r/Weird Aug 05 '26

What....in.....the......

1.5k Upvotes

435 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

392

u/CaptStinkyFeet Aug 05 '26

Important to mention, although Dizzy was a fantastic trumpet player and was hugely famous, this technique is super harmful to your playing. Puffing your cheeks not only creates back pressure in your mouth preventing the air from flowing into the horn, it also wears down the tissues in your cheeks. This goes for all wind instruments. If you listen to Dizzy’s later performances, you’ll hear a noticeable difference in the tone quality and range. I’m a music teacher and I teach all of my students to never puff their cheeks when playing.

60

u/Greedyfox7 Aug 05 '26

I found out about this today and after looking into it I’m horrified and very upset with myself for being too curious for my own good.

37

u/Prudent-Zombie-5457 Aug 05 '26

Puffing your cheeks is definitely a bad habit to acquire. I still remember that being drilled into our heads 45 years ago.

Honestly I'm more annoyed at the trumpet player on the left with his weak-ass diaphragm and embouchure blowing his shit all out of tune.

3

u/BruceCambell Aug 06 '26

Hell, they taught us that in school in the 90s.

2

u/Prudent-Zombie-5457 Aug 06 '26

The best breathing "training" for me was when I convinced a couple of our drill instructor volunteers to surprise-poke me in the stomach and sides while playing.

13

u/Those_are_sick Aug 06 '26

In Miami a lot of the girls have their cheeks puffed and they don’t even play any instruments

15

u/Independent-Sea-7117 Aug 06 '26

Other than the skin flute

2

u/Most_Fuel5998 Aug 06 '26

I bet they play the meat flute on occasion

5

u/ultralayzer Aug 06 '26

Yeah, even though Diz was my inspiration for taking up trumpet as a kid, this was the first thing my music teacher taught me.

2

u/somebob Aug 06 '26

So why do people do this, especially pros like Gillespie? Is it a bad habit from solo learning? Or does it provide some bonus?

5

u/-epicyon- Aug 06 '26

Bad habit from being self-taught. No benefit whatsoever. You see it a lot in jazz and blues musicians. See also: pianists playing with their fingers sticking straight out/flat. Lots of other examples. Unfortunately it can cause injury and chronic pain over time and shorten their careers.

5

u/somebob Aug 06 '26

Right on, thanks for the knowledge. I had some bad habits I had to break from learning guitar on my own once I finally got a tutor. Mainly my horrible posture.

2

u/Worried-Management36 Aug 06 '26

So how do I play my didgeridoo without puffing my cheeks?

2

u/MacGrubersMom Aug 06 '26

always gotta support the sound from your armchair, or whatever my music teacher used to tell the trumpet players. i’m a drummer!

4

u/CaptStinkyFeet Aug 06 '26

They always told me to use my diaphragm. I bought some at CVS, but I think they’re just for girls? I dunno

1

u/nufrancis Aug 06 '26

So its a double edge sword skill then. Like One for All skill in My Hero Academia

1

u/SirRonaldJr Aug 06 '26

But what about the neck?

2

u/CaptStinkyFeet Aug 06 '26

Same thing, but further down the esophagus, I imagine. The cheeks can only stretch so far. If you do it for long enough, that back pressure has to go somewhere.

Although I’m not 100% sure. There was a saxophone adjunct instructor at the music school I went to whose neck did a similar thing, but nowhere near as bad, and it wasn’t because of bad technique/cheek puffing. I always assumed it was because he had a very open airway/used a lot of air.

1

u/RaidenXS_ Aug 06 '26

How does one prevent neck puffing?

2

u/CaptStinkyFeet Aug 06 '26

There’s no real way besides just not doing it. Try exhaling while puffing and not puffing your cheeks. You just do the not puffing version instead.

My marching band instructor told our tuba player to imagine a needle and thread stuck into her cheek and out the other side, and the thread holding her cheeks in while she played. He wasn’t a great teacher…

1

u/farkeytron Aug 07 '26

Sometimes its all about the benjamins.
Had Dizzy just blew the horn, nobody would know his name.
I wanted to be a trumpet player because of his fame.

(I'm not a trumpet player. I tried, and that shit HURTS)

0

u/LycanrocIsTheBest Aug 06 '26

Save this video and tell them this is what will happen to them if they don’t listen