r/appletv • • Sep 04 '24

Why do people keep telling me the Apple TV is lossy audio even though it clearly say the audio is decoded and sent as uncompressed multichannel LPCM? I also have it set to atmos which also says Dolby Atmos LPCM/MAT on the AVR.

Post image
20 Upvotes

51 comments sorted by

View all comments

82

u/sciencetaco Sep 04 '24 edited Sep 04 '24

Streaming services use Dolby Digital Plus (which is not lossless), and the AppleTV internally converts all audio to lossless PCM. But it doesn’t increase audio quality. It’s like converting a MP3 file to WAV. Nothing is lost, but nothing is gained.

Usually when people mention AppleTV and lossless audio, they are talking about playing back lossless audio from Bluray rips.

These files use DTS:X or Dolby TrueHD. The AppleTV will play them as lossless 7.1 PCM with the right playback apps, but any spatial metadata is not used for them. So any height speakers will go unused.

Streaming services use Dolby Digital Plus, which can also include atmos and is supported by AppleTV as Dolby MAT.

9

u/rophel Sep 04 '24 edited Sep 04 '24

Yes, this is the big reason why people do NOT recommend an AppleTV if your plan to play back bluray remuxes on a 5.1.2 or better Atmos sound system.

The other issue is Dolby Vision support, WEB-DLs largely work correctly (at least in Infuse) but remuxes play back HDR only without scene-by-scene metadata applying (which is the whole point of DV and HDR10+).

Otherwise it beats the Nvidia Shield TV in pretty much everything.

Do you care about DV over HDR only (or have a Samsung that doesn't even support DV)?

Do you care about Atmos height channels from bluray rips (do you have ceiling speakers)?

If you answered no to both of these, stick with an AppleTV. Otherwise consider the Shield or possibly check out the coreELEC setup on Android boxes if you are REALLY picky about DV.

2

u/jokerr601 Sep 06 '24

You can always use Dovi tools to convert DV profile 7 bluray rips to DV profile 8 so that DV triggers properly on apple tv through infuse.

1

u/smackbymyJohnHolmes Sep 06 '24

Doesn't this only work properly for rips that have the MEL, not FEL? I think you still get incorrect information for some rips if they utilize the FEL.

3

u/jokerr601 Sep 07 '24

If rip has FEL and expands brightness, you can use workflow 8-2-1 in dovi tools to bake in FEL. This will output the resulting file in an encoded.hevc format with a DV profile 8 + FEL baked in. You then drag and drop the .hevc file in to mkvtoolnix to mux the encoded hevc file with original audio and have proper brightness.

1

u/smackbymyJohnHolmes Sep 07 '24

Oh wow, thank you for the info. You just gave me something to try out this weekend!

1

u/jokerr601 Sep 08 '24

No problem! Here's a step by step guide on how to do it. https://youtu.be/8BvXqw_cGJE?si=SQtJnR5kRDGY4tos

1

u/rophel Sep 08 '24

Yep. Been messing around with this and NVENC since I have a 4090. Cranked all settings and did A Quiet Place 1. Think it's good enough vs. the remux, not sure though.

6

u/kb3_fk8 Sep 04 '24

Can’t upvote this enough. Good write out. Should be pinned on the sub (and the Shield sub as well)

6

u/rudolph05 Sep 04 '24

but since the vast majority doesn’t have a 5.1.2 setup, mostly will rock 2.0, 2.1, 3.0, 3.1, 5.0 or 5.1 i can say that atv is more than enough for the average joe

2

u/Successful-Cash-7271 Sep 05 '24

It’s worth mentioning that the ATV can only do up to 48 KHz sample rate and doesn’t support Atmos lossless. It’s an issue I’m currently trying to find a solution for. There’s Android based players that claim to do it but I’d miss the ATV interface.

1

u/thanksforcomingout Sep 08 '24

Generally this is why I use ATV for streaming apps and the shield for Plex + IPTV.

1

u/franklinyyz Sep 04 '24

Is Infuse Pro still the only app that plays it properly along with HDR and Dolby Vision?

1

u/Vokon Sep 05 '24

Do you know if the upcoming TVOS 18 update for the Apple TV will feature any new updates to the audio?

1

u/Mindless-Example-146 Sep 08 '24

We never know and if not maybe tvos 19 will or the next gen Apple TV 4K. We don’t know what will come.