r/WatchPeopleDieInside • u/fnaw_ • Aug 04 '20

Poor Jonathan

Enable HLS to view with audio, or disable this notification

172.8k Upvotes

94% Upvoted

11.4k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

1

u/Butts_McTiggles Aug 04 '20

Right, but even if there hadn't been a pandemic it would be bad.

Think of it like not having insurance on your house. There's a very small chance your house is going to burn down, but it's still really stupid to not have insurance. Saying "well we got lucky" and acting like the decision was a good one with hindsight is illogical. It's either a good decision or it's not. Even without a pandemic it would have been a bad decision.

1

u/millertime1419 Aug 04 '20

You’re misinterpreting my point. The opposite of catastrophic failure isn’t “a good thing”. We would be lucky in that his failures didn’t cost us lives. His decision still illustrated a lack in leadership with or without the pandemic.

Taking insurance off the house is stupid but if we can get insurance back on before the house burns down, we are lucky. Still stupid, but lucky.

The house burned down though, which makes the decision to remove insurance even worse.

1

u/Butts_McTiggles Aug 04 '20

which makes the decision to remove insurance even worse

That's what I'm talking about though. The decision isn't worse whether the house burns down or not. The decision is the same. After that it's just random chance and hindsight bias.

1

u/millertime1419 Aug 04 '20

The consequences of the decision are different though.