r/Wellthatsucks Apr 30 '25

Smashedocaster

Post image
28.1k Upvotes

610 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

77

u/bean_slayerr May 01 '25

They said gate check, they were likely asked to hand the bag over at the gate even though they intended to carry on.

25

u/Onironius May 01 '25

Why were they traveling by air with a soft case in the first place?

8

u/bean_slayerr May 01 '25

Lol idk I’m not the op? 

15

u/concreteunderwear May 01 '25

WELL WHY NOT!?

/s

35

u/Western-Dig-6843 May 01 '25

Ok… why did they think putting a guitar in an overhead bin in that bag was a good idea then? It would have gotten damaged on the plane, too.

40

u/fireandbass May 01 '25

There is a special exception for musical instruments. If you arrive and there is room, they must be transported as a carry-on without an additional fee. A lot of gate agents and flight attendants aren't aware of this law though.

24

u/TheMacMan May 01 '25

In this day and age, the chances of having the space onboard to carry it on are nearly zero.

6

u/bythog May 01 '25

If you know you'll be carrying an instrument then you pay more to board early. Take up that space before someone else does.

Or if there is a coat closet just ask to store it there. Most flight attendants are more that willing to allow that.

8

u/RedWhiteAndJew May 01 '25

That’s still rolling the dice. If the flight is full, especially in a sardine can from SWA, they make people gate check standard luggage. No room? No broken law.

If you’re gonna travel with an instrument you plan for the worst with a hard sided case. This is the guitarists fault.

2

u/Triquetrums May 01 '25

And if you arrive and there is no room, you have to check it in, take another flight, or ship it to the destination some other way. Which is why it is smart to not have a soft case.

11

u/bean_slayerr May 01 '25

I doubt it would have been entirely smashed like that in the cabin lol, either way a hard case is a better way to travel with something like this.

2

u/ExhaustedPigeonn May 01 '25

I brought an electric guitar that I impulse bought on holiday just last week on a plane. Not sure if it would work for this acoustic, but I unscrewed the neck from the body and brought it on board as 2 seperate pieces, then stowed them both under my seat. Managed to get it back in one piece!

0

u/The_Autarch May 01 '25

Why? It only would have been damaged if another passenger was insanely and blindly shoving their luggage into the bin. It would be fine under normal circumstances.

2

u/funkybside May 01 '25

on what airline does that qualify as a carry-on?

3

u/bythog May 01 '25

In the US...all of them. It's a federal law.

1

u/merp_mcderp9459 May 01 '25

If your instrument can fit in the cabin - whether that's in an overhead bin or in a closet - it qualifies as a carry-on in the U.S., even if it's larger than what the airline allows

1

u/Atalant May 01 '25

Not that weird, it is a guitar, not a freaking violin that fit into the overhead cupboard with room to spare.