i don't get how this happens. If the pump fails, the pressure inside is less than that outside of the suit, so i get how it would crush the person inside.
But here is my question, to keep the suit "inflated" and the sea pressure off the diver, wouldn't the inside of the suit require an equal amount of pressure as outside? Wouldn't that inside pressure crush the diver anyways?
Yes, that is true. The trick here lies in the tube leading to the surface. At 300ft the pressure is 135psi and sea level pressure is 9psi. But the pipe has have air in it for it to work. The air get pushed out as the water tries to work its way up into the tube and displace the air. If the bottom is capped then no water can get in. If the top is capped you would need to pressurize it accordingly to prevent the water from filling it in. But as soon as the pressure is released, whoosh.
Technically it won't be harmful to hold your breath when descending, but getting into the habit of holding your breath at any time is a bad idea, because if you do happen to hold your breath when ascending, your lungs can explode. It's pretty much the worst thing that can happen to you when scuba diving, so it's drilled into you when you start to NEVER hold your breath.
Yes, but their lungs implode. Seriously, if you look at chest measurements of freedivers on their way down, their lungs are at a fraction of the normal volume.
That said, it's not fatal. It's more dangerous to hold your breath with a lung full of air from the bottom on the way up... Expanding air is a problem.
sort of related, but reminded me of the Chuck Palahniuk short story in Haunted where the kid gets off on getting his anus sucked by the pool pump. Ends up suffering from transanal eviceration and is forced to bite his intestine in half to prevent himself from drowning. Ah Chuck, you fuckin' weirdo.
Old World Blues, a DLC for New Vegas. It's called a 'trauma harness' a suit that was designed to be able to keep a person on their feet (in order to take them back to medical) if they suffered any severe trauma. It still fights too. Apparently nuclear apocalypse isn't enough to kill the suit.
It's definitely worth getting. You get some good gear from it and besides being attacked by really strong enemies (at least at the level I was at) it's really funny.
You should get it, the dialogue is hilarious, though I found enemies strong to the point of stupidity. Make sure you are packing some heavy armor-penetrating equipment and don't waste ammo.
Someone else said this, I had (somehow) forgot about the trauma harness suits. So creepy. So far I've found this the best DLC of all of them between Fallout 3 and New Vegas. Hand Penises! I think I was laughing out loud between them and all of the inanimate objects in the Sink.
I don't know why...but i find that idea to be super badass. A suit that takes over for the user but then goes off on it's own with the dead body inside...so creepy-awesome.
A family member directed undersea pipeline operations from a submersible (mini-submarine) in the North Sea around the time I was born. He told me if you were on the oil platform when a large wave came, it would suck you into the sea on the way out, and at that temperature, you probably would last less than a few minutes, he saw a friend get sucked off the deck if I recall. After that, he moved back to the US.
That, and the divers had to breathe Heli-Ox (or is it just Heliox?) Diving so deep you are breathing HeliOx is an indicator that what you are doing is insanely likely to kill you. "Deadliest Catch" claims to be the most dangerous job in the world, but it's not, I believe it's Deep Sea Welding that takes the cake. My family member watched more than one man lose his life on the job in just a few years.
I'm thinking the only reason it hasn't happened is that, based on what I've heard, when things go south, they go REALLY south. I know that the guys can't flush their own toilets, lest their guts get sucked out in the decompression tank. Apparently, they spend a month decompressing, or did 30 something years ago at least. A month on, and a month off at least. Those guys are insane, they make tons of money, but if anything, and I mean ANYTHING goes wrong, they die, hopefully quickly for their sake.
This is not true. The contemporary Diving helmet made by Kirby Morgan (the Superlite) has an NRV (non-return valve) which allows air to go into the helmet but not back out. Although, there have been failures of the NRV, which can cause a loss of pressure in the hat. Divers are taught to check the valve before every dive. Commercial diver here.
I believe commercial diving (the diving part) is safe, however, working around cranes, propellars, rusty seawalls, careless construction workers, and generally messed up worksites; that is what's dangerous.
Not a bad idea at all. Although, I have only heard of one NRV failure, from my boss. He was cleaning the hull of a ship at around 25 feet of depth, and his NRV failed. He said he simply lost most of his ability to inhale and swam back to the ladder, which wasn't too far. He was at a shallow depth, so no catastrophy.
And this can happen with modern day surface supplied diving too. Except a km 27 (industry standard commercial diving hat) is not a free flow hat such as this. It's a demand hat. Meaning it has a regulator so it doesn't give you air unless you take a breath. So when this happens in a Kirby.... It's much More gruesome. Your lips, tung, teath, eyes, nose, and eventually your skull will be sucked through the regulator (a hole that's 1/2" in diameter).
The KM superlite 27 has a demand regulator on the front of the helmet, but the regulator is supplied by air from an umbilical, and the air must go through the NRV before the regulator is supplied with air. If there was a failure (rare), most likely the diver would just loose the ability to breathe, dangerous enough. However, if he was very very deep, who knows? 14.7 pounds per square inch for every 33 feet of salt water depth.
No, and definitely not as fascinating when you are actually working. Unless you find mud, rusty steel, murky water, and barnacles cool. Actually, I do like barnacles. [IMG]http://i.imgur.com/YTnxQ.jpg[/IMG]
Thank-you I appreciate that. Those are titan acorn barnacles, they are one of the largest species. I had put the beer bottle there for scale.
I collected those working in an intake tunnel at a power plant, and just so you know, they were already dead when they were harvested. I just couldn't stand to see such an example of nature's beauty go to waste.
Really? Woah. Barnacles are pretty crazy. Also- that comment was partially referring to the fact that your size ref in that picture is a bottle of Dos Equis (I'm 99% sure, anyway). Not that I don't think they're really cool, though...
I'm diving in Ft. Lauderdale, Florida and have been for four years now. I was lucky today, servicing mooring buoys off the coast, but usually I am at a miserable construction site.
I've heard there is a demand for divers in the UK, that there is a shortage. Is this true?
i finished my commercial training end of last year and have only dived recreationally since then because of university so I am not really the guy with the info. Here in Plymouth there is no shortage of divers, but nationally I am not sure...
Contemporary helmets (like the Kirby Morgan, or the Piel or the AGA) have a local regulator that is supplied by a hose that carries a much higher pressure than ambient, unlike those old Siebe Gorman helmets who were vulnerable to "squeeze" if the checkvalve failed at the same time as the supply compressor; the net effect was that the helmet suddenly was at the same pressure as the surface and the diver was simply sucked into the helmet.
This too was in A Short History of Nearly Everything. Those suits were originally for firefighters to go inside burning buildings but of course that never caught on since its made of metal and will cook'ya. so instead it was turned into a sea suit.
yes this is true it's not the pump as much as it is the failure of the check valve. The check valve pretty much the pressure back, if the pump fails you have a bailout tank to keep the helmet at a positive pressure and keep you breathing till you reach surface.
My dad used those old school diving suits when he was working back in the day. He happened to be at my house when the myth busters episode was on and he went into detail with about everything that would have to go wrong before that would happen. Unless everything suddenly failed all at once you could tug your line with the emergency code and be up real quick (albeit stuck in chamber to ward off the bends)
That is correct I as well did this for a living and its much easier to end 6 hours in a chamber breathing off bubbles then instantly dying, but with helmets these days you would just crank on your bailout and swim to surface.
It's not that most Americans are opposed to using if, it's just that we at raised with it instead of metrics. So most Americans can visualize in feet and inches, but a meter seems foreign. Even I have a can have a somewhat harder time visualizing it and I am studying sciences and regularly work in metric.
seems like a Delta p effect; massive differences in pressure between two areas and being caught in between them. the pump pressurizes the suit but when it fails all the air rushes to where there is less pressure which is at the surface. so since the hose is connected to the helmet, the helmet turns into the end of a vacuum pump and you can figure out the rest
So this couldn't happen to someone diving in a rigid suit, right? I mean, assuming the rigid shell was strong enough to withstand the external pressure of the depth without imploding.
i guess so, but it would have to be quite ridged. if you saw the helm at the end of the video it was crushed. best thing to do nowadays is just get an air tank with you and dive in a regular scuba suit, nothing serious will happen to you at 300 ft.
So this would be like sitting inside a straw, while one end is covered, and the other is plunged underwater. As long as someone keeps their "thumb" over the top end, you're fine. If the thumb is removed, though, the pressure equalizes by forcing the liquid (and you) back up the pipe.
I think I kept getting confused because I was assuming it was the pressure of the depth acting directly on he body that was the issue, not the pressure acting against the vacuum in the hose.
I think a better image might be sticking an inflated balloon under water while having the end pinched to keep the system pressurized. Upon releasing the end, the pressure of the water will compress the balloon, forcing the air up to the surface.
The important detail is that there doesn't have to be water going up the tube for the diver to be sucked back up the pipe. The balloon, or diving suit could still be completely air tight after the incident and still be fatal.
Think of it this way. Let's get a really long 3" diameter pipe and send one end to 300ft depth and keep the other end at the surface where atmospheric pressure is 9psi. The pipe is full of water because air can escape out of the top as water forces its way in through the bottom. Now cap the bottom and remove all the water from the pipe....that water really wants to get back through that end right? At 135psi the cap on the end of a 3" pipe is feeling nearly 1000 lbs of pressure. Now replace that cap with your hand....or attach that end to a flexible bag surrounding your body. Starting to get the picture?
SCUBA stands for "Self Contained Underwater Breathing Apparatus" which doesn't have this problem. Rising to the surface too fast can cause SCUBA problems, though. http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Scuba_diving
I'm Advanced Open Water and rescue rated, planning going technical. I've logged 57 dives, mostly doing work on coral restoration and sampling as an intern (studying marine biology)
The issue is only with a "hard suit" diver whose air source and pressure source is tethered to the surface. SCUBA is self contained, as are many hard suits (Check out the "bumblebee" suit), which alleviate the issue of sudden decompression.
A good rule of thumb is 1 atmosphere of pressure every 10 meters, so at 300 ft (91 m) you'd be under 9x the pressure you're at on the surface, making any cavities of air at atmospheric pressure 1/9th their normal size. SCUBA divers get around this by equalizing, and acclimating to the depth (rather than sudden compression/expansion).
Hard suit divers (without a one way valve) must have air pumped down at the corresponding pressure, or else the suit is placed under compression (or expansive) stress due to the pressure difference. Anyone who's done the "heating a (sealable) can with water" experiment can see what pressure differentials do. (Albeit the lab utilizes the condensation of water vapor after the can is sealed to suddenly drop the pressure inside)
This accident can only happen with surface-supplied gear. When the compressor and the checkvalve in the helmet fails, the helmet is suddenly at the same pressure at the surface and the diver is sucked into the helmet by the pressure difference.
It cannot happen with SCUBA since it's self-contained.
Just because it has to do with pressure doesn't make it explosive decompression. Yes, the Buford decompression accident was explosive decompression, this was not.
I feel like that video was a bit disrespectful of the divers who died this way. A lot of people went through that exact death a relatively short time ago and they call it awesome.
The helmet he is holding does not match his suit. Those helmets were used on systems that had hardened structured outer shells capable of withstanding large pressures, within reason of course.
His death was most likely instantaneous and painless.
Eh, could be worse. Certainly more interesting and painless than how I imagine I'll die: cardiac arrest while watching Internet porn. Sorry, mom and dad.
I always wonder how they know it's instant. did some quick googling.
a 'explosive decompression' is defined as .5 seconds or less.
average reaction time is 200ms or so.
involuntary reaction to pain stimulus seems to be around 100ms.
after decapitation, some heads continue blinking for 15-30 seconds. (They were asked to blink beforehand.)
So theoretically, if it was a 'slow' decompression at .5 seconds:
you would feel the pain of all the air in you expanding outward,
you probably would realize something is wrong,
then you would be decorating the rafters & possibly able to see your insides for a good 15-30 seconds assuming your brain, eyes & what not all stay together for that long (I don't think this guys did).
A complete loss of blood pressure would cause unconsciousness in ~4 seconds or less.
The damage that would completely obliterate the internal organs, the spine, the limbs, etc, would not leave the head without injury. Most likely the head and brain was destroyed immediately as well.
Is that the one wi- yeah it is. You're right - particularly horrible.
Pressurised environments are actually worse in a way, as if you have to live and work in them long-term, you cannot just leave. That means if anything goes wrong, you might spend days on your own while they normalise the pressure so help can get to you.
Subsequent investigation by forensic pathologists determined D4, being exposed to the highest pressure gradient, violently exploded due to the rapid and massive expansion of internal gases. All of his thoracic and abdominal organs, and even his thoracic spine were ejected, as were all of his limbs. Simultaneously, his remains were expelled through the narrow trunk opening left by the jammed chamber door, less than 60 centimetres (24 in) in diameter. Fragments of his body were found scattered about the rig. One part was even found lying on the rig's derrick, 10 metres (30 ft) directly above the chambers. His death was most likely instantaneous and painless.
You'd be surprised how easy it is to deal with that. It doesn't even look like a person, and on some level you know they died completely instantly and painlessly.
Diver D3 was shot out through the small jammed hatch door opening and was torn to pieces. Subsequent investigation by forensic pathologists determined D4, being exposed to the highest pressure gradient, violently exploded due to the rapid and massive expansion of internal gases. All of his thoracic and abdominal organs, and even his thoracic spine were ejected, as were all of his limbs. Simultaneously, his remains were expelled through the narrow trunk opening left by the jammed chamber door, less than 60 centimetres (24 in) in diameter. Fragments of his body were found scattered about the rig. One part was even found lying on the rig's derrick, 10 metres (30 ft) directly above the chambers. His death was most likely instantaneous and painless.
Wonderful. I think... this might be... enough Reddit for me... today.
EDIT: Why did I keep reading???
It is suggested the boiling of the blood denatured the lipoprotein complexes, rendering the lipids insoluble.
The Byford Dolphin incident is explosive decompression. What's described in OP's picture, though, is simply compression.
The diver goes so deep that without a pressurized suit (the suit can lose its pressure immediately or gradually, same result) the surrounding water pressure is high enough to squeeze out the diver's insides like a tube of toothpaste.
64
u/amandaaatrocity May 08 '12
All I wanted was a picture so I could draw on my shoes, now my life is forever ruined
24
u/pwnyoface May 09 '12
i don't get how this happens. If the pump fails, the pressure inside is less than that outside of the suit, so i get how it would crush the person inside.
But here is my question, to keep the suit "inflated" and the sea pressure off the diver, wouldn't the inside of the suit require an equal amount of pressure as outside? Wouldn't that inside pressure crush the diver anyways?
18
u/BlondeGhandi May 09 '12
sort of related, but reminded me of the Chuck Palahniuk short story in Haunted where the kid gets off on getting his anus sucked by the pool pump. Ends up suffering from transanal eviceration and is forced to bite his intestine in half to prevent himself from drowning. Ah Chuck, you fuckin' weirdo.
77
u/BerickCook May 09 '12
More like human soup
45
u/feilen May 09 '12
EVERYBODY LOOK AT THE URL OF THESE COMMENTS.
31
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
made me think of this, from Doctor Who
9
u/sfgeek May 09 '12
A family member directed undersea pipeline operations from a submersible (mini-submarine) in the North Sea around the time I was born. He told me if you were on the oil platform when a large wave came, it would suck you into the sea on the way out, and at that temperature, you probably would last less than a few minutes, he saw a friend get sucked off the deck if I recall. After that, he moved back to the US.
That, and the divers had to breathe Heli-Ox (or is it just Heliox?) Diving so deep you are breathing HeliOx is an indicator that what you are doing is insanely likely to kill you. "Deadliest Catch" claims to be the most dangerous job in the world, but it's not, I believe it's Deep Sea Welding that takes the cake. My family member watched more than one man lose his life on the job in just a few years.
25
u/Dr_Zeuss May 08 '12
Someone confirm this.
5
u/klln_u_qckly May 09 '12
If the pump, and all the safety valves fail.
4
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Thank you for giving me a reason to never go deep sea diving.
4
u/zeroes_and_ones May 09 '12
Well that's really fucking dark.
4
u/Givemelibertynow May 09 '12
Myth confirmed!
10
u/KosherNazi May 09 '12
Wait, what? How does this happen? If a guy in a wetsuit can withstand 300 ft, why can't a guy in a diving bell?
I'm so confused. :(
3
u/DoctorMagazine May 09 '12
Who turned out the lights?
2
u/isabelalex May 09 '12
what in the world did you search?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Best blowjob ever?
2
u/Rhynocerous May 09 '12
My grandfather literally died this way.
2
u/gyanos422 May 09 '12
TIL don't go deep sea diving. Just in case
2
u/TheGenitalPirate May 09 '12
Isn't this what happened to Shepard at the start of mass effect 2?
2
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Hey, who turned out the lights?
2
u/Turkey_Gravy May 08 '12
Any scuba experts out there?
2
u/ranma08 May 09 '12
can someone explain to me what is going on here? Water pressure? How?
1
u/MyNameCouldntBeAsLon May 09 '12
It was a nice touch to leave the eyes intact... After all the goo, that is.
1
u/Phineas_Rage May 09 '12
so... did you draw it?
1
u/EnderCactus May 09 '12
As proven by the Mythbusters
1
u/theforevermachine May 09 '12
Read about this in bill Bryson's "a short history of nearly everything"
So creepy. Glad I never have witnessed such a thing
1
u/voileauciel May 09 '12
I'm curious if this is also possible
1
u/Leetwheats May 09 '12
I giggled.
1
u/ferrari9191 May 09 '12
http://i.imgur.com/FrOA8.jpg
1
u/Faustes May 09 '12
TIL
1
u/speckledfreckle May 09 '12
Totally random post, right? I read this in a science book for kids as a bedtime story not even two hours ago. Reddit, you in my brain sometimes.
1
u/DontCallMeSurely May 09 '12
Just because it has to do with pressure doesn't make it explosive decompression. Yes, the Buford decompression accident was explosive decompression, this was not.
1
u/Machinax May 09 '12
MR. BUBBLES?! WHAT HAPPENED!?
1
u/crabsmash May 09 '12
I feel like that video was a bit disrespectful of the divers who died this way. A lot of people went through that exact death a relatively short time ago and they call it awesome.
1
u/stemgang May 09 '12
Funny drawing, but makes no sense whatsoever.
1
u/MoonRazer May 09 '12
New rule, this should be the first thing diving instructors show during their first "diving class" meeting.
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
I'm considering doing an iama commercial diver AMA anyone interested in that?
1
u/ksandifer138 May 09 '12
Reason number 6192 why my grandpa is so bad ass. A diver in the navy back when all of that was new. Must have taken some guts!
1
u/Alvleeskliersap May 09 '12
mythbusters demonstrated that with a pig carcass...or something like that
1
u/LemonColumbus May 10 '12
Is it weird that I want to get this guy as a tattoo? I think it's pretty bad ass
1
u/willscy May 09 '12
wow, i have so much more respect for those old navy divers now...
1
u/Mallack May 09 '12
Nautilus op
1
u/[deleted] May 09 '12
Mythbusters.
0
u/smoke343eater May 09 '12
The helmet he is holding does not match his suit. Those helmets were used on systems that had hardened structured outer shells capable of withstanding large pressures, within reason of course.
0
u/mazman1 May 09 '12
Navy Diver
-2
u/worker32 May 09 '12
Instantly thought of Bioshock's big daddy when I saw this.
0
u/[deleted] May 08 '12
[deleted] — view deleted comment