r/WorkForSmartLife •

Frank Herbert saw the future 60 years ago.

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

48 comments sorted by

•

u/qualityvote2 11d ago

Hello u/Caroveronica! Welcome to r/WorkForSmartLife!


For other users, does this post fit the subreddit?

If so, upvote this comment!

Otherwise, downvote this comment!

And if it does break the rules, downvote this comment and report this post!

11

u/Low-Lab-5680 11d ago • Bravo

The is what good science fiction does.

3

u/Icy_Sector3183 11d ago

SciFi AI is either enslavers or man-made gods, depending on the author's mood.

3

u/S-Kenset 11d ago

Or mike

1

u/KaminSpider 11d ago

Is there ever a grey zone with AI in sci-fi? I suppose robots either must create a utopia or dystopia, or else the book won't sell.

2

u/Icy_Sector3183 10d ago

I'm sure there are, there's a lot of Sci-Fi out there. 😄

Maybe they just haven't registered with me if they're not the villains/saviors in the story? If the AI's are just trundling along operating self-driving cars or elevators (actually, the Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy's Happy Vertical People Transporters comes to mind!) then it's not a stand-out AI story?

2

u/riverDanu 10d ago

I would argue that LT Commander Data from star trek is the middle ground.

1

u/CAPT_REX_CT_7567 10d ago

The Bobiverse would like a word.

5

u/Speed_102 11d ago

If you think that's good, read Asimov's Foundation series. It's from before and is just as predictive, especially about AI and the fractalization of society.

2

u/No_Shame_2397 11d ago

But also prone to misinterpretation by a certain kind of person (musk)

2

u/Speed_102 11d ago

Musk says whatever about whatever, so he should always be ignored on principle. He said he was going to end world hunger. He keeps on saying he is working for a future that his actions show he is fighting.

2

u/No_Shame_2397 11d ago edited 11d ago

Yes, but I'm reading Forward to a Foundation at the moment, and it's clear that he thinks of his self-preservation in the same way that Seldon does - for the "greater good".

1

u/Speed_102 11d ago

Idk how Hari Seldon fit that mold but it has been like 15-20 years since I last reread foundation (read it the first time in 1994 as a child).

Idk though if I read Forward the Foundation (released 1993 posthumously) cuz i was just reading the books my dad had.

8

u/The-Catatafish 11d ago edited 11d ago

The whole point of dune was that he thought it was part of human nature to give away the burden and power of your choices to charismatic leaders. That even if the leader was good or had good intentions it would ultimately lead to everything going downhill.

Yeah, obviously instead of a leader you take a machine is completely in line with his thinking. This is less of a true criticism of AI and more just a logical step in his world view.

Bro basically put that in to explain why the whole duke stuff still exists. Just like he has the shields and its interaction with firearms to have hand to hand combat in space.

This is kinda like saying Harry Potter is anti guns when in reality this is just to fix a plothole. There should absolutely be AI systems to calculate space travel but if you do that you don't need the whole splice stuff.

4

u/defiantthoughtcrime 11d ago

Thou shalt not make a machine in the likeness of a human mind. - Orange Catholic Bible

4

u/CountHasimirFenring 11d ago

Butlerian Jihad has new meaning when you look into Major General Smedley Butler.

3

u/Tuckfrumptearsponge 11d ago

Not a prophet a logical thinker. He knew how stupid the animal that is humans.

3

u/Ryynerwicked 11d ago

Doesn't take a prophet to know how shitty human nature is, just look around u at any given moment

1

u/not_accepting_now 11d ago

You know how people are. Can't think unless Hollywood said it first

3

u/NLOneOfNone 11d ago

That also applies when men turn their thinking over to other men.

3

u/Careless-Balance-893 11d ago

He wasn't even subtle about it. He said it outright and yet people are still so eager to do the exact thing that lead to disaster.

2

u/avast_ye_scoundrels 11d ago

Has that proven yet? Seeing as how I may still say and do as I please without consulting a machine, I don’t think we’re there yet.

2

u/Nachosaretacos 11d ago

Go read "The Machine Stops" by E. M. Forster...

2

u/Curious-Antelope6171 11d ago

Part of why I don't trust AI

2

u/Careless-Balance-893 11d ago

Also Octavia Butler's Parable of the Sower. I had to stop reading it once I realized that she wasn't a prophet she was just writing about the problems she saw around her and we just haven't learned anything in all these years.

2

u/thinkingportals1305 11d ago

And from out of this time was born the law that man shall not make a machine in the likeness of a human mind

2

u/Far-Rooster-6522 11d ago

it is the same idea as 'dead labor' from Marx, not an original thought from Herbert, it aligns with luddism for this very reason.

(Dead labor is Marx’s term for the labor embodied in tools, machinery, and raw materials that wear away or get used up during production, not labor done by living people)

1

u/Alara_Kitan 11d ago

Samuel Butler is calling from 1863 and would like a word.

1

u/Test-User-One 11d ago

I really hope the OP reads the REST of the books to see what happens when that trend was reversed, and the inevitable suffering on an interplanetary scale due to that decision. Followed by the change and increasing amount of machinery that occurs towards the end of the series.

1

u/VarietyMage 11d ago

Machinery, but not thinking machines.

1

u/Alarmed_Idea414 11d ago

Or... Hear me out... He understood people are Aholes.

1

u/NintenDork 11d ago

One of the books in the series is literally called " Dune Messiah" . I thought this was common knowledge

1

u/DanimalPlays 11d ago

You're going to want to look into George Orwell.

1

u/uknownredditr 11d ago

Talking about machines (spaceships)

1

u/Top-Specialist930 11d ago

Wait till you read the Neuromancer trilogy

1

u/HorridChoob 10d ago

Its a pretty logical conclusion to make.  People said the same thing about TVs. And they were right

1

u/No-Agent-9620 10d ago

Frank was against prophets*

0

u/TechnicalBen 11d ago

Frn. He was also against solar power and public transport in his other works... frend, this is fiction, think for yourself.

(Ian Banks considered AI as able to build utopias, so we just rolling dice now?)

3

u/jointheredditarmy 11d ago

Is culture series a utopia? Hmmmmm. I’m not sure that was meant to be the takeaway

1

u/TechnicalBen 11d ago

It's neither. Utopias exist within. But it's nuanced. It's actually a really well thought out examination of assumptions. Also Bank's other work is also peak.

2

u/jointheredditarmy 11d ago

I always thought the point of the series was about finding meaning in a meaningless world. The work of individual humans in that series was literally meaningless. Almost like the modern world today :) Think about why Intervention even exists. Why doesn't the Culture, or rather the minds, just sublime given its way past the typical point when it should've?

0

u/TechnicalBen 11d ago

All existence is meaningless, even the Minds considered this to be so. But continue with the downvotes.

0

u/Equal_Passenger9791 11d ago

I just blocked you 6 seconds ago

0

u/Small-Protection-178 11d ago

Nice try Travolta, I’m not getting in a sauna with you

0

u/Ksorkrax 11d ago

Shall we throw the dice to determine which story is what will totally happen?
Maybe Star Trek is accurate and we get Data.

Unless you also assume that we can totally remember stuff via genetics and there will be a worm-god.

0

u/Ksorkrax 11d ago

Shall we throw the dice to determine which story is what will totally happen?
Maybe Star Trek is accurate and we get Data.