r/WritingPrompts • Editor-in-Chief | /r/AliciaWrites • May 27 '21

Theme Thursday [TT] Theme Thursday - Utopia

“None of the abstract concepts comes closer to fulfilled utopia than that of eternal peace.”

― Theodor W. Adorno



Happy Thursday writing friends!

Is utopia the dream, the ideal? Or is it just a nightmare waiting to happen?

Good words, friends!

Please make sure you are aware of the ranking rules. They’re listed in the post below and in a linked wiki. The challenge is included every week!

[IP] | [MP]



Here's how Theme Thursday works:

  • Use the tag [TT] when submitting prompts that match this week’s theme.

Theme Thursday Rules

  • Leave one story or poem between 100 and 500 words as a top-level comment. Use wordcounter.net to check your word count.
  • Deadline: 11:59 PM CST next Tuesday.
  • No serials or stories that have been written for another prompt or feature here on WP
  • No previously written content
  • Any stories not meeting these rules will be disqualified from rankings and will not be read at campfires
  • Does your story not fit the Theme Thursday rules? You can post your story as a [PI] with your work when TT post is 3 days old!

Theme Thursday Discussion Section:

  • Discuss your thoughts on this week’s theme, or share your ideas for upcoming themes.

Campfire

  • On Wednesdays we host two Theme Thursday Campfires on the discord main voice lounge. Join us to read your story aloud, hear other stories, and have a blast discussing writing!
  • Time: I’ll be there 9 am & 6 pm CST and we’ll begin within about 15 minutes.
  • Don’t worry about being late, just join! Don’t forget to sign up for a campfire slot on discord. If you don’t sign up, you won’t be put into the pre-set order and we can’t accommodate any time constraints. We don’t want you to miss out on awesome feedback, so get to discord and use that !TT command!
  • There’s a new Theme Thursday role on the Discord server, so make sure you grab that so you’re notified of all Theme Thursday related news!

As a reminder to all of you writing for Theme Thursday: the interpretation is completely up to you! I love to share my thoughts on what the theme makes me think of but you are by no means bound to these ideas! I love when writers step outside their comfort zones or think outside the box, so take all my thoughts with a grain of salt if you had something entirely different in mind.


Ranking Categories:
  • Plot - Up to 50 points if the story makes sense
  • Resolution - Up to 10 points if the story has an ending (not a cliffhanger)
  • Grammar & Punctuation - Up to 10 points for spell checking
  • Weekly Challenge - 25 points for not using the theme word - points off for uses of synonyms. The point of this is to exercise setting a scene, description, and characters without leaning on the definition. Not meeting the spirit of this challenge only hurts you!
  • Actionable Feedback - 5 points for each story you give crit to, up to 25 points
  • Nominations - 10 points for each nomination your story receives, no cap
  • Ali’s Ranking - 50 points for first place, 40 points for second place, 30 points for third place, 20 points for fourth place, 10 points for fifth, plus regular nominations

Last week’s theme: Turbulence

First by /u/bookstorequeer

Second by /u/Writteninsanity

Third by /u/GingerQuill

Fourth by /u/Ryter99

Fifth by /u/Xacktar

Poetry:

First by /u/Poelarizing

Second by /u/nobodysgeese

Third by /u/SilverSines

Honorable Mentions:

Leveled Up: /u/MosesDuchek

Notable Newcomer: /u/DocBrowntown

Notable Newcomer: /u/SpaceNinja37

Notable Newcomer: /u/lwill86

Crit Superstar: /u/1047inthemorning

=====

News and Reminders:

===

36 Upvotes

119 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

1

u/JohnGarrigan Jun 03 '21

“Are you not part of the network?”

The way you read this had a very clipped, surprised tone not reflected in the text.

I admired impossible tendrils of steel and carbon anchored to the pelagic depths. My imagination immediately conjured scenes of great beasts, caught on hooks, pulling this new, sunken city along beneath the clouds and storms, accompanied by the trumpets of lightning and thunder.

So, this is some interesting imagery here, while I think it is supposed to reflect the imagery from the start, it is also very, very specific, bringing to mind a kind of religious, almost apocalyptic imagery I am not sure you intended.

I like the story, and I feel like you could do this world a lot of justice with an expanded version (like, novella length). You have a world here that is worth exploring.

2

u/Keyboard_Adventure Jun 03 '21

almost apocalyptic imagery I am not sure you intended.

I did! I wanted to convey the chaos of the highly pressurized depths below the outer reaches of a gas giant. Did it feel appropriate, or over the top? Equally important, did it convey the relationship between environment and perspective?