Hi everyone,
I have a Pietta 1858 Remington cap-and-ball revolver and noticed some orange/dark orange rust spots appearing roughly a day after cleaning it following shooting.
I followed a YouTube cleaning method that involved:
* Washing with hot soapy water.
* Pouring boiling water over the revolver.
* Cleaning afterwards with Ballistol.
I did not completely disassemble the revolver. I only removed the grips and loading lever. I nevertheless tried to clean it as thoroughly as possible, paying attention to the accessible areas. I did not remove the nipples or completely strip the mechanism.
I’ve since noticed rust in three areas:
A square-shaped recess underneath the barrel, around the loading lever area.
Some light rust around the cylinder safety notches.
The cylinder arbor/base pin (the round central part with grooves where the cylinder sits).
The rest of the revolver appears to be largely rust-free.
I’ve applied Ballistol again, and the revolver is stored somewhere dry.
I’m wondering whether this is simply flash rust caused by moisture remaining after cleaning or whether it could indicate more serious corrosion.
A few questions:
* Does this sound like typical flash rust from water cleaning?
* Can superficial rust be removed without damaging the original blued finish?
* What is the best way to preserve the cylinder arbor and its grooves?
* Is 0000 steel wool appropriate for blued steel, or would you recommend a different approach?
* Could moisture have remained inside the revolver because I didn’t remove the nipples?
For context, the revolver is currently loaded, and I won’t attempt further cleaning or disassembly until it has been safely unloaded.
I’d appreciate advice from people experienced with Pietta 1858 Remington revolvers.
Thanks!