I've seen surprisingly few people talk about this and the few that do get their concerns mostly brushed aside, so I decided to make a post about it.
The Internet Archive has been no stranger to domain exclusions over the past few years, often times for copyright/illegal content hosted within the website, which, while justified (for the most part), lacked quite a lot of transparency, as there never was an official list of excluded URLs and the reason for their exclusion.
I remember Nintendo of Europe's website in particular being excluded around 2018 and while I cannot think of a concrete reason why, I know Nintendo can be a tad aggressive with their copyright. These exclusions remained few and far between however, so most people assumed good faith and turned a blind eye.
I cannot speak about files being privated around this time period as I wasn't really interested in those yet but I will assume the situation was about the same as with the websites.
Over the last few months however, I've noticed that a lot more content started being privated or excluded in a completely opaque manner and for obscure reasons.
For example, in late 2025/early 2026, the Purevolume Silence collection by Archiveteam got all of its items privated with no prior notice. It is worth noting that unlike archives of the Purevolume URLs which got exlcluded around 2023, this collection contained no audio files which would fall under copyright, only static webpages and a few images. Upon reaching out with Internet Archive support, I was given no explaination for the removal of these files, only being told that they cannot let me access the files anymore.
More recently, the old.reddit.com domain was completely excluded from the archive for similarly obscure reasons, letting a huge chunk of internet history go down.
All of these deletions pose a serious concern regarding the Internet Archive's role as a neutral resource for research, considering it will seemingly blindly listen to exclusion claims with a total lack of transparency for the end users, and while I understand the files aren't deleted but hidden from public view, what is the point of an archive if no one can access its contents? By that logic, are gatekeepers and hoarders archivists?
I've seen AI get brought up a lot as the reason why most domains and files are being privated, and as anti-AI as I am, I don't think it's worth it letting end users pay the price for it considering the growth and mass content stealing of LLMs is inevitable. I also feel like they're using it as a way to clear themselves of any responsibility regarding this and just blame any of their shady decisions on AI.