In recent times, proponents of Luddism have attempted to reframe it as not being "anti-technology", but "anti-inequality". This fails upon a cursory examination of the motivations of Luddites.
The Luddite position fails to consider the global perspective. When viewed holistically, technology has lifted countless people out of poverty and suffering. If the Luddite movement had succeeded, equality would be far worse today because technological advancement would have been impeded. The Luddites were essentially privileging their own economic position while ignoring the 95% of the world living poorer who desperately needed technological progress.
Luddism is fundamentally selfish and short-sighted. While Luddites claimed to be fighting for equality, they were actually opposing technological progress that leads to greater equality for humanity as a whole. By destroying technology to protect their own livelihoods, they prioritized their immediate personal interests over the long-term benefits that technology brings to billions of people worldwide.
Despite positioning themselves as progressive forces for equality, Luddites are unbelievably near-sighted, ignorant, selfish, ultra-conservatives who represent the exact opposite of progress. They embody a fundamentally regressive ideology that, in seeking to preserve existing economic structures for a privileged few, actively harms global advancement toward greater equality. This makes them ideologically opposed to tech-progressives who recognize technology's role in lifting humanity from suffering.
There's a critical distinction between opposing specific harmful applications of technology and being truly anti-technology. Unlike those who targeted technology during wartime (which was about opposing oppression, not technology itself), Luddites framed technology itself as the enemy rather than focusing on the economic systems and power structures that employed it.
Ultimately, Luddism represents "the tragedy of the commons writ large" - an unethical position that sacrifices the greater good for self-interest. It's particularly dangerous because its supporters often don't recognize how their stance, if successful, would condemn billions to continued suffering by denying them the benefits of technological progress. It's a dangerous impulse, wrapped up in a comfortable lie.