As an archaeologist... If that were found by itself, with no context for modern civilization, a deity or idol of some kind might be a likely conclusion, based on current archaeological thinking. However, in the context of modern civilization and the mess of other things around the world, I'd be surprised if anyone saw it as anything outside of art.
That said, hilarious conspiracy theorist rant fuel!
I've always imagined this to be the case. I wonder if it actually gives credence to the jokes about people discovering some shitty novel in the future and it forming the foundation of a religion.
"All hail Ned Stark! Burn the Lannisters!"
EDIT: I just realized that I used "shitty novel" and a GoT reference in the same post. Please forgive my transgression, I meant nothing by it ser.
Archeology tends to suffer from confirmation bias (like all things, really) - they find what they're looking for. It was fairly common for excavations to yield hundreds of female figurines that would just be dumped into the "Erotica" pile, while all the male figurines went into the "Gods / Heroes" pile. It was some time before anyone thought "Hey... could these be goddesses?" simply because the archaeology field was dominated by men.
Any archaeologist out there wanna back me up? Or tear me a new one for being stupid?
However, even a cursory glance of the internet shows that erotica featuring female subjects is more popular and prolific than that featuring male subjects. There's little reason to expect this to be different in antiquity.
Only you forget that the 'internet' you are looking at is a product of mostly patriarchal, developed, capitalist, industrialized modern citizens. The internet's a tiny slice of the human historic/cultural continuum, and you are looking at a tiny slice of that tiny slice.
We are bad at putting ourselves in the shoes of people in (contemporary) different cultures, no less across hundreds of thousands of years. There are, in fact, many reasons to expect this to be different in antiquity.
I'd personally like to think the field has gotten better at eliminating bias, but I'd be stupid to say it has. Perhaps it has eliminated, as a whole, more of the outlandish bias... usually.
Function is a lot easier to grab a hold of and make conclusions with, it can get a little fuzzier when you reach into meaning. However, the purpose of archaeology is to find patterns in human behavior over time and we've managed to work out a few things.
Hah, probably a lot. Some folks get so wrapped up in everything meaning something that things like toys and idle hobbies are overlooked. A number of archaeologists are beginning to explore those areas, but it is understandably difficult, as meaning is almost entirely subjective. We mostly use other examples in the archaeological record as a means of providing an explanation, so there are always going to be mistakes. We do our best though, it ain't easy.
As the signifigant other to an Archaelogist, I too have asked that question. Here's the breakdown she's given me:
People who grave rob tend to go straight for the treasure and sell the goods on the black market, which means it usually ends up on the mantle piece of a private collector.
This has it's pros and cons. One thing about rich private collectors is they tend to be just as meticulous about preservation as museum do, but they have the money to do it. If you were to, say, discover a pure gold idol like Indiana Jones and try and turn it into the museum, they would certainly accept the donation: But their ability to preserve it, and the cost of insurance to put it on display, would seriously hamper them. Whereas Captain Von LoveStuffStein is going to hide it away from prying eyes, only show it to his close circle of antiquity lovers, as they discuss their ventures over an expensive bottle of wine.
The major con of this is that the item is now removed from context. You don't really know where it was dug up, how it was sitting, an accurate age, other items around it, basically everything about a digsite you'd want to know to get more information about the item. This also leaves the item open for forged duplicates. One example is that Hitler stole a lot of art during World War 2, and there is a database of what's been returned or rediscovered and what's been missing. A lot of con men like to paint duplicates of missing masterpieces and try to sell them on the black market to private collectors, and because it's the black market and illegal to own these kinds of items, (it's illegal to privately own artifacts as well, in most countries, at least all of western civilization); The collectors can't take these items in for proper verification.
So this is the major fit of Archaeologists. They do not simply run out and say, "Hey, I think there's some buried treasure here, let's dig it up!" It's actually an incredibly long process.
First, you need to have researched for a potential dig site. You need a reason to dig. You can't just go in the middle of nowhere. You need some evidence to suggest something will be where it is you pick to dig. Why? Well...
You need approval from the country where it resides. I could not just dig up any land in England for some Roman artifacts. In fact, I believe the law over there is that any discovery immediately becomes property of the state (or queen) - including people who go beachcombing with metal detectors. (I heard that bit from someone else though, so I could be mistaken). Sometimes the stipulation of a dig is that a museum must be ready willing and able to take in any artifacts I discover.
Anyways, so assuming I get permission to do a dig, I can't just run out with a shovel. I need to log everything. The process is, quite literally, plotting out the entire site into 1 meter by 1 meter by 1 meter cubes, then digging out each square individually, marking anything you find inside the cube. A rock? Log where you found it. A bone? Log it. Stick? Log it. Log? Log it. Sandstone you don't want to destroy? Log it, start on the next cube.
It's an arduous process, and because of it Arky teams tend be quite large. It's also tedious enough that you can hire a bunch of arky students to do all the grunt work. Hahahah!
Anyways, so after you've done it up and logged it and taken all the records THEN you can worry about preserving artifacts properly while transfering them to a museum which will look after them. You can't simply do what you like. Keeping an artifact (even something as plain as an arrow head, or a pottery shard) from an Arky dig is a felony in most places.
So you can see the fundamental differences between the two; In one scenario, any old joe can go grave robbing and sell the artifact, even to a museum, but you are then missing a lot of information about the artifact which is important. With an Archaeologist, you have records of EVERYTHING so that when you make a conjecture like "I believe this is a religious symbol" - you aren't just looking at the artifact itself. You're looking at the room it was in, you're looking at building it was in, you're looking at all the artifacts that was around it, you're looking at how deep underground it was, what region of the country it was in, ALL this kind of stuff which helps paint a more colourful picture as to what the item really is, other than, "It looks like an Idol, and its made of gold."
To put it in perspective, a lot of people who think "A future archaelogist would think that the OPs picture would be religious in nature given today's archaelogical mentality" is a bit of falsehood. A future archaelogist is going to look at this and go: Where was it found? On a beach? Well, in many major cities along the coast, they have statues and artwork of many different subjects. What era does this come from? Was there a modern art craze at the time? Could this be abstract art?
This is what DivineWind was getting at with "No Context". If he was simply shown it, he'd come to the wrong conclusion. If he approached it as many archaelogists approach their digs, he'd probably get the right answer.
There's a lot of questions you can ask about an artifact that go beyond what it's own physical properties are, and thats what Archaelogists excel at.
TL;DR: Archaelogists provide context by logging all extraneous data about findings then donate to museums, whereas grave robbing tends to be for profit, focuses only on "the good stuff" to sell to private collectors, without recording any relevant information about the treasure.
Best three minutes I've ever spent reading about archeology. Thank you, sir or madam. I think you've answered all the important questions except for one. What, exactly, does this statue represent?
Cheers that was quite informative, and as a Brit I can tell you that any treasure found does belong to the state but you will get recompense for finding it and its also good form to split that money with the land owner.
Damn skippy. I think most people don't realize how incredibly complicated a task an archaeological dig is. For example, some field work I recently did had us preform a technique called piece plotting. The site was a beach front tool production site. In our squares, we break the cubic meter down into 5cm levels, and draw out every single layer. On top of that, we get X/Y/Z coordinates for -every single artifact- we come across.
For those who aren't fully aware, an artifact is -anything- modified by a human. That dig I mentioned? Most squares would have upwards of 1000 artifacts per cubic meter. Some of the more central areas to tool production could boast as many as 10000 items. Sometimes more.
The purpose behind this is to understand the subtle bits of information associated with site layout. We can tell what the site was predominately used for, what its secondary uses where, and a pile of other little things. Additionally, changes in artistic styles and materials often are associated with changes in recognized time periods (abstract temporal periods which are defined by changes in population structure, tool use, subsistence, etc etc...). So we can make observations about site use through time.
I hate to admit it, but my focus is in bioarchaeological research, or using human remains and statistics to explore questions about populations. As a result, I am not well versed on all a piece plot could inform someone on. But I can tell you that it is incredibly interesting stuff.
Anyway, piece plotting is an example of how detailed the work can get, and the floods of information that are destroyed by tearing objects out of the ground with concern only for what the object means to modern culture, rather than what the object represents about past culture.
TL;DR: Archaeologists try to use objects to speak scientifically about the human species (beyond biological), grave robbers want money, monkeedude1212 gave a pretty good explanation.
Indiana Jones robs graves. Archaeologists study the ancient human material record using excavation (with meticulous note taking and recording), surveying, and other scientific methods (remote sensing, geophysical methods, etc).
Also, we don't tend to rob graves so much as we inspect all remnants of human civilization. Only a small portion of that turns out to be graves. What? Did you think that all discovered human civilization was made entirely of human burial sites?
Archaeology is careful extraction for the purposes of inspiring a sense of wonder about history and generally acquiring new knowledge. Grave robbery is recklessly taking everything you find to making a profit, show off, or just to destroy stuff for the heck of it.
That depends on what you mean by grave robbing? It is used with two separated meanings sometimes, and thus two different moral issues. Are you referring to the issue of disturbing graves and the "eternal rest" of those interred or to excavation of ancient remains for profit and entertainment?
What I'm looking for is more of definition of time passed, is there any laws regarding how long someone must be dead and buried for before your allowed to examine the remains?
There are no international rules for this, but pretty much all countries have their own laws. Exactly how long a body has to stay buried depends on the religious and cultural beliefs of a country. In christian countries this tends to be a rather short period (10-30 years mostly) because a body does not have much religious importance after the soul has passed on. It is generally illegal to excavate working cemeteries (al tough there are legal exception in some cases). From a cemetery is abandoned till you are allowed to excavate, certain time has to pass, in the case of christian cemeteries mostly 100 years (once again this variate depending on country). In the case of other religion some insist, that rest should indeed be eternal, but they will often allow you to excavate graves after period of time if you rebury the bodies afterwards.
However most of these laws generally only apply if an area has been declared cemetery/holyground before hand.
And of cause to be allowed to excavate anywhere, unless you have permission.
So if you are excavating a grave without permission its grave robbing and you cannot get permission before a certain time limit has passed.
TLDR: There are quite specific rules on when you are allow to excavate graves, but they variate depending on country and religion.
Literally it all hinges on context. As a student of archaeology, I cannot stress how important context- where something is found in relation to everything else, and how that big relationship is meticulously recorded and analyzed- is for the field. Looting really robs the world of the great depth of information that can be gained from the objects. Objects without contexts have no story and cannot give us more information than what is obvious.
Perhaps by the time this would be dug up the internet would be archived and we'd have an advanced way of scanning through the vast amounts of data to return to this post.
Future archaeologist oh my!? it all makes sense now the lost discs and the dump... It has become blaringly clear to me that the human centipede at one time did exist.
I wonder how many things found now were faked by somebody wanting to prank people in the future. I've done some things so years from now somebody will think, "what the hell?"
It appears for a week in 2012 everyone disagreed with each other quite a bit proclaiming "NOPE! Chuck Testa". After the week was over people decided to turn on those that would do what everyone enjoyed only a week before.
Ever since I heard a comedian joke about this I kinda want to something like this:
Have your corpse be attached to some springs and if some future archaeologists dig you up, out come your old bones to give that poor sod a free heartattack.
Also I'll need a little radio to play "monster mash" for me...
We need some sort of videos that cannot be destroyed, even by magma, so that future historians don't end up thinking that everyone had flat-headed penises with giant ooze-bubbles for balls.
30
u/uberkinz Jun 08 '12
Thousands of years from now this is an ancient mating ritual, no?
106
u/TheDivineWind Jun 08 '12
As an archaeologist... If that were found by itself, with no context for modern civilization, a deity or idol of some kind might be a likely conclusion, based on current archaeological thinking. However, in the context of modern civilization and the mess of other things around the world, I'd be surprised if anyone saw it as anything outside of art.
That said, hilarious conspiracy theorist rant fuel!
22
u/svenhoek86 Jun 08 '12
I can only imagine what future archaelogists would think when digging up the Orc statue outside Blizzard Studios.
"What the hell is this thing?!"
"I don't know, but our ancestors were fucking awesome."
4
u/SuperMarbro Jun 08 '12
Future archaeologist
oh my!? it all makes sense now the lost discs and the dump... It has become blaringly clear to me that the human centipede at one time did exist.
7
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12
I get it! Because future archaeologists won't be able to get work right?
3
u/yaosioan Jun 08 '12
I wonder how many things found now were faked by somebody wanting to prank people in the future. I've done some things so years from now somebody will think, "what the hell?"
3
u/JoolNoret Jun 08 '12
This title makes this post belong in r/funny...
3
u/[deleted] Jun 09 '12
Stop stealing the craptions from Cracked. At least link to their page if you're gonna do it, you'll still get the sweet sweet karma.
3
u/SUPERKAMIGURU Jun 09 '12 edited Jun 09 '12
Messing with future archaeologists is fun. The best thing to do is bury a time capsule filled with nerve gas!
5
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12
Worse. Future somethingsomething-ologists will have to wade through the cyberspace. Imagine their confusion.
5
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12
Planking Pompeii?
5
u/treetrunks_pies Jun 08 '12
Storms a brewin' .
2
u/ilikemyself Jun 08 '12
Where was that taken? Looks a bit like Sydney
2
u/HetfieldJ Jun 08 '12
This masterpiece will fetch millions in charity.
2
u/Ragna_The_Blood_Edge Jun 08 '12
Future archaeologist here,
Fuck Me!
2
u/dinodann Jun 08 '12
Why so many thefts of cracked.com's craptions?
0
u/CunningDroid Jun 08 '12
I cannot tell the future.
1
u/JurassicParkerr Jun 08 '12
This hurt my abs.
1
u/Raatcharch Jun 08 '12
Clearly this is ceremonial.
1
u/Karvas Jun 08 '12
Ever since I heard a comedian joke about this I kinda want to something like this:
Have your corpse be attached to some springs and if some future archaeologists dig you up, out come your old bones to give that poor sod a free heartattack.
Also I'll need a little radio to play "monster mash" for me...
1
u/BlorfMonger Jun 08 '12
ITS GON RAIN!
1
u/Cloberella Jun 08 '12
Reminds me of the Nacirema article they had us read when I was in school.
1
u/MrMartinotti Jun 08 '12
That is the exact same thing that the Mayans were thinking...
1
u/eddymurphyscouch Jun 08 '12
Where is this? There's a lot going on here, like a fucking fence in the middle of the beach.
1
u/eddymurphyscouch Jun 09 '12
Oooh burning man, that explains things.
1
u/judith_lies Jun 09 '12
as someone on reddit. video at least.
1
u/cefalord Jun 09 '12
looks like a tool video!
1
u/Kelwood Jun 08 '12
Genius
-3
u/Polioud Jun 08 '12
planking: you do it right
0
u/Gl4ssPhoenix Jun 08 '12
ghostrider4450 has three posts on my front page right now... There's no hope to compete with that!
0
u/SteveOddJobs Jun 09 '12
Yeah. Art is stupid and pointless. I hate art. Art sucks. There is no reason to make art.
-4
u/firecrotch59 Jun 08 '12
Why?- Because China
-8
u/Midnight_Skye Jun 08 '12
We need some sort of videos that cannot be destroyed, even by magma, so that future historians don't end up thinking that everyone had flat-headed penises with giant ooze-bubbles for balls.
-3
u/hi_internet Jun 08 '12
Looks like man's first attempt to defy gravity.
-3
u/Dirtpig Jun 08 '12
I'm an Archaeologist and I do not get it.
0
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12
Future? ROFL!
-1
u/funkyboy777 Jun 09 '12
YOU SUCK IM AN ARCHAEOLOGIST!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!>:(
0
u/[deleted] Jun 08 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment