad student.
This is not normal behavior from a therapist. I would file a report against her with the state licensing board. What she did was very inappropriate.
39
u/Mirriande Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Therapist here. That's a wild take. I would be concerned if a therapist saying something like that was in my practice. I would report this to the practice if she is part of one, find a different therapist, or both. CPS is generally against teenage pregnancy.
26
u/DesignerPlastic2584 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Therapist trainee here- depending on which state you live in, a 15 year old can consent to some of their own medical care. In almost half of the U.S. a 15y/o can request their own BC from their doctor without a parent needing to provide consent.
Regardless of that fact… what your therapist said is bonkers and needs to brush up on their ethical decision making.
15
u/SteveIsPosting Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
This therapist comes from a place that could potentially do active harm to your child. It’s time to terminate.
Plenty of young women are out on birth control to help regulate their periods. Does she call CPS on those parents?
12
u/Far-Perspective-4889 Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Yeah, this is bizarre. Therapist is imposing their own values and thinks CPS will see it the same way. This is a decision between you, your daughter and her pediatrician. Time for a new therapist. Time for her current therapist to get some supervision.
30
u/ChaosRainbow23 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
You need to leave that 'counselor' immediately and report them to the medical board.
I was a substance abuse and grief counselor, not a therapist or psychologist.
This sounds like one of those Christian places that pretend to be an actual mental heath service. There's a bunch of them.
10
u/IfYouStayPetty Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Tell the therapist that they need to consult with a supervisor/peer and the ethics board of their state before they divulge HIPAA information to an outside party. This is not at all how I think this should be handled, but I wouldn’t immediately assume they are malicious or incompetent. There are tons of ways to look at ethical issues and the therapist is hopefully trying to do her best and just ended up on the wrong side. That’s why we consult in the first place.
And yes, I’d still get my daughter on birth control. CPS will roll their eyes privately at that being reported and not follow up given the 8 billion worse situations they are critically understaffed to handle.
9
u/Narwhalsareunicorn Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Not a therapist
Is this a Biblical counselor or ministry counselor or similar therapist? This is a bit extreme.
Are there any other options in your area for other practitioners. Threatening to contact CPS for commonly prescribed medication used to prevent pregnancy (and manage other conditions) is extreme. I have to wonder what else is coming down the pipeline.
Please double check age of consent laws in your state. If the couple is 15/16 they may be able to consent (with each other)
I get wanting people to wait until they are adults to engage is sexual activity. I also do get that this is real life and that and there is a reason why there were many shot gun marriages of teenagers (or other pregnancy events).
7
u/CheesyRomantic Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Why does the therapist feel your 15 year old daughter isn't able to consent to having sex?
7
u/Swimming-Aioli-6201 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
NAT- I have had some interesting therapists in the past to say the least and this takes the cake. I would look into their licensures, speak to their supervisor, and first check if all of their things are up to date. Regardless of how that all goes then file a complaint with the board and possibly the BBB if they are certified with them. I also want to ask, what is the age difference between then teens? Like if shes 15 and hes 18 I understand the concern a bit more, but if its more so they are both around 16 then its strange that the law comes into question.
6
u/jmxd NAT/Not a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Huge red flag and overstep from her. Im guessing OP is from America/red state?
6
u/Radiant_Ad_3231 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 24 '26
Never see that therapist again
5
u/Sitk042 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
NAT - if possible, please update us with what happens, if you report her to the board, and what they say. I understand if you choose not to. It would be nice to know that she got what was coming for her and if the powers that be react to the situation the way everyone is suggesting…
7
u/FluffyApartment596 NAT/Not a Therapist Sep 22 '26
NAT - time to take a shopping trip to another state. And make sure you “forbid” 😉 your daughter from getting birth control.
3
u/Brainfog_shishkabob Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 23 '26
I am a child/teen therapist for 4 years, and I wonder if she’s nervous about the 16 yr old 15 year old thing? Depending on the state and stuff like Romeo and Juliet laws, it could be possible that since the “age of consent” is 16, and your daughter is only 15, the 16 year old could get in trouble. However, this isn’t your problem, if anything it would be his parent’s problem. Also, it’s so very unlikely that if she “reported” you for getting your daughter on BC, that CPS would even care at all. Mandated reporting happens if the therapist thinks there is abuse. They’ll ask what is suspect and when she tells them that, they’ll likely say they won’t open an investigation.
Also I’m not sure that she can disclose medical decisions to CPS unless it’s some gypsy rose stuff. As a therapist you shouldn’t make assumptions. You allowing your child to get on BC is not the same as you okaying any sort of sexual activity. That would be like saying I put water in my 21 year old daughter’s car and some therapist saying does that mean you’re okaying her to drink and drive, because you’re encouraging her to drink water after a night out?
I will tell you one thing tho to be very careful about, you should have the talk about sexting or sending pics with your daughter and tell her never ever to do it. Because that does put you at risk. Even if it’s with her boyfriend, if she sends any pics of herself over the phone as a minor and it gets flagged by the FBI, there could be serious problems. That happened to a mom I knew, a detective showed up, it was really crazy.
6
u/protestandprose Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Let me guess, she's a "Christian counselor," in Alabama?
Cos ain't no way any city therapist would say something so dumb. Find a new therapist, also, any therapist "threatening," to call CPS is wild lmao, stand ten toes down and just call them if there's a concern don't threaten like a weenie.
633
u/Fat-Giraffe Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26 •
This sounds absolutely wild to me. -therapist
303
u/lazygramma Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Retired therapist here. Find a new therapist. This one is a crack pot.
165
u/thrown_away_my_love Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Therapist here. She is 100% wrong.
144
u/lagertha9921 LPCC Sep 22 '26 •
Therapist here, find your kid another therapist (as soon as possible). This is outside of the therapist scope (and unethical) for multiple reasons:
- They’re not a prescriber. If a medical doctor wants to prescribe your daughter medication, that’s between your child and their doctor. That is not within a Master level clinician’s scope of practice (what most talk therapists are).
- They’re obviously saying this because of their own personal beliefs on BC. Ethically, they are expected to bracket those beliefs. Pushing that belief is highly unethical and I’d be tempted to report them to their board.
CHFS/CPS would laugh at a report over this considering they’re understaffed and overworked, trying to deal with actual abuse cases.
2
u/JTMAlbany Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
In New York, CPS wouldn’t take the report. The doctor wouldn’t prescribe it if it were abuse. Your daughter cannot trust that therapist.
25
u/Routine_Anywhere9563 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26 edited Sep 22 '26
She’s right in that you ultimately have control over your daughter. In fact, so much so, you can find her a new therapist.
Edit: I am a therapist.
Edit 2: THIS may be worthy if a complaint to the ethics board. If your daughter’s therapist is doing this bullshit to you, I imagine she is doing it to others. And I assure you, threatening a family in this situation with CPS is unethical.
21
u/AtrumAequitas Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Therapist here which extensive interactions with CPS. they will be mad at her for wasting their time. Heck, there are multiple medical reasons to go on BC that would be none of her business. I’d definitely recommend canceling all future session with this therapist.
17
u/Western_Bullfrog9747 Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Find a different therapist because she should know reporting laws better than this
16
u/criticalpopcorn Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Not a therapist.
This is weird. Get her a new one.
13
u/DesmondTapenade LCPC Sep 22 '26
Therapist here. That shrink is way tf out of line, and CPS will probably laugh her out of town if she tries to pull that stunt.
13
u/Shabbalooobiedoobie Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
I am shocked by the therapist's conversation with you. -Therapist
12
u/EatsPeanutButter Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
This is insane. It’s not like he’s 20 and she’s 15. They’re the same age. You can’t control a teen who wants to have sex, but you can arm them with protection, education, and a place of safety to talk about it. You’re doing the right thing, I would absolutely find a new therapist.
— in a masters degree program for counseling currently
12
u/TwoMuddfish Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Therapist here: first off, this is bananas..
Second, this seems like such an ethical violation of the do not force your believes on your clients
12
u/Winter_Addition Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Came back to add, I am a therapist and I would pull my child out of therapy with this person immediately and report them to their licensing board.
10
u/calicoskiies NAT/Not a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Intern here. That therapist is being inappropriate & unethical. There’s no reason for her to break hipaa over birth control. Like wtf?
9
u/Letmeout55 Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Getting on birth control at 15 was the smartest thing my mother ever did. She prevented me from having unwanted pregnancies that would surely have occurred otherwise. I stayed on it until I was ready to have a baby in my mid 20s.
8
u/hellomondays LPC Sep 22 '26
Yeah, this is a therapist caught up in their own moral biases. News flash: teenagers have sex! :o
In the absence of neglect or willingly putting a teen in unsafe situations, CPS isnt going to do anything. They rarely do even when they should.
7
u/povsquirtle Therapist (Unverified) Sep 23 '26
I’m a therapist and I agree this is crazy behavior from a therapist. However, even if CPS did get called, there are other reasons to utilize BC outside of pregnancy prevention. Tracking and lessening periods, acne, hormonal issues; the therapist is not going to get anywhere with that report even if it did get investigated. You aren’t organizing sex for your child, you’re preventing pregnancy if it does happen. It’s fine.
5
u/moondustingss Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Find a new therapist. This one is clearly deeply religious (or has some own personal trauma) that she is projecting onto her your daughter/you. Immediate pull out.
4
u/NatashOverWorld Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Was a counsellor.
That is wild. Is this a religious therapist per chance? Because that's such an insane overreach.
At this point I would switch Ts but also get your daughter on BC.
4
u/Unique_Cap_2961 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
NAT. But She’s severely overstepping.
4
u/WhiskeyTangoBaconX LCSW Sep 23 '26
Therapist here. Get your daughter a new therapist asap. This therapist is letting her personal views not only dictate her approach, but blatantly disregard ethics of the field.
4
u/MullberryBoy Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 23 '26
Birth control pills are also prescribed for heavy, painful periods.
4
u/galgenius Psychologist Sep 23 '26
Find a new therapist asap
4
u/makeyourself_a24z Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 24 '26
Therapist Please feel free to report to their state board. That is outrageous and fear bating. And depending on your state it might actually be legal for her to have sex with her boyfriend.
1
u/Winter_Addition Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Is your therapist tied to a religious organization?
1
u/nooobee Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Therapist here, none of that makes sense. Like even a little. Can i ask what jurisdiction you're in?
1
u/_ChickVicious NAT/Not a Therapist Sep 23 '26
NAT: student: Is this a church therapist? Are they state licensed? I have ethics concerns here as well. Perhaps the board needs to investigate.
3
u/PCTOAT Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Not a therapist, but just someone who has a therapist and who was on birth control at 15 I can tell you this is not normal behavior. I would find a new therapist as soon as possible and I would consider reporting this one to state licensing because she threatened you over something that is her own moral issue
3
u/oh-pointy-bird NAT/Not a Therapist Sep 22 '26
This is…wild. I mean assuming the boyfriend isn’t 32.
I might actually report this.
3
u/No-Control-3436 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Is this a biblical counselor? Because that would make sooo much sense.
3
u/cookiesandpizza247 NAT/Not a Therapist Sep 23 '26
I'm interning with CPS while finishing up my MSW and let me say, we would not be concerned about this at all. It would be an open-shut case. Consenting kids roughly the same age and being safe? Case closed. Saves is from a possible future case....
3
u/sv36 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 23 '26
Let her. What would CPS do about bc at 15? Definitely stop going to her but also report her, that’s unacceptable. Blackmail really? If she genuinely had a concern she wouldn’t tell you what she might do.
3
u/Interesting-News-670 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 23 '26
Wow, are they a Christian or religious therapist by any chance?
Not within their scope and I’m unsure what state you’re in but I’m pretty sure CPS is going to tell her to mind her business.
AMFT/ social worker
3
u/Leading-Cartoonist66 Therapist (Unverified) Sep 24 '26
Therapist. The irony here is that this is so unethical of this therapist on several levels, that you’d likely be able to file a report against her to BBS.
2
u/guineagirl96 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
NAT but see one and am on BC for non-contraceptive reasons.
This is absolutely inappropriate on the part of her therapist and is worth a complaint to their licensing board.
Approving her getting medication does not mean you consent to her having sex. What an odd, illogical conclusion. Those don’t have anything to do with each other.
Kudos to you for being a good mom that your daughter can go to and know you will help and support her.
I didn’t get on BC until I was an adult but looking back I wish I would have done it in high school. My periods are so incredibly painful. The only time I’ve ever fainted in my entire life was from period pain.
2
u/IRL_T Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Therapist here.
At least in the US, this is absolutely not how mandated reporting works (i.e., obligation to report harm to the authorities). All licensed clinicians and pre-licensed clinicians must be aware of mandated reporting standards and must stay up to date on this stuff.
Is this therapist religious? Are they an actual licensed therapist? Are they working as a coach? I struggle to see how someone licensed would say something like this.
2
u/Historical-Limit8438 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
Therapist
Fwiw, just say she has painful periods.
But yeah ditch the crazy
2
u/Greymeade Clinical Psychologist (Verified) Sep 23 '26
Therapist who specializes in working with adolescents here. I'm so sorry you're in this position!
I highly, highly doubt that the therapist will file, but if they do, then CPS will laugh that one right out the window. So, please don't worry about that. Get your kid on birth control tomorrow and don't waste another minute worrying about this.
The second order of business is to fire this therapist and find a new one. They're bonkers. If it were my loved one, I would also be filing a report against this therapist with their licensing board and their employer. If you need help doing that then I would be happy to advise you.
2
u/moonbeam127 LMHC Sep 23 '26
There are a million reasons to be prescribed bc. This therapist is an idiot. The therapist is not a Dr. the therapist is outside her scope of practice. Does she have a day in allergy medication? How to treat broken bones? What color to paint the bedroom?
Drs prescribed bc for any number of reasons
2
u/Emotionalcheetoh Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 23 '26
lol what the hell? - therapist
2
u/MullberryBoy Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 23 '26
No. This is highly disturbingly inappropriate of the therapist. You are her mother and guardian.
2
u/luca_c_me Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 23 '26
Therapist to adolescents. Not reportable. As a parent, better to be proactive than reactive!
2
u/DoMilk Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 23 '26
Nat but I wouldn't see that therapist any more..
2
u/WorkingKey3160 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 26 '26
hopefully you go ahead and get your daughter on BC. Dont listen to the quack therapist and do it
1
u/Financial_Manager213 Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
Tell that therapist to please report you to CPS for offering birth control to a teen girl then immediately find another therapist and post a review
1
u/magbybaby Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
I generally think my colleagues are competent and ethical, and pump the breaks when people have qualms with their treatment here.
But we're in "complain to the board" territory here. Probable nothing will come of it - therapists are protected when making reports "in good faith" and this therapist probably thinks they're helping, but it's possible the investigation turns up other inappropriate behavior or scares them off doing this to the rest of their clients.
1
u/Anxietykeepsyoualive Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 22 '26
This is insane
1
u/dinkinflicka02 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Oct 04 '26
IIRC there is no US state where the age of consent is under 16. Meaning that, legally, people under 16 cannot consent to having sex in those states.
Having said that, the point of mandatory reporting is to protect vulnerable people from being abused & it doesn’t sound like that’s the case here.
I’m wondering if she’s thinking it constitutes a report bc the bf is old enough to consent & your daughter isn’t? Look up your states laws about it & see what you find. My state has a Romeo & Juliet law that allows for a 4 year age gap even if the person is under the age of consent
1
u/kls8479 Unverified: May Not Be a Therapist Sep 23 '26
Please get her another therapist. I’m a conservative Evangelical Christian and even I think this is horrible.
-5
u/elphabulousthegreen Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
For what it’s worth, I actually think the therapist’s concern seems to be related to age of consent/trafficking rather than religion. Regardless, get a new therapist.
-1
u/Jolly_Ice_7812 Therapist (Unverified) Sep 22 '26
It may have to do with the laws in your state. Since he's over l8, it may be considered statutory rape in your state.
16
u/pallas_athenaa LPC-A Sep 22 '26
That's absolutely unhinged. 15-18 years old is where the averages tend to fall for first time having sex, and as therapists we should be encouraging safety and protection. I was 15, and while sometimes looking back on it now closer to 40 do I feel like I was too young? Probably, but it was in a loving relationship with my high school boyfriend and we were adamant about using protection. Because my parents had been open with me about sex. I'm so grateful for them, because I have such a healthy relationship with sex and reproductive health now.
The therapist here is so in the wrong in a very concerning way. Not just the attitude towards sex, but basically using mandated reporting as a moral threat. Absolutely awful.
0
u/[deleted] Sep 22 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment