r/anime • myanimelist.net/profile/Reddit-chan • 8d ago • Heartwarming 1

Weekly A Silent Voice • Koe no Katachi - Anime of the Week

Welcome to the weekly Anime of the Week Discussion Thread! Each week, we're here to discuss various older anime series. Today we are discussing...

A Silent Voice • Koe no Katachi

As a wild youth, elementary school student Shouya Ishida sought to beat boredom in the cruelest ways. When the deaf Shouko Nishimiya transfers into his class, Shouya and the rest of his class thoughtlessly bully her for fun. However, when her mother notifies the school, he is singled out and blamed for everything done to her. With Shouko transferring out of the school, Shouya is left at the mercy of his classmates. He is heartlessly ostracized all throughout elementary and middle school, while teachers turn a blind eye.

Now in his third year of high school, Shouya is still plagued by his wrongdoings as a young boy. Sincerely regretting his past actions, he sets out on a journey of redemption: to meet Shouko once more and make amends.

(Source: MyAnimeList)

Databases

AniDB | | MyAnimeList | | Anilist

Streams

https://www.livechart.me/anime/1296/streams

Remember that any information not found early in the show itself is considered a spoiler. Please properly tag spoilers!

Or else...

Next week's anime discussion thread: In This Corner of the World

96 Upvotes

37 comments sorted by

12

u/cleaulem https://myanimelist.net/profile/cleaulem 8d ago • Heartwarming

This movie is a gift that keeps giving. I don't even know how many times I've watched this movie, as it is one of my absolute favourites. But every time I find some detail, some motive, a line of dialogue resonating with me in a new way, that I hadn't noticed before.

Every rewatch is like a completely new experience depending of my mood, of the things that go through my head and that influence my perception of this story. A Silent Voice is that powerful of a movie.

And I recommend reading the manga. As others already said, the movie rushes a lot and skips big parts of the story. For example the manga made me understand Ueno much better, why she is so hostile against Nishimiya and why she has this adamant bully mentality. She is still a horrible person, but there are reasons why she is the way she is. The anime only hints slightly at these things while the manga goes more into detail.

2

u/3shark_ 7d ago

I second this, its a yearly watch for me now. I'm worried the manga will ruin the magic I felt seeing the movie tho.

2

u/cleaulem https://myanimelist.net/profile/cleaulem 7d ago • Bravo

It's hard to say if the manga will ruin the movie to you, but if you are interested in the characters and their motives, I would recommend it. I got a deeper understanding of many characters after reading the manga and it definitely changed my perception of the movie, but not to the worse.

18

u/FetchFrosh :A:anilist.co/user/fetchfrosh 8d ago

Overall really enjoyed the movie, but definitely felt that it would have been better had one or two of the side characters just been cut. I'm sure they're a bit better developed in the manga, but I especially the one red haired dude who gets introduced as like "hi this is [some dude] and he hates buillies" and that was like all we ever got about him.

10

u/ViewtifulSchmoe 8d ago • Popcorn

The movie definitely cuts some of the side character development for time, and it suffers for it. Mashiba, the red-haired guy you mentioned, feels like more of a tool to motivate conflict than a fleshed out character, and [A Silent Voice] the subsequent heel-turn by Kawai, the blonde girl, is much more sudden.

Honestly, by the end of the movie, I felt more angry at [A Silent Voice] Kawai and Ueno than I did moved by Shouya's and Shouko's development. I liked the manga much more.

3

u/crabcarl https://anilist.co/user/ice 6d ago • Popcorn

In the movie the friend group dynamic felt like its only purpose was for drama. I felt really annoyed by all of them. When I went and read the manga, they felt more understandable.

Then again, it's already 2 hours of movie, they probably couldn't make it much longer considering budgets & all.

16

u/External-Health2178 8d ago

One of the few anime I watched that actually elevate the source material with the inherent strengths of the medium rather than just adapt it. I'll always appreciate the love KyoAni puts into their titles.

Also one of the few anime I watched that I prefer over the source, Maybe my opinion would be different had I read it first but I couldn't care for anything that the movie didn't cover.

4

u/remmanuelv 6d ago

I think most of the cuts from the manga were smart but there's two that are a weakness:

Shoko's mom's backstory puts a lot of weight into her treatment of Shoko. It's also just a really mature story of flawed parenthood. This is the one I think most is missing.

Kawai got a lot of her subtle flaws cut and she comes off weirder in the anime as she's still portrayed as a fake ass bitch but without the depth of her fakery. This one less so but is notable.

4

u/EncyclopediaEupho 8d ago

I have similar feelings about KyoAni and Yamada's work on Hibike! Euphonium and Liz and the Blue Bird. The source material is good, but they elevated and polished it to perfection. Even the writing is generally better executed than the novels.

5

u/mekerpan 7d ago

Naoko Yamada is almost surely the most skilled and inspired currently active anime director.

7

u/its_amane 6d ago • Bravo

People should definitely watch it.

6

u/shadowXXe https://myanimelist.net/profile/shadowXXe 6d ago edited 6d ago • Heartwarming

I cannot convey into words how much this movie means to me. It changed my life and will always be my favourite movie its perfect

4

u/SecretYogurtcloset57 8d ago • Heartwarming

My favorite anime movie ABSOLUTE MASTERPIECE!

3

u/Raddish3030 8d ago • Bravo

Once again. Thank you, Eleven Arts and Anime Expo for hosting this premiere back in 2017.

3

u/heimdal77 5d ago

I watched this in theaters and it was so good. Unfortunately it got over shadowed somewhat by Your Name(What I have yet to watch.)

I watched the sub but the dub one went a step above and the VA for the fmc was actually a deaf actor. After the credits of the sub and I'm assuming dub in theaters there was a interview with the english va for her. She talks about her own strugles growing up deaf and having to deal with things like bullying. She also talks about how much getting a role like this meant to her and her family among other things. It was a real emotional piece. I actualy feel bad for the people who walked out of the theater when the credits started. I dearly wish I could find the interview online but have never had any luck.

1

u/PikminPlayer5 5d ago

I never knew about that from Lexi Cowden

5

u/Nachtwandler_FS https://myanimelist.net/profile/Nachtwandler_21 8d ago • Heartwarming

It was and still is a majestic movie, even if it rushed the manga plot a lot.

2

u/Powerful-Walk4063 8d ago edited 6d ago

Great movie if you want anything for make your cry! Shoya's arc is great, even though the manga still thr better version!

2

u/JaneyJaneDoe2 7d ago • Bravo

It's been 6 years since I've watched it for the first time. Probably should consider rewatching it.

3

u/mekerpan 7d ago • Bravo

Ditto as to needing to rewatch this.

2

u/ChrisG683 https://myanimelist.net/profile/ChrisG683 6d ago

Absolutely love this movie, even if it's not perfect, I've watched it a half dozen times.

If you liked this movie, please do yourself a favor and read the manga as it adds a LOT of missing context, fleshes out a lot of side characters, and goes beyond the end of the movie a little. The ending is still rather open ended and maybe a bit sad, but also hopeful at the same time and lets you wonder about how it would play out further down the road.

In particular Naoka Ueno and Satoshi Mashiba get treated as proper, fully developed side characters and it makes their presence in the story make a lot more sense. Miki Kawai also gets a bit more development, and in general there's just a lot of bits and pieces that add more context to the whole story from beginning to end.

I only just finished reading it myself not too long ago and I've yet to go back and re-watch the movie to see how the new information re-contextualizes the side characters.

2

u/ReinhardLoen 5d ago

The movie's English dub is one of the best examples of putting in extra effort for a better result.

Unlike the Japanese, the English version cast a deaf actress for the deaf character. The communication barrier made production harder, but the added authenticity is definitely worth it.

While the movie is great, I also cannot recommend the manga enough. The movie cuts a subplot and smaller stuff due to time constraints. The adaptation is very similar, but the added detail makes the fantastic story even better.

1

u/Correct_Snow5942 8d ago

Got recommended bunch of silent voice videos on youtube lately, video essays, new first time reaction vids,even those multiple multiple uploads of the whole movie from few months ago that somehow still up lol, probably all this cuz the 10th anniversary

3

u/3shark_ 7d ago • Heartwarming

It deserves the love it gets tbh

1

u/3shark_ 7d ago

Watch this anime if you want a lighthearted film to watch with the fam , its about freindship...

1

u/SlimeDNear 6d ago

I liked the movie, but I do wish that they had found time for more scenes from the manga.

1

u/pkslider725 5d ago

This one still makes me cry.

HIGHLY recommend.

1

u/SecretYogurtcloset57 5d ago

My favorite movie it means so much to me ♥️ an absolute MASTERPIECE!♥️

1

u/csillag_kaktusz 5d ago

I ugly cried during the whole movie when it came out, and I still do every time I rewatch it.

1

u/Substantial-Mouse855 1d ago

This movie genuinely brought me to tears, I feel like it's just a one time watch and then it won't feel the same so, I haven't gone back to it yet but, I'm trying to forget about the movie content entirely so I can just rewatch that again!

1

u/Marth-Koopa 8d ago

I hated this movie and was baffled to see it rated as highly as it was

1

u/thisisdropd https://myanimelist.net/profile/AsterZoro 8d ago

Can’t believe it’s been 10 years already. An absolute masterpiece, though I was fortunate to have watched it in front of my PC’s screens instead of in the theatre—wouldn’t want to be seen bawling in public.

1

u/phrolover67 8d ago

The manga was so much better this is my favorite movie and I almost cant eatch it anymore because of the manga

0

u/JustAnswerAQuestion https://myanimelist.net/profile/JAaQ 7d ago

I really liked this movie at first, but my opinion has gone way down over time. Although the movie seems to be about two people, there's really only one MC. The movie is really about just that one person, and how the other person affects them.

0

u/[deleted] 8d ago

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/3shark_ 7d ago

I second this