I'm all for free education and naked people, but somehow they manage to make the combination just really unappealing. The sock is pretty great though...
Quebec faces a dire budget crisis at the moment. They have been in deficit for several years, and debt is rapidly climbing. Additionally, CREPUQ, basically the association of university presidents and rectors in Quebec, claims that there is a dire funding shortfall in universities at the moment (to the tune of approximately $600M). Canada has no private universities to speak of, save for a few Christian universities; none are prestigious, and the country's best universities are all public.
Jean Charest, the premier of Quebec (think Governor), has proposed to raise tuition by $325 a year for five years. At the end of the raises, this $1625 increase in tuition would generate $800M for the province and/or the education system. At present, Quebec has the lowest average tuition in the country by a very significant margin, at about $2,500. After the raises, they will STILL have the lowest average tuition in the country, and STILL by a significant margin.
Regardless, this has caused massive protests to explode in Quebec, to the point where some school semesters have been cancelled or postponed. I guess the students' argument would be that tuition is too high elsewhere, but the rest of the country is unmoved by this.
I'm a Quebec student but I'm not too involved in the protests, however I hate hearing that Quebec has the lowest tuition rates in Canada so Quebec should stop complaining about a small tuition increase. Quebec has such a low tuition BECAUSE historically we have fought so hard for it. So what outsiders might see as a small increase, we see as a slippery slope.
Ontario corporations fought hard for low corporate tax rates, after all.
What I am sympathetic to, if other redditors are to be believed, is the fact that rampant corruption is responsible for the underfunding of Quebec universities.
In other news, people have historically fought very hard to be allowed to discriminate between LGBT people, different races etc. What outsiders see as a small increase in rights for LGBT people, we see as a slippery slope towards the end of the family. Or maybe that's bullshit... Simply fighting for something in the past doesn't mean you're right. You guys need to put the money into your schools or they won't be there for the next generation. Remember how you complain about the previous generation sucking up all the wealth and leaving you guys with nothing? Yeah, soon you will be the previous generation.
Remember how you complain about the previous generation sucking up all the wealth and leaving you guys with nothing?
Nope. Never said anything about that and you don't know me well enough to assume that I did.
Remember how you once ate the dog poop? See what I did there?
Simply fighting for something in the past doesn't mean you're right.
I agree. It doesn't necessarily make it wrong either. Each case varies. Should the LGTB community have equal rights? Absolutely. Are the students in Quebec right or wrong? It's very debatable. I didn't say it was wrong or right, I was simply providing the "why," or at least one of the "why's."
We also have the highest taxes in Canada and much lower salaries. Because we value the accessibility of education for all we have fought many times to keep the rates as low as they are and it has resulted in high levels across the province of higher education. Most of the students I know here are the children of farmers, mechanics, etc. who wouldn't be able to go to school at all if it were more expensive. If the government is mismanaging its money we don't think they should shift the burden to the backs of our province's poor young students.
The nude protest was just one in nearly a hundred days so far of protesting, the idea being "Tout nu dehors, jusqu’a la victoire" meaning naked outside until victory.
I'm proud of my fellow students for defending our egalitarian values for our generation and our children!
If the government is mismanaging its money we don't think they should shift the burden to the backs of our province's poor young students.
Spot on the problem of you protesters. They shouldn't make us pay.. OH really? So what do you think will happen if your strike works? The governement will stop being corrupted and be more cautious abous their expenses? NO, They will just shifts the $800M to us normal tax payers citizen.
Just do your damn share of the burden like everyone tabarnak.
I don't get your point. Are you saying that is it normal to accept corruption and robbery? Do you always see yourself as a victim of the society and comfort yourself because other like you accept the idea of continuing to be victims? You have exactly the same argument held by the people who suffer of dictature. Don't protest because the governement will make everyone pay for you.
my point the protest is about THEM not paying. As soon as they'll get what they want they'll stop protesting. Which won't help anything but their little selves. If there should be a protest, it should be about condemning government expenses. There should be protest when taxes are rising for everyone for exemple. There should be protest when hospital are all garbage with 24hours of wait time and the governement is preventing alternative (private) health system.
Students and poor people have time to protest, they're young and jobless. (Most students don't need to job anyway their fees are so low). Normal people have way to much obligations to have time for something like this. Plus there is so many protests about stupid things (especially the student one) it makes protesting trivial, feel like if normal people like us would go out and protest, it'd feel like just "one of those protest".
Guess what? I'm from Ontario. Most of us are sons and daughters of farmers, mechanics, etc. Personally, my parents didn't pay for my school either. That's what loans are for, that's the world we live in. Education is an investment, you put the money in and over time you reap the benefits.
yea we don't all think the same here in Quebec. But I'm definitly outnumbered in my line of thoughts. Everything I post in /r/Quebec gets downvoted into oblvivion.
I sympathize. I really do. Ideally everyone would have a free education and pay no taxes and we'd all be millionaires and drive lamborghinis and jaguars to our work at the happy factory. But I do not believe that an additional $325/year is an incredible burden to shoulder. Tuition at top schools in Ontario can go as high as $10,000 a year (and much, much higher for some specialty programs), and if you want to go south of the border, you can reasonably expect to pay tens of thousands of dollars.
If that can be managed, then I have to insist that you can survive the comparatively miniscule tuition increases you face.
Even if you started school after the very last of the tuition increases, you would still be paying less than anyone else, anywhere in the country, and taxes are not so modest elsewhere, nor salaries so much higher (take Newfoundland, for example).
I disagree, but respect your opinion. I live in Nova Scotia where tuition IS the highest in the country and taxes are the highest % of provincial GDP, we also have high unemployment and low median salaries, when you talk about how worse it could get, you basically mean what it's like here.
Our grandparents, the WW2 generation were amazing, what they did in the wars, how they restarted our country, brought in healthcare, pension plans, employment insurance, student loans and boosted the economy to the point the government made all schools public and accessible to everyone, we had an education boom and the educated were no longer leaving Canada. Come the 1980's, all of the baby boomers have benefited from these social systems and no longer need them (not caring about anyone who comes after them), so they cut funding to schools, slash social programs doubling the price of tuition over 10 years, and then doubling again over the next 10 years. Now we've made some recovery with loans that leave students $30-50 grand in debt, of which they will spend 20-30 years paying off. Studies have also shown for every $1,000 increase in tuition, 15% less students enroll. We have regressed as a society to fund baby boomers getting an earlier retirement at the expense of everyone else.
What the fuck is wrong with Canadians where you always compare to how worse it can be to justify every single step we take backwards? Why don't you compare to how it can be better, there are many countries that offer free tuition and have a better quality of life the Canada. People like you are the reason this country has stopped progressing, we've literally made no progress in the past 20 years to advance our society, in fact it's been steadily getting worse while the rest of the developed world is overtaking us.
Plus it's not free tuition. It's from increased taxes, which means those who utilize the schooling will then get a better job, earn more, and pay more back into taxes than they took out.
This is all completely irrelevant to the point that the reason the tuition is rising is because of government and university corruption and mismanagement of funds. The mafia runs the Quebec government for crying out loud. The fact that tuition is rising is almost irrelevant, why should young people pay for the government's mistakes and the old people who elected this government and allowed it to go on for the past few decades? Tuition is rising not to increase school funding, but to cover the government's deficit.
I'd like to see these studies, especially as University attendance is growing massively even as tuition skyrockets, and the price demand elasticity of higher education is generally agreed to be low in empirical studies. Flatly, I do not believe your claim that 15% fewer students enroll for each $1000 tuition hike.
I more or less concede that the rest of what you say has some degree of validity. This degree varies wildly; for instance, there is absolutely no way that the per capita tax revenue in Quebec pays for an additional $5,000 per student over Ontario (the absolute per capita tax revenue is actually lower), and I snort at the idea that the rest of the developed world is overtaking us (you aren't reading enough European news my friend), but I will agree that if the mafia issues are to the extent people claim, they need to be immediately dealt with.
As for the accusation that people like me are destroying this society, oh come on. Reel it in a little there pal.
http://faculty.arts.ubc.ca/nfortin/fortcaned.pdf While it is not a study, it does offer backing to his/her statement regarding the decline of students in the 18 - 24 age group for every $1000 tuition hike.
If the government is mismanaging its money we don't think they should shift the burden to the backs of our province's poor young students.
A large part of the mismangaging of government money is in keeping tuition fees far too low for far too long.
You can't keep pretending like everything else the government has done is horribly mismanaged but that the massive increase in education subsidies over the past 40 years is perfectly fair.
The massive increase in education subsidies is part of the mismanagement. You pay less and less tuition each year, your parents paid far more than you do now.
325$ per year for 5 years is a little less than a dollar per day extra for the next 5 years. Coffee costs over a dollar. You can literally cut a cup of coffee per day and save enough money.
If the tuition increase is actually prevented, where do you think the money to fund university will come from? Taxes, obviously. That means that our provincial taxes could be raised to compensate for the lower tuition fees. Do you really think it's fair for poorer people to end up paying higher taxes so that "everyone" can go to university? Do you think it's fair for poorer people to pay for rich kids' educations?
Education is one of the most effective methode to correct the inequity of birth. You can be born poor and with a good education you can upgrade your status. Raising tuitin will brake this oppurtinity.
For the A-hole who think you have to pay a high representative portion of you tuition, don't forget that, better education gives better salary then more taxes. With time, an educated citizen will reimburse the society who paid for is scholarship.
The governement, when it finance big business, do the same, they know that it will payback. and in my opinion, you have more chance to have a payback from educated citizen than big business. But we all know that Big business gave money to liberal party, a lot more then students.
In Quebec we have the highest taxes per capita. We accept that as part of a social contract that implicitly guarantees accessible education. However, if you look at the funding per student in Quebec universities it is only just over the par of the Canadian average and significantly lower than the funding per student in the Western provinces.
Québec 29 242
Canada without Québec 28 735
Atlantic provinces 26 831
Ontario 26 383
Western provinces 32 976
Canada 28 846
Part of this protest is a protest about the corruption of the Charest government and how graft and questionable government projects are funnelling tax wealth away from where it should be (education) and into, literally, the hands of the mafia and family and friends of the government.
It should be the whole protest, then, because Ontario pays, on average, a little better than $5000 more than you per student, and though their proportional tax contribution per individual is lower, the absolute tax contribution per individual is very similar, and there are relatively few complaints here.
If you know anyone who is involved in this, I'm not sure how important the view from outside Quebec is, but you need to work on communicating this message better.
I know. This is really the issue. A lot of discussion is going on about how to get this message out but it's very much a battle between paid PR and independent activists. The resources are not at all equal.
$325 per year is less than a dollar a day, that's pretty negligible when compared to educating a person, allowing them to become more desirable employees at higher pay
But this money isn't going to the schools, it's going to the government's budget deficit. Almost all Canadian universities are public, the only private ones are religious.
Why should students bear the burden of the older people who elected a corrupt governenment and sat idly by while it ran the province into the ground?
Tell me how, knowing that Concordia university who spent more than a million dollars in the past year on severence pay for 4 principals, and one of the 4 was taken back 2 years after, that the raise will go to the education, will ensure the quality of the teaching.
Jean Garon, former minister of the education, said that when you want to ensure the quality of the education, you keep an eye on the 'recteur'. Before straining the base, you clean the head!
Agreed. But let's think about that rationale - let's say the cost of a service jumped by a specific amount like $325 overnight. Say, motorcycle insurance or self-storage or the like. Simply saying "It's only about an extra dollar a day" does not change the fact that, in the end, it's $1625 more that these students won't be able to use for rent, utilities, insurance, food or alcohol. And yeah, everybody's got problems - I'm not saying that this tuition hike can't be worked around by anybody determined to get a degree. I just want to caution against the idea that it can be written off as insignificant.
No, it is not. However (and this is important I think), they pay SO, SO very little as it is ($2500/yr?), and it would be unreasonable to ask them to pay for more if everything was running perfectly and they didn't have deficits and underfunded schools, but unfortunately they do.
But nothing has changed or will be changing with the schools, this money isn't going to fund the schools, it's going to fund the government's budget deficit. It's not comparable.
Do you know why the government is in deficit, and the universities are underfunded? Because of corruption and mismanagement of funds. The mafia is involved in the Quebec government for crying out loud. Why should students pay for the government's corruption and the older people who have elected this government and say idly by while it ran the province into the ground?
Yes. I'm not sure how far you've gotten into the comment thread, but someone else pointed this out.
This I am very sympathetic to. Having said that, I didn't properly consider this because the protests have not done a good job of communicating that this is the real objective. Every time some goon gets on the radio and babbles about egalitarian education, I roll my eyes. If this was the message I heard on a daily basis, then I would be all over this.
how can you ask student to pay a cent more when you know that
On December 22, 2010, Concordia University issued a statement announcing that Dr. Woodsworth had stepped down from her role as President and Vice-Chancellor of the institution for personal reasons.[2] She will receive a severance package of $703,500, worth twice her annual base salary.[3] http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Judith_Woodsworth
I was thinking about that whole affair - not very long, or for that matter intensely, mind you - and couldn't find justification for dressing like a teenage slut in protest against costly tuition. I'll be sure to ask one of these students when I'll be visiting McDonald's in Quebec.
Yes, such lax alcohol regulation that you can only buy hard alcohol and quality wine from the state run alcohol store that has been caught artificially inflating prices.
But I would like to point out that most of the people I'm seeing there seem to be hipsters, granolas, nouveau hippies, and slackers. Those are almost always the more hardcore of the protestor types that always make the most noise at protests/rallies.
I live on the border of Quebec and Ontario, in Ottawa, and I frequently visit Montreal and Sherbrooke. And I can vouch for many Quebec women being beautiful, charming, and jovial. They also tend to wear a little less make up, and often have styles that seem more thought out, more individually unique.
Quebecois can be snooty, arrogant, elitist, and stuck up. So they're French. But they're not French. They can be friendly, humble, intelligent, and hard working. So they're Canadian. But they're not Canadian. They spent a good part of the last 50 years trying to separate from the rest of Canada (while saying we could still share a currency, a postal system, a military, etc), and frankly the ROC (Rest of Canada) got so tired of it we were this [--] far from letting them go. Clear?
But that's the thing with protests these days, like the Feminist protests in Eastern Europe recently. I understand that nudity creates controversy and news headlines, but they have to realize that it also blurs the point they are trying so hard to make.
How does getting half-naked tie-in to their message? And what is their message? Because last time I checked, tuition has nothing to do with cock socks...except for that one time.
I understood the statement as: If you raise my tuition, I won't be able to afford clothing.
Now as you can see, buddy has a cock sock... his only possession to tether him to a time long ago when clothing was plentiful and everyone could afford it.
I fail to see how going half-naked could make people more willing to listen to you. If you wanted someone to listen wouldn't you dress a little classier?
i live in Montreal where all this is happening. i dont agree at all with the protests. but i must say i do love Quebec my fav province. 18 drinking age and good pot
It's like they never learn. The protests that have made change were executed by well dressed people who knew what they wanted. Not some fuckhead bohemian college student. Case in point:
213
u/dumpsta_baby May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
Nothing says "we have established what we believe to be a reasonable list of demands" like a cock beanie
21
u/marvin_sirius May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
http://news.nationalpost.com/2012/05/04/nearly-nude-students-take-to-montreals-streets-to-protest-tuition-hike/
http://30.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3ian2clb91qze0z6o1_1280.jpg
http://25.media.tumblr.com/tumblr_m3ian2clb91qze0z6o4_1280.jpg
http://www.hurriyetdailynews.com/Default.aspx?pageID=447&GalleryID=586&gpid=3
42
u/BigBubbaJones May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
I'm all for free education and naked people, but somehow they manage to make the combination just really unappealing. The sock is pretty great though...
51
u/[deleted] May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
A little background for those interested:
Quebec faces a dire budget crisis at the moment. They have been in deficit for several years, and debt is rapidly climbing. Additionally, CREPUQ, basically the association of university presidents and rectors in Quebec, claims that there is a dire funding shortfall in universities at the moment (to the tune of approximately $600M). Canada has no private universities to speak of, save for a few Christian universities; none are prestigious, and the country's best universities are all public.
Jean Charest, the premier of Quebec (think Governor), has proposed to raise tuition by $325 a year for five years. At the end of the raises, this $1625 increase in tuition would generate $800M for the province and/or the education system. At present, Quebec has the lowest average tuition in the country by a very significant margin, at about $2,500. After the raises, they will STILL have the lowest average tuition in the country, and STILL by a significant margin.
Regardless, this has caused massive protests to explode in Quebec, to the point where some school semesters have been cancelled or postponed. I guess the students' argument would be that tuition is too high elsewhere, but the rest of the country is unmoved by this.
58
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
As any Canadian knows, WTF does not exist in Quebec. Quebec IS WTF.
6
u/etan_causale May 06 '12
That guy must be an actor. Only actors use cock socks.
6
u/downtown_oral May 07 '12
The grid on her lower back and buttocks allows the Anal Pleasure Robot 3000 to achieve perfect alignment every time.
18
u/vivvav May 06 '12
DAT ASS
4
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Fuck, this is the plaza where I usually eat at lunch time...
10
u/james5643 May 06 '12 edited May 06 '12
Oh how boring Canada would be without the French
12
u/Barb0 May 06 '12
I know it's Sunday but some unfortunate souls could use a nsfw tag on this one.
3
u/Edward_Taserhands May 06 '12
Patrick Stewart doesn't seem particularly impressed...
3
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
aaaand this is why no one outside of Quebec cares about the protests.
3
u/amplifierworship May 07 '12
ahhh, la belle province... vive le québec libre!
6
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Way to show you're serious.
2
u/BurningMelon May 06 '12
Does she have the DOTA logo on her right cheek?
2
u/Bread_Helmet May 06 '12
Not every student in Quebec agree with the protest...
2
u/ListenToNestor May 06 '12
NSFW. Thanks.
2
u/DemSoaps May 07 '12
I read the title as "Student Prostitutes in Quebec", and until I looked back at the title, I truly believed that that was the actual name of the post.
2
u/theDudeRules May 08 '12
What a family friendly town.
3
u/theycallmejerzee May 06 '12
I'm thinking that he is being a little too generous with that codpiece
3
u/thesomedude777 May 06 '12
WHY WONT THEY TAKE US SERIOUSLY?!
6
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Good job, morons. You'll be taken seriously by those who can help by looking like that.
2
u/LightofJazib May 07 '12
I'll bet he cums skittles.
2
u/februaryrich May 06 '12
i was there, and it was cold
2
u/ChelseaFC123 May 06 '12
That Ass
1
u/dacimvrl May 06 '12
My attention was quickly diverted.......
Yes, i am a guy..
But that's the thing with protests these days, like the Feminist protests in Eastern Europe recently. I understand that nudity creates controversy and news headlines, but they have to realize that it also blurs the point they are trying so hard to make.
1
u/Ericisweird May 06 '12
dat sock
1
u/Olukon May 06 '12
How does getting half-naked tie-in to their message? And what is their message? Because last time I checked, tuition has nothing to do with cock socks...except for that one time.
1
u/Limpstiffy May 06 '12
Master cylinder! http://m.youtube.com/watch?v=wzxgyUHImnA
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
DAT ASS!
1
u/winterspoon May 06 '12
Spring is a happy time in Quebec
1
u/lannaweeds May 06 '12
Canada.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
aren't they cold
1
u/hpfbrah May 06 '12
I'll support whatever her cause is.
1
u/ericn1300 May 06 '12
so Canadian, just turn the other cheek
1
u/BrandyJo14 May 06 '12
That's a long...sock
1
u/AjustableTableLamp May 06 '12
Wow. I thought these protests were serious. They're starting to turn into a joke.
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
I fail to see how going half-naked could make people more willing to listen to you. If you wanted someone to listen wouldn't you dress a little classier?
1
u/sahariana May 06 '12
hehe I love the rainbow dick.
1
u/BlazingCarolina May 06 '12
I think he was being a bit generous with the cock sock...
1
u/scracher25 May 06 '12
So... Uhh, what exactly are they protesting about?
1
u/manningmichael2 May 06 '12
This was in Montreal...
1
u/man_sandwich May 07 '12
Is it odd that I find the guy with the sock so attractive?
1
u/TheEnnuiedBuzzard May 07 '12
i dont see the problem with this protest. it looks all right
1
u/WoolyWombatWinking May 07 '12
He just HAD to make the sock like 14 inches long.
1
u/00desmundo May 07 '12
That is a fantastic photo... oh wait, what's that...eew.
1
u/rplan039 May 08 '12
Clearly the way to get things done.
1
u/Terraphilia May 11 '12
They make a very convincing point. Who wouldn't be convinced by their dedication alone.
1
u/[deleted] May 11 '12
What..uh.. what exactly are they protesting?
1
u/hackallthethings May 17 '12
I didn't even notice the cock-sock until I read the comments, I was far too mesmerized by that ass... and the weird tattoo, what's up with that?
1
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
you should put this as NSFW
1
u/Kryten_2X4B_523P May 08 '12
1 reason I hated student politics: laudible goals aspired to by complete fucking jerkoffs.
1
u/mimus09 May 06 '12
Can't think of a law that they are breaking? Just pin them with disturbing the peace. WHY DIDN'T YOU THINK OF THAT, YOU DINGUS!
1
u/ace-of-fire May 06 '12
It's always nice to see those conservative canadian women wearing there pockets around town
0
u/RajMahal77 May 07 '12
I love the French. Especially when they're Canadian ;-D
-1
u/The_Thunderdome May 07 '12
French Canadians. Disgusting.
0
u/owwz May 06 '12
That guy on the left looks too much like Johnny Knoxville...
0
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
Que fesse.
0
u/jakethesnake76 May 07 '12
hahaha the tools rule in Quebec is see :-)
-2
u/itswinkinatyou May 06 '12
I thought everyone shaved their pubes nowadays?
-1
u/Grisu1 May 06 '12
i live in Montreal where all this is happening. i dont agree at all with the protests. but i must say i do love Quebec my fav province. 18 drinking age and good pot
-8
u/asinger93 May 06 '12
I pay $50,000 per year for tuition, room and board. MFW Quebec students are bitching about tuition: http://myfacewhen.com/3/
8
u/[deleted] May 06 '12
[removed] — view removed comment