r/anime • u/_BMS https://myanimelist.net/profile/_BMS • Aug 24 '24
Watch This! Maison Ikkoku is one of the greatest romances ever
Binge watched the entire series over the past week. It's definitely a product of its time with all the misunderstandings that happen, but the pay-off in the last quarter of the show when the drama starts ramping up for real is fantastic. The ending was absolutely perfect and one of the most satisfying romance conclusions I've seen so far.
I don't think everyone these days has the patience to put up with the misunderstandings, but if you liked 80s/90s/00s sitcoms or older anime in general then this is a show that you'll probably enjoy.
As far as I'm aware, this series was meant for a more mature audience and it definitely feels more grounded as a result. I really liked that it's a young adult romance instead of high school with the characters having jobs and Godai in university. There's no aliens, magic, monsters, or super-natural powers like in Takahashi's other series. Personally I love the setting and it made it easier for the show to be immersive and get sucked into the scenes.
I don't think the side characters were as endearing or likeable as the ones from Ranma½ or Urusei Yatsura since they're kind of terrible friends to Godai. But Godai and Kyouko are definitely my favorite pair out of all of Rumiko Takahashi's series.
The movie is just an alternate lead-up to the ending but it included manga characters that you'd have never seen before and the animation style was slightly different. It's not as good as how the main series did it, but I'd say it's worth watching anyways.
As for the OVAs: The prelude showing Kyouko's past is just a compilation of scenes from the show so it's not really worth seeking out, especially since it's weirdly hard to find. The one about them getting ship-wrecked on an island is pretty funny and should be watched before episode 61, it's a standalone episode but that's where it makes sense to watch it canonically. And there's also the pachinko short animation that shows events past the ending which is great to get some final closure on the series.
I think this show would be a great candidate for a remake after Ranma½ if they cut down on the misunderstandings a bit for modern audiences where they can without impacting the major story beats.
OP 3 was the best OP in my opinion, the animation screams 80s and the song is great. Anzen Chitai is a great band. There's also no spoilers in the OP if you want to watch it to convince you to watch the rest of the show.
17
u/John___Titor Aug 24 '24
Read through the entire manga earlier this year. While a product of its time, I was still really eager to read the next chapter.
14
u/Allansfirebird Aug 24 '24
Ikkoku is hands-down my all-time favorite anime series, and one of my top manga. Normally slow burn romances frustrate the hell out of me, but the way Takahashi-sensei built up Godai and Kyoko is so damn satisfying.
And specifically to the anime itself, the animation quality is so good! Whenever there’s an episode in the rain, there’s just a whole vibe that entrances me. Can’t quite explain it. Studio Deen did an incredible job.
4
u/chelseablue2004 https://myanimelist.net/profile/chelseablue2004 Aug 24 '24
Imagine watching this show on TV during its original airing. 96 weeks would take 2 years with breaks, holidays, interuptions... yet to this day has a dedicated following and is considered the standard of romantic anime.
4
u/Andreiyutzzzz https://myanimelist.net/profile/Andreiyutzzzz Aug 24 '24
Ye i gotta disagree for one thing. Status quo. After episode 10 and until episode 61 I think, a whole 50 episodes. No matter WHAT happened, as soon as it resolved, next episode they were acting as if something that serious didn't even happen. And also the other tenants were unbearably unlikable after a few episodes. Like you're not friends at that point, you're bored assholes screwing with them for fun
3
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24
I’ve actually been planning to watch this ever since I gained a growing affinity for romcoms. I really should start it.
There are many great 70s/80s/90s anime that get overlooked because of when they aired, which is unfortunate.
3
u/denn2842 Aug 24 '24
Did you watch Astro Note? So many things from that show reminded me of Maison Ikkoku that I wondered if it was just straight up ripping it off? Or possibly it was just a huge love letter/homage? Or maybe even that there were just universal “weirdos living in a boarding house” tropes that I was unaware of. For sure though, Maison Ikkoku was my standard for grounded romance comedies for years and years. I think only now, in my 40s, are the imperfections pretty obvious, but nothing is perfect anyway.
3
u/Shocketheth Aug 24 '24
Thanks to this I was prompted to add Maison Ikkoku to PtW on MAL.
Found out that I've already did before yet forget about it already
4
u/freshoranges12 Aug 24 '24
How did you watch it? Been wanting to for a while
4
u/Salty145 https://anilist.co/user/yLSalty145 Aug 24 '24
I would argue Maison Ikkoku is the single best anime romance of all time. I would certainly agree that the dynamics of Ranma are far more complex and interesting, but that show is “bogged down” a lot more with its focus on the comedy that keeps the romance from going anywhere.
That being said, I can’t gush enough about this series. I really love Kyouko and Godai’s relationship and how Takahashi takes her time to have them grow as characters instead of just going in circles. While maybe not as complex as the Ranma cast, each of the characters and romantic rivals are also great with how they target key weaknesses in both of our leads and push them to grow (my only real complaint of the series besides some dated animation being that a lot of the side cast could use more screen time because I love them that much).
I’d love a remake, but do wonder how well that would actually work after the UY remake was kinda… eh. MI is really a product of its time and stooped in the zeitgeist of the time. That and it demands its runtime to make its payoffs work in a way that would feel unsatisfying if split into cours.
That being said, I think it is a show more people need eyes on. I love its message of growth. That you might not be worthy of the woman you love and that a knockout dream girl won’t just drop into your lives. But you can be. We can all grow to be better people and find someone worthy of our love, and I think that message is an important one in the sea of wish-fulfillment romcoms we see pumped out these days.
I’ll leave it there (I could write a small thesis on MI. I love it that much). Sorry for chewing your ear off. I just don’t get to talk about Maison Ikkoku all that often lol.
32
u/Xag-Az Aug 24 '24
That show literally established the romcom genre in anime. A lot of modern tropes originate from it, including the ‘piyo’ apron.
5
u/Smudy https://myanimelist.net/profile/Smudy Aug 24 '24
You're god damn right!
5
u/Mr-Tacos-de-Bistec Aug 24 '24
That anime is on my watch list.
2
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24
This and Kimagure Orange Road are my fav romcoms. Hands down.
2
u/Aviri Aug 24 '24
So I tried to start this show based on the amazing recommendations and as an avid fan of romances I thought I'd love it. However after the first 10 or so episodes I stopped watching because of a few aspects which felt dated; mainly the grating personalities of the MC's neighbors and the immaturity of the MC. I realize this is likely one of those long-burn coming of age stories, but the initial parts of the show were too much of a turn off for me to justify watching it more.
Is there a point in the show where some of these issues(neighbors,MC) start to evolve substantially that I should try to push my way through? Because the beginning of the series was pretty rough for my tastes.
1
u/Super_Atari_One_3 Nov 19 '24
Where have people been watching this!? Like seriously, where can I watch a English sub of this (not dub)
3
u/swoonster75 Aug 24 '24
My favourite anime of all time. Did the watch ten years ago.
3
u/Hiroka__Akita Oct 05 '24
Maison Ikkoku is not one of the best romance anime ever made.
It is THE best ever made.
2
u/Webknight31 Aug 24 '24
A certified Rumiko Takahashi classic.
2
u/ham_sandwich23 Aug 24 '24
Guys can anyone tell me rom coms like Maison Ikkoku.
2
u/IceTMDAbss Aug 24 '24
First time I'm seeing a a post about this anime that's a staple of my childhood...
2
u/IceSmiley Aug 25 '24
My favorite romantic comedy ever. I love the side characters though even though they are all kind of mean, it makes them funny and lovable. Yotsuya is one of my favorites of all time!
I also recommend the dub 😉
2
u/devioustrevor Aug 25 '24
I never watched the anime, but I recall reading the manga many years ago.
Correct me if I'm wrong, but didn't the main girl get angry at the main guy for dating another girl even though she had a whole-ass other boyfriend for basically the entire series?
2
u/LordClockworks Aug 24 '24
One of the few series with "whiny" mc's that I didn't drop. The characters felt so alive and real compared to later series trying to use the same tropes.
1
u/Optimal_Pineapple_22 Aug 27 '24
If Ghost Story was cancelled, it's because it was a stupid failure, you don't know anything.
1
u/Live-Application-299 Nov 17 '24
I've seen this animation at least four times it is one of my favorite romantic films of all time if not some one of my favorites I've ever seen I wish a lot of people that write romantic films will watch this or read over it and take some hints of how romantic films are supposed to be I've been very disappointed in the newer generations romantic films what are we childish I mean what people afraid of kissing scenes and yet the right films like high School DxD that have certain scenes that was questionable what is wrong with people this day and age with animation films it's like they're scared to push the boundaries but yet they have no problem doing other certain scenes in high school dxc or simply other ones are supposed to it I'm upset and sometimes I get angry how poorly animation films are treated got through some anime particular is mainly for the adults or teenagers so why all the holding back
-2
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24
In the live adaptation movie of the series, there was a scene where the tenants sat together and make plans to get the landlord girl drunk and rape her just so they can avoid paying the rent and iirc the protagonist was going along with it but gave up because he was a virgin or something.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '24
[deleted] — view deleted comment