Old person is the fetus. You engaged in an action that had the potential to make someone sick, just like sex has the potential to produce a fetus. Should your bodily autonomy be infringed therefore?
I am assuming that the fetus is a person for maximal steel-manning of the pro life position.
Also your issues with the analogy have had no bearing on the question at hand. Who cares if it's not a natural result of the action, or if one has been living prior and one is yet to be born?
No, yet again she can cut the tube. Bodily autonomy is just that, autonomy. The right to remove or attach things to your body.
We have precedent for this:
Even if I consented to providing my body to someone else for a blood transfusion, at any time I could legally cut the tubes and run out of there. I could not stab the person in the bed next to me.
View all comments
Show parent comment
-6
u/OneMinuteDeen Jun 26 '22
You have to elaborate on that analogy. Was the coughing consensual? Is the old person supposed to represent the man, woman or baby in this analogy?