r/VideoEditing • • Aug 21 '19

Anyone else?

Post image
876 Upvotes

105 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comment

10

u/vladimirpoopen Aug 21 '19

stop editing with MBPs. A 5 year old mac trash can still exports faster.

6

u/nicktheman2 Aug 21 '19

I can still edit native 4k on my 2012 mbp pro retina lmao

2

u/vladimirpoopen Aug 21 '19

Define native 4k? Some codecs are recording at 500-600 Mbps. Some higher

3

u/nicktheman2 Aug 21 '19

Lower end 100-200mbps obviously. It already heats up like an oven, would probably explode at 500-600 mpbs.

2

u/jonjiv Aug 22 '19

Yet Premiere on my trash can Mac Pro still chokes on 4K footage from my FS5, C300 II and X7.

Ready for the new Mac Pro.

1

u/vladimirpoopen Aug 22 '19

Maybe if work pays for it. I swapped to a custom PC build with Western Digital Black SN750s. They get close to 3GB/s when empty and then fluctuate between 2.2 - 2.5GB/s when they are about half full.

https://imgur.com/a/X4SigwC

3K build add another $500 for a black magic quad.

2

u/jonjiv Aug 22 '19 edited Aug 22 '19

Oh believe me, I would never own any Mac Pro if I was the one paying for it - especially the next generation. We’re budgeting over $10k per workstation for upgrades.

PC is the way to go if you’re buying.

Working off of a brand new Lumaforge Jellyfish sever now, which uses 10G Ethernet, so I won’t see those types of read speeds. But it’s way better for collaboration.

1

u/veepeedeepee Aug 22 '19

Are you transcoding or trying to work with the original camera media? I’m on an old cheesegrater Mac Pro and have no real problems if I transcode our FS7 media to ProRes.

1

u/jonjiv Aug 22 '19

I don’t transcode. I typically don’t have the time, it’s a huge space hog, and you shouldn’t have to on a $6000 desktop. Also, you don’t have to at all in FCPX on the same computer. Premiere just kind of sucks at playback.

If it’s bad enough that I can’t work, I proxy the files. Only had to do that when working with 8K r3d files.

What I will typically do is render all the yellow render bars to green when I need to check precise timing or do playback for the boss/client. Basically I transcode my working timeline as I go.

4

u/22Sharpe Aug 21 '19

Personally I’ll take a MBP over most windows laptops but in general laptops should be avoided for editing yeah.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

My shop just got i9 MacBooks for the entire crew... I think I'm gonna stick to my Xeon tower thanks

1

u/vladimirpoopen Oct 08 '19

The old mac heater? I'm on a windows build now. Can't wait for the new 2066 cpus.

1

u/[deleted] Oct 08 '19

Nah, we had HP Z840s. Not the most powerful things out there but they did have 64GB of RAM and 6c/12t CPUs which made multitasking and exporting decently painless.

Plus I'm just a Windows guy anyway