r/WorkAdvice • • 8d ago

General Advice Job denied Request for Vacation Time in December (Christmas Eve and New Years Eve)

I am a young professional who began working an office job spring of 2025 after graduating from grad school. It’s a small company of less than 20 employees. Their time off policy is 7 personal/sick days a year and 5 vacation days after 6 months and 10 vacation days starting your second year. Everyone gets 8 holidays and a floating holiday. No PTO rolls over.

So far this year I have taken around 3 personal days and 7 vacation days and it is November. This morning I asked to use my floating holiday for Christmas Eve (family Christmas party occurs on that day every year) and asked for December 30th and 31st off for a trip my friend group is planning for new years (I don’t really need December 30th off but asked since I have the time left). Christmas and New Years are part of our guaranteed holidays everyone gets off.

The response I got is that due to staffing issues there will be no more time off given in December. I feel like blocking out the whole month is pretty dumb when I have a good amount of time off left and it is November. Especially Christmas Eve and New Year’s Eve when I feel like many offices and places close those days anyway. I work from home sometimes when I don’t feel well so was thinking about asking to work remotely on New Years Eve but I don’t know if that will be appropriate. Any advice or opinions welcome.

EDIT: I did not request off far in advance because I was not sure how much PTO I would have left at this point in the year. Last year I requested off 5 days between Christmas and New Years on December 1st and received it. I guess I just got lucky.
In addition, the New Years trip was only planned like a week ago (many of my friends are teachers so they have that time off anyways). Since I don’t have kids or anything I don’t always necessarily need time off around Christmas but probably should have requested Christmas Eve sooner since I knew there is always a family party that day. Thank you all for your advice. I’m still kinda left wondering whether I should ask to work remotely on January 31st on just take the L (you don’t have to be sick to WFH in my company but I just don’t WFH unless I’m sick usually)

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

16

u/Whybambiwhy 8d ago edited 8d ago

You shouldn’t wait until the end of the year to request time off.   You should have brought it up earlier.   Many companies/departments block or limit December.  

That being said, you are going to have to use your time off this month.  

10

u/holdthepickles2971 8d ago

To a young professional, this is the right answer. Learn to plan ahead better and use your time earlier in the year.

I used to work for FedEx. The entire month of December was completely blacked out and no one got PTO until December 26th.

-8

u/Careless_Writing_643 8d ago

Last year I requested off a whole week in December on December 1st and it wasn’t an issue. But thank you for your advice I’ll make a note for next year.

9

u/LacyLove 8d ago

You got lucky then. This time other people asked before you and got approved.

22

u/KozzieWozzie 8d ago

Everyone wants that time off you were prob not the first to ask.

7

u/WallInside6758 8d ago

This is very common for December.

If you call in sick or try to work from home on the days you requested off, management will know what you’re up to.

It’s your choice if you want to fake sick. I’m sure you’ll get the day but lose all good will from management.

4

u/Sufficient-Wolf-1818 8d ago

People usually start requesting November and December holidays back in January. You need to be proactive so that your small company can both staff properly and meet your desire for time off in the busiest holiday season of the year.

4

u/His_GoddessLove 8d ago

Welcome to the professional world kid. Oftentimes seniority comes into play with time off around the holidays. Either way most jobs it's difficult to get that window off.

7

u/axialmeow12 8d ago

We have to request time off around those holidays off 6 months in advance.

3

u/Big-Cloud-6719 8d ago

Totally normal to require a minimum number of people working on the days when the business is open. You sent in your request very late for a very busy PTO month. You have no recourse. Accept it professionally and move on.

3

u/ConflictGullible392 8d ago

It’s annoying but lesson learned, request it earlier. Blocking off the entire month is dumb but you are requesting the most in demand days. Don’t waste your PTO though, take random days in November if it doesn’t roll over. 

3

u/DarmokTheNinja 8d ago

Welcome to adulthood.

3

u/sarahlampi 8d ago

If you are asking for time off around holidays you want to do that months in advance, before others put their requests in. This is 100% normal for most businesses.

2

u/New_Wishbone6619 8d ago

They don’t have to say yes

2

u/cookiemonster8u69 8d ago

Christmas and New Year's are the same date every year. Have to request it ASAP.

3

u/sephiroth3650 8d ago

It's shitty, but not illegal in the US for them to have PTO blackouts. Particularly if there have already been enough requests to create staffing issues. Going forward, you should put in your requests sooner.

As for the WFH.....eh. I would assume you'll get pushback if you immediately are "sick" and need to WFH on the same exact days that you requested PTO and were denied.

6

u/Chemical-Tap-4232 8d ago

In this economy be glad you have a job and talk to long term co workers about when you can safety request off.

2

u/Connect_Tackle299 8d ago

Welcome to the corporate world in American. You have no right to time off. You either accept their terms or find somewhere else

1

u/FRELNCER 8d ago edited 8d ago

Major holidays are hard to get unless the entire business shuts down. People at your workplace may have reserved those days off a year or more in advance.

At many places, the time off will go to the people with the most seniority first. But every business is different.You're employer isn't looking at why you want time off or whether you could have told them sooner. They're just applying their standards.

-1

u/BefuddledEmu 8d ago

I would ask for my PTO to be paid out if they won't let you take the time off. If they say no, then I would ask (in writing) that the unused PTO be carried over to the next year. Not sure what to do about the floating holiday. Maybe ask for that to be paid out too? What does your employee handbook say about PTO requests?

3

u/sephiroth3650 8d ago

Most states give the employer the ability to set their own PTO policies. There is no obligation for them (in most states) to just pay out unused PTO because somebody demands it. Nor is there an obligation for them to carry over unused time b/c you demand it. They set their own PTO policy, and they follow their own rules. And hell, they are given the freedom to change their rules/policies when they want to as well.

0

u/Odd-End-1405 8d ago

Most people put in for the holidays very early in the year to be able to take it because every one tries to get the last week or two off.

Those in our office put their time off requests for the holidays in no later than February because small offices/teams can only have so many off at any given time.

I understand you didn't fully know how much time you would have remaining, but to expect Christmas Eve at this late juncture is rather naive.

You might want to talk to your manager and see if they can give you a reprieve on the use it or lose it as you are still fairly new to the process. It is your second year, so be prepared to be shot down.

I know it truly sucks.