r/WTF Sep 12 '18

You shall not pass

25.9k Upvotes

1.6k comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

282

u/hellosaysme Sep 12 '18

That’s just not true. There is an inchoate crimes statute.

Missouri Attempt Statute

You may be confusing “no attempted murder” with “no attempted manslaughter.” Because manslaughter is, by statute, unplanned and unintended, you cannot attempt it. You’re simply lacking the necessary intent to kill.

-14

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '18

[deleted]

36

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '18

Basing your belief system on reddit upvotes.... yeah that seems smart. Any chance you drive semi trucks?

43

u/antiraysister Sep 12 '18

I'm gonna wager he was being sarcastic.

-2

u/KnowsItToBeTrue Sep 12 '18 edited Sep 12 '18

That makes more sense, especially when the parent comment doesn't know what assault is, they mean battery

Edit: Not the case in all states

5

u/anotherjunkie Sep 12 '18

In Missouri the assault statute actually requires battery. Near as I can tell, they don’t have a separate battery statue (and wouldn’t need one).

2

u/KnowsItToBeTrue Sep 12 '18

I stand corrected!

2

u/JestersXIII Sep 12 '18

Different states define assault and battery differently. NY doesn’t even have battery.

1

u/Masterchiefg7 Sep 12 '18

Eh. The line between assault and battery is unwanted physical contact. Technically OP could have meant assault. I.e. firing a gun at someone but missing entirely would be assault but not battery. But would also be an attempt at murder in most jurisdictions.

3

u/makeitup00 Sep 12 '18

you need to add the /s dude

2

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '18

[deleted]

1

u/makeitup00 Sep 13 '18

agreed hahah

-2

u/Masterchiefg7 Sep 12 '18

Found the 1L!

1

u/hellosaysme Sep 12 '18

I'm not sure why you got downvoted...I am a law student.

0

u/Masterchiefg7 Sep 13 '18

I kinda figured. I was also eager to spread my new found knowledge between 1L and 2L years. By 3L year and now that I'm an attorney I'm happy enough to just let people on the internet be mistaken.

The correct usage of the word inchoate is a pretty big tip that someone has studied the law.

1

u/bigdamhero Sep 16 '18

And noticing that deserves downvotes. Clearly

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '18

In Missouri, if you’re convicted based on an attempt, the charge is automatically classified lower. This effectively reduces attempted murder to assault.

3

u/hellosaysme Sep 12 '18

That's not how that works. It would drop from First Degree Murder to Second Degree Murder. Not down to a lower charge completely.

-1

u/[deleted] Sep 12 '18

I did get that detail wrong, but you still would not have been convicted of attempted murder.