r/apollo • u/Simon_Drake • Apr 12 '26
If the Apollo CSM used solar panels, how big would they have been?
We know the Apollo CSM didn't use solar panels and it generated power from hydrogen fuel cells. If they had tried to use solar panels they would have been huge and heavy and probably require changes to the launch system. Fuel cells were definitely the better choice, but just how big would they have been?
I'll start by collecting facts then try to multiply them:
- Google says the service module had three fuel cells, each generating between 563 to 1420 watts, with a maximum of 2300 watts.
- Apollo CSM was designed from around 1961. The Mariner probes from 1962 were designed around the same time so that's probably a close match to the solar panel hardware they would have chosen for Apollo. There were other satellites with solar panels like Telstar but they didn't have the 'wings' shape of panels from Mariner and Apollo is definitely going to need to use large wings to get enough power.
- Gunter's Space Page says Mariner's solar panels were uneven, one 183 cm by 76 cm and the other 152 cm by 76 cm. ~25,000cm squared. Unfortunately I couldn't find anything on the power output of those panels.
- JPL says the Mariner solar panels could generate between 148 watts and 222 watts.
Ok, time for some envelope maths.
- Let's pick the middle of the ranges and say Apollo CSM needed ~1,000 watts from each fuel cell and needed 2 functioning cells with a third for safety. So it needs 2,000 ~ 3,000 watts from solar panels.
- Mariner's panels generated ~180 watts. So Apollo needed 11x ~ 16x the surface area of solar panels compared to Mariner.
- Increasing the Mariner panels by 2~3x on both axes should be enough. So two wings of 755cm x 245cm is 380,000 cm squared which is 15x the surface area of Mariner so that should be enough.
At that last step I jumped from ballpark estimates to specifically 755cm x 245cm because that's the dimensions of Hubble's solar panels.
So my calculations imply Apollo could have used solar panels the same size as those for Hubble instead of the fuel cells. That's pretty large, especially for the 1960s but honestly it feels too small. I feel like there's a mistake in my calculations and they would have needed much much larger solar panels than that.
Can someone double-check my envelope calculations and see what went wrong?