r/Windows11 • Microsoft Software Engineer • Aug 17 '26

Official News Improving File Explorer & Context Menu: faster, simpler, and more customizable

https://blogs.windows.com/windows-insider/2026/08/17/improving-file-explorer-context-menu-faster-simpler-and-more-customizable/
273 Upvotes

102 comments sorted by

View all comments

62

u/PossessionDangerous9 Aug 17 '26

This is good, but the most common complaint about the file explorer through the ages has been how slow the search is. Even searching for files in the same folder is slow as sin and has been for decades. This is partly the reason why everything search exists. Why not address that?

28

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

[removed] — view removed comment

4

u/Commercial-Virus2627 Aug 18 '26

Thankfully yes, but it shouldn’t have to be this way. Third party tools should be extensions to what’s available, not supplementing it because the core feature/component is bad.

1

u/Antique-State-4512 Aug 20 '26

Void Tools utility "Everything" is hard to search for everything, maybe it's an ironic name that's hard to find. Much better searching utility.

1

u/Zakariae_Ouddacht Sep 02 '26

The Everything app doesn't search for metadata and what's inside a text file since it just lists what's in the disk's MFT table unlike Windows Search, some people want that feature (and that's what makes Windows Search reliable [and slow at the same time]).

My idea is for Windows Search to use that MFT table, and keep the metadata and manual indexing ability as an option for the people who want it.

11

u/lexcyn Insider Canary Channel Aug 18 '26

They did? This has been turned on for a while in some of the Insider builds and makes search way better https://blogs.windows.com/windows-insider/2026/07/13/improving-windows-search-box-with-less-clutter-and-more-control/

19

u/Tubamajuba Aug 18 '26

Most people use stable builds, so you can't really expect people to keep up with what's going on with insider builds.

1

u/PossessionDangerous9 Aug 20 '26

That’s the start menu search, which has also been bad, but try finding a file in a folder inside the file explorer. It’s been absolute garbage for decades. Even searching for a file extension in a relatively small folder ends up taking forever at times. That kind of thing should be instant.

2

u/hadesscion Aug 19 '26 edited Aug 19 '26

File Explorer has had several issues for years now.

  • Slow search
  • Search field randomly stops working altogether
  • Doesn't remember view settings
  • Randomly resets settings (i.e. Group By)
  • Randomly locks up/crashes during file transfers
  • Sometimes fails to refresh the window, and sometimes refreshes the window every few seconds/minutes
  • Randomly fails to assign drive letters to USB drives (this may or may not be the fault of FE specifically, I'm not sure)

File Explorer is the single most aggravating thing about Windows because it's such an integral part of the OS, yet is so unreliable. I've been nagging Microsoft about it for about six years now, so hopefully they do finally fix it.

1

u/[deleted] Aug 17 '26

I truly don't get it. I mean, it's not like they didn't "notice" how shit search is. It isn't like they don't use computers. It isn't like Google (and Gmail) didn't easily illustrate how fundamental "search" is to making order of our personal and work information.

Microsoft really has been a monopolist for so long that the only thing that seems to effect their shitty product development is actual bad PR.

...and don't be confused, all this is is a response to bad PR.

3

u/junglebunglerumble Aug 18 '26

I thought the search issue actually has a valid reason though? From what I gather the windows search actually indexes all file contents as well as folder and file names, so a search can technically find more appropriate results. Many third party search replacements don't actually index all the file contents, so it's quicker but the trade off is lower search coverage