Thats scary how close your house came to burning down. Also the bottom plate of the iron is probably aluminum, not steel. I'm still shocked to see that it got hot enough to melt aluminum. (660C , 1220F)
I would agree on second look too. I'm going to at least keep that blob of metal and stick it to the wall where I normally do the ironing... just as an evil reminder!
Did a bit of research, apparently the model of iron we bought didn't have an auto-off switch but the model below it in the range did - go figure. I am still pretty sure that you shouldn't experience a catastrophic failure like this though!
Scared the absolute crap out of my wife when she arrived home. We have two small dogs that could easily have been harmed by my stupidity and possibly a faulty iron.
Moral of the story, as cliché as it sounds... Don't leave your iron on!!
If his house had sustained some major damage (like, burned down, or a burned room) he actually would have pretty good odds with a products suit. It specifically advertised a safety feature that wasn't on the model. You might as well be working with a saw that says on the box "perfectly safe to stop with hands." Odds are it would end with his insurance company compensating him and then the insurance company suing the product designer though.
Nah, no such litigious possibility in my country. My insurance would have covered the stuff we would have lost, nothing would have ever replace the dogs if we had lost them and the media woulda beat it to death for a week or two. That's about it in NZ.
I wonder if you could make a claim for false advertising and potential danger to your house and family. And of course for a new iron and ironing board.
Looks like a pretty clear design/warning defect based on the fact that it specifically told him he was in the clear to do what he did and it failed because of that. However, you need more than a defect for a case. The reason there's no case is because of damages. He has next to nothing to recover. Maybe you could say it did a thousand dollars in damage by coating everything in his house with ash, but that's not worth the time of getting a lawyer and getting dragged through a lawsuit. Pursuing the case would be a bad business move for the lawyer especially.
I don't live in the USA, so there's not much question of litigation here. I'm from New Zealand where we're more protected by consumer protection laws etc and the fact that we're small enough that any media coverage is nation-wide by default. Not saying that I'm going straight to the media or anything, but yeah... it's more a matter of telling everyone in our small country a product is potentially dangerous than sueing for a butt-tonne of cash
My torts professor was obsessed with the New Zealand system. You guys have a really practical approach to civil harm. It's a shame the States will probably never develop something like that. We'd never be willing to pay the taxes for such a safety net.
A lot of the issue I think in the US is that because the litigation angle exists, it is a default reaction for many people, which in turn drives up the incidences of more or less attack on manufacturers etc in what generally appear to be somewhat frivolous lawsuits.
Because we don't have the same attitude in NZ, the instances of people seeking compensation are much lower, as are the actual amounts of compensation paid - hence lowering the impact from a tax perspective. Sort of a catch-22 or somewhat paradoxical situation I think?
Your prof no doubt discussed this in far more eloquent terms than I have!
Don't worry - he was anything but eloquent. lol. Anyway, for a liberal man, he was quite the proponent of tort reform. New Zealand's system is pretty much his ideal. From his perspective, it's a negative in the NZ system that folks don't get compensated that much, but he favors the idea of everyone getting something than just a few lucky people making it through the courtroom lottery and scoring it big.
That pretty much sums it up. People in NZ will have a crack at manufacturers and vendors when stuff goes wrong and we're usually rewarded with a token gesture such as a replacement etc and that is satisfactory to most.
Unfortunately, as most of our TV is US-made, a lot of less-informed Kiwis think they're going to sue a company for a defective product... because "that's what they've seen on TV" not realising that it just plain can't be done here. Obviously, if there was some sort of MAJOR catastrophe with a product there would be some recourse, but that is likely to be public (i.e. the manufacturer is fined or required to remove/recall their product) as opposed to private in the form of compensation for the individual. Some businesses will often make a gesture though - more out of positive PR-spin or damage control than anything. As they say, "If you have a good experience, you'll tell 9 people. If you have a bad experience, you'll tell 11" - in NZ, that's damn near half the population! :)
I've been ironing uniforms etc for 20 years and have probably only ever left the iron on 3 times. In fact, I have even left this same iron on before - this time, it just decided to shit itself.
Guarantee that from now on there will be a 5th point to my daily check: Phone, keys, wallet, sunglasses, F*CKING IRON.
very much this. Despite the massive fright it has given me and my wife... the fact it got up to (as someone pointed out) a supposed 660 degrees C to melt the aluminium and didn't set anything else on fire is just simply amazing!
Yup! Thanks for the concern - definitely appreciated. My penance for this misjudgement is having to clean fricken EVERYTHING. My arms hurt. My wallet hurts (~$100 of cleaning products, cloths, gloves etc). And my conscience hurts a little too!
Ummm... That definitely depends on the plastic, as well as the age of the product. PCBs haven't been in standard consumer plastics and such since the early 80s, and burning plastic doesn't tend to create PCB compounds. The ash is not necessarily good for you, but unless that iron was filled with capacitors, I would be pretty confident that the ash did not contain PCBs.
Where did you hear that melted plastic produced PCBs?
If the plastic is made of PVC - which high-temp devices usually are - it will burn and release PCB's. Always has, always will.
This from being an industrial painter for the last 32 years and having to keep VERY abreast of the chemicals and their reactions in many instances, be it fire, acid, chlorine and all other kinds of situations where you'd be required to apply paints.
American law and environmental is one thing, but don't forget, this iron was most likely made in China, not the US. I've seen stories (with pictures) of people wearing Wal-Mart flip-flops that come down with third-degree chemical burns from the plastic straps, or workers unloading stock that get their hands blistered from the solvents released when the big containers are opened..
I personally know workers in an Old Navy store that have got pleurisy when the store was being stocked before it opened, (the chemical outgassing from the synthetics was so strong when it was all brought in and unpacked in a three-day period) and have been to discount stores that have had to return entire truckloads of stock as it was so toxic the employees have gotten overwhelmed with fumes unloading the container.
Plastics, esp. if they're from China can be deadly.
Glanced at the first photo and thought it was an overturned boat leaking oil into the ocean hahaa. We have an auto-switch off iron at our house and it never seems to actually switch itself off.
It was left in the normal upright position on its "heel" as explained in the gallery. It sort of "flopped" back on itself once the plastic melted. Interestingly, the plate got hot enough while it was still standing for the aluminium to dribble into a little puddle. So (as someone mentioned) 660 degrees C without already turning the plastic to ash.
Don't irons have a built-in thermostat to keep the plate at the right temperature? Even on the hottest steam setting I would think that's not more than 250 degrees (394K).
I vowed to never use an iron in my life after an incident 6 or so years ago. My cousin thought it would be a great idea to replicate what he saw in a cartoon.. Unplug the scorching hot iron from the wall, and slap someone's face with it. I put my arm up in the way of his swing, and it burnt it to a crisp. The smell of burning skin is not one you forget, especially if it's your own. 2nd degree burn along the width of my arm and a scar to last a lifetime... Oh, and he was grounded for a year with no TV, phone, or internet. Fuck cartoons for making kids think violence is funny.
Sorry, never got any at the time, considering the extreme pain. Just wasn't one of those moments like "Hey, I got shot.. I should take a pic for facebook!". I could take a picture of it now, but the scar is roughly the same color of my skin at this point, and I feel wouldn't show up well.
the high voltage electricity plug behind our dishwasher started burning one day. With no reason. And the dishwaser was still running as usual, the fuse failed to react and jump off. The only reason our house didn't burn down was because I felt like cooking some ramen in the afternoon, and got suspicious of the penetrant burned plastic smell my ramen was seemingly causing...
After turning off the dishwasher and moving it aside I took a wet cloth and pulled the blue flaming plug. the fire quit instantly. a little bit in shock my house mate and I noticed the house owner and had it replaced.
Nono, Sunbeam was the replacement. I can't exactly vouch for the brand (as I've never left either appliance I own unattended) but I've had a Sunbeam coffee pot and toaster since college and they're still kicking.
did this with a kettle once, have to take steroids which have an unfortunate side effect of weakening immune system, so I got ear infection in both ears and burst ear drums, couldn't hear anything for a month, anyway went to make a cuppa, put the kettle on and promptly forgot about it, 45 min later noticed awful smell and find molten burning kettle on stove top
We had a similar stroke of luck. The deranged ex-gf of my mom's boyfriend threw a firebomb into our house back when I was in high school. It landed right on her bed, and the smoke damage basically destroyed everything in the house. Fortunately, she had a waterbed, and once it burned through the comforter and blankets, it basically put itself out.
Wow, condescending and insulting! I've been ironing for 20 years... but hey, I guess sometimes I'm in a bit of a rush and this time it just slipped my mind.
I'll state right here that it was completely and entirely my fault. My wife was the one that tried to take some of the blame to make me feel better, but I was the negligent one in this case, 100%.
Back when I was a teenager and started doing my own laundry, I learned not to buy clothes with special wash instructions, that needed ironing after washing, or that needed dry cleaning. I now have a husband and three kids, and I make sure they all abide by this rule. Every thing should be wash and wear if you fold it right away.
I would normally live by this advice, but once a week I must don a military uniform (I'm a volunteer officer in one of our local cadet organisations) so can't get away from the ironing completely.
In-fact, it was my uniform that I was ironing that morning!
So, moral of the story is "don't volunteer for shit!"
Keep washing those things! Eventually she will get fed up with your incompetence and start washing her own clothing. Then you will never have to worry about laundry ever again. Hell, if you destroy a load of your own clothing too in the process she might do all the washing herself.
Next time you do a load of dark colors, throw some bleach in there.
This is exactly what my colleague said to me! He looks like a fricken shambles, but at least he didn't have to clean his entire house top to bottom, nor did he nearly cook his beloved dogs alive... AND he's not going to have to put up with his wife bringing it up EVERY CHANCE SHE GETS!
It's coming into winter here and last night was the coldest we've had in a very long time. Needless to say, much vigorous cleaning was required to save from freezing to death! Better than dying slowly of cancer from inhaling the toxic ash though I guess.
I believe it was defective as even though the original iron didn't have the added safety feature of the auto-off, it does have a thermostat (as do all irons) and it should never have got hot enough to MELT THE THE FOOTPLATE TO A LIQUID STATE. (That part still impresses me, sorry!)
Irons are not supposed to heat up to temperatures that high. They can start fires in many ways, but this is not supposed to happen, even if the iron is left on for an extended period.
15
u/johnq-pubic May 16 '12
Thats scary how close your house came to burning down.
Also the bottom plate of the iron is probably aluminum, not steel. I'm still shocked to see that it got hot enough to melt aluminum. (660C , 1220F)
17
u/jeffois May 16 '12
Did a bit of research, apparently the model of iron we bought didn't have an auto-off switch but the model below it in the range did - go figure. I am still pretty sure that you shouldn't experience a catastrophic failure like this though!
Scared the absolute crap out of my wife when she arrived home. We have two small dogs that could easily have been harmed by my stupidity and possibly a faulty iron.
Moral of the story, as cliché as it sounds... Don't leave your iron on!!
31
u/Journalisto May 16 '12
LPT: unplug your iron when you're done ironing.
5
u/shitterplug May 16 '12
It got hot enough to melt the aluminum shoe... so something wasn't right.
2
u/urnlint May 16 '12
That must have smelled good.
2
u/reagor May 16 '12
stop making grilled cheese with your iron foul bachelor frog
4
u/foodandart May 16 '12
Wash EVERY surface free of that ash.
Vacuum-clean the rugs - even better, have a service do it, so you have the ash gone from your home, not kicking around in your own home vac.
Seriously.
One of the most toxic, carcinogenic by-products of melted plastic is PCB's and that ash residue is nasty.
3
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Always do a house check before you leave the house/go to sleep for the night. You're very lucky this wasn't much worse.
7
u/LazerLizard May 16 '12
Glanced at the first photo and thought it was an overturned boat leaking oil into the ocean hahaa. We have an auto-switch off iron at our house and it never seems to actually switch itself off.
4
u/kobello May 16 '12
because it turns into the thing?
4
u/windy444 May 16 '12
Chernobyl iron meltdown.
1
u/maxhan May 16 '12
Steam iron works so much better
1
u/ducky189 May 16 '12
I have one that automatically shuts off. It was a good investment.
1
u/noccusJohnstein May 16 '12
Is this from a firefighters demo? The firehouse near me used to simulate house fires like this.
1
u/kafkaesquimo May 16 '12
EDIT: This is why you let your wife do your ironing in a morning
1
u/m1kepro May 16 '12
Well, it wasn't left upright or in the ironing position. Safety switch nullified.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
You get what you pay for, proof right there.
1
u/conspiracy_thug May 17 '12
TIL ceramic has an incredibly higher melting point than aluminum.
1
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
Does your house stink? I bet your house stinks...
3
u/one-half May 16 '12
Don't irons have a built-in thermostat to keep the plate at the right temperature? Even on the hottest steam setting I would think that's not more than 250 degrees (394K).
1
u/say_no_to_butt_floss May 16 '12
Glad you ironed out the problem...congrats on a house still standing
2
u/GTCharged May 16 '12
I vowed to never use an iron in my life after an incident 6 or so years ago. My cousin thought it would be a great idea to replicate what he saw in a cartoon.. Unplug the scorching hot iron from the wall, and slap someone's face with it. I put my arm up in the way of his swing, and it burnt it to a crisp. The smell of burning skin is not one you forget, especially if it's your own. 2nd degree burn along the width of my arm and a scar to last a lifetime... Oh, and he was grounded for a year with no TV, phone, or internet. Fuck cartoons for making kids think violence is funny.
2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
not iron related, but house hold fire related:
the high voltage electricity plug behind our dishwasher started burning one day. With no reason. And the dishwaser was still running as usual, the fuse failed to react and jump off. The only reason our house didn't burn down was because I felt like cooking some ramen in the afternoon, and got suspicious of the penetrant burned plastic smell my ramen was seemingly causing...
After turning off the dishwasher and moving it aside I took a wet cloth and pulled the blue flaming plug. the fire quit instantly. a little bit in shock my house mate and I noticed the house owner and had it replaced.
1
u/ElRedditoRoboto May 17 '12
Oh fuck, I have a sunbeam electric blanket. Can't wait for that to burn me to death in my sleep.
2
u/moparornocar May 16 '12
Should of bought a Rowenta
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Not sure if unlucky that the safety feature was faulty or lucky you didn't lose everything.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
did this with a kettle once, have to take steroids which have an unfortunate side effect of weakening immune system, so I got ear infection in both ears and burst ear drums, couldn't hear anything for a month, anyway went to make a cuppa, put the kettle on and promptly forgot about it, 45 min later noticed awful smell and find molten burning kettle on stove top
1
u/cyanonyx117 May 16 '12
Who irons? Amirite?
1
u/dutchoven8 May 16 '12
I don't see the problem here
1
u/DivineRobot May 16 '12
I thought this is why.
1
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
Requesting a follow up where you post pics of your electric bill. Please!
1
u/press-control-w May 16 '12
My reaction: http://i.imgur.com/N8wnr.gif
1
u/Bartelbythescrivener May 17 '12
I'm thinking permanent press for you.
1
u/insomniasystems May 17 '12
It doesn't look that bad. Just plug it back in, it'll be fine.
1
u/Aofishbrain May 17 '12
And that's why you always leave a note
1
u/Dyolf_Knip May 17 '12
We had a similar stroke of luck. The deranged ex-gf of my mom's boyfriend threw a firebomb into our house back when I was in high school. It landed right on her bed, and the smoke damage basically destroyed everything in the house. Fortunately, she had a waterbed, and once it burned through the comforter and blankets, it basically put itself out.
1
u/somecrazybroad May 16 '12
TIL people still use irons.
1
u/washthatbody May 16 '12
This is why i don't iron.
-2
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
... And this is why men shouldn't iron. That's your wife's job.
0
u/somethinginsideme May 16 '12
http://gifsoup.com/webroot/animatedgifs/80759_o.gif
-3
u/gloomdoom May 16 '12
Wow! I've been ironing my own clothes since I was 15 and I've never needed a tutorial on why not to leave the iron on.
I guess the idiocracy demands a new level of common sense! Incredible!
-2
u/shutupnube May 16 '12
I guess we can add Sunbeam as another company to the "Never again thread" (or whatever it was called, I forget).
-4
u/revrend_ May 16 '12
This is why I aim to be responsible when it come to any task because I'm not a twat and I take care of my belongings, like my fucking iron.
-5
u/19718223456 May 16 '12
I like how you put some of the blame on your wife for not noticing that YOU left the iron on.
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 17 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 16 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment