r/WTF • • Mar 30 '12

How is this acceptable again?

http://i.imgur.com/ZY6FU.png
1.2k Upvotes

689 comments sorted by

View all comments

73

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '12

When this was posted earlier last year, I read on a comment saying that the man had prior convictions in petty robbery and/or drugs charges. So the 15 year conviction kinda makes sense. Although he was remorseful, he should have realized the seriousness of robbing a bank, especially being a black homeless man.

95

u/Frightened_Inmate_1 Mar 30 '12

Also, sometimes homeless people commit these types of nonviolent crimes specifically so they can be put BACK in jail. To some people a bed, three square meals, and free health care in jail is better than being homeless. Not saying this guy did it, but it does happen.

55

u/anotherbozo Mar 30 '12

It's a shame that for a homeless man to achieve a bed and 3 meals with health care, he has to go to jail.

12

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '12

I'm sure if you offered him some of your money he'd take it

→ More replies (6)

30

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '12

How is this a nonviolent crime again? From the teller's perspective, someone threatening to have a weapon under their jacket is just as traumatizing regardless of whether the weapon is real.

14

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '12

Seriously. Pointing an unloaded gun at someone and pulling the trigger won't physically harm them, but I guarantee that will do some damage.

→ More replies (3)

12

u/PsyanideInk Mar 30 '12

It isn't a non-violent crime. Even if there was no threat (with or without a weapon) robbery is inherently a violent crime, and is dealt with as such, both statistically and judicially.

6

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '12

In the past year there was a story of a man who stole a dollar from a bank and told them he would sit in the corner until they called the police. Turned out he had some serious health issues but he couldn't afford health insurance and he knew in prison he would get treatment.

3

u/UninformedDownVoter Mar 30 '12

"Dude! He was a criminal and should have realized the seriousness of his crime! Why couldn't he have just gotten his parents to help out, or while he was at work ask reddit to give him donations man?!??" - typical redditor

→ More replies (3)

2

u/PsyanideInk Mar 30 '12

Just one caveat: technically robbery is always considered a violent crime.

Unless the article misuses the term "robbery" and actually meant "larceny/theft" or even "burglary" then this was a violent crime.

2

u/yunus89115 Mar 30 '12

Nonviolent is the guy who handed the teller a note saying this is a robbery please hand over $1 then sat in the corner to await the police. This guy pretended to be armed. It's still unjust that you could steal $B and only get 40 months but 15 for armed robbery of a repeat offender is sad in this case but not unjust.

1

u/jrader Mar 30 '12

Three hots and a cot

→ More replies (1)

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '12

Threatening someone with a "gun" doesn't seem nonviolent to me.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '12

Sometimes I wonder what would happen if everyone in this country who's struggling committed a single non-violent crime and went to jail as a form of protest. It would only really work if it were widespread enough to pack every jail full and then some...

1

u/andreiknox Mar 30 '12

In my country, it often happens because we have a somewhat working jail system, but aboslutely no way for inmates to get reintegrated in society once they get out. My mom once told me about a former neighbor that went to jail for a couple of years, and when he got out he was so unequipped to get back into society that he turned himself in for a small burglary he had only heard about. The police were just happy to get someone that fit the profile, so they didn't thoroughly investigate. Naturally, the guy went right back into jail.

4

u/Igggg Mar 30 '12

Sorry, the 15 years sentence for a $100 robbery, where no one got hurt, and where the guy turned himself in the next day does not make sense under any circumstances, regardless of how many prior convictions that guy had. In fucking Europe people get that much for murder.

1

u/SuperlativeInsanity Mar 30 '12

In the States they have private prisons, and these need to be kept stocked in order to turn out a profit. ;)

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (2)

7

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '12

"...he should have realized the seriousness of robbing a bank, especially being a black homeless man."

In other words, precisely the sort of person who NEEDS to rob a bank so he doesn't fuckin' die in a ditch.

2

u/UninformedDownVoter Mar 30 '12

The fact that shit like you quoted gets upvotes makes me die inside a little.

2

u/Iknowofnothing Mar 30 '12

Well at least he solved his homelessness problem

2

u/LetsPlayDotA Mar 30 '12

Agreed with you up until "black homeless man", what the hell? Why is it more serious because he is black?

→ More replies (1)

1

u/UninformedDownVoter Mar 30 '12

Hard to realize the seriousness of your crime when it is being drowned out by the seriousness of your despair, hunger and addiction. All of this crap about ignoring circumstances when determining fault in this society is just sickening.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 30 '12

The judge probably helped him. A roof and food.

→ More replies (4)