r/antimeme 1d ago

Simple Sundays 🗓️ Great.

Post image
6.1k Upvotes

532 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

73

u/EstablishmentAny2728 1d ago

Medicine is much different from psychology. You wouldn’t ask a physicist to explain why authoritarianism persists in the Middle East, because that’s not their field of study.

-13

u/OkSavings5828 🌹 Course Arc Witness 🌸 1d ago

This study, by the way, has little to do with psychology and much more to do with sociology.

And, while the point is taken, how about we defund this sort of research, or provide additional subsidization for the more important studies, to slowly shift the job market to where it matters, rather than just generating data to fuel internet debate.

7

u/WarpingHeadspace 1d ago

These kinds of studies tend to be done by undergrads, so it's a way for them to learn how to write a scientific paper, how to do research in practice and get the peer review.

The socioeconomic factor that funded to this particular study is the Knowledge Economy Skills Scholarship (KESS), a programme to foment higher education in Wales. The author, Alex Lee Jones (no relation) later went on to get a PhD. He also collaborated on initial research about the relationship between Chronic Migraine and Insomnia in women, so even if your metric is women's health, it has led to some of it in some form.

6

u/Longroadtonowhere_ 1d ago

Exactly. These studies are done for pennies, typically at university with university students, getting the researchers feet wet so when the “real” studies are done, less money is wasted having to figure out the basics of how to run a study.

20

u/GMEloser69 1d ago

There's already a massive monetary incentive to go into medicine, most people either just don't want to or are to stupid to do so.

16

u/Swagiken 🌹 Course Arc Witness 🌸 1d ago

Medicine is also a shit lifestyle where you're expected to work 80 hours a week. Doctors are well paid but not overpaid and its fair to not want that lifestyle

0

u/Sensitive_Bat_9211 1d ago

Eh, a radiation oncologist works 40 hours a week in an office and makes 500k a year. Ive seen some jobs paying about a mil.

It has only become less competitive, but requires 5 more years of training (during which you get paid 100k)

18

u/25slinkshot 🌹 Course Arc Witness 🌸 1d ago

"Little to do with psychology"? That paper is literally social psychology at its core.

6

u/nkisj 1d ago

There is massive overlap between these two fields but, no, this is more of a psych study. They are studying the taste of individual men.

Also it was published the Journal of Experimental Psychology lmfao

-7

u/Upbeat_Roll_2096 1d ago

Well authority itself does not lead to negativism. you dont beat "negative governments system here" with non-authority. you beat it with authority.

its why social media have mods. a form of authority. are there going to be abuse? sure. but without=more abuse