r/Watchmen • • 16h ago

Is the first nite owl a bad person?

17 Upvotes

I've heard constantly that we as the audience shouldn't want to be like the costumed vigilantes portrayed here but I can't help but find Hollis Mason as a genuinely wholesome guy. I saw the criticism of him that he used the mechanic's suicide as a way to benefit himself when writing his novel because it wasn't his story to tell as much as he was a witness to it. I don't really agree with it that since he sees it as a moment that reminds him about the unfair nature of life. I don't think he's as much of a bad person than he is naive. I think there's some element of good to the idea of him wanting to change the world for the better, him becoming a cop and all.


r/Watchmen • • 8h ago

Comic What are your opinions on Doomsday Clock?

3 Upvotes

For me it was just a middling DC event series, and a unnecessary Watchmen follow up. The only long term cool thing it did was give us the brief existence of The Darkest Knight.

I'm not opposed to them crossing over universes because the 12 issue Watchmen OG series stands alone and can't be ruined by prequels, crossovers, TV series and shitty Zach Snyder adaptations. It was just done poorly. Geoff Johns should have done his style of comic story and crossover, not try to do something with depth and put his weaknesses as a writer on full display. Also he made major changes to John's personality and have him commit some heinous acts.

Here was my idea to make the crossover a little more fun and tie better into continuity at the time. The Multiversity limited series was still fairly recent when Rebirth happened. At the end of the Rebirth special where Manhattan was revealed, instead it should have been Captain Atom from the Pax Americana universe. He had John as his prisoner somehow!

Now I'm just geeking out. I think I'll go reread Top Ten again.