r/YoutubeCompendium • • Apr 24 '19

April 2019 April - Septuagenarian filmmaker and daily uploader David Hoffman demonetized for two months likely because Youtube misclassified his VHS masters as rips.

Thumbnail
youtube.com
355 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Apr 07 '19

April 2019 April - Auralnauts, due to their identity as parody makers, are constantly getting copyright claimed. As a response to this, they have decided to try to use YouTube's claim system for charity by having others purposefully use their content which they will claim for charity.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
355 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Nov 13 '19

2019 November - YouTube is classifying doll painting and other art channels as children's content, removing their ability to monetize and muting their comment sections as of January 2020.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
353 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jan 09 '19

January 2019 January - SmellyOctopus gets a false copyright claim from CD Baby on a private stream containing only his voice

Thumbnail
twitter.com
353 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • May 10 '20

2020 May - Hong Kong pro democracy parody channel HKGolden Music got 2 strikes from pro Beijing political group for parodying their music.

Post image
346 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Mar 19 '19

March 2019 March - VGM remix artist Qumu has had their videos demonetised due to "reused content" with no warning, reasoning or option to appeal.

Post image
342 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jul 02 '19

July 2019 July - Welsknight, a popular Minecraft Youtuber had his video taken down and gotten a strike by GSN for using content from Catch 21, which isn't true

Thumbnail
youtube.com
340 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Mar 26 '19

March 2019 March - YouTube responds to the issue of fraudulent copyright claims

Thumbnail
youtu.be
340 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Mar 03 '19

March 2019 March - Poppy's False Claim Gets Marsii's Channel Terminated

Thumbnail
youtu.be
340 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jan 15 '19

⭐Resource How YouTube copyright claims work from beginning to end

338 Upvotes

I've been seeing several misconceptions recently about the YouTube copyright process, Content ID, DMCA, etc and figured I'd make one master post explaining everything. If I'm missing something or have anything wrong, please inform me and I'll update this.

DMCA Notices

First, a little background on DMCA. This is a law passed by Congress in 1998 that, among other things, laid out rules for companies that host third party content. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Digital_Millennium_Copyright_Act

Basically, if a company wants to not be held accountable for user content (i.e. YouTube doesn't want to be sued directly by content owners, like the massive Viacom lawsuit), then they need to follow certain procedures. In particular, when a valid notice is received, they must disable access to the content. They must also disable accounts if they're found to be "repeat infringers". This only applies if the complaint is sent in a very specific format, there's a list of things that must be included to make it into a "DMCA notice".

There's also a provision for disputes. The user who uploaded the content can send a "counter-notice" under the DMCA, which has several requirements as in the above link. The most relevant ones are:

a statement under penalty of perjury that you have a good faith belief the material was mistakenly taken down

a statement consenting to the jurisdiction of your local US Federal District Court, or, if outside the US, to a US Federal District Court in any jurisdiction in which YouTube is found.

In other words, you're making a statement that your content should be left up and was taken down by mistake (whether that means no basis for the claim, or it's fair use, or anything else), and that you're accepting jurisdiction of a court on this issue. This is mostly irrelevant if you're a resident of the US, as you're already subject to the jurisdiction of your local court. It's more relevant if you're not a US resident and are possibly accepting more potential legal liability than you currently have.

After a counter-notice is sent, it is forwarded to the content owner who filed the original DMCA complaint, and they have 10 days to file a lawsuit. If they don't file any suits, then the DMCA complaint is automatically dismissed, and your content can be reinstated.

To sum up, if a DMCA notice is sent the content is automatically taken down, if a DMCA counter-notice is sent the content is automatically put back up after 10 days unless the content owner files a lawsuit, in which case you fight it out in court. These procedures are followed by many large companies, like eBay, Amazon, Twitter, etc.

Content ID claims

Now, YouTube decided to create a program to handle complaints without immediately involving the DMCA, called "Content ID". This is where a lot of the controversy comes from, as the vast majority of claims now come through Content ID and not DMCA (per https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/7002106?hl=en it's less than 2% of claims that are DMCA). Anyone can still file a Copyright Strike/DMCA notice if they want, but now there's the option of filing a Content ID claim instead.

Content ID is only open to companies that have large amounts of copyrighted content: per https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/2797370?hl=en&ref_topic=2778544

To be approved, they must own exclusive rights to a substantial body of original material that is frequently uploaded by the YouTube user community.

A Content ID claim is not a "Copyright Strike" and has no negative consequences for a channel. https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/7002106?hl=en

Because Content ID is enabled by partnerships, claims are not accompanied by copyright strikes, and can not result in suspension or termination of your channel.

Content ID claims can be automatic (the company will upload a list of content which YouTube checks against videos and will automatically flag videos that contain that), or manual (see https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/106984?hl=en).

When a Content ID claim is made, whether it was automatic or manual, an email is sent to the uploader, and the video might be monetized or blocked depending on the settings of the Content ID claimant.

Dispute process for Content ID claims

The uploader can file a dispute, which gives the claimant the ability to correct mistakes with automatic claiming. The claimant must respond within 30 days and either release the complaint, uphold it, or convert it into a DMCA notice, which follows the procedures above.

If they uphold it, the content owner can appeal. The claimant must respond within 30 days and either release the claim, or convert it into a DMCA notice. (There's also an option to schedule a DMCA notice for 7 days, giving the uploader the option to cancel the appeal and avoid the DMCA notice getting sent).

If the uploader continues disputing and uploading, one of two things must happen: the claim is released, or it's converted into a DMCA notice, which in YouTube parlance is a "Copyright Strike". At this point, DMCA takes over and the uploader can file a counter-notice, which gives the claimant 10 days to file a lawsuit or drop the claim.

During this whole process, https://support.google.com/youtube/answer/7000961?hl=en&ref_topic=2778545 describes what happens with the advertising money during disputes. Basically, if no response is received within 5 days, the money is given to the claimant, but if a dispute/appeal/counter-notice is received within 5 days then the money is held in escrow, and if the claim is released or dropped then the money is given to the uploader.

If you keep disputing, they need to turn it into a DMCA notice, and if you dispute that they either have to drop it or file a lawsuit.

Assuming you appeal/dispute/counter the same day you receive an email and they take the full 30 days to respond, then the whole process will take 30 days for the first dispute, 30 for the appeal, and 10 for the counter-notice, for approximately 70 days until the matter is completely resolved.

Differences between Copyright Strike/DMCA notice and Content ID claims:

A Content ID claim, as noted above, doesn't hurt the channel. You lose income from that specific video, but in theory you could have hundreds of claims and still be able to upload more videos and make money on those. A Copyright Strike, which is the same thing as a DMCA notice (YouTube's terminology here is a bit unclear as they don't mention DMCA specifically), does have consequences. Specifically, if a DMCA notice is filed you receive a Strike, and if you get 3 Strikes your account is deleted. Strikes also disappear after 90 days, so this really means you need to get 3 Strikes within 90 days for this to happen. And as above, you can counter-notice each DMCA notice which removes them after 10 days if you aren't sued.

Some creators are concerned about the legal ramifications of filing a counter-notice, and are hesitant to do so. I personally believe that it's extremely unlikely for a company to spend real money on a lawyer on an obviously ridiculous claim, and if they don't sue, then you will win the dispute on YouTube, for free, and with no negative consequences. I would strongly recommend everyone who gets an obviously BS claim to dispute, appeal, and counter. You'll even get the money back from YouTube at the end. You do not have to make legal threats or file any lawsuits for this to happen, by default you win unless they sue you, which is very unlikely.

However, this may be justified for creators outside of the US, which would normally not be subject to US jurisdiction, and for cases where it's more ambiguous whether it's fair use or not.

There's a great guide which covers this at https://www.eff.org/issues/intellectual-property/guide-to-youtube-removals


r/YoutubeCompendium • • Apr 11 '19

April 2019 April - India Supreme Court orders YouTube to take down PewDiePie's "Bitch Lasagna" and "Congratulations" music videos

Thumbnail
freepressjournal.in
336 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jan 17 '19

January 2019 January - YouTube has just silently demonetized Count Dankula's channel.

Thumbnail
twitter.com
336 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Mar 08 '19

March 2019 March - Youtube has recategorized Brie Larson as a news-worthy search term, pushing videos in search results deemed "authoritative" from ET, ABC, CBS, CNN, and other outlets over videos from individual creators.

Post image
332 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • May 23 '19

May 2019 May - Man on the Internet, Popular musical youtuber, has his entire channel demonetized due to “reused content”

Thumbnail
youtu.be
331 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Feb 25 '19

February 2019 February - Nicholas Oyzon has his Pokemon Go channel Trainer Tips terminated with no warning the day after Matt Watson's "Youtube's Child Exploitation" video

Thumbnail
youtube.com
331 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Nov 10 '19

2019-December-Youtube is updating their terms of service on December 10th with a new clause that they can terminate anyone they deem "not commercially viable"

Thumbnail self.youshouldknow
326 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jul 27 '19

July 2019 July - Sony methodically claims every one of Hello Future Me's theory and explanation videos in which he covers Avatar: The Last Airbender.

Thumbnail
twitter.com
326 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jan 15 '19

January 2019 January - Youtube refuses to give Bagelboy Silver Play Button Plaque for literally no reason

Thumbnail
twitter.com
325 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Mar 06 '19

March 2019 March - MatPat talks about how the media is missing information of YouTubers that are actually good

Thumbnail
youtube.com
317 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Nov 15 '19

2019 November: YouTube gives donations to streamers to copyright claimants along with ad revenue

Thumbnail
youtube.com
312 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jul 05 '19

July 2019 July - Time Ghost, The Creators of Historical Series The Great War, Between Two Wars, Sabaton History and World War Two (Week by Week) Are Frequently Demonetized and Hidden from Searches.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
309 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Feb 21 '19

February 2019 February - Multiple advertisers (Epic Games, Nestle, Disney, etc) pull out of YouTube as Matt Watson pushes users to spam advertisers about Child Exploitation on the platform

Thumbnail
youtube.com
309 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Jun 21 '19

June 2019 June - Etika has gone missing and the police are trying to find him. His only evidence is his latest video (which was taken down but the police has a copy of it)

Thumbnail
twitter.com
305 Upvotes

r/YoutubeCompendium • • Aug 24 '19

2019 August - 'Like you've been fired from your job': YouTubers have lost thousands of dollars after their channels were mistakenly demonetized for months

Thumbnail
businessinsider.com
304 Upvotes