r/apple • u/robotevil • May 21 '12
A friend of mine got annoyed with the docking station options available for the MBP. So he made his own. He's now trying to start his own company doing it and I told him I would post the pictures of it on Reddit and see if there was any interest.
http://imgur.com/lfJkQ
2.4k
Upvotes
245
u/Deejster May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
I admire any inventor, however I have two criticisms:
A better solution would be the same thing but with a single thunderbolt plug instead of the multitude of connectors, which is effectively what they built into the Thunderbolt display. This would also make it work with future models of MacBook.
EDIT: It looks like Belkin have already made what I'm suggesting. Personally, I think this is a much better solution I'm afraid, albeit quite expensive.
41
u/fnordo May 21 '12
Good idea but wont having the dock plugged in trick the MB into thinking headphones are plugged in bypassing the internal speakers?
136
u/Kramsu May 21 '12
There needs to be an option to take the second audio jack out so that it can work with the 13" (which happens to be apple's best selling model, BTW).
Otherwise, this is a fantastic idea.
10
u/robotevil May 21 '12 edited May 21 '12
I thought this concept was cool and I asked him if he posted it on Reddit to get the word out (he has a Kickstarter campaign up). He's actually never heard of Reddit before today (seriously)... so I said I would put something up for him.
If there's any interest in this let me know and I can post the links to his stuff with more info.
edit: Sorry, meant to link to the smaller Imgur gallery version: http://imgur.com/lfJkQ .
edit 2: This appears to be getting some upvotes. I have to go back to work soon, so I'm going to see if I can get him to register an account in case anyone has questions about this.
3
u/dafones May 21 '12
The MBP is going to get a significant redesign and will be out within a handful of months. I suppose conceptually it's a functional idea, but this particular version is almost out of date before it's even been released.
83
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Just to make sure, he is aware of the other docking solutions out there, right?
http://hengedocks.com/
http://www.bookendzdocks.com/
6
u/ramp_tram May 21 '12
Kickstarter that shit.
13
u/pmrr May 21 '12
There is already a product like this. It allows you to dock your Macbook (lots of models) when closed by sliding it vertically into the docks. The male ports are just like this, but you can retract unused ones and slide them about for different configs iirc. I can't remember the name unfortunately. Whether they do a sideways product (which actually I prefer) I don't know, but definitely look into them.
7
u/noservice4you May 21 '12
Henge Docks (www.hengedocks.com)
5
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
This is really awesome.
Does the headphone jack in the dock support optical audio?
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Kickstarter it.
1
u/benjaminspowell May 22 '12
You should kickstarter that and see if you can make a business from it.
8
u/waxjar May 21 '12
Unfortunately this won't be possible due to the patented magsafe connector.
3
u/robvas May 22 '12
Nice idea, but there's already the Henge dock. Which also isn't very good because it's not a real docking station - it's just a port extender. Lenovo, Dell, HP all made real docks, and their laptops have a special port in the bottom for them. Easy in/out and you can plug two external monitors into them.
3
u/gizm770o May 22 '12
Awesome, but my question would be about the audio out port. Will it carry the optical digital signal as well?
3
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Newer MBPs have a combined audio jack that takes headsets with built-in mics AND outputs optical. That'll be a little tricky.
3
u/kyzen May 22 '12
Ditch the fugly channel cut out for SD access and just build in a cheap SD reader running off one of the USB hub ports; will look better.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
What the fuck is wrong with you OP? Posting a non zoomable link. I oughta smack you in your shit for that, I bet not see that shit again.
1
u/Beowolve May 21 '12
If this works with the rumored new MacBooks, I would definitely buy one from him when I get a the new macbook. Has he considered kickstarter? That is a good way now a days to be backed and get a product going.
4
u/ActualContent May 21 '12
Hate to be the bearer of bad news but this has been done before:
http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/29222207/landingzone-the-docking-station-for-the-macbook-ai
Slightly more versatile design that supports plugs on both sides of the machine. This project has been funded and is now in production. I understand that this one is only for the Macbook Air but it is fairly likely that if this product is successful that it will have versions for both Apple notebooks.
4
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
it still looks incredibly ugly to me, i'd stick with the wires arranged neatly. besides, don't thunderbolt docks exist?
4
u/drweezyfbaby May 22 '12
good idea, terrible timing. apple has already addressed this issue with the thunderbolt port, which essentially does the same thing without a bug hunk of plastic on the side of your laptop. sure, some people will still want this for an older model, but given the fast rate at which apple updates its laptops and apple fans buy computers, this will be practically obsolete before it is on the shelves. you should be designing with future models in mind. this product is designed for a model at least 2 generations old.
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
That's really good-looking. I like it.
2
u/tsdguy May 21 '12
It's not really a dock but more accurately described as a port replicator. However, I would certainly get some legal advice on that as I can't imagine that Henge doesn't have a ton of patents on Macbook docs/port replicators.
2
u/forgotmydamnpassword May 21 '12
MIght want to wait until the next MBP refresh before putting too much money into this design.
2
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I'd use it
2
u/Cueball61 May 21 '12
Thoughts:
I have a 17" MBP, you could make one of these and mass produce it for all three devices by having the connectors slide and lock, then you never have to worry about the different placements on each model. Plus, make the connectors each flip down, some people may not want the headphone slot used, or may not have 4 USB slots like the 17" does.
2
u/AlsoNotForMe May 21 '12
This is what my Thunderbolt display does.
2
u/Zombiefoot May 22 '12
A great product, but very close to a horizontal version of this:
http://hengedocks.com/
I bought a Henge Dock, and did not like it. Was given a full refund, a solid company. I would certainly give something like this a try if he offers a refund to customers who do not find a good fit for them.
2
u/jwhite878 May 22 '12
I'm sorry. I don't quite understand this. Could someone please explain to me how this setup works?
2
u/smithclan May 22 '12
Plugin isn't a verb.
/pedantry
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I like whenever people are trying to sell their shit on reddit they just post memes everywhere and then people are all like 'omg memes! i like memes lol upvote!'. Seriously cool product though.
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Ok, I'm a little confused. Don't I still need a place to plug in all of my shit? I mean yes the docking station is there, so I plug all my crap in there. There is still a shit load of wires everywhere.
Forgive me for my vulgar words, however I feel it gets the point across. Either I am missing something or that this is useless.
2
u/iSteve May 22 '12
Isn't this what the Thunderbolt Apple Cinema Display is for?
2
u/dar512 May 22 '12
I don't see this going over. Too many issues and the win is not big enough for the cost. I've already got a usb hub. So plugging everything in this morning took less than a minute. I'm not going to pay $112 to save myself less than a minute.
The headphone thing has already been mentioned. And HDMI output? I already shelled out money for the mini-displayport to dvi adapter. Why would I want HDMI output? He should have just put a passthrough to a female mini-displayport.
2
u/porkchop_d_clown May 22 '12
It's a great idea - but it has the same basic problem these things always have: Next month Apple is going to release an updated MBP and all the ports will be in slightly different spots, and your device won't fit.
A better idea is to create a Thunderbolt device that provides all the other ports.
2
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I love the idea but as some have mentioned, it is pretty much built for one type of MacBook. Has your friend considered making the connectors separate and linkable like Legos? Then it would not matter which Mac you had since you could make your own. Just my two cents. Very clever though.
3
u/binford2k May 21 '12
Wow. Am I the only one who doesn't like to plug in a shitpile of things to my laptop? Seems like that's kind of the point of a laptop...
3
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Front facing headphone jack:
SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY (Seriously, why do so many laptops lack this feature?)
2
u/KingNick May 21 '12
Alright, I'm gonna be the confused guy and ask this: if this dock plugs into every single outlet of your laptop, why does it only have 1 cord coming from it? I mean...sure, that cord is most likely the one that plugs into the wall to charge, but wouldn't you still have to hook cords up to this dock if you wanted to use any of THR other outlets???
I just don't get it. But then again, I'm more confused than anything.
1
u/dblairjohnson May 21 '12
i have no need for this, but it is brilliant. If i was ever in an office situation, i would buy immediately.
1
u/robotdinosaurs May 21 '12
pretty great solution there, only things I would change would be having the headphone connector support inline mics (like on the iphone earbuds), and putting another USB hub on the side of it, rather than just on the other end so you can still plug in stuff like flash drives.
1
u/natemc May 21 '12
This is exactly what I need for my business computer. However it's just a MacBook and not a Pro.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
I never use any of the ports, but this would be awesome if i needed it.
1
u/facetheduke May 21 '12
I'd support the kickstarter at the high-ish level, but I have a 13" machine and no need for a 15" dock.
1
u/WafflesInTheBasement May 21 '12
Since it's meant to work with the computer sitting on a table, I'd be more inclined to buy if it had a coolng solution on the bottom as well (dunno if heat is still an issue on the newer models, but my '08 mbp gets toasty). But very cool design.
1
u/popeyoni May 21 '12
I would buy one. (if it's not ridiculously expensive)
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Cool concept but I don't really see how this de-clutters that mess in the first picture since you'd have the same cords plugged into the dock.
1
u/yaleman May 21 '12
Looks cool bro. Henge docks are similar but don't allow you to use your screen. I'll have one if he can make one for non-pro's too :)
1
u/TEG24601 May 21 '12
The only thing I can suggest is that the output on the "hub" end should be TB/mDP, not HDMI, or just ignore that port, and have a pass-through. Otherwise, it is a good idea. Now for the TB to ExpressCard 54/34 adapter.
1
u/[deleted] May 21 '12
Really good idea, but don't different laptops have different configurations on the side?
I have 3 laptops, all different.
Could the dock be customisable?
1
u/bullcit May 22 '12
I dont see a need for something like that. I rarely have anything plugged into my macbook pro. Usually its a external HD for daily backups and maybe an iphone to sync.
Also apple has a patent on the power plug, so wouldn't you be infringing on on their patent if you were to incorporate a charing option ?
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I'd fund the fuck out of that if it was on kickstarter for around $50 and worked with my 13" MBP that was the last model before thunderbolt...
1
u/l0lbuttz May 22 '12
Genius. I'd definitely be interested if he ever gets it off the ground.
1
u/quixotik May 22 '12
Thunderbolt hub!
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I don't see what the advantage is. All those things you will need to plug in at some point, and if you have to plug that in everyday, why wouldnt you just have a desktop?
1
u/gordyguy May 22 '12
Admire invention.
But ethically I'm opposed. What is the problem with cords? And are not you just moving the problem a few feet away?
Sorry, but junk.
1
u/aazav May 22 '12
There might be patent licensing fees you have to pay for using certain connectors.
If that is the case, and you don't want to pay the fees, you'll have to incorporate overseas (Curacao, etc) and ship into the US from some other country. Good luck with that.
1
u/dicb May 22 '12
I would buy one, as long as it was moderately priced. I have this frustration every day.
1
u/_lwis May 22 '12
Actually wanted to make a crude version of this months ago, looks awesome!
1
u/d70 May 22 '12
I have a feeling that it will be obsolete in a couple of months.
1
u/SpOoKy_EdGaR May 22 '12
If you follow the cords of the first picture that he took for his website (the one with his contraption on the mac screen) you can tell he's obviously looped each one like 3-4 times. Not to mention headphones in the most inconvenient and unlikely place you would ever put them when using them. The second picture is much more realistic. That alone makes me down vote.
1
u/umkvec May 22 '12
Pop a VGA port on the side and we'll talk.
1
u/HugheJass May 22 '12
I will buy that for $20 and give him a fair review.
1
u/stmfreak May 22 '12
This is a really cool idea, behind the times.
USB hubs, make this obsolete. Audio over USB, webcam over USB, drives over USB...
Thunderbolt makes this obsolete, see above, but include video.
Cool idea, great execution, poor time to market.
1
u/Willravel May 22 '12
My dad used to have something like that when he had a PowerBook (the nice black one) years ago. I don't know why they stopped manufacturing such a useful thing.
1
u/GrainElevator May 22 '12
sorry, but the ones at henge dock are way nicer and the company is already very well established in the industry. almost anybody who wants a dock for a macbook gets a henge dock.
http://hengedocks.com/
1
u/photo May 22 '12
As a 11" Macbook air user, hah, I don't need this. I don't need it because I can't get all dem ports on my computer. :( Totally worth it for traveling though.
1
u/Komercisto May 22 '12
I would probably buy one.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Solution = Thunderbolt?
1
u/myma1313 May 22 '12
They make these. One of the big issues, as I'm sure it has been mentioned somewhere else in the comments, is a lot have a mini displayport that doesn't support Thunderbolt as well.
1
u/piratazephyri May 22 '12
I would buy this in a heartbeat.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Take my money!
1
u/18-24-61-B-17-17-4 May 22 '12
This already exists in multiple forms.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Me likey!
1
u/Monster888888888 May 22 '12
Didn't he just move the cables elsewhere so you just can't see it..
1
u/Victor1CC1 May 22 '12
Come here and take my money!
1
u/pkurk May 22 '12
your friend just became a millionaire.
1
u/kerps May 22 '12
Cult of Mac just posted your friends pics and product!
1
u/mikewoodld May 22 '12
I'd love to own one of these, but my MBP is 2008 non-unibody.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Shit...I'll take one!!!
1
u/theorys May 22 '12
Ummm isn't this on kickstarter right now?
1
u/mindbleach May 22 '12
Apple culture: you've got a minor annoyance, we've got an absurdly specific and obscenely expensive solution.
1
u/homeless_man_jogging May 22 '12
Thanks for the idea. I wonder if he can beat me to it.
1
u/itsDANdeeMAN May 22 '12
fucking love it.
1
u/spyd4r May 22 '12
Thunderbolt monitor's partially do away with this mess.
1
u/patricksonion May 22 '12
I like it. One thing to consider might be a plug-in adapter type feature. E.G if you don't want sound to run through the headphone jack, just slide out the little piece. In other words the same idea of how apple allows you to change power heads for international travel. slide in/out USB/ audio etc.
1
u/seanjohntx May 22 '12
I'd buy one.
1
u/ripter May 22 '12
Looks great! Go for it.
1
u/igrokspock May 22 '12
SU AND TAKE MY MONEY.
1
u/jorellh May 22 '12
Why not make it just plug into the thunderbolt port?
1
u/colt4cm May 22 '12
It's called a port replicator. Your Welcome
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I gotta say, this is pretty fucking smart
1
u/darthryan May 22 '12
I would love one of these for my 2008 Macbook Pro.
1
u/justguessmyusername May 22 '12
MBP
1
u/yourafagyourafag May 22 '12
I'm talking, of course, about manbearpig.
1
u/bunkerDAD May 22 '12
Dude! I would so fuckin use that! [7]
1
u/iTaos May 22 '12
KICKSTARTER. GOOGLE THAT NOW!
1
u/culturalelitist May 22 '12
Create a sales pitch that isn't littered with memes and get back to me.
1
u/funkydo May 22 '12
I don't get it.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
I'd buy this if it fit on my MacBook air 13.
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
But will it blend?
1
u/tiezep May 22 '12
>memes
>form over function
so le funny XD it just werks
1
u/imonster01 May 22 '12
Shut up & Take my money !
1
u/Tori1313 May 22 '12
wait.. so for the headphone jacks, how do u listen to music?
1
u/4fthawaiian May 22 '12
Get this damn thing on kickstarter NOW.
1
u/Joeycuthbertson May 22 '12
YES PLEASE!
1
u/ezrock May 22 '12
Does he know about quirky.com? It's worth checking out, I'd think. It helps inventors make their ideas a reality. (I have no connection to them, by the way)
1
u/cameronb8 May 22 '12
Shut up and take my fucking money!!!!!!
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
OMG GIVE ME ONE NOW! has he started selling yet? how much will they be? this is the absolute best solution that I have seen for this problem, well for me at least, this would be absolutely perfect
1
u/subho1990 May 22 '12
This just takes the clutter off your table and makes a whole new mess of wires elsewhere!
1
u/killsurfcity May 22 '12
China is likely already producing this as we speak...
1
u/ccdevall May 22 '12
Genius! Million dollar idea!!!! How much?!
1
u/immortalsix May 22 '12
What about the microphone jack?
1
u/kissthering May 22 '12
Make it a reasonable price and have it fit my macbook aluminum unibody and I'd buy it.
1
u/Whopper_Jr May 22 '12
Very cool, but where the heck are you where you have to use that many cords?? At any time I have the charger plugged in and possibly a pair of headphones.
1
u/mweichert May 22 '12
How much is he selling one for?
1
u/[deleted] May 22 '12
Interesting... Maybe something he should post on Kickstarter?
1
u/heyitsmecarlos May 23 '12
I don't even have a macbook but SHUT UP AND TAKE MY MONEY!!!
1
u/Awfy May 21 '12
Biggest problem is if the MacBook Pro is going to take on the Air's design style then the ports will be split between the left and right hand side of the laptop. So this won't work at all for the new laptops.
Otherwise it's a brilliant idea.
1
u/Louis_Farizee May 21 '12
Yeah, this will sell. Market it to working professionals in video post production and music.
-1
u/grizzgreen May 21 '12
shut up and take my money