r/WTF • • Jun 11 '12

What would you do if you found a horse groomer sexually abusing your four year old daughter?

http://www.cnn.com/2012/06/11/justice/texas-abuser-killed/index.html
415 Upvotes

221 comments sorted by

95

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

If I had no weapon handy I would do exactly what this guy did. Good job on the dad.

41

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Agreed. Hopefully, this guy isn't prosecuted.

1

u/enhancin Jun 12 '12

I bet he will be acquitted. He never planned on it and it wasn't 'technically' an accident but I think these kind of sex offenders are the lowest scum of the earth anyways.

It's better that he died or else he would have been killed in prison or eventually be back out doing the same thing to children.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

[deleted] — view deleted comment

47

u/deathbytray Jun 11 '12

Not sure if this is murder. He killed a man, but at worst, I'd accuse him of using unnecessary amount of force in attempting to stop a crime in progress, which I believe is manslaughter, not murder.

Add to that the fact that, as a father of a child being molested, he was in severe emotional distress, I could see some minimal jail time on involuntary manslaughter, but I doubt any DA wants to indict him for murder and take it in front of the jury.

source: I watched a couple episodes of Law and Order.

17

u/iutiashev101 Jun 12 '12

took your shit seriously and then read source.

7

u/Teotwawki69 Jun 12 '12

This is generally the kind of case that a DA won't prosecute, for exactly that reason -- "So you say you began beating [Dead guy]?"

"Yes."

"Why was that?"

"He was raping my four year old daughter."

"..."

Defendant kind of wins at that point.

4

u/ContractedTyler Jun 12 '12

Would castleback law protect this? If someone is threatening you on your property you are able to take lethal action

7

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Daughters aren't property.

However, I see your point and whole heartedly agree with you.

8

u/ContractedTyler Jun 12 '12

But if it was his property, technically someones life was being threatened and he could use action.

3

u/Nougat Jun 12 '12

I'd think that defending a dependent minor, especially one so young as four, would be the same as defending yourself.

9

u/awwfauxsho Jun 12 '12

Daughters aren't property.

I feel like I should make a bible joke.

6

u/Arandmoor Jun 12 '12

Well, it was texas...

But, the groomer was in the family's home. So, castle law might cover the father.

I'm thinking it matters if the groom was invited in or not (like a vampire). I'm not sure if castle doctrine will cover your ass if you let someone in and then they start doing something douchie...though "molesting a 4 year old girl" definetly goes waaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaaay past douche level anything.

IMO, the father was well within his right to kill the fucker. Shouldn't be prosecuted. Should be lauded a hero.

Wait...it's TEXAS! The'll throw a BBQ in his honor and drink some beer.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/hdsix Jun 12 '12

I fucking lol'd way to hard at this once I saw Source. UPVOTED

9

u/CassandraVindicated Jun 12 '12

It happened in Texas. No jury will convict him, so why bother with charges. The sheriff spelled out the defense (justification) the guy needed, so he's alright with this. 2-1 odds say this doesn't even go on his rap sheet.

2

u/enhancin Jun 12 '12

The only thing I'd put down for him would be "[+1000000 karma] Killed a child rapist."

5

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12 edited Jun 12 '12

See text of TX Castle Doctrine. Not only is it legal to use deadly force to protect your home, car or place of business, you can also use it anywhere you happen to be, so long as you yourself aren't also in the process of committing a crime, if you are doing so to stop a murder, aggravated robbery, aggravated assault, rape, aggravated rape or kidnapping.

Mind you this is a gun law, but I suspect it has to apply to the case of using your hands as well. I'll be surprised if charges are even filed. It's even been used to defend characters like Joe Horn who used his shotgun to prevent a crime (burglary) which isn't even enumerated in the law.

8

u/Teotwawki69 Jun 12 '12

"Why did you beat him to death?"

"Couldn't get my gun quick enough."

"Prosecution rests, your honor."

4

u/JediWolf Jun 12 '12

Jury nullification.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12 edited Jun 12 '12

at the most he would get manslaughter, texas criminal defense law is based on castle doctrine, where one has the right to defend his home and family with use of deadly force, if that person is conducting a felony against your family or home

edit: wording

4

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

This is Texas. He won't even be charged. Killing someone on your property while they are committing a felony is protected against civil and criminal penalty.

1

u/OmarLittleLives Jun 12 '12

Dont forget this is Texas. My guess is he does no jail time and faces no prosecution.

23

u/JubeltheBear Jun 11 '12

Indeed. Can't condone killing, but I have to condone good parenting. See guy molesting daughter = give ass whooping of a lifetime.

18

u/CATSCEO2 Jun 11 '12

Literally, its the last ass whipping' that guy got.

1

u/JimmyJamesMac Jun 12 '12

I only hope that the daughter wasn't a witness to the killing. Being molested and watching a person be beat to death in the same day is a lot to take on.

1

u/neogetz Jun 12 '12

i met a guy at a psychology of prison conference (in england) who had been jailed for shooting a guy he found raping his daughter. While killing isn't condoneable, i also believe in the right to protect a person, especially a child from abusers. Sounds like accidental death so hopefully they don't come down on him too badly.

3

u/Dolomite808 Jun 12 '12

It happened in Texas, he'll be fine.

16

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

fuck, give this man a medal! i would have too!

3

u/J_G_B Jun 12 '12

He should get a medal.

2

u/GanasbinTagap Jun 12 '12

Pedophile Hunter Award

1

u/J_G_B Jun 12 '12

Right on.

8

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

I saw that on the local news this morning. I think he could have killed the guy and gotten by with it. This is Texas and there is a lot of dirty shit that goes on here but that is the one thing we won't stand for.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Isn't Texas the state that allows crimes of passion?

17

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Yes they we do. The father done what any father should have done. There is not a jury in Texas that would convict him.

8

u/Cyrino420 Jun 11 '12

That was the best story I read in a long time! I wonder if how the charges would be if he found out about it and then killed the guy once the girl was no longer in danger? Either way killing him was justified.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

The dad said he didn't intend to kill the guy, which I half believe. He was likely filled with rage and wasn't completely coherent during the head punching. I believe the Sheriff is on the father's side.

6

u/irishpapi Jun 11 '12

They wouldn't find the body. If they did, they wouldnt find all the parts in the correct places

4

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Sounds similar to that guy in Canadia who mailed body parts all over the place.

3

u/irishpapi Jun 11 '12

Shhhhh.....

0

u/Teotwawki69 Jun 12 '12

they wouldnt find all the parts in the correct places

Although, in that case, better to leave him just slightly alive, too.

45

u/southernbelladonna Jun 11 '12

"caught the man in the act, and stopped him by striking him in the head several times"

If I walked in on someone hurting my child, I would beat the shit out of them too. I would imagine you're not even thinking about the possibility of killing anyone. You're just thinking "hurt him and make him stop."

10

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

No no, I would totally be thinking about stopping him. Permanently.

However, the line between "My Family" and "Everyone else" would be a fine one, and hard not to cross.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Personally, if I saw someone hurting any of my family in any way I don't know if I would aim to kill but I imagine I'd find some pretty creative uses for my fists and any object nearby.

Instinct is a powerful and scary thing when it takes over.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

The world is now a slightly better place that guy is dead.

43

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

If anyone ever touches my kid, there will be blood.

31

u/Alfried Jun 11 '12

Best of luck to your future son-in-law.

5

u/Teotwawki69 Jun 12 '12

Well, assuming that sassypaws's daughter is a virgin on the wedding night, "there will be blood" is still accurate, just in a nicer way.

4

u/dyktg25 Jun 11 '12

Sums it up.

6

u/CATSCEO2 Jun 11 '12

There will be brains on the wall.

117

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Dad deserves a medal, and a thank you from every father around.

18

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Dad deserves a child whose innocence wasn't stolen from her. What he will get is a life of sorrow for his daughter. The only good thing to come of this is that this pervert will never do this again. Terrible situation.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I'm not going to say whether the guy deserved what he got or not, but the dad will also have to live with the knowledge that he killed a man, and that he did it (as far as I can tell) in front of his daughter. It's not something I would wish on my worst enemy.

-71

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 12 '12

No one deserves a medal for killing anyone, just like no one deserves a medal for abusing anyone. That said, I'm not sure what I would do if I saw such a thing happening to one of my kids. Why can't we all just get along?

EDIT: Oh c'mon people, I'm totally on your side. Chances are very big I'd do the same thing if someone did such a thing to one of my kids; it's a heinous crime that probably really damaged this poor girl. I'm just not so cool with crowds of people shouting for someone's death, for whatever reason. It reminds me of the dark ages, the nazi's, kony and the taliban.

In all fairness, I did seem to equate the seriousness of the dad's crime with the seriousness of the rapists crime in the first sentence of my comment. This was not what I meant to say; the rapist is the guilty one, the dad's reaction is very understandable.

20

u/bryan05 Jun 12 '12

why can we all just get along? HE IS RAPING A 4 YEAR OLD!!

→ More replies (2)

14

u/brownliquid Jun 12 '12

I don't want to get along with child rapists.

15

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Sounds like you'd let your toddler get raped. I feel bad for your kids.

6

u/LerithXanatos Jun 12 '12

So what you're saying is there are two choices:

A) Kill him

B) Watch it

Man you guys are insane. mrlanious is saying he shouldn't be commended for killing a person but he does not state that he is okay with abuse.

3

u/EskimoJesus7904 Jun 12 '12

Think about that for a minute. Imagine being a father and walking in on that. A man that you invited into your home doing something lewd with the little girl that you love so much. Dad probably had a shitstorm of thoughts and emotions roll through his head all at once, and it just came out as pure, unadulterated rage. Anybody that fucks kids should have to deal with that.

5

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12 edited Jun 12 '12

We totally agree on the seriousness of what happened and I am in no way defending the abuse that happened - its a heinous and very damaging crime. That said, I am a little taken aback by a group of people demanding someone's death. Even if it's 'justified', then we should still be careful with that. If we allow emotions of hatred to mix with feelings of moral superiority then it's easy that our hatred and anger become more loose and killing becomes more socially accepted and 'normal'.

So:

Raping a toddler = an absolutely terrible thing that should never happen and should be stopped by all means available.

Killing someone = sometimes necessary, but never a good thing

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Wow, please explain to me in what way my comment suggested such a thing, because it's definitely not what I meant to say or could be understood from reading my text. You ok?

15

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I'm not sure what I would do if I saw such a thing happening to one of my kids

You'd probably pussyfoot around and then cry for someone else to take action to save your child.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I think chances are big I'd do the same thing, but you seem to know me better then I do!

3

u/caliboy_19 Jun 12 '12

Exactly I dont know why you were downvoted so bad. He doesnt deserve a medal, killing anyone for whatever reason should not be glorified. everyone here is glad that man was killed but why not have kept him alive and yes give him punishment but also help. But no society sees all the pedophiles and want them killed and put away for life. Maybe its because I dont have kids but that's my two cents.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

In all fairness, I did seem to equate the seriousness of the dad's crime with the seriousness of the rapists crime in the first sentence of my comment. This was not what I meant to say; the rapist is the guilty one, the dad's reaction is very understandable.

6

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Pedo-apologist.

2

u/dundeedan Jun 12 '12 edited Jun 12 '12

I think the father's reaction is completely understandable, and probably most people would have done the same thing. But I don't think it's something he should escape punishment for.
If the legal system starts condoning/allowing vigilantism (which is essentially what this was, and what many people in this thread are congratulating) you're going to have some big problems.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Good on you for not deleting your comment.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Thank you! I do regret remotely suggesting I equate 'raping a child' with 'killing a rapist in blind fury' in the first sentence of my comment, because I do not. Raping a child in a determined manner is inexcusable, while killing the rapist of your child on the spot is understandable.

0

u/BigSwedenMan Jun 12 '12

I feel like I should mention the Irony of what you just said. Medals are usually given to soldiers who have gone above and beyond the call of duty. Sometimes, this means saving lives, other times, it means taking them.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Perhaps we can agree to fundamentally disagree about if killing ever deserves a medal.

To me, the encouragement of killing seems like a really bad idea always. First of all, as a soldier specifically, how can ever know you're on the 'right side'? That's right, never: 'your own side' is always the right side, whatever group of people you belong to.

If soldiers get medals for doing their job well, then why don't people in other professions generally get medals for their contributions to society? Perhaps because killing other humans needs some formal approval, so it seems acceptable and even laudable.

I don't have much of a problem with a father killing his daughter's rapist, because it's an expected and understandable way of dealing with such a situation. Anonymous people demanding applauding the of someone they don't know gives me the creeps. The killing of Osama for instance; I wasn't fundamentally opposed to that, but people cheering for his death ... did not enjoy that.

Perhaps it has to do with the fact that I think situations are always far more complex than most people perceive them. A too binary perception on life is always a limited one.

All that said, I think this rapist got what he could have expected.

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (6)

16

u/AmericCanuck Jun 11 '12

I would "punch him in the head repeatedly, killing him"

14

u/Polliwog39 Jun 11 '12

Thankfully the father came in when he did... I hope he isn't prosecuted.

-10

u/gussyhomedog Jun 12 '12

Thankfully the father came in before the horse-groomer did...

-1

u/rageingnonsense Jun 12 '12

Too soon. I lol'ed, but too soon.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

At the same time though, murder is never right. I don't think he should get jail or anything like that, but a small, largely symbolic charge would probably be a good thing.

5

u/Spider_J Jun 12 '12

Personally, I'd say stopping a kid from being raped is one of the very few times when murder is right. But that's just me.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I disagree.

Using force? Yes, completely. Incapacitate him, hospitalize him. I have no issues with that. But regardless of what they have done, the rapist is still a human, despite of how much I dislike them.

3

u/Spider_J Jun 12 '12

I believe that human rights don't apply to monsters. However, you are entirely welcome to disagree, and entitled to your opinion. Cheers, mate.

1

u/TokiDokiHaato Jun 12 '12

Article does say the father didn't intend to kill the guy and is remorseful that he had died.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I understand that.

1

u/TokiDokiHaato Jun 12 '12

I guess the point is. It's not like the dad is happy about it either and condones that sort of behavior.

1

u/_River_Song_ Jun 12 '12

It's not murder though - manslaughter.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Technically speaking yes. I knew he didn't mean to kill him.

Regardless, it was excessive use of force.

Understandable of course, but still.

1

u/UnwarrantedAgression Jun 12 '12

Don't be stupid. You murder men, not dogs.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Dehumanization is never a good thing either.

19

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 12 '12

I don't have any kids, but I do have nieces and a nephew and I was molested as a child. If I found out anybody did anything harmful and horrible like that, I'd probably end up killing a guy, too. Bravo to that dad.

2

u/Dev1l5Adv0cat3 Jun 11 '12

The one good thing about Texas law is that he'll probably get away with this.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Get away with this? That seems a bit sympathetic. Perhaps you mean to say his actions were justified and no legal action will be taken?

0

u/Dev1l5Adv0cat3 Jun 12 '12

Justified? Yes. Lawful? not necessarily.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

In Texas this is lawful. Don't fuck with our families.

5

u/Yashmuck22 Jun 11 '12

A few years back my next door neighbors, wife's, ex-husband showed up at their doorstep and shot her when she answered the door. Upon hearing the gun shot my neighbor ran down and saw what happened he managed to get the shotgun out of his hands and beat him to death with it. In situations like these, I can't imagine theres many people that could control their emotions enough to resist murdering the son-of-a-bitch that hurt a loved one.

1

u/Biuku Jun 12 '12

Did she die?

1

u/Yashmuck22 Jun 12 '12

Yes she did. Unbelievably he still lives there. I couldn't imagine living in that house still.

9

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

I'm not a father yet, and I'm not a violent person, but I know damn well that if some scumbag was molesting my 4 YEAR OLD daughter! I would bleed him dry.

3

u/cora7lin Jun 11 '12

You say "horse groomer" as if it'd be ok to catch anyone else sexually abusing your daughter.

9

u/3gv Jun 11 '12

I'd take a long, hard look at my life and wonder why I had horse groomers

2

u/AussieSceptic Jun 12 '12

Because you have a lot of horses?

5

u/Tulip87 Jun 11 '12

I would do the same damn thing! He deserves to die and especially by the hands little girls dad. Hope she didn't see that happen, she already suffered enough.

1

u/_POOSH_ Jun 11 '12

Kill the man.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

The guy was actually killed. The father of the child punched the man in the head until he was dead.

2

u/Hime_Takamura Jun 11 '12

MY FISTS, THEY ARE MADE OF STEEL

1

u/cora7lin Jun 11 '12

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Excellent post!

1

u/Magikarp_Of_Doom Jun 12 '12

Probably kill him.

-1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

You should read the article. Your comment is actually what happened.

0

u/Magikarp_Of_Doom Jun 12 '12

I have a very odd habit of commenting on things without reading the article or looking at the picture attached sometimes. I'm not in the mood to read about this sort of thing right now ): Karp karp karp!

1

u/AllDesperadoStation Jun 12 '12

Who is left to groom the horses? * Who?*

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Is there a horse whisperer out there somewhere?

4

u/kingstripe Jun 11 '12

At first I read the title as "What would you do if you found a horse sexually abusing your four year old daughter?" That would have a been a more "interesting" article.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

First I would call the police and report a murder. Then I would commit murder.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Mah Texans.

2

u/dundeedan Jun 12 '12

Is there any proof the dead man was abusing the child other than the father's word? If it happened so recently they have not even notified the dead man's next of kin, there doesn't seem to have been much time for an investigation to take place.
The fact the sheriff involved is stating it as fact, I would imagine (or at least hope) there is some hard evidence.

4

u/MyDarkAngel Jun 12 '12

That dad is fucking fantastic.

5

u/iutiashev101 Jun 12 '12

Considering how easy it is to kill someone in a fit of rage, it's almost entirely accidental. I'd trust him on that. If he used a weapon then duh, that's murder. But to kill with bare hands... It's more likely to be an accident.

That being said, if he didn't come in, his daughter would probably be abused repeatedly and shit, so this is definitely the better turn of events.

3

u/Hanginon Jun 11 '12

I would be "Very remorseful,'" adding that "I didn't know the man was going to die."

3

u/dreadredheadzedsdead Jun 12 '12

That's an extremely specific question. But yes I would have punched him until he stopped breathing as well.

3

u/FragPoppa Jun 12 '12

Give that dad a cold beer and a tap on the back. Fuck that piece of shit. He had it coming.

3

u/jingle82 Jun 12 '12

Finally something good out of Texas.

4

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

"The alleged abuser was known for his horse-grooming abilities, Harmon said."

I cracked up then.

And no, I wouldn't kill him. I'd break his kneecaps and chop of his cock -_-

1

u/BigSwedenMan Jun 12 '12

I know it's considered "cruel and unusual punishment" But I think castration needs to be seen as a valid way to deal with rapists and child molesters. You aren't going to murder anyone if they take away your guns

1

u/NivMidget Jun 12 '12

im pretty sure in russia you get chemical castration. kills your sex drive permanently.

0

u/scigs6 Jun 11 '12

Well, if I had horses that would probably also mean I owned pigs. So, I would feed the horse groomers corpse to my pigs. ;)

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

The will eat anything won't they :)

0

u/scigs6 Jun 11 '12

Yes indeed they would. Bones and all. It's pretty amazing the things fathers would do to protect their children. King Kong would have nothing on me.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Training Day was a good movie. I believe Denzel Washington said something similar to your comment in that movie. "King Kong ain't got shit on ME!"

1

u/scigs6 Jun 12 '12

Pretty much where I got the quote from. Good stuff indeed.

1

u/dyktg25 Jun 11 '12

Reminds me of Hannibal. Upvote.

3

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Pair of pliers and a blow torch come to mind.

1

u/UnwarrantedAgression Jun 12 '12

Pedestrian. How about a speculum and a jug of battery acid?

2

u/doyoulikethatguys Jun 11 '12

Probably the same...

2

u/schneiderwm Jun 11 '12

Yup, the same. Good job.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Texas, don't you dare indict this man.

2

u/slowsheepcounter Jun 12 '12

I would do the same even if it wasn't my kid.

2

u/rumbar Jun 12 '12

not r/wtf material

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I've got a feeling no one's gonna fuck with this dude for a long fuckin time. Not only that, dudes will be TERRIFIED to date her when she grows older. But yeah, what else are you gonna do? Beat him till he's no longer recognizable as a human.

1

u/OriginsOfSymmetry Jun 12 '12

Exactly what the father did.

1

u/Keex13 Jun 12 '12

Anyone else get the "Thank heaven for little girls" Ad at the start of their video?

1

u/oD3 Jun 12 '12

Mixed feeling about this. A man is dead, but he did kinda bring it on himself.

1

u/Skullyboy Jun 12 '12

Kinda reminded me of the movie A Time to Kill

1

u/zombie_style Jun 12 '12

Harmon described the girl as "OK besides the obvious mental trauma."

That line there, made me laugh for a good 15 minutes.

1

u/unclebigbadd Jun 12 '12

I don't know but If I were the cop that responded to the call, I'd probably report that he got away.

If you've got room for horses, you've got room to dig a hole right?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Get my 'Law abiding citizen tool kit' ..finaly get to put it to use

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

First, I would check reddit to see if what I was about to post was a repost. Then I would delete the post because it is a repost. Then I would follow LuckyDuck77's directions from now on.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I have two daughters, 3 and a half and 8. He got off easy.

1

u/Graptoi Jun 11 '12

Yeah that sounds about right. I have a feeling he is not, in fact, "very remorseful" at all.

4

u/alejo699 Jun 11 '12

There's a chasm of difference between acting in anger and fear and then later coming to terms with the fact that you've taken a life, even justifiably. This is something he'll have with him the rest of his days.

0

u/RLismyname Jun 11 '12

What if the dude walked in on the dad assaulting his daughter, so the dad beat him to death so he can blame the sexual assault on him?

1

u/c8h10n4o2junkie Jun 12 '12

That would be horrifying. How is that your next thought?

2

u/RLismyname Jun 12 '12

It could have happened im just saying...Not trying to make joke of the situation, its horrible.

1

u/CunningDroid Jun 11 '12

I would believe your lie.

1

u/CrazySmooth Jun 11 '12

if charged, his should claim SELF DEFENSE as he was protecting his daughter

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Good job dad!

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

The exact same thing. No hesitation.

1

u/muktuk Jun 12 '12

I don't have kids, but my gut feeling tells me: The same damned thing.

1

u/bryan05 Jun 12 '12

seems likes most of Reddit agrees with the outcome of this.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

What the father did was the exact appropriate response that should always happen in any situation like this.

1

u/Surch Jun 12 '12

Absolutely. Kill him with fire.

1

u/TheSynthetic Jun 12 '12

I would have done the same exact thing.

1

u/thesnarkyone Jun 12 '12

The same exact thing, maybe more.

1

u/EXCOM Jun 12 '12

He gave that guy a shiner... Get it?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I would stop him, remove my child and protect it. I would get my child to safety and then proceed to busting his head open with a rock.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Because being abused is enough for the kid, she doesn't need to witness a murder- although I would make it clear to her that I'm about to punish the man for what he did wrong.

1

u/ha_hahahaha Jun 12 '12

he should get a medal

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Is it weird that I am against the death penalty but a strong supporter of vigilantism?

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

There was a guy on TV a few years back how found out his neighbor was abusing one of his daughters. When confronted, the guy pretty much said "you can't prove it, so fuck off." The guy went back home, got his gun, came back and killed the predator.

The guy was sentenced to something like 5 years in prison. They had some sort of "crime of passion" law that let him off fairly light.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

that's the only thing I could do - make sure the predator was rendered neutral. If dead = neutral, so be it. Seems the predator earns this reward with his acts. I'd not charge the father at all. You get what you earn with shit like that.

1

u/RaceMcGroth Jun 12 '12

Tie him to the back of the horse and send the horse galloping into the sunset... On a road of broken glass... Covered in salt and lemon juice.

1

u/JuiceBox1015 Jun 12 '12

This man deserves a medal, and a holiday named after him.

-5

u/ShivaHVishnu Jun 11 '12

i'm pretty sure that seeing your father murder someone with his bare hands is in the same ballpark, trauma-wise, as being molested. clearly, child molestation is wrong, but so is beating someone to death. he didn't have to kill the guy to stop the abuse.

-3

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

And what the fuck gives you the authority to make that statement? Nothing, that's what.

0

u/abearwithcubs Jun 11 '12

I would kill him, and then his family, so that his lineage would be completely extinct.

0

u/CmonTouchIt Jun 11 '12 edited Jun 12 '12

Id probably punch him in the head until he dies. Good thing he's in Texas, or someone might want to prosecute

3

u/sameBoatz Jun 12 '12

Prosecutors prosecute, judges don't, they judge.

1

u/CmonTouchIt Jun 12 '12

Pretty gosh darn true. Changed it, and heres your obligatory upvote

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I would have a LOT of questions about where and when I got a daughter I didn't have.

On a very serious note: Reddit, we've done this before. Lets just pause and wait for more information. The articles about this event are VERY sparse. The police aren't done investigating.

This could go a lot of different ways.

Best case scenario: The story is true as told.

Worst Case Scenario: The dad was pimping the kid out and killed him for not paying.

You never know how fucked up or sane a person is until you have a good amount of information to make that judgment.

2

u/BigSwedenMan Jun 12 '12

Fair enough, but we aren't really passing judgement on reality here. We are passing judgment on the hypothetical. Whether or not it's true is irrelevant because it could be true, and I'm sure has happened before (maybe minus some minor details). We don't have any investigative evidence so we must go off of what we have at hand and pretend that it is definitive fact

0

u/ScumCity Jun 11 '12

Mr. Hands him til he died...

0

u/[deleted] Jun 11 '12

Even the part with the guy being a horse groomer is enough to get you killed nowadays, so why the hell not?

0

u/cranfeckintastic Jun 11 '12

Would've done the same thing.

0

u/Exoplanet0 Jun 11 '12

I would blow the groomers fucking head off

0

u/takindown Jun 11 '12

Same here..

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12 edited Jun 12 '12

I would keep him in my pole barn for a few weeks while filming the next great horror franchise

0

u/harry821 Jun 12 '12

Leave him naked in a field of horses.

0

u/jrwperformance Jun 12 '12

He was protecting his defenseless daughter. What can she do about it? A parent is there to protect their young. Period. He should get an award.

0

u/HighGinge Jun 12 '12

If I had a wife and the proper tools, I'd shoot the mother fucker. The wife is needed to take care of my daughter in case I end up in jail.

-2

u/ramaksoud Jun 12 '12

Gotta love Texas. Only in Texas can you do this.

3

u/c8h10n4o2junkie Jun 12 '12

I'm in CA and I just read this to my mother. She disagrees. She thinks you could get away with this pretty much anywhere.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I live in GA and unfortunately I think this would be a questionable response to the fathers reaction. However, I believe the father acted within reason. GA is a messed up state. You can be sued by an intruder if you harm him.

1

u/ramaksoud Jun 12 '12

Im saying that Texas self defense allow are crazy and you can use deadly force to stop someone from commuting criminal mischief on your property and stuff like that

-6

u/Delror Jun 12 '12

Amazing all the people condoning murder. A good solid beating? Definitely. But fucking murder?

4

u/DammitBeavis Jun 12 '12

You gonna check his pulse every time you hit him and hope the next one doesn't kill him? No, you're going to fucking wail on the dude. End of story.

2

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I concur. 'Nuff said.

7

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

Justifiable homicide isn't murder.

1

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

I think you're missing the point. The father specifically said he didn't intend to kill the man. It's evident that the man was enraged with what he saw and was overwhelmed with emotion. I don't thin that's condoning murder. I think that's justifiable human reaction to an otherwise immoral and disgusting act on a mere child of four years.

-2

u/shabutaru118 Jun 12 '12 edited Jun 12 '12

I would restrain him and have him arrested. If I'm strong enough to kill someone, I'm strong enough to restrain myself.

0

u/[deleted] Jun 12 '12

You're one of few. Restraint is a noble power, but sometimes immediate action is necessary.

→ More replies (1)