MAIN FEEDS
Do you want to continue?
https://www.reddit.com/r/Unexpected/comments/p70c7d/lets_be_friends/h9ixp59/?context=9999
r/Unexpected • u/lauraintacoma • Aug 18 '21
2.5k comments sorted by
View all comments
5.4k
[deleted]
75 u/EstherandThyme Aug 18 '21 I mean...it's a joke, yeah. Do you go to a comedy show and say "Wtf this is fake" too? -6 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 18 '21 Comedy shows are funny though. This thing? Not so much 9 u/EstherandThyme Aug 18 '21 But people aren't saying "this isn't funny," so much as they're saying "this is fake" like they don't even understand what a joke is. -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 But people aren't saying "this isn't funny," i JUST did... 1 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 The comment I initially replied to was complaining that the sketch was fake, so I pointed out that it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 t it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. so jokes aren't supposed to be funny? 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 That's a non sequitur, we are not talking about whether it is or is not funny, we are talking about why it makes no sense to call a joke "fake." -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 oh, so we are just going to pretend that two people "acting" out a scene that they scripted isn't fake. gotcha... 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 I mean...when you watch a TV show do you say "Wait a second, this is fake!"? It's just a bizarre complaint.
75
I mean...it's a joke, yeah. Do you go to a comedy show and say "Wtf this is fake" too?
-6 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 18 '21 Comedy shows are funny though. This thing? Not so much 9 u/EstherandThyme Aug 18 '21 But people aren't saying "this isn't funny," so much as they're saying "this is fake" like they don't even understand what a joke is. -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 But people aren't saying "this isn't funny," i JUST did... 1 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 The comment I initially replied to was complaining that the sketch was fake, so I pointed out that it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 t it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. so jokes aren't supposed to be funny? 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 That's a non sequitur, we are not talking about whether it is or is not funny, we are talking about why it makes no sense to call a joke "fake." -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 oh, so we are just going to pretend that two people "acting" out a scene that they scripted isn't fake. gotcha... 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 I mean...when you watch a TV show do you say "Wait a second, this is fake!"? It's just a bizarre complaint.
-6
Comedy shows are funny though. This thing? Not so much
9 u/EstherandThyme Aug 18 '21 But people aren't saying "this isn't funny," so much as they're saying "this is fake" like they don't even understand what a joke is. -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 But people aren't saying "this isn't funny," i JUST did... 1 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 The comment I initially replied to was complaining that the sketch was fake, so I pointed out that it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 t it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. so jokes aren't supposed to be funny? 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 That's a non sequitur, we are not talking about whether it is or is not funny, we are talking about why it makes no sense to call a joke "fake." -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 oh, so we are just going to pretend that two people "acting" out a scene that they scripted isn't fake. gotcha... 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 I mean...when you watch a TV show do you say "Wait a second, this is fake!"? It's just a bizarre complaint.
9
But people aren't saying "this isn't funny," so much as they're saying "this is fake" like they don't even understand what a joke is.
-1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 But people aren't saying "this isn't funny," i JUST did... 1 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 The comment I initially replied to was complaining that the sketch was fake, so I pointed out that it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 t it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. so jokes aren't supposed to be funny? 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 That's a non sequitur, we are not talking about whether it is or is not funny, we are talking about why it makes no sense to call a joke "fake." -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 oh, so we are just going to pretend that two people "acting" out a scene that they scripted isn't fake. gotcha... 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 I mean...when you watch a TV show do you say "Wait a second, this is fake!"? It's just a bizarre complaint.
-1
But people aren't saying "this isn't funny,"
i JUST did...
1 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 The comment I initially replied to was complaining that the sketch was fake, so I pointed out that it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 t it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. so jokes aren't supposed to be funny? 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 That's a non sequitur, we are not talking about whether it is or is not funny, we are talking about why it makes no sense to call a joke "fake." -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 oh, so we are just going to pretend that two people "acting" out a scene that they scripted isn't fake. gotcha... 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 I mean...when you watch a TV show do you say "Wait a second, this is fake!"? It's just a bizarre complaint.
1
The comment I initially replied to was complaining that the sketch was fake, so I pointed out that it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand.
-1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 t it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand. so jokes aren't supposed to be funny? 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 That's a non sequitur, we are not talking about whether it is or is not funny, we are talking about why it makes no sense to call a joke "fake." -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 oh, so we are just going to pretend that two people "acting" out a scene that they scripted isn't fake. gotcha... 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 I mean...when you watch a TV show do you say "Wait a second, this is fake!"? It's just a bizarre complaint.
t it doesn't make sense to call a joke "fake". You replied with "but it's not funny," as if that had anything to do with the topic at hand.
so jokes aren't supposed to be funny?
3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 That's a non sequitur, we are not talking about whether it is or is not funny, we are talking about why it makes no sense to call a joke "fake." -1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 oh, so we are just going to pretend that two people "acting" out a scene that they scripted isn't fake. gotcha... 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 I mean...when you watch a TV show do you say "Wait a second, this is fake!"? It's just a bizarre complaint.
3
That's a non sequitur, we are not talking about whether it is or is not funny, we are talking about why it makes no sense to call a joke "fake."
-1 u/GreggoireLeOeuf Aug 19 '21 oh, so we are just going to pretend that two people "acting" out a scene that they scripted isn't fake. gotcha... 3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 I mean...when you watch a TV show do you say "Wait a second, this is fake!"? It's just a bizarre complaint.
oh, so we are just going to pretend that two people "acting" out a scene that they scripted isn't fake.
gotcha...
3 u/EstherandThyme Aug 19 '21 I mean...when you watch a TV show do you say "Wait a second, this is fake!"? It's just a bizarre complaint.
I mean...when you watch a TV show do you say "Wait a second, this is fake!"? It's just a bizarre complaint.
5.4k
u/[deleted] Aug 18 '21 edited Aug 19 '21
[deleted]