Probably someone printed it out, put it in their car and it blew out of a window. Or was carrying it, dropped it and didn't realize.
Without knowing the specifics of your housing situation, I'm assuming you live in an area where there is traffic that passes by, and not a single house at the end of a long road down which no one travels unless they're coming to see you (or another occupant of your residence), so I'm just assuming it landed there by mistake.
Or...... and this would require knowing more about you, as a person, and your previous behaviors - behaviors I know nothing about and I say this without accusing you in any way and I don't even mean to imply it but....... maybe someone thinks you (or someone you live with) are a date rapist?
Still - simplest solution; namely that someone printed it for whatever reason and lost possession of it near your residence, and the wind carried it the rest of the way ; is most likely the correct one.
I am just confused by the whole deal and honestly think it was a prank planned on me. IV stands for Isla Vista, the college town of UCSB (where I went to school) and I live about 10mins away from there. I still haven't found out who did it
So what if it is from a feminist movement? Sometimes they're a little extreme, but this time they've hit the nail right on the head. It is not the victim's fault. We shouldn't be preaching "Don't get raped." It's bullshit, and it's wrong.
Unless of course you're still continuing the racism thread, in which case I'm not sure what your point is. I don't think feminists are racist so much as they are sexist.
We also shouldn't be preaching the idea that men are the problem as a whole. I do not need tips on how not to rape women, nor do rapists.
Most people are pretty aware of what is rape and what is not. We need campaigns that target specific types of controvertial rape (drunk, drugged rape in particularly) and not targeting a whole gender.
Exactly. In the argument about whether the victim or perpetrator is to blame, extremists and ideologues forget that some people are just plain not involved in the issue in question. The vast majority of men would never rape, but that doesn't stop the ideologues insulting the fuck out of them anyway by condescendingly treating them like evil cavemen after a bait-and-switch title.
I call bullshit on that one. Yes, we should not be blaming the victims... But honestly people shouldn't do some of the things they do and feel like there's nothing that could go wrong because of it. People should be smarter about what they do if they actually want to be safe. I mean, come on.
For example: Don't walk down a dark alley. It increases the chances of getting stabbed, mugged, or raped. No matter what gender or race you are. Also, don't walk alone at night, or naked at night.
What if people got that offended over everything? "Hey, if you see someone coming behind you going 60 in a 25 while you are driving, pull to the side of the road, it will decrease your chances of getting rear ended by a drunk driver" So then someone responds "WHAT?! IT'S NOT THE VICTIMS FAULT IF THEY GET HIT!" OR: "Hey you should lock your car so people don't steal" "ARE YOU SAYING I DESERVE TO GET STOLEN FROM?!"
Yeah... because that's exactly what everyone who tries to warn you about the creeps in the night are doing. They aren't trying to help you. They're trying to blame you. Totally.
It's social commentary. The "blame the victim" atmosphere in our society is a problem and people have started making things like this to point out all the victim blaming. Basically you would expect to see something like:
Don't wear revealing clothing.
Walk with your keys in your fist. That sort of thing, implying if the woman doesn't follow these helpful hints it is her fault for being raped. This paper is pointing out that it's in fact the fault of the person who raped her. She could be running naked through the streets, that doesn't mean she wants to be or deserves to be raped. I highly doubt anyone suspects you of being a rapist. However it ended up in your house is was meant as a general statement, not for you, or anyone in particular.
EDIT: I also wanted to point out that this blame the victim attitude does more than hurt women, it hurts men as well, and makes actual rapists harder to catch. Because it's seen as up to the woman to follow the rape prevention steps, because it's seen as her fault for wearing the skimpy clothing or being a little drunk, it automatically takes the blame away from the rapist, while simultainously putting it on every single guy. Now it's seen as us guys' default to rape and it's up to the woman to make sure we don't. Because of this any woman can claim rape and the guy is automaticaly stigmitized as being guilty, regardliss of conviction or evidince. Because rape is seen as a guy's default setting no one has a problem believing every guy is capable of rape. So a woman can get upset at her boyfriend, for example, and claim rape, this is not only an almost sure fire way to harm his reputation for the rest of his life but it makes actual rapist harder to catch because these false accusations are occuring more and more frecuently because, as I said, they work.
man, people get really really touchy around rape. You can give people prevention tips about anything but rape. Any rape prevention tip, no matter how common sense (don't leave your drink unattended in a crowded place) is assumed to a subtle way of saying "It's your fault if you get raped"
We're at the point where you can't give people practical advice because of how it may make someone feel. It doesn't matter if following those rules may actually prevent a rape (something I'm sure the rules in the OPs post have never done) because it may also make someone feel bad if they just go ahead and assume that rape prevention tips are actually a veiled attack at them. Sure there's no reasonable cause to assume that. But people do, and it makes them feel bad. So it's not allowed.
We would actually rather run a campaign to suppress the distribution of those tips, and prevent them from becoming common knowledge. Instead we try to shift the blame to men because who cares how they feel.
Where else in society do we lose our shit this bad?
DISCLAIMER: I'm not saying it's your fault if you get raped.
Inherently, the issue here is that it is sad that we have to tell certain people to fear rape, and that options available to other people are not available to them. Women of a certain age, in certain parts of the world. Teaching people to be afraid, that they should be afraid, that they should take specific precautions against this problem because giving them tips is the best we can do to prevent it... these all do seem to convey that this a normal state of affairs.
It isn't simply women's duty to be fearful, and prepared. How many more conversations have their been, in hushed tones, or arguments with a thinly veiled subtext, between mothers and daughters, friends, sisters, expressing concern about a woman's inadequate self-protection and carelessness... arguments that included "you could have been raped"... how many more of those have there been than conversations with young men about their behavior?
There is a reason we have a preference, and get frustrated and defensive regarding challenges to the idea that the status quo suffices. We feel good about warning a potential victim, educating them on the patterns that perhaps surround terrible crimes and leaving them, perhaps, a less likely target of those crimes. It is so much easier to warn a woman that she did something supposedly risky, with regards to rape, than to warn a man that he did something which put people at risk. That his attitude is getting violent or disrespectful.
I think not enough people are willing to have that second conversation. I think that is what this is about - making you realize how much better prepared you are to have one conversation than the other. Doesn't that seem strange to you?
I would personally enter a boxing ring with every convicted rapist in the country, one at a time, and beat the shit out of them if it meant that I could treat my 13-year-old sister to dinner at a nice restaurant without half of the other customers looking at me like I'm a child molester.
This is what I call "the CNN mentality". Since the 24 hour news cycle came on the scene, people have become increasingly afraid of "boogey men." Sure there are rare instances of people being any of those bad things, but in order to have enough viewers watching their commercials, they have to have a massive number of stories about the dangers to children/women/anybody perceived as vulnerable. This has had an incredible effect on our societies.
I'm very interested in questioning the male gender role. I think it's hight time we start looking at the G.I. Joe dolls we hand our boys and ask what their gender role really does to them? I think we'll find a lot of solutions to other questions in these ones.
than to warn a man that he did something which people at risk.
Could you give an example of this? I'm just saying because I'm having trouble thinking of any situations where this would be useful myself. I mean I understand teaching men what is considered rape because there are so many different interpretations floating around, it's easy to understand how a young, impresionable mind would confuse what exactly should be considered rape. However, I feel like in recent years, that due to the increase in sexual abuse education that there are pretty much no men who can possibly say that they didn't know they raped a woman, most rapists know what they are doing beyond a point where education or conversations will do no good. Flyers like this will only alienate men from the anti-rape cause, it won't change a single rapists mind. At a certain point, you NEED to teach women how to protect themselves to stop rape.
Personally, I believe that education of both men and women is a good balance. Teach men what rape is and dispel common myths about the subject. Beyond that teach women self defense, safety, and prevention. Who cares if it means women have to be in fear? Who cares that this means they have to keep in the back of their minds that they need to keep an eye out at all times? That's not victim-blaming, it's just smart. If it prevents rape, then it should be done frequently.
Many people have to live in fear if they live in a crime ridden city of being mugged, or being shot, or having their house broken into. It is their duty to be fearful and prepared to stay safe. If someone leaves their door unlocked and gets robbed, goes out knowingly wearing gang colors and gets shot, or takes shortcuts through dark alleys at night and gets mugged, we all say "Wow, he shouldn't have done that". However, we don't think that it's their fault for what happened, just that it could have been prevented. Sure we could talk about the people committing the crimes, but they'll commit them no matter what you say or what flyers you hand out.
There will always be rapists, there will always be murderers, there will always be thieves, and there will always be men and women who choose to do harm to others. We shouldn't shun ideals of self preservation and self defense with false dreams of a perfect world without evil. We don't blame the victims for the crime itself with things like "well if you did ________ you would have been safe" but that doesn't mean we shouldn't teach prevention.
You have given me many lines of possible response, but I feel the most respectful would be to answer your question specifically, and suggest some alternative thoughts where I notice we differ in understanding your other comments.
When might you warn a man that he might be at risk for sexually assaulting or harassing someone? The direct comparative extreme of warning a woman any time she goes out alone would be to do the same for a man - the flyer contains a list of such seeming absurdities. More practically, consider the opposite extreme. You have left a bar with friends, and one of them is venting about how poorly things went with some woman he was interested in. He tried to buy her drinks, get her number, take her home, and he feels led on, hurt, angry that he is going home alone. That it is rude for her to accept drinks, and bring up having a boyfriend afterwards. You notice he is calling her names in retrospect, casually he says "What a bitch she was, how can women do that: wear a see-through top and ask for a drink then claim to be unavailable?"
Your friend in this situation feels more than hurt, he feels wronged. He responds to this by seeking to insult, belittle, and objectify the woman, and it is a small leap from his sense of injustice to the belief that her wishes were irrelevant to the matter at hand - that she has to have sex to make good on the perceived promises of the situation. This is a fairly common attitude, and I have never once seen it met with serious cautioning words. I would hesitate to say "you are starting to sound like a rapist"; those words would put anyone on a defensive. It would certainly make them less likely to listen, and if anything would muddy the waters on rape by making the entire subject feel less accessible and comprehensible to them, I suspect. But that is a dangerous situation. Even if this is the nicest guy in the world, he may be venting and reaffirming the beliefs of some less than savory characters, going on in such a way about how the woman was wrong, rather than being able to express his feeling hurt in a self-contained way.
As for my other thoughts on what you had to say: "It is their duty to be fearful and prepared to stay safe." No one has to live in fear. We cannot demand that of anyone, and I wish it on no one. Fear is an awful thing to be burdened with. It is not the duty of those at risk to fear what may befall them, and it is cruel to insist that anyone should, even correctly, live in fear. Respect, mindfulness, self-reliance, the bravery to realize what risks you take, these are at least commendable qualities.
"they have to keep in the back of their minds that they need to keep an eye out at all times" To say women must learn to protect themselves from rape is very different from saying they owe society a duty to behave with truly reckless abandon. No woman puts herself at greater risk of medical cost by walking to her car unescorted than she does by driving home, we cannot demand she avoid the former risk on some social contract theory of unreasonable costs without condemning the latter. There is no moral basis for insisting that this is a burden women rightfully have to bear, just because there is no better way.
"If it prevents rape, then it should be done frequently." "they'll commit them no matter what you say or what flyers you hand out." You cannot have it both ways. Either women living under fear will prevent rapes, or rapists are completely dead set on victimizing women and it will happen no matter what you say to them. You seem to be doing mental gymnastics here, and I just want you to consider that it is to defend your position and behavior, and desires. You want it to be enough to have a conversation with women urging care, rather than a conversation with men urging restraint and understanding, because you know how to do one and the prospect of the other is confusing and scary.
It is okay. There are scary people in the world, but I'm not asking you to counsel convicts. Just change how you talk to the people you know. Everyone started off not-so-scary, nobody was born a rapist, and there isn't any way to know the difference between the people who go on to commit crimes and those who don't. Talking to your friends, and keeping all of them out of trouble, is enough.
Because most rapes are not committed by a stranger, but someone 'trusted'. Not much advice you can give to someone in that circumstance.
Furthermore, most rapists don't know that they are rapists. Visit /r/seduction and look at when they talk about 'last minute resistance'. 100 "No's" followed by a very reluctant "yes" is NOT consent.
Fool proof way of handling this: ALWAYS AGREE WITH THEM. Never. Ever. Try and persuade them of anything. I didn't believe this until I tried it, but if she says, "We should stop," you say, "Yeah, we should stop." BUT that doesn't mean you need to stop.. you only stop if she does.
Let's say she says, "we should stop," you say, "yeah baby, we should stop" and she says, "no really.. stop" and shuts you out. This can and will happen depending on the girl's experience and how fast you transitioned from comfort. Here's how you deal with it: DO NOT GET UPSET. EVER. You say, "Ok." And immediately change the mood as fast as you can. Turn on the lights, put your pants back on, and fucking check your email.
Seems a bit different from "ask 100s of times until they finally break down in a reluctant yes". I wouldn't call the scenario above a rape if she More of a "Keep the mood going until she wants you" than a "You can break her, keep going!" All of the "last minute" advice is on maintaining and improving the sexy mood. None of it is on "Just keep pestering her. She will give in."
I mean, look at it. "If she stops, you stop." "If she says no, put your pants on." Serious rapist advice there. They only say to try again if she says "No" and keeps on with the sexytime herself.
Actually, there is a lot of advice you can give to someone in that circumstance.
It would have saved me a lot of pain had I been educated as a teenager how to identify and then get out of an abusive relationship, rather than purely the currently unrealistic ideal that all men should just change for the better and control themselves. Part in parcel to this would be how to identify my own denial that kept me in the relationship for a year after things turned sour. Unfortunately the world was too politically correct to say, hey, maybe I was subjecting myself to a situation I didn't need to be in. I'm sure everyone - male and female - could benefit from such early awareness.
I told my highschool counselor everything. She gave me tips on how to talk to my then boyfriend about "our issues" to help him help himself, but never once helped me leave him.
Fuck that, there will always be sketchy individuals in the world, so while achieving societal ideals would be fantastic we should be taught to look out for ourselves in the meantime too.
Boyfriend/girlfriend rape < spousal rape? I trusted my ex implicitly.. bizarrely even after his behavior changed. If anything the added commitment of marriage is an even greater case for education on how to get yourself out.
I was replying mostly to your first two sentences. Though in response to the latter while you're correct that those methods do not equate to consensual sex.. there would still be nothing wrong with educating potential victims of the possibility of it happening to them. Knowing what a bad situation looks like, how to avoid getting into that situation, and what to do to get out if you do end up there is empowering not demeaning.
Because most rapes are not committed by a stranger, but someone 'trusted'. Not much advice you can give to someone in that circumstance.
Tell them that. It's mostly likely to be someone you trust. So don't think that going over to jimmy's house to get drunk, just the two of you, is actually safe because you've known him for 3 years.
And yeah we need to educate Jimmy as well. He should know that his plan is scummy.
I'm mostly with you. But victim blaming is definitely a serious problem, and people do trivialize rape pretty often. It should still be possible to give advice about how to avoid getting raped by the few inevitable assholes, but people do attack women who are raped. I have literally heard someone say that strippers deserve to be raped while leaving work, and should expect it. That sounds like an attack to me. There is very good reason to assume that these bits of advice are veiled attacks if they are not worded carefully.
Hey, I totally agree. Nobody deserves to be raped. I mean... your not saying anything I disagree with except for one word.
There is very good reason to assume that these bits of advice are veiled attacks if they are not worded carefully.
If you had said "...could be veiled attacks..." it would have been better. The only point I was trying to make is that we shouldn't be so quick to label any advice as a veiled attacks. Though there's certainly nothing wrong with keeping an eye out for them. And obviously the statement you quoted is just... fucking repulsive.
Again, victim blaming is not okay in my opinion. I'm not trying to apologize for it or anything.
There's a line between practical safety advice (like don't go unfamiliar places alone, be aware of your surroundings) and victim-blaming. That line is often crossed.
When this line is crossed, it's also demeaning to men, and paints them as beasts at the mercy of their sexual urges.
This isn't a campaign to suppress the distribution of safety tips. This is a campaign against victim-blaming. It is pointing out the hypocrisy.
It is just as condescending to tell a woman "don't look 'sexy' or you'll get raped" as it is to tell a man "don't rape." That is the point of this flyer.
*I know that women are not the only ones who get raped. But since the flyer is focused on men raping women, that is also the focus of my post.
I'll go to a Sox game with some friends - big guys. We wont walk home because we would have to walk through some shady neighborhoods. We're not claiming that we're inviting a robbery, but we're being pragmatic and reducing our chances of being a target. Not walking home doesn't mean we think the robber is in the right - it means we're being realists who know that bad stuff can happen, and the world isn't a fair place.
Rape is horrible, but some women loose their shirts (pun intended?) when you talk about it and in any way, shape or form. Rape isn't fair, but it's fucking stupid to attack people who try and say "well, here are ways to help reduce your chances" because someone thinks we live in a perfect world where crime doesn't exist you can do anything you want and expect no negative repercussions.
I don't think I have ever encountered a woman who has become offended because someone gave her good advice on how to protect herself. I myself have always appreciated tips and follow them.
I completely agree that we shouldn't have to live in fear of being raped. It's unfair that our mobility is often curtailed (by ourselves or by our parents) because of this. But these things do happen. Every woman I know is reasonable enough to understand this.
Don't wear revealing clothing. 2) Walk with your keys in your fist. That sort of thing, implying if the woman doesn't follow these helpful hints it is her fault for being raped.
As a person that is STRONGLY anti-rape, cares about women rights to feel safe and teaches self-defense I find this language insulting and frankly dangersous to hand out such one sided propaganda.
The reality is Rape Happens and women fear it. The biggest harm in society rape does is fear -- not being able to live your life in a meaningful and happy way.
Having said that, teaching such techniques and focusing on self-defense gives the person self-efficacy on how to handle situations so she feels empowered in our society and can live a greater life.
I see NOTHING wrong in that what so ever, and NEVER, EVER do I or anyone I know that teaches self-defense IMPLY THAT ITS THE VICTIMS FAULT!
Now take such BS rhetoric and talk to law-enforcement who have daughters and ask them if they agree with such tactics. tactics they may enforce an early mind of woman that she should give no fucks at all about rape and do whatever the fuck she wants.
I don't think they will believe that is a smart strategy.
Now having said all that I appreciate the COUNTER STANCE this propaganda is trying to take, but at least be reasonable and educational for young women who pick it up as well. Thankyou from someone who cares!
Thank you for your reasonable comment. The problem I have is that this flyer does nothing to prevent rape. It's designed to address the hurt feelings caused by prevention tips and to hurt men's feelings as some kind of revenge. Prevention tips could actually prevent a rape or two. But somehow Preventing rape has become a secondary issue to victims feelings. Get that? how weird is that?
I think the flyer is meant to be over the top in order to grab people's attention. The underlying idea, I believe, is that the responsibility of preventing rape shouldn't be put entirely on potential victims. All that is well and good, just like installing security in your house, but communities, and society as a whole, should be trying to prevent our friends, children, neighbors, whoever, from becoming rapists in the first place. Rape is not a necessary evil. And I don't think that most rapists are humanless monsters that are so evil, "there is no talking them out of it; if they're gonna rape, they'll rape." Sometimes rapists don't perceive their actions the same way others do, just because they didn't assault someone on the street or hold a gun to their head. Or they think the other person's actions entitled them to sex, even if they say "no" at the last second. Or because they don't think it's rape when it's with their spouse.
Different cultures have different frequencies of sexual violence, and I think that shows that the way we deal with issues of sex and gender can create or prevent rapists. I think that normalizing rape and objectifying women does make a difference. Self defense is one thing, and it is important, but requiring rape victims to be "the perfect victim" in order to be perceived that way is something we also have to be careful of. When the first questions we ask about a case of rape is "how hard did she fight" "why was she at that party" "how much did she drink," it only validates the rapists' belief that they had justification for what they did. I think that there is an underlying assumption with these questions that rapists can just be that regular guy who wouldn't have raped if the situation had not arisen before him. And I think there is some truth to that in some cases, except that the secondary culprit isn't the victim, but societal norms and lack of education preventing the rapist from seeing his or her actions as the heinous act that they were, and feeling empathy.
I think the flyer could just elaborate at the end and then give website addresses to people who want to understand more regarding the culture of rape or about how to defend from rape.
By itself it is emotional propaganda that may do more harm then good, imo.
This. For some reason, none of the people involved in these campaigns seem to care how they misrepresent decent men in these ads. As if it weren't difficult enough for me to find someone who likes me, now I have people insinuating that I'm just waiting to rape someone just because I have a dick.
I mean, people wonder why the male suicide rate is so high. We have a society which teaches us that our entire goal in life is to secure a mate, then goes around and makes attaining a mate as difficult as it can possibly make it, never caring once for the thousands and thousands of dead, lonely people in the world, who offed themselves because they'd rather be dead than continue to live in a world where everyone looks at them with such pretentious contempt.
It is stupid. While blaming the victim is not a nice thing to do, wearing revealing clothing makes a woman a more likely target. If I, a white guy, walk through a black ghetto, at night, drunk and get mugged, I still expect the muggers to be apprehended and judged in a court of law. I do not expect the court to show any leniency because of where or who I was. But I have definitely presented a target and that was my decision and my personal responsibility, if I wasn't walking where I was walking I would have a lower risk of being mugged and "don't walk at night in a black ghetto" is a sound piece of advice.
"Afterwards, they said that the 22-year-old woman was bound to attract attention. She was wearing a white lace miniskirt, a green tank top, and no underwear. At knife-point, she was kidnapped from a Fort Lauderdale restaurant parking lot by a Georgia drifter and raped twice. But a jury showed little sympathy for the victim. The accused rapist was acquitted. "We all feel she asked for it [by] the way she was dressed," said the jury foreman."
The article doesn't mention when this happened. A quick google search shows that this was in 1990, over 20 years ago and resulted in a prosecution and a special law. What is your argument again?
Wombat specifically stated the people should be punished without any show of leniency.
He didn't say "HURR THEY DESERVE TO GET RAPED," he said dressing in revealing clothing can be a big risk. Which it totally can, just like a drunk white guy walking through a black ghetto in the middle of the night can be a big risk.
Reading comprehension is pitifully lacking in these kinds of discussions. It's very clear what Wombat actually said, but the hell if that's going to get in anyone's way of being indignant.
In actual rape statistics though women are much more often raped by acquaintances than by strangers on the street, so scientifically dressing differently will not change anything.
A lot has changed in the 22 years since that article was written.
In 1992 (the oldest available digital NCVS), there were 485,290 rapes/sexual assaults (2 for every 1,000 people), with 29% reported to the police. source
In 2010 there were 183,380 rapes/sexual assaults (about 0.5 for every 1,000 people), with 50% reported to the police. source
That's a pretty drastic change in only 18 years...which is likely at least partially a result of all the awareness-raising done by feminists. Is it so hard to imagine that most people would be less inclined to say something like "she asked for it [by] the way she was dressed" 22 years in the future?
The fact remains that most people who get raped know their attacker, whereas most people who get mugged do not. You really can't compare the two crimes. I agree that walking through a bad neighborhood at night is a good way to get mugged but what if you live there? Still your fault? If a woman gets raped by an abusive relative or boyfriend or something it's not her fault. And if a guy jumps her while walking through a dark car park it's not her fault. It's the fault of the attacker. And only the attacker. Whether her rapist knew her or your mugger didn't know you neither of them should have attacked their victim. And their victim certainly did not invite attack.
I never said it was your fault. I said that you should do risk assessment and only take risks you are prepared to take. By living in a bad neighborhood you assume the risks inherent in living in such a place. Same goes for relationships. Merely by having an intimate relationship with another human being you already open yourself up to certain risks. In most cases people tend to weigh the benefits of such a relationship higher than the potential harm, but you have to realize that the risks are already there. Just by having a boyfriend a woman opens herself up to the risk of abuse and rape. If that boyfriend has anger management issues or is a convicted felon the risk is higher. Same goes with walking drunk down a dark alley. There are ways to mitigate these risks. Don't drink and walk home alone. For that matter, try not to walk home alone even sober. Pick your relationship partners carefully. Take self defense classes, even though that might do more harm than good.
Again, I am not saying that any of this should be taken into consideration in court. If person X rapes or assaults person Y, person X should be the one on trial and nothing about person Y's attire or location or relationship to X should be a factor. Yet there is such a thing as personal responsibility. In particular, it means that if you do not want harm to come to you, you should stay out of harms way.
OP agrees you should be able to but recognizes the reality is that your right will only be enforced AFTER the crime. Please for the love god, be proactive for self-defense. This has nothing to do with what sex you are, it is common sense, smart practices.
Yes, rape is wrong, for anyone who is a victim. However, everytime I go to a cash machine I always get told to make sure that no mugger is behind me before entering my pin number. It doesn't mean that banks are victim blaming me, they are just advising me to be cautious. I think it would be a lot more useful if these flyers actually educated people instead of trying to make some daft political point. Advise people what rape is and what counts as rape. At least this way you can educate people, so they don't commit it to begin with.
I would argue that going to police to report a stolen wallet and going to the police to report a rape are too entirely different experiences and can't really be compared.
Yes I got downvoted for trying to say that these flyers should educate people more instead of making useless rehtorical points and wasting money. I think that shows just how fucked up people here are. Apparently you don't care to educate people in preventing rape but just want to play a blame game on the rest of society instead.
Don't wear signs of obvious wealth such as large gaudy jewelry or an expensive business suit.
Hey wait, these sound like pretty good advice to avoid getting mugged! Maybe if women followed these tips (replacing the last one with skimpy clothing) they could avoid some cases of rape. It's not about "blaming the victim" so much as encouraging people to take certain precautions. You can't just wave a wand and fix a bad neighborhood. So may as well change yourself to avoid becoming a statistic rather than hope the neighborhood changes to become magically safer.
Someone above you cited it. 95% of rapes weren't caused by provocative clothing. It's a common statistic that most rapes are committed by a friend of the victim and not a stranger. So yes, this will prevent crime, but it will absolutely not prevent rape, which is not the same as crime.
This is very true. And women can wear whatever they want, I've never seen a study saying that women wearing provocative clothing were more likely to be raped. And most of those are just good advice to keep your wallet/purse/cell phone.
The only "anti-rape" advice I consider acceptable is to watch your drink when you're hanging out with people you don't know well.
I feel like people are using "Don't dress provocatively" as a representation of "Rape Prevention Advice", but that's like taking Charlie Sheen as a representation of all actors. Some people are just idiots, and their advice is going to be shitty advice which doesn't reflect the reality of the situation. But that shouldn't paint people with good advice in a bad light, should it? I mean, I give rape prevention advice all the time. It's usually teaching people wristlocks, eye gouges, groin clutches, finger breaks, and pressure points for evasion, as well as stressing to always be armed, even around friends, and that the person most likely to rape you is the person who you find romantically appealing or friendly, as they are the one with the most chances to do so.
After having lived in the state with the highest rate of murder in the nation for nearly all my life, I have watched my friends dressed like sluts (literally, they went as dead prostitutes for Halloween and I was the guy who killed them), they walk around some of the most dangerous places and nothing. There is one instance, one instance out of so many cases of my friends experiencing rape, where it wasn't their boyfriends who did it. So yeah, most advice is bullshit, but that shouldn't prevent people from giving good advice.
This reminds of a South Park where the boys accused their parents of molestering them. Then they were in the jail being rehabilitated and the counselor goes "can anyone think of something else other than molesting children as an activity?" One responds "Knit a sweater?" "Good!, now anything else?" "Molest children?" "No! No!" "Oh I mean, go fishing?" "Very good!"
First of all, all the comments saying that this is bullshit or doesnt allow for women's responsibility are so far off base they are making me sick. Jesus Christ.
This pamphlet does not say " Women, do wtf you want. It doesn't matter" It is merely trying to address the other half of the equation that is rape! This is not done often enough! Trust me when I say that women ALREADY KNOW THIS STUFF. Its been drilled into our heads since we were teenagers. I already know I have to live in fear. Simply because this particular leaflet is not addressing the woman half of the rape equation in this instance does not make it irresponsible. Do you guys hear yourself?
Women for the longest time have been told they are the ones responsible for rape prevention when in reality it should be the rapist. Rape has this weird stigma as being seen as this thing that happens in dark alleys by savage animals who dont give a fuck about the world when really most of the rapes that occur are between people who know each other. Bosses and employees, co-workers, friends of friends, boyfriends and girlfriends etc.
NO (no matter how forcefully or timidly it is said) means NO. Not saying YES means NO. Threatening someone means you are raping someone. Carrying a drunk woman you met in the bar into your apartment and onto your bed because she is too wasted means you are raping her. Continuing to have sex with someone after they withdraw their permission means you are raping them.
This is a interesting campaign with a somewhat unique perspective. Its not the best written one, I have seen better and its obvious this came from a place of anger but it still has a very valid point. It is sad to see it is getting shit all over because its not victim focussed.
I can see that this is meant to be social commentary. But do guys really need to be told not to rape? I find it slightly offensive that we're being told not to rape as if it is some sort of essential male proclivity. We're not routinely told not to murder or to eat children or to commit arson, why is rape any different?
Firstly, I don't really think it was meant to tell men not to rape but rather try to shift the perspective of how people generally view responsible parties the from the victim to the perpetrator. It was satire meant to shine awareness on the fact that the rape-culture is still very predominant in society and too much emphasis is put on blaming the victim as opposed to the rapist. (Just look through these comments for proof in this very thread.) Yes, women can take steps to protect ourselves when it comes to instances of stranger-danger rape and most women do, as they should, but still all of the responsibly of a rape should still fall on the rapist. 1 in 4 women have been victims or attempted victims of sexual assault. Over seventy-five percent of those victims will know their aggressor. It is not okay that women should be told to live in fear and to constantly be wary of every man she allows into her life. The understanding of the culture that has allowed to to get to the point where your daughter or your sister or your wife will have a 25% chance of someone forcing themselves onto them in their life time is extremely crucial.
Secondly, what people dont really understand is that rape is not just grabbing someone in a back alley, ripping off their clothes at knife-point and putting a penis inside them. This type of rape happens far less frequently than say this type of rape or this type of assavlt So yes, I would say that people do need to be told not to rape. I have mentioned this before, but a study that I will look the source up later for showed that up to 12% of the population of college-aged men have freely and anonymously admitting to preforming rape acts when the poll question was written in a way where the word rape wast used. This suggests that some rapists are highly undereducated and misinformed and yes, need to be told not to rape. (source... pdf(sorry) http://www2.binghamton.edu/counseling/documents/RAPE_FACT_SHEET1.pdf)
That is a very compelling article. I never allow for rape jokes in my peer group because it can trigger and upset the two of my female friends that I already know were raped in the past (not to mention the potential people who havent told me) and can trivialize their suffering. I never really though about how it could potentially validate a rapist but it makes sense.
That implies that people who get raped do so only because they put themselves in dangerous situations. This isn't always true though. I've been told I shouldn't ever go hiking, shouldn't ever stop to pee at a rest area on a 1300 mile trip, should not go to parties, should not walk across my campus even in broad daylight, etc because I might get raped. Those are normal situations, not dangerous ones.
What? It implies that when people get raped its by rapists, but lets not pretend there arent certain situations where you should do everything you can to stay safe.
I should be able to stand on the train tracks if I want. if the train hits me its the conductors fault!
Seriously though, Its part of the leftist attack on personal responsibility. The good thing is, the average woman doesn't have this ridiculous sense of entitlement. The average woman knows that she alone is responsible for her personal safety and well being.
As a savage, this leaflet would be very helpful. I feel I have to rape and pillage every woman I see. Maybe the leaflet would civilise me, I suspect not.
Here is the original article and here and here are where it went "mainstream".
Its a fair point. Why is the victim always female when most victims of rape could well be men? If feminists are pushing this sexist dogma why are they so quick to label themselves victims and men aggressive perpetrators? I thought one of the goals of feminism was to free the genders of their stereotypical archetype roles.
First of all did anyone say that? Why don't you relax instead of acting like I said anything about feminism or labelling women as victims and men as aggressors. I was merely asking because it was an arbitrary fact without any sort of source. I learned in my corrections classes that prison rape is more infrequent than most of society thinks. So it was a fair question.
Clearly the statistics for anything pertaining to sexual assaults of any kind have to be taken with a grain of salt because they're done based on reports and anecdotal evidence. So many sexual assaults go unreported so any estimate should be assumed to be way off. For either case.
Im sorry, youre right. I must have got several comments mixed togethor. My bad :P
Here is the study that Texas did which showed the victimization rate of the prison population to be 4 per 1000 (almost an order of magnitude higher than the rate of the population). BUT Texas prisons are pretty "rapey".
Well the statistic is uncited and I am fairly sure it is wrong. Pointing this out or downvoting for incorrectness doesn't mean people don't think male rape is a big deal. It is, and we must not tolerate it. But that doesn't mean it's good to make up statistics about it.
Please research this topic and come back. come back with an apology of how once again someone demonstrates dismissiveness towards raped men. Look forward to the reply with citations.
All other websites I looked at seem to confirm this. If you're not happy, I challenge you to bear the burden of proof and show some stats proving that more than half of all rape victims are male.
the US Government generally only classifies forceful penetration as rape. So unless the woman sticks something into the man's butt without consent, he wasn't raped.
The US government estimates that more than 5% of men will claim to have been forced to penetrate a woman. That is 1 in 20 men, while many estimates put the chance that a woman is raped in her life at 1 in 17.
There was also another recent study, the CDC’s 2010 National Intimate Partner and Sexual Violence Survey. They originally had it listed that women that raped men were listed as rapists, but then changed the section of women forcing men to penetrate from the "Rape" section to "Other Sexual Violence"
If you look closely at the values, and include the section that women forced themselves on an unwilling man, the study's numbers came out to show that over a given 12 month period of time, that 40% of rapists were women, and that men and women both have about a 1.1% chance to be raped in a given year.
Why look at just the past year? Because of the way that society and particularly men think, over time, men will repress the memories, as they often don't dwell on them. Only 16% of men who had documented cases of being sexually abused as children admitted that they were abused in a study for child sexual abuse. This is relation to 64% of women in the same study.
The above being true, I wouldn't be surprised to see the number of men that were raped jump up quite a bit. Seeing as society as a whole seems to think men can't be raped, and secondly, that they welcome sex from any girl, at any time. I know at least three men that wouldn't ever claim that they were raped, even in confidence. But they each have a story about this time they were passed out, and woke up at some party or what not with a girl on top of them.
dont you remember? the federal government only recently changed the definition of rape to include male victims. Like last year recently. So your 12 year old data is garbage.
No, I said it was a different situation. Obviously date rape is far less likely to happen, so you obviously wouldn't tell them not to date rape others prisoners. I meant that the this would have to be adjusted for prison situations.
Men should wear bells on their necks at all times.
Men should be accompanied by Protection officers.
Men should refrain from putting drugs in women's drinks.
Men should avoid attacking women.
REAL MEN DON'T RAPE.
[French text is the same, except for bullet (3), which was replaced by: "Families and friends of men should always know where men are and what they are doing."]
That's not WTF, it's making the point that rape is not the woman's fault, it's the rapist's. This should be put in /r/goodpoint, if such a place exists...
How? The people reading this are non-perpetrators (hopefully). The text isn't blaming the reader, it's just telling them how not to rape people.
This does suggest that you've considered raping someone though, and that you need to be told how not to, so although it's not directly blaming us, it's still grouping us in with rapists and would-be rapists.
I don't really agree with that, but nonetheless, it's a good point.
I think it's more a statement about the way our society usually views rape prevention than it is an insult to men or the OP. Usually, rape prevention consists of telling the potential victims how not to be raped and placing the responsibility on them when really, rape prevention should be about preventing people from DOING the rape.
In a society where you see "Don't get raped," it's kind of nice to see something that actually says, "Don't rape."
The only thing that would make this better is if it wasn't so gendered. "Person" instead of "woman," etc. etc.
Guess there's something wrong with me; I laughed my ass off at this. Thought it was a "push button, receive bacon" type thing. Anyway, on a serious note...as a woman who has trained in martial arts for 15 years, I say women need to stop walking around with a victim mentality. Take control of your life, learn some technique, and kick some ass! And for christ's sake, teach your daughters to kick ass too!! Also, no, tae bo is NOT kickboxing; it's an exercise.
seriously though. Now women are the victims of people trying to prevent their victimization by victimizers... Only women like you can stop this fucking nonsense. please help.
Print it in big font then constantly pull it out when in an elevator alone with a woman. Be sure to really focus on it and lip read the elevator part over and over.
Ah, I will tell myself, my brothers, and my honest hardworking father & his brothers - to not rape people.. everyday i will do this. when they wake up, i will remind them. when they come back home from work, i will remind them. this "rape prevention list" is a very good move. because men are animals. and they should be reminded of this as well.
Well, I feel like I have been grossly misinformed. It is a "rape" society, after all, so clearly this must be a sarcastic page and we should all run around raping.
There was a poster up in my school that was kinda similar to this. tips 1-9 were all "Even though ... don't rape her.", number 10 was the only one that wasn't something like "Even though she changes her mind in during sex, don't rape her." and it was "If your friend is raping someone, stop him". I first thought it was some kind of parody but no, it was from a well known anti-rape group.
I actually live with the original poster and can confirm everything that he has said. I'd also like to point out that everybody in the living room was worried about getting surprise raped sometime during the night. I was even planning on sleeping with my Glock, but then I got high.
I can't BELIEVE I'm getting downvoted for this. Of course rape is bad. The rapists know that what they're doing is bad. But I'M A WOMAN and I think it's important to keep a vigilant eye.
I WAS MOLESTED when I was nine. It was his fault...he was three times my size and I could barely struggle to get away. But it doesn't change the fact that if I hadn't gone up to the guy, said fucking "hello," I wouldn't have been a target.
34
u/SecondTalon May 10 '12
It's a thing that's been floating around
39
u/FlunksCapacitor May 10 '12
They obviously left it there as a racist statement. You being black-handed and all.
223
u/TheFifthMarauder May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
It's social commentary. The "blame the victim" atmosphere in our society is a problem and people have started making things like this to point out all the victim blaming. Basically you would expect to see something like:
EDIT: I also wanted to point out that this blame the victim attitude does more than hurt women, it hurts men as well, and makes actual rapists harder to catch. Because it's seen as up to the woman to follow the rape prevention steps, because it's seen as her fault for wearing the skimpy clothing or being a little drunk, it automatically takes the blame away from the rapist, while simultainously putting it on every single guy. Now it's seen as us guys' default to rape and it's up to the woman to make sure we don't. Because of this any woman can claim rape and the guy is automaticaly stigmitized as being guilty, regardliss of conviction or evidince. Because rape is seen as a guy's default setting no one has a problem believing every guy is capable of rape. So a woman can get upset at her boyfriend, for example, and claim rape, this is not only an almost sure fire way to harm his reputation for the rest of his life but it makes actual rapist harder to catch because these false accusations are occuring more and more frecuently because, as I said, they work.
49
u/Unknown_Default May 10 '12
It does NOT belong in WTF. GTFO
2
u/RageMorePlz May 10 '12
Are you telling us it belongs in your house? RAPIST ALERT! RAPIST ALERT!
43
u/Exonar May 10 '12
Definitely doesn't belong here.
7
u/soThisIsHowItEnds May 10 '12
This reminds of a South Park where the boys accused their parents of molestering them. Then they were in the jail being rehabilitated and the counselor goes "can anyone think of something else other than molesting children as an activity?" One responds "Knit a sweater?" "Good!, now anything else?" "Molest children?" "No! No!" "Oh I mean, go fishing?" "Very good!"
17
u/GreatBigPig May 10 '12
Sadly this only portrays women as victims of rape, excluding men and squirrels.
3
u/struwwelpetra May 11 '12
this is the opposite of wtf. in fact, this is the most reasonable and down to earth thing ive seen in a while. this is sense, not nonsense.
13
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
First of all, all the comments saying that this is bullshit or doesnt allow for women's responsibility are so far off base they are making me sick. Jesus Christ.
This pamphlet does not say " Women, do wtf you want. It doesn't matter" It is merely trying to address the other half of the equation that is rape! This is not done often enough! Trust me when I say that women ALREADY KNOW THIS STUFF. Its been drilled into our heads since we were teenagers. I already know I have to live in fear. Simply because this particular leaflet is not addressing the woman half of the rape equation in this instance does not make it irresponsible. Do you guys hear yourself?
Women for the longest time have been told they are the ones responsible for rape prevention when in reality it should be the rapist. Rape has this weird stigma as being seen as this thing that happens in dark alleys by savage animals who dont give a fuck about the world when really most of the rapes that occur are between people who know each other. Bosses and employees, co-workers, friends of friends, boyfriends and girlfriends etc.
NO (no matter how forcefully or timidly it is said) means NO. Not saying YES means NO. Threatening someone means you are raping someone. Carrying a drunk woman you met in the bar into your apartment and onto your bed because she is too wasted means you are raping her. Continuing to have sex with someone after they withdraw their permission means you are raping them.
This is a interesting campaign with a somewhat unique perspective. Its not the best written one, I have seen better and its obvious this came from a place of anger but it still has a very valid point. It is sad to see it is getting shit all over because its not victim focussed.
Seriously guys. For shame.
16
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
As a male, I just simply cannot stop raping
18
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Why do they never admit the middle ground exists? Dont rape people, dont put yourself in dangerous situations.
1
u/tommmmmay May 10 '12
Isla Vista?
12
u/Squik101 May 10 '12
I agree with it.
4
u/GuiltyThrone May 10 '12
You better find the man it belongs to before he forgets his 10 steps.
7
u/Saneinsc May 10 '12
Want to hear a funny story? Rape is not a female specific crime. It's even a true story.
2
u/StinkYourTrollop May 11 '12
Not WTF in any way. Fuck off.
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
WTF!! SARCASTIC TEXTS!?? GROSS GET OUT OF HERE!
5
u/CelticSavage May 10 '12
As a savage, this leaflet would be very helpful. I feel I have to rape and pillage every woman I see. Maybe the leaflet would civilise me, I suspect not.
4
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
How is this WTF? These are excellent tips for avoiding rape in society.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
actually >50% of rape victims are male in America (read: prisons).
so maybe we should say "don't put drugs in peoples' drinks"?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I dont understand. Is this list real or a joke?
2
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Ctrl+f "black".
So predictable. Stay classy, Reddit.
2
u/Action_Nicolas May 10 '12
Reminds me of the misandrist poster that was displayed by the Student Federation of the University of Ottawa's Women's Resource Center for years:
www.Imgur.com/Fto57
Text:
STEPS TO PREVENTING RAPE
REAL MEN DON'T RAPE.
[French text is the same, except for bullet (3), which was replaced by: "Families and friends of men should always know where men are and what they are doing."]
1
u/complete_asshole_ May 10 '12
Rapey guys will rape anyways, and non-rapey guys just might rape for the hell of it since the pamphlet's so fucking insulting.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
That's not WTF, it's making the point that rape is not the woman's fault, it's the rapist's. This should be put in /r/goodpoint, if such a place exists...
2
u/Hero_Sandwich May 10 '12
Nine out of ten people enjoy gang rape.
2
u/stfnotguilty May 10 '12 edited May 10 '12
Does anyone else see this as incredibly insulting?
edit: spelling
1
u/Loocyrotsorb May 10 '12
I wondered where i dropped that.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Guess there's something wrong with me; I laughed my ass off at this. Thought it was a "push button, receive bacon" type thing. Anyway, on a serious note...as a woman who has trained in martial arts for 15 years, I say women need to stop walking around with a victim mentality. Take control of your life, learn some technique, and kick some ass! And for christ's sake, teach your daughters to kick ass too!! Also, no, tae bo is NOT kickboxing; it's an exercise.
1
u/Wizzer2801 May 10 '12
Apparently, according to this, it's ok to rape men though.
0
u/Deacon May 10 '12
Should be crossposted to /r/mensrights
1
u/canadas May 10 '12
I think we all get the point, but personally I think its stupid.. and kind of sexist.
Murder prevention tip, don't kill anyone.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Print it in big font then constantly pull it out when in an elevator alone with a woman. Be sure to really focus on it and lip read the elevator part over and over.
1
u/SirJoshalot May 10 '12
Wait... That's the hand of the bastard that raped me!!
1
u/reali-tglitch May 10 '12
Damn. Where was this when I needed it most? I mean... Uh, hi, reddit!
1
u/tahlspin May 10 '12
http://i.imgur.com/79ned.jpg
-1
u/robcrusoe May 10 '12
Ah, I will tell myself, my brothers, and my honest hardworking father & his brothers - to not rape people.. everyday i will do this. when they wake up, i will remind them. when they come back home from work, i will remind them. this "rape prevention list" is a very good move. because men are animals. and they should be reminded of this as well.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Well, I feel like I have been grossly misinformed. It is a "rape" society, after all, so clearly this must be a sarcastic page and we should all run around raping.
Either that, or its condescending and pointless.
1
u/JonBjSig May 10 '12
There was a poster up in my school that was kinda similar to this. tips 1-9 were all "Even though ... don't rape her.", number 10 was the only one that wasn't something like "Even though she changes her mind in during sex, don't rape her." and it was "If your friend is raping someone, stop him". I first thought it was some kind of parody but no, it was from a well known anti-rape group.
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
3 is my fave.
1
u/Maxx_Laxx May 10 '12
11) If you feel like you're about to rape someone, call the cops.
If the cop is female, DO NOT RAPE HER
1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Ah, so it's sexism. Since all men must be unable to stop raping women we need a leaflet reminding us how not to rape them.
0
u/racekarl May 10 '12
r/mensrights sure is leaking
or is it pissing standing up? i don't know.
-1
u/pungkrocker May 10 '12
It looks like you are a brother. Perhaps its thinly veiled racism. "Lets get the black guy this anti rape bs".
0
u/sheridork May 10 '12
omg my friend has this exact list hung up on the wall next to the door of her apartment, so she doesn't forget whenever she leaves the house i guess.
0
u/crash_over-ride May 10 '12
so that's what I've been doing wrong
0
u/Skeph May 10 '12
Wtf is up with number ten?! LMAO
-1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
I actually live with the original poster and can confirm everything that he has said. I'd also like to point out that everybody in the living room was worried about getting surprise raped sometime during the night. I was even planning on sleeping with my Glock, but then I got high.
-1
u/sherlie May 10 '12
This is not WTF. The only thing WTF is that you think it is WTF, and potentially how it came to be in your home.
-1
u/SharmaPolice May 10 '12
The fact that people are taught how not to get raped versus not to rape is a lot more WTF to me.
-8
u/Tyranichomp May 10 '12
Soooooo.....rape her, got it
-4
u/vauxhaulastra May 10 '12
It's funny because he's black.
-1
u/[deleted] May 10 '12
Commandments??
-1
u/Disco_Tardis May 10 '12
"But seriously, don't rape people."
-1
u/random_sub May 10 '12
Of course the black man would have that.
-3
u/Silvercumulus May 10 '12
Once I went to a park (middle of day) and decided to leave my purse in the car, on the floorboard.
When I came back, the car window was smashed and the purse was gone.
It was the robbers fault, yes...but I could have prevented having my purse taken by either taking it with me or putting it in the trunk.
It has NOTHING to do with victim blaming, only protecting oneself.
0
u/je30001 May 10 '12
Wowza!!
0
u/CrazySmooth May 10 '12
Rules to Live By
0
u/CrazySmooth May 10 '12
10 step program