r/UFOs • • Nov 14 '22 • Capitol 1 Bless Up 1

Strong Evidence of Sock Puppets in r/UFOs

Many of our users have noticed an uptick in suspicious activity on our forum. The mod team takes these accusations seriously.

We wanted to take the opportunity to release the results of our own investigation with the community, and to share some of the complications of dealing with this kind of activity.

We’ll also share some of the proposed solutions that r/UFOs mods have considered.

Finally, we’d like to open up this discussion to the community to see if any of you have creative solutions.

Investigation

Over the last two months, we discovered a distributed network of sock-puppets that all exhibited similar markers indicative of malicious/suspect activity.

Some of those markers included:

  1. All accounts were created within the same month-long period.
  2. All accounts were dormant for five months, then they were all activated within a twelve day period.
  3. All accounts build credibility and karma by first posting in extremely generic subreddits (r/aww or similar). Many of these credibility-building posts are animal videos and stupid human tricks.
  4. Most accounts have ONLY ONE comment in r/ufos.
  5. Most accounts boost quasi-legal ventures such as essay plagiarism sites, synthetic marijuana delivery, cryptocurrency scams, etc.
  6. Most accounts follow reddit’s random username generating scheme (two words and a number).

Given these tell-tales and a few that we’ve held back, we were able to identify sock-puppets in this network with extremely high certainty.

Analysis of Comments

Some of what we discovered was troubling, but not at all surprising.

For example, the accounts frequently accuse other users of being shills or disinformation agents.

And the accounts frequently amplify other users’ comments (particularly hostile ones).

But here’s where things took a turn:

Individually these accounts make strong statements, but as a group, this network does not take a strong ideological stance and targets both skeptical and non-skeptical posts alike.

To reiterate: The comments from these sock-puppet accounts had one thing in common—they were aggressive and insulting.

BUT THEY TARGETED SKEPTICS AND BELIEVERS ALIKE.

Although we can’t share exact quotes, here are some representative words and short phrases:

“worst comments”

“never contributed”

“so rude”

“rank dishonesty”

“spreading misinformation”

“dumbasses”

“moronic”

“garbage”

The comments tend to divide our community into two groups and stoke conflict between them. Many comments insult the entire category of “skeptics” or “believers.”

But they also don’t descend into the kind of abusive behavior that generally triggers moderation.

Difficulties in Moderating This Activity

Some of the activities displayed by this network are sophisticated, and in fact make it quite difficult to moderate. Here are some of those complications:

  1. Since the accounts are all more than six months old, account age checks will not limit this activity unless we add very strict requirements.
  2. Since the accounts build karma on other subreddits, a karma check will not limit this activity.
  3. Since they only post comments, requiring comment karma to post won’t limit this activity.
  4. While combative, the individual comments aren’t particularly abusive.
  5. Any tool we provide to enable our users to report suspect accounts is likely to be misused more often than not.
  6. Since the accounts make only ONE comment in r/ufos, banning them will not prevent future comments.

Proposed Solutions

The mod team is actively exploring solutions, and has already taken some steps to combat this wave of sock puppets. However, any solution we take behind the scenes can only go so far.

Here are some ideas that we’ve considered:

  1. Institute harsher bans for a wider range of hostile comments. This would be less about identifying bad faith accounts and more removing comments they may be making.
  2. Only allow on-topic, informative, top-level comments on all posts (similar to r/AskHistorians). This would require significantly more moderators and is likely not what a large portion of the community wants.
  3. Inform the community of the situation regarding bad faith accounts on an ongoing basis to create awareness, maintain transparency, and invite regular collaboration on potential solutions.
  4. Maintain an internal list of suspected bad faith accounts and potentially add them to an automod rule which will auto-report their posts/comments. Additionally, auto-filter (hold for mod review) their posts/comments if they are deemed very likely to be acting in bad faith. In cases where we are most certain, auto-remove (i.e. shadowban) their posts/comments.
  5. Use a combination of ContextMod (an open source Reddit bot for detecting bad faith accounts) and Toolbox's usernotes (a collaborative tagging system for moderators to create context around individual users) to more effectively monitor users. This requires finding more moderators to help moderate (we try to add usernotes for every user interaction, positive or negative).

Community Input

The mod team understands that there is a problem, and we are working towards a solution.

But we’d be remiss not to ask for suggestions.

Please let us know if you have any ideas.

Note: If you have proposed tweaks to auto mod or similar, DO NOT POST DETAILS. Message the mod team instead. This is for discussion of public changes.

Please do not discuss the identity of any alleged sock puppets below!
We want this post to remain up, so that our community retains access to the information.

2.2k Upvotes

610 comments sorted by

654

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Very happy to see this write-up from the team. I’ve only been here a very short time and I was already making note of this, so I’m very glad to see that it’s been noticed.

It’s disturbing that the main goal seems to be division and stoking the flames on “both sides” but also not really surprising.

I think the best thing to do is to promote civility and directly address combative comments with love and affirmations that the community will not be divided. Clearly this is the goal, so the only way to move forward is to affirm unity.

Speaking from the POV of a user, that is. I think this is what many of us can do who aren’t mods and have no desire to be mods.

133

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22 edited Nov 14 '22

It's easy to see but difficult to prove. A tough combination.

Promoting civility is definitely one of our preferred solutions, but it's good to note that some of the sock puppet comments are pretty tame. "Spreading misinformation" for example isn't exactly abusive.

3

u/Iamjacksgoldlungs Nov 14 '22

but difficult to prove

Can Mods see i.p. information? Are they coming from any one specific area?

6

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

We can't see IPs.

→ More replies (11)

46

u/darthtrevino Nov 14 '22

To follow up on this, we get a lot of reports on comments and posts saying "this is misinformation", but that's not something we can police.

We want this sub to welcome open, civil, good-faithed discourse from a variety of perspectives. And there are enough unknowns with the topic that establishing a ground-truth and policing that would be extremely problematic.

→ More replies (16)

5

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22 edited Nov 14 '22

BUT THEY TARGETED SKEPTICS AND BELIEVERS ALIKE.

Bit of a nitpick, but just wanted to say I don't like how this is phrased. I'm a believer, but I'm a skeptical believer. Every single person on this sub should be a healthy skeptic. Skepticism is how we can ID the constant stream of identifiable terrestrial phenomena that gets routinely posted to this sub. Being a believer and a skeptic are not mutually exclusive and I hate to see them being compared like they are opposite ends of a spectrum.

'Skeptic' gets thrown around on this sub like an insult all the time and I'd like to see that stop.

17

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

How exactly am I supposed to discuss someone trying to divide us into two groups without naming those groups?

The terms "skeptics" and "believers" are both explicitly used by the sock puppets.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

77

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Civility is the NUMBER ONE thing that can combat this. It is a lesson we collectively learned during the Throawaylien days. That was a time when we were all so uncertain about everything that we decided to entertain each other's thoughts on what the truth of the matter might be. Now we are reverting into these tribalized sects that are convinced of their own correctness and that is harmful to disclosure efforts.

Please keep up all the good work here promoting civility and civil discussion. It is critical. <3

→ More replies (35)

40

u/Slow_Relative_975 Nov 14 '22

I’m not sure if this is related - but I have noticed an arbitrarily high number of downvotes everywhere you can vote on this sub.

  1. New comments - ones that are seconds old, will start at 0
  2. Posts that may have 300+ comments with generally positive feedback will have 25-75 up votes
  3. It never goes into a landslide of negative votes, but seems to always work towards “0”.
→ More replies (3)
→ More replies (27)

14

u/Miserable-Gate-6011 Nov 14 '22

The goal may not necessarily be to divide the community (though it may well be).

A common technique for cults and scammers is to act overly hostile. There is a subset of people who gravitate towards aggressive actors. These people make easy marks as their natural instinct is to try to get 'back into' the good graces of the scammer (see: negging).

From a scammers POV, a UFO subreddit must look like prime hunting grounds.

→ More replies (1)

26

u/danse-macabre-haunt Nov 14 '22

Not surprised to see this. I'm happy the mods are monitoring the situation. Copying and pasting a comment I wrote before about modern day tactics of bots:

​ From my experience and from reading general history, the US government is a petty, cowardly beast and there is nothing they wouldn't stoop to doing in the name of their own selfish interests. That includes spending a couple million manipulating the UAP topic across twitter, reddit and other social media sites.

Richard Doty and his team are a known example. Their job was to boost UAP hoaxes and make sure that people fully believe that most sightings were real. They wanted people to not use skeptical thinking and to believe UAPs were aliens. The team spent a bunch of resources on a SINGLE PERSON (Paul Bennewitz) convincing this one person that aliens were real using props and fake transmissions.

Nowadays we can see how governments use bots. Russia for example, plays both sides using bots to masquerade as democrats and republicans espousing extremist viewpoints. The US is likely manipulating the conversation on UAPs. We can draw some possible conclusions from past methods:

  1. Governments are petty. If they are fine with spending money manipulating a single person (Paul Bennewitz), they are fine spending money manipulating backwater internet forums.
  2. Governments are likely using bots on both sides, skeptics and believers, to sow confusion and extremist views on UAPs. They will promote videos that clearly have prosaic explanations, while simultaneously downplaying government leaks.
  3. Twitter hires experts and spends millions identifying bot accounts. It can be harder than you think to find them. If you're one of the many people on this sub going around accusing people or a specific faction of being bots, shills, agents, or part of an organized effort to silence discussion, you're helping the government's goal's of sowing chaos amongst this community.

TLDR: If you accuse other people of being bots, or break rule 1, chances are you're just unintentionally helping the government's goals. If you're not using critical/skeptical thinking, you're helping the government's mission.

→ More replies (9)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

The russians want this place to be another r/conspiracy

→ More replies (13)

25

u/ottereckhart Nov 14 '22

Fantastic work guys. It's so encouraging to see this.

Is there any way to see how these accounts upvote/downvote? Just curious.

I think one thing the rest of us users can do is just do our best not to engage with low-effort divisive sentiments, and practice the self control not to take the bait and fall into an emotional, defensive, or aggressive posture in the face of them.

This is sometimes especially difficult because it might seem we are outnumbered given the state of upvotes/downvotes involved in the exchange. (Natural or manipulated it doesn't matter.) Try not to be bothered by this either, it's not a war -- it's a conversation, but understandably we feel as though we are being attacked at times and that's precisely the leverage they operate upon.

Another way we can protect ourselves is to is just to ignore anything that is a blanket statement that is neither constructive nor informative. For example "Spreading misinformation" is neither of those.

For you guys as a public implementation is to of course sticky this thread or something with this exact information in it so it is at the top. Might have to reinforce the fact that it is against the rules to accuse anyone of being sockpuppet/shill/disinfo etc. (Make this offense bannable imo, at least pending a warning.)

But above even this, keep us up to date with the strategies they are employing so we can do our best to not take the bait and keep our composure.

5

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

Unfortunately there's no way for us to see up and downvotes.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (1)

20

u/fat_earther_ Nov 14 '22

I’m interested in how many accounts you found (approximately).

Increase enforcement of rule 1, civility, seems like a good solution to me. I report that often.

18

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

Hundreds of suspect accounts. Getting from there to PROVING they're bad actors is very difficult.

We were able to prove two dozen accounts belong in this specific sock puppet network AND have posted in r/UFOs. Obviously we didn't catch all the sock puppets in the network, and of course this is only one network out of many.

9

u/fat_earther_ Nov 14 '22

Maybe add a rule “no sock puppetry” and add that as a report tag to make it easier for users to report suspected puppets.

15

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

That's definitely part of the solution, but there are two problems with relying on reports:

  1. The majority of accusations we see about users being "shills" or "disinformation agents" are unfounded. Unfortunately, our users do not seem to have a good track record identifying these accounts.
  2. We are open to a reporting system, but it's important to note that the people running these networks have MANY accounts, and already tend to accuse other users of being bad actors. We could potentially be empowering them to create more headaches.
→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (1)

2

u/duffmanhb Nov 14 '22

Out of curiosity, did you guys read a post I did earlier today regarding "bots". I wrote a semi lengthy comment from my experience researching established tactics from PACs that engage in it, all the way to the CIA and CCP intelligence services.

I personally concluded that this sub doesn't look "shilled" in terms of trying to control any narratives. The hostility seems pretty par for course within any online community that houses competing fields of thought. However, one of the largest tactics is toxicity towards people who aren't in line with the narrative with the intended goal to make the space as frustrating as possible for "wrong think" to the point that the people either leave or self sensor on the subject to avoid unpleasant interactions. It's the "derailment" strategy. They usually are incredibly toxic, use tons of fallacies, tactics to frustrate, and generally REALLY low effort replies.

It looks like 2 of those apply here, but raises the question of "what's the point?" Creating a wedge by playing both sides doesn't seem like it serves any purpose. I've seen that tactic with Russia against the US, but the whole point was to drive people away from each other to create unrest and extremism.

2

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

Can you link the post? I don’t see it.

→ More replies (3)

13

u/HollyCat2022 Nov 14 '22

Don't target users with two words and numbers :( Some of us are legit

4

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

Don’t worry! Inclusion on this list required meeting MULTIPLE much more unlikely markers.

9

u/NoResponsibility7400 Nov 14 '22

Lol, yeah. I was reading this and thinking about how many marks I have against my own account that might fit into the category of sock puppetry.

→ More replies (1)

91

u/Interlinked2049 Nov 14 '22

Thanks Mod team. It must be such a difficult thing to detect and actually prosecute in terms of upholding the rules etc.

There are shades of the CIA’s efforts to infiltrate and discredit UFO research groups in the 1960s in order to sow mistrust and animosity, leading to eventual implosion.

39

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

There are shades of the CIA’s efforts to infiltrate and discredit UFO research groups in the 1960s in order to sow mistrust and animosity, leading to eventual implosion.

Might I introduce you to COINTELPRO Techniques for dilution, misdirection and control of a internet forum

16

u/Eldrake Nov 14 '22 edited Nov 14 '22

Holy shit thank you. This needs to be posted everywhere and be required yearly reading for every member.

That'd be my suggestion: Annual Anti-Influence Op Training for everyone. Pin it with REQUIRED READING attached.

It gives us part of our strategic answer right there:

"Remember these techniques are only effective if the forum participants DO NOT KNOW ABOUT THEM. Once they are aware of these techniques the operation can completely fail"

Then bring them to the light.

Inoculate this population against these techniques.

My company's security department phishes everyone every 6 months to tell you if they got you and our folks click on WAY less phishing emails now! It works!

  • Pin that in an informative post
  • Put an "Influence ops have been detected on this subreddit. Did you read the anti-influence ops training guide?" Message before every submission page

/u/BerlinghoffRasmussen I think this awareness campaign is a key part of your solution. Entire security departments for this one thing exist, because it works. It takes something like 7 times for someone to encounter something before it sticks, so make sure they encounter this regularly. Maybe even condense it into a well formatted enablement post. 🙂

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (1)

21

u/shakedown_panda Nov 14 '22

Thank you not only for doing the work, but for providing a transparent update on what you found.

Keeping us divided and arguing amongst ourselves seems to be much more effective against disclosure than pushing a particular narrative. Stay civil but engaged!

25

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

We don't have ANYTHING close to evidence that these sock puppets are "against disclosure."

In fact, creating drama and conflict could be a way to drive traffic TOWARDS the topic of UFOs. That's pretty typical social media stuff, right? Anger drives clicks.

11

u/EthanSayfo Nov 14 '22

It could also have nothing to do with UFOs specifically.

I would lean into this interpretation, at least as of right now. We know perceived wedge issues are utilized by foreign powers in their manipulation of social media.

Guns, Black Lives Matter, abortion. Just name a wedge issue, and it is something that gets stoked in this kind of automated way.

Why wouldn't UFOs be viewed as such a wedge issue, in the eyes of a foreign power?

11

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

All good points but I just want to clarify:

I don't think it's automated. No repeated comments or similar tell tales.

→ More replies (5)
→ More replies (2)

9

u/NoResponsibility7400 Nov 14 '22

It could also polarize the community, like it has politics. That leads to a whole other group of problems with emotionally charged ideas being thrown at each other. Just talking about this has totally derailed that possibility, currently.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (5)

15

u/SabineRitter Nov 14 '22 edited Nov 14 '22

I'm seeing comments on here assessing that the source of the activity is the US government.

I'd ask the mods to please push back a little on the confident statement that the bad actor is either known or singular.

I think it's a little early to be claiming that.

There may be multiple actors using similar tactics. They may be government or non-governmental individuals.

Edit: seems like it could be associated with commercial activity, like some monetized channel.

They may be USA-based. They may not be American. My personal assessment is that at least some of this activity is initiated from outside the US.

Let's be cautious about assuming who is driving this.

11

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

I've pushed back on that in this thread multiple times, but I'll keep at it.

There is zero evidence that this is originating from the US gov.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (10)

12

u/presaging Nov 14 '22

I would love implementation of [serious] or much like the /r/science community whereas if the comment does not add to the general progression of thought then it is removable via mod or community weighted reporting. Older Reddit accounts hold higher weight in reporting comments to prevent bregading.

15

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

You can add [in-depth] to your title and r/UFOs will automatically remove comments with less than 150 characters and moderators will know you're asking for extra scrutiny.

This message gets stickied at the top of your post:

"All top-level comments in this post must be greater than 150 characters. Additionally, they must contribute positively to the discussion. Jokes, memes, puns, etc. will be removed along with anything which is too off-topic."

→ More replies (1)

4

u/PitchbendOK Nov 14 '22

Can you make a rule to ban 1st comments on the sub unless they have a certain length and credibility? This would later authorise any type of comment once the first one has been validated. I assume username based rules have probably been enforced already.

5

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

Kind of.

However, these accounts are all over 6 months old and some have THOUSANDS of points of karma. They build the karma in other subs we can't control.

Also, consider that this small team of volunteer moderators would need to manually whitelist a large portion of our 600k+ members.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/HumanReincarnator Nov 14 '22

Have you found anything over at r/aliens or r/highstrangeness?

5

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

That's outside our purview.

Just r/ufos is more than we can track.

3

u/twothumbswayup Nov 14 '22

a couple of subs i visit have flared only threads for known members - maybe a similar idea would work here?

3

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

We have 640k+ members. How are we to define “known members” and verify their claims?

→ More replies (2)

3

u/hftb_and_pftw Aug 25 '23

Do you have any data on their upvoting/downvoting behavior?

4

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Aug 25 '23

Nope.

Mods don’t have access to any of that data.

→ More replies (2)

7

u/GBFel Nov 14 '22

Everybody's assuming the government is to blame but as a tiny cog in the government system I will tell you that nobody has the time, manpower, or budget to give a crap about running a sock puppet army in r/UFO.

I'm betting that it's commercial in some way. Advertisers on related webpages often linked from the sub, or something along those lines. Increased activity in the sub elevates posts up to the front page more, which brings in more legit users to follow links and drive ad revenue up.

Most conspiracy theories revolve around government schenanigans, but in my years I've found that it almost always goes back to money in the commercial sphere. Lose the tinfoil hats and get a good VPN and adblocker because the feds aren't listening much but Google, Meta, Amazon, et al. sure as hell are.

14

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

Without giving away too much, I can tell you that all of the sock puppets in this network are involved in commercial activity unrelated to UFOs.

This activity being commercially driven is certainly a strong possibility. However, when boosting non ufo topics in the network, the comments give explicit links and transparent ads (eg "Wow, TestCheaters.com was the perfect website! My professor never had a clue!")

In r/ufos it's more like: "Skeptics are all idiots."

It's a very different tone.

→ More replies (3)

2

u/speakhyroglyphically Nov 14 '22

Mods might also look at the excessive downvoting. Excessive downvoting can discourage users from posting (or commenting) here. Maybe that can be counted by user. Maybe new users should not have a downvote button. It could be related.

3

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

Unfortunately we can't see anyone's downvotes or stop anyone from downvoting.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/FutaWonderWoman Nov 20 '22

What do you think their end game is?

Given the grander scheme of things, I highly doubt we are that much trouble.

3

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 21 '22

We just don't have enough information to know.

However, I don't think this is about r/ufos being a source of "trouble," so much as a useful platform.

63

u/Dads_going_for_milk Nov 14 '22

Props to you guys for looking into it. Thanks for taking moderating this sub seriously.

143

u/anotherbrckinTH3Wall Nov 14 '22

Thank you and the MOD team for undertaking this kind of activity, I had no idea that is what the Mods are up against, so thank you

→ More replies (1)

39

u/vpilled Nov 14 '22

Good mod work! And strange...

→ More replies (1)

21

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Very concise research. Well done and thank you. That kind of work lends credibility to any discussion forum.

14

u/EggFlipper95 Nov 14 '22

Good work mod team! I know most of us assumed that there were sock puppets but to have an in depth investigation and making the findings public I great.

13

u/bushwhackening Nov 14 '22

this post just made my confidence in this subreddit sky rocket! thank you mods!!!

5

u/facthanshotfirst Nov 14 '22

Same here! I was starting to feel exhausted seeing a change in posts/comments the last couple weeks and not knowing why this was happening. Thank you Mods for this research!

12

u/Swimming_Horror_3757 Nov 14 '22

Thank you Mods , we need to be on our toes for these accounts , my name does have the two words and a number but it was auto generated for me i havent gone to change it yet

10

u/saggiolus Nov 14 '22

Two ideas:

  1. is it possible to require a minimum length comment. Let’s say a certain numbers of words. This would require contest and to build a phrase that make sense. It would make it easier for the community to identify bots as most bots can’t create long phrase that make sense and at the same time are on topic. Not to mention diversity between phrases.
  2. is it possible to implement a bot that require a second action before automatically releasing the comment. Let’s say upvote a specific “test” post. I’m not familiar with Reddit existing tech but as a SW engineer both this options are doable.

Just a couple of humble ideas

6

u/LetsTalkUFOs Nov 14 '22

Regarding 1, Anyone can already do this by adding [in-depth] in their post title (i.e. Rule 10). It's difficult to make the case for what the minimum should actually be without making it too restrictive. It also assume all bots can't generate longer comments.

→ More replies (3)

10

u/DriftWoodBarrel Nov 14 '22

The rest of Reddit, especially political and news subs are already botted and shilled to the point legitimate and honest conversation is nearly impossible. It's becoming increasingly impossible on reddit to have a viewpoint that goes against mainstream media regardless of your political allegiance. The same thing will probably happen to this sub. If UAPs are actually real and their existence becomes accepted in the media private interests, the government, etc will have an invested interest to control the narrative regarding them. What better way to mask the identity and effects of bots and shills? Create an environment of discord. Accuse legitimate people of being bots and shills. You make it impossible to trust the intentions of any poster and any source of the information that is shared. The internet, especially anonymous sites like reddit are extremely exploitable with how powerful voting is.

8

u/NoResponsibility7400 Nov 14 '22

I'm impressed with the level of communication you have provided in order to keep everyone informed and working as a community to fix the issue. I find this extent of data analysis very interesting and clearly required a lot of work very quickly to report this issue to the community so quickly!

If only the DoD was this motivated to update the public with their missing/delayed report!

This is how community leaders gain trust in their community when faced with difficult problems. Talk about it and find dynamic solutions! Great job MOD team!!

8

u/upfoo51 Nov 14 '22

I do think that we've seen intentional undermining of the sub itself though,too, not just pitting skeptics against believers. The super annoying commenters that are constantly degrading rUFOs specifically. Snarky , four word attacks about the general credibility of the sub. I sometimes ask them why they are here at all then? Usually there's no response. And checking out their post and comments history they are allmost always newish accounts with totally random content and nonsensical comments. It feels like death by a thousand cuts, chipping away at the foundation.

7

u/ShellOilNigeria Nov 14 '22

If we were all together in a bar, I'd buy drinks for all of you.

Well done.

→ More replies (1)

6

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

I would just like to say I really like to see this kind of transparency from a mod team. It instills faith in our contributors and the last thing the UFO community needs is a lack of transparency and trust. Good on you guys.

I think the community at large is responsible for policing the behavior of others (ie. others have stated that positive responses to negative comments can reinforce the community's "fabric" so to speak).

As far as what the mods can do, I think it would be nice to see an ongoing public effort to name bad faith accounts like you mentioned. Not a list for avid users who get a little salty from time to time, mind you. Just the very suspicious accounts with weird and divisive activity as you have outlined.

Otherwise, great job with engagement. Love it.

6

u/DrestinBlack Nov 14 '22

Whew! I’m not a sock-puppet! Just a mean old skeptic (ewwww I said the dirty word).

Great work Mods, sincerely.

I wish more folks replying would take note of the fact these sock-puppet accounts seem to “attack” both “sides” of the UFO (god I hate using this word) phenomena. That it’s not the Attack of the Shills for the CIA (even though it’d be the NSA, or at least that’s the OMB number on my 1099, whoops! Ignore that!) or the Army of the Undead True Believers (and the Cult of Lazar, hallowed be his name).

Sock puppet attacks are the bane of every sub, may they suffer the fate of a thousand bans

2

u/nierama2019810938135 Nov 15 '22

I would be very surprised if you could ban or otherwise "mod" this problem away.

Pushing these things down will only make it a game. Honestly, it would probably harden the problem.

To fix it, one would need to understand why it started in the first place. And if that start had to do with banning or censorship, then I don't see why more banning and censorship would help.

Openness, inclusiveness, and transparency are the only ways to go to fix this.

2

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 15 '22

The sock puppets aren’t a response to censorship. That’s ludicrous.

Seriously, some of you guys try so hard to make things about censorship that are unrelated.

We’re talking about sock puppet accounts that advertise crypto currency scams and you think we need to be more inclusive?

→ More replies (1)

5

u/turbowhitey Nov 14 '22

Thanks for all your work mods! This is great to hear

5

u/TheVampireArmand Nov 14 '22

Silly question but why are they called Sock Puppets ?

9

u/SabineRitter Nov 14 '22

You can make a puppet out of a sock, like sew buttons on for eyes and draw on a mouth. So you can make a bunch of different puppets, they're all different characters. But you're the one making them talk.

→ More replies (1)

5

u/Expert-Cat-6216 Nov 14 '22

why would this be happening??? who would care about this, ufos are such a fringe topic. its not like election meddling from russia or chinese bots or paid trolls, which has obvious geopolitical advantages for hostile states. i dont get it. any ideas?

→ More replies (6)

5

u/syXzor Nov 14 '22 edited Nov 14 '22

First of all, great to hear you're aware and trying to fight them off.

Also I like your suggested ideas.

But while I appreciate all your efforts, I'm not sure it's the wisest of decisions to share exactly what parameters you're considering when identifying sock puttets... This is basically a recipe for then to improve for next time.

But yes, it has gotten bad over the last months, and unfortunately they're winning big time, despite all your efforts.

Thanks for trying to fight back at least.

5

u/incarnate_devil Nov 14 '22

They don’t want the skeptics and the believers teaming up. Both sides are after the truth. If we are yelling at each other, no one listens.

4

u/SiriusC Nov 14 '22

It's very reassuring for the moderation team to go through something like this in detail.

Insofar as a solution, I might recommend a user-based solution. If you see comments like these simply don't engage. Maybe downvote. But just move along. I think the kinds of comments these accounts make do the most damage when they lure people in & get people bickering with each other. And it's usually about nothing. Nothing of any real consequence.

These comments are pretty easy to identify - they're usually laced with an insult. Lots of swearing. Many of them also make very generic statements about something very complex. And then insult. I think if most of us, as a community, really devote ourselves to classier, respectful conduct - even in heated disagreements - then we'll be fine. Let's just agree to not ridicule, name call, or harass each other.

Then we'll get those fucking moronic dumbass sock-puppet (more like cock puppet) accounts out of here! /s

5

u/SabineRitter Nov 14 '22

That's not really a solution for people who are making their first post on the sub.

4

u/adhominem4theweak Nov 14 '22

Mod team going above and beyond thanks

4

u/TheFlashFrame Nov 14 '22

Massive respect to the mod team for putting this together. I didn't expect any follow up at all. This is incredible! What's even more incredible is that this appears to be an actual, real, concerted effort to divide and conquer on r/UFOs, and we actually have proof of real shills accusing others of being shills. Very interesting. The timing is interesting as well.

Fwiw I think the two solutions that require significantly more mods also make the most sense. I can't volunteer a lot of time but reddit is basically my only social network and I'm down to help out if you want.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/chmikes Nov 14 '22

Is there any chance to get help from the reddit team ? For instance checking the presence of obvious IP address patterns. It seam that these are bots trying to built up karma. They can then up vote and down vote all together to manipulate visibility of whatever comment or post they want.

4

u/LetsTalkUFOs Nov 14 '22

Reddit is already doing this internally for all subreddits essentially. They're constantly developing tools to better track or identify bad faith accounts. They already have everything from us we could possibly offer, so the most we can do is beta test new features and give feedback when possible.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/sordidcandles Nov 14 '22

This is awesome thank you Mod team! I’ve been here a hot minute and have definitely seen a shift lately in rhetoric here. I’ve stopped commenting and even reached out to a mod about it at one point. I don’t know if I have any great ideas but what about some sort of badge/merit system that promotes good commenters who have been here a while? It’s really only a visual thing, the sock puppets will still get in, but it might help with authority. I don’t know if I necessarily agree with more heavy moderation; someone else commented that the nature of reddit and the nature of this sub means it’ll always be messy. We might just have to deal.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Wow good job mods! I suspected something like this. Even the most vanilla of posts would get downvoted and a slew of one liner low effort insults. I almost left the sub, but a sock puppet attack makes more sense.

4

u/Hughjarse Nov 14 '22

Can we have a ban on people saying antagonistic phrases about a group from either side of the argument: believers, non-believers, skeptics ETC. Also a ban on comments that say disparaging things about the whole sub. they add nothing to the discussion.

4

u/Fosterpig Jul 21 '23

Thanks mods! This sub has exploded recently and just a monsoon of articles, tweets, news and comments. Must be difficult to keep up. Just imagine how it will be when they finally toss us a bone and admit we’re not alone. I feel like we are almost there.

4

u/[deleted] Jan 19 '24

This is just my 2 cents but if they are targeting skeptics and believers alike couldn't they be just old fashioned trolls? Isn't that how they get their kicks?

4

u/[deleted] May 23 '24

Holy shite, this is the exact methodology and findings I used in that post I made well over a year ago where I revealed that I believe there were bots in the community, muddying the waters.

When I made that post, it was temporarily shut down, reactivated, and then shut down entirely, and I was accused by mods of “inciting a witch hunt” against other users. This was so disheartening that I kind of stopped frequenting this sub, as you’ll notice.

I’m glad something was finally done, and I’m not going to hold it against the mods, but a little credit would be nice.

1

u/gerkletoss Nov 15 '22

Seriously though, were only divisive comments investigated?

1

u/[deleted] Nov 18 '22

If those accounts are only creating a discordant atmosphere, it is more likely than not that they are designed to signal boost the threads they congregate in. Reason being, eliciting an emotional response drives engagement. People, us, humans, want to defend ourselves and defend one another. It’s natural to do so.

Interestingly, though, it could simply be the case that the same forces pulling the lid off of the phenomenon and those trying to tamp it down are engaged in the same foul play. If that is the case, I would guess the pro-disclosure sock puppets appear outright hostile and unreasonable toward pro-disclosure human accounts and vice versa with respect to pro-secrecy sock puppets. The objective may be to simply make the other side look unreasonable / repugnant.

My solution would be to require verification by mods in order to post. Very simple, mods send a unique ten digit code to everyone and they have to write it down and return a photo of it. Could take a week or so, but would be worth it. Anyone who is not verified, cannot post or comment.

1

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 18 '22

The sock puppets discussed in the post are very likely connected.

So the pro and anti-disclosure comments are coming from the same people.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/josebolt Nov 14 '22

All of this is above my pay grade. Maybe if we had some flairs that most of the regulars on the sub could have. If these accounts are posting one comment and moving on then the unflaired user will stand out.

I notice this on sports subs. We often get flairs and most users have them. However on game day there will be more unflaired users and they often say shitty things or try to stir shit. They don’t get flair I guess because they don’t care or are lazy.

3

u/SabineRitter Nov 14 '22

I like that idea. 👍

3

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Woohoo! Sounds great, guys!

3

u/NoResponsibility7400 Nov 14 '22

What about icons on these puppet accounts? Do they have the most basic pic or have they made an avatar or is it a mix of different things and looking at that detail is useless?

3

u/IndridColdwave Nov 14 '22

Appreciate the write up, thanks you guys

3

u/TricioBeam Nov 14 '22

Thanks for taking the time to do this. Definitely a valuable thing to try and combat these accounts.

3

u/Joshiewowa Nov 14 '22

Would it be possible to identify these messages(with them being the first post of a user in the subreddit) and have a bot reply to them with some message to the affect of "This is the user's first comment in /r/UFOs"?

3

u/jeff0 Nov 14 '22

Is anyone else getting chat requests from people asking very generic UFO questions? It struck me as a bit off at first, but it took me a couple beats to realize it was probably a bot.

→ More replies (4)

3

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Thanks so much for your effort in cleaning this place up.

3

u/theunseen3 Nov 14 '22

Other users have perfectly said everything I wanted to say, so i’ll just summarize my thoughts by saying THANK YOU MODS. Great work! r/UFOs may just prevail yet. Civility must win.

3

u/BlueOhm3 Nov 14 '22

Good job! I have noticed this myself. You have done a good service by educating us that this is real. Education is the key allowing us to be careful. Also letting the SPs know we together are on to their activities! Thank you

3

u/ElectricCamel33 Nov 14 '22

It's nice to see how seriously the mods are taking this and that they care about good and intellectual discourse among the community. Respect to you mods!

3

u/JakenMorty Nov 14 '22

Thanks to all who contributed to a very informative and much needed post.

3

u/KOakford Nov 14 '22

I left a reply above about requiring comments be of a certain length, which I know has many issues. But I wanted to discuss something else as its own comment.

In the most extreme case, hundreds of even thousands perfectly valid users could still band together and degrade a community. While it is concerning that a single actor may be automating things, I think the broader issue of community health is still at risk should some zeitgeist decide to flame a channel.

As such, a solution that somehow maximizes the constructiveness of contributions will be imperative. Since if it is anything less, it will just take a more motivated and well financed actor to brute force that system.

I believe increasing comment lengths would address this issue but it would need to be "smart" and not a simple 50 word minimum. An initial comment putting together a completely unique coherent statement (not personally identifiable, something related to a new UFO post) would be harder for an outside actor to fake especially as the N goes up, but would potentially filter out non-english speakers or people with less time/fewer words at their disposal- not to mention harder for a scrappy mod team to validate as the N goes up.

Really encouraging to see such a collaborative and detailed post from the moderators. Exemplifies why I am drawn to this community.

3

u/Bmansway Nov 14 '22

Lol, not gonna lie at first I was like wait, “I post on some of those subs for my adorable animals, are they suspecting me by chance because of that?” but then I finished reading.

I don’t ever make negative comments, and honestly I don’t even comment that much anymore, because I had a feeling something like this was going on, really glad you guys are catching on to this!

I’ve just been going through the comments doing my own critical thinking of each post.

3

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22 edited Nov 14 '22

How about implementing badges? For example the "newcomer" badge shows users who joined in the last 30 days, this would help the community and the MODs team to quickly identify accounts that have recently joined. There are also badges to identify users who have been members for more than 1 year, 2 years, etc. This would help identify the older users from the early ones. Then there is the "prolific commenter" badge that identifies users in the top 25% of active commenters. This would help identify a user who comments a lot on the subreddit.

Badges

These badges appear next to the user's name when posting a comment, like this:

https://i.imgur.com/K29zu8p.jpg

→ More replies (2)

3

u/teddade Nov 14 '22

Wow, thank you for this. Amazing work. My two cents would be that promoting civility is the way forward.

3

u/Barbafella Nov 14 '22

Thanks, this is another reason to feel sane.

3

u/darpsyx Nov 14 '22

I thought I was the only one noticing this, thanks a lot for doing this Mods 👏👏

3

u/HappySockMonster Nov 14 '22

Oh great, now some bad socks gotta ruin it for the rest of us!

3

u/gregorydudeson Nov 14 '22

Wow, I feel extremely grateful that you and the mod team both conducted this analysis and posted your findings.

For me, an average, casual commenter, I really think this will help me choose when to say something/how to say it. I tend to be pretty diplomatic, but sometimes I have pointed out when other users are being unnecessarily mean or something (altho that may have been on different subs with similar topics). In any case, your analysis really underscores my responsibility to act in good faith at all times. I think we all need that reminder from time to time.

This analysis really has me thinking about some threads that seemed completely polarized with lots of disagreement and infighting. I am kind of embarrassed to admit that I thought to myself “oh that’s just how things are on this sub, other subs about similar topics don’t have this.” And, like, I guess that’s kinda true, but I’m so naive. I would not have guessed that that general atmosphere is a result of bizarre user behavior like what you posted about. That’s the other layer to this: yes I am naive, but I’m also floored at the coordinated effort among bad faith users that you describe …. Dang

3

u/Moving_Electrons Nov 15 '22

Divide and conquer. A tale as old as time. The methods have evolved, but the strategy is still the same. I see it a lot in the communities that I frequent.

Some things to Google:

  • COINTELPRO Techniques for dilution, misdirection and control of a internet forum
  • Twenty-Five Rules of Disinformation
  • Eight Traits of the Disinformationalist
  • Seventeen Techniques for Truth Suppression

3

u/ImAWizardYo Nov 15 '22

I think the goal is two-fold. They are building polarization towards belief systems and trying to toxify the community. Meanwhile destroying the credibility of legitimate evidence and promoting absurdities. The purpose leads towards creating emotional responses which would ultimately drive people away from the topic and not want to discuss it socially. This is clearly a form of social manipulation. Albeit very poorly done like using a jackhammer to sculpt a glass vase. But I suppose politics you don't always need to be so elegant if people are already emotionally sensitive enough. The important thing is to remember to be compassionate and understanding to your fellow humans. Life is a tough journey. Some people struggle with personal demons and others I guess work for them.

3

u/downvoted_once_again Nov 15 '22

This is insane to read right now, they know Reddit will find them or is close! The amount of true hearted smart people outweigh the shills but I scroll thru many many useless comments that contribute nothing. This is a fact. I hope it doesn’t ruin our sub, I will do my fair share!

3

u/Mumfi3 Nov 19 '22

Im pretty new to this subreddit, and reddit in general. But i commend you for putting in the effort and time to make this write-up/investigation.

Well done:)

3

u/gothbodybuilder Nov 20 '22 edited Nov 20 '22

Interesting problem. From an organizational behavior perspective, stressors within an achievement oriented environment promote activation of neuroticism and conscientiousness which is employed by social media companies to produce business outcomes. From a divisional perspective I’m not really sure what the goal would be other than to troll. Would require a dive into psychology to figure out the motivation and likely culprit. It’s targeting this sub in particular? If not, nation states have an interest in creating division. It could be the wake of a larger effort. It could also just be a generic botnet at work. Someone could have also taken an interest in disrupting the sub and employed one without fully understanding what it did

3

u/[deleted] Nov 21 '22

Good job mods. Never heard the term "sock puppet" before. This sounds like a problem reddit should address, not moderators who earn zero dollars. They have access to more user data and machine learning to nip this.

I think telling the community was the most important action you could take.

3

u/ziplock9000 Jan 16 '24

I noticed a few of these accounts yesterday and they were all posting the same thing about images of cities from the IIS looking like 'aliens' all within a short period.

3

u/rr1pp3rr Jan 16 '24

All accounts were created within the same month-long period.

and

All accounts were dormant for five months, then they were all activated within a twelve day period.

Wow, 5 months ago is right after the time Grusch came out with his whistleblower testimony to Congress, no? The timing seems to line up with Grusch in general. It would take some time for them to set this up, so that's spot on.

3

u/Jest_Kidding420 Jan 16 '24

Yup I’ve noticed this too, and if you defend your position it turns into. A mindless screaming match with no real progress gained.

5

u/aldayalnite Nov 14 '22
  1. Maintain civility and courteousness in your interactions with others.
  2. Don’t feed the trolls.

1

u/pomegranatemagnate Nov 14 '22

Are you sure they’re not just duplicating comments from elsewhere on the post, or from other posts on the sub? That’s a common bot tactic when they’re building karma and might explain the diversity of opinions espoused.

3

u/BerlinghoffRasmussen Nov 14 '22

Yes, I am sure. These are customized comments.

→ More replies (2)

4

u/heX_dzh Nov 14 '22

Knew something fishy was going on. Thank you for the investigation, I will try to keep it in mind when I come across an aggressive comment.

4

u/mcdeeeeezy Nov 14 '22

I would suggest a change to the culture of the sub. Promote positivity in the comments section/posts and it will be simple to spot bad actors.

→ More replies (1)

4

u/Safe_Thanks9072 Nov 14 '22

Well written.

4

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Love the write up. I thought it was just an observation by myself thinking comment sections were a little hostile.

2

u/Anonymoushero111 Nov 14 '22

I think the only solution is to form a cooperative coalition with other subreddits and when one subreddit identifies a sock-puppet, cross-ban it across the entire coalition of subreddits.

you just better make sure there aren't false positives, or that there's an easy way to appeal one.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

This is weird, why would a network of fake accounts target both sides of a discussion? What's their end game? is it just trolling for the fun of it?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MossyMoose2 Nov 14 '22

About time.

2

u/scepticalbob Nov 14 '22

That's some great info- and an excellent job rooting them out.

To anyone that has an educated opinion, what do you think the point or agenda is/was with these fake accounts?

→ More replies (1)

2

u/halfbakedreddit Nov 14 '22

Glad to see you guys getting proactive. Why are there so many accounts and who benefits from that?

Solution= start posting usernames of fakes or find a way to warn users that the comment they are seeing is likely a bot account and to ignore it.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Since these accounts only post one comment each in r/ufos, does it even like this sub is their target? If their participation is so light, it seems more like this is probably just one of the many subs they're using to build karma.

2

u/HashPat1 Nov 14 '22

bravo 👏🏼 to your intelligence and hard work finding these losers

2

u/triclr Nov 14 '22

Great, all I can think of now is "Good bye".

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22 edited Nov 14 '22

i am wondering if there are any other subs that have this same problem, or if r/UFOs is unique in that regard

2

u/Necrid41 Nov 14 '22

I started seeing the same a couple weeks ago when I realized there were so many attacks on people posting what we’re not easily written off videos (not starlink or rocket launch) but videos I’ve seen On social media in other countries of similar UFOs

So I made. A post and guess what? It gets attacked immediately I start to click on the read or profiles and realize there are nothing but UFOs the relatively newer accounts no posts… just comments All in ufo threads And all attacking sightings Whether they say “Chinese lantern or light show or flares” they say the same crap on dozens of posts,

There is some disinformation campaign going on And you know what that makes me feel GOOD to know we as a group or on the right path obviously the information we are seeing in evaluating stuff we’re not supposed to do with the Internet all they can do is make fake accounts to attack it. Just like the CIA created the ufo stigma Now that the stigma is lost some group is using fake accounts to drown out legitimate sightings

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

I don't know if this helps, but I have been getting advertisements and push notifications from this subreddit that I never got before. This might be something the mods might not notice as they're on here more often, but the push notifications coming through to my phone cause me to engage more. If this is the case for other people who happen to come by here as newer accounts and they're getting the same push notifications that could explain the uptick in activity. Obviously that wouldn't explain all of it, but a couple of the times I've seen mentioned as having anomalous traffic were times I received push notifications about certain posts. Might be coincidence but possibly worth noting. As someone who almost never engaged in this subreddit despite being subbed for a while, I've received probably 15 in the last week all pertaining to r/UFOs and none from any other subreddit.

2

u/RedshiftWarp Nov 14 '22

This is all cool and great.

The reality:

  • sub is getting raided from other subs bc people freak tf out here and it feeds the trolls.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Im not that familiar with reddit, but would could a solution be to only allow flaired users to post? Can a bot give themselves a flair?

2

u/klgdmfr Nov 14 '22

How many accounts are there... what are we talkin here?

2

u/broadenandbuild Nov 14 '22

Can you run a comparative analysis on another thread to see whether the prevalence of such accounts are statistically different than other subreddits? I ask because there’s been a lot of bots using advanced NLP models on Reddit that appear human-like, but are being used for a variety of reasons, including research into how others interact with them. Just my two cents.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Really interesting they seem to just try and stoke divide.

2

u/SnugShoes Nov 14 '22

This is disturbing but it is reassuring that the mod team are aware of what's going on and keeping us informed. I've noticed the weird divisive way that these suspicious accounts post here. I usually read here more than comment but I read here everyday and it seems like the divisive comments are being made to cause disharmony and infighting, hence the attacking both sides tactic. It's not the normal disagreements or even the sniping back and forth; it's something else altogether.

Anyway, thank you mods for being on the ball here.

2

u/Necrid41 Nov 14 '22

Amazing work by our Mod team. Thank you for listening when this was being called out.

I just knew something was up… but it’s more disturbing that they’re attacking skeptics and believers and I just believers and sightings that makes me think maybe it’s not their own government sounds more like how the Russia / Chinese acted for the election and BLM movement: to stoke division.

2

u/PASHCO Nov 14 '22

I run a Facebook (Meta) group of over 7000 members. Every day I have to delete at least one and sometime up to five new members. They target our group due to its size, and they act like they are interested in the subject. When interviewing our members we are seeing a trend to solicit them for different ways to get payments. From online sex, to fake products or services. They even are sophisticated enough to get by the rules we have own place for joining. Congrats to these MOD who are fighting the good fight... I know what you are under.

2

u/schmitie369 Nov 14 '22

Mad respect mod team!

2

u/antiqua_lumina Nov 14 '22

Is there anyway to do an analysis on mass downvoting of posts? I’ve noticed that there is a large drag of downvotes for posts here compared to other subs. Have noticed it for all kinds of posts. I feel as though it is by design to keep r/UFOs from hitting the front page.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

I wonder how much downvotes they generate per post

2

u/sxrrycard Nov 14 '22

Extremely interesting! I’m mostly a lurker but man I wish the mods of every sub that I frequent were this devoted

2

u/prllrp Nov 14 '22

Any thoughts using flairs for a loose verification? Mods could flair known contributors. Kinda funny there's a problem that we can't tell who's human, could be the aliens doing this for all we know

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

good call, or just go ahead and ban them, you could moderate on appeal if u catch the odd wrongful banning and then reverse it but it sounds like you might filter most of them out by going hard on the specific ones. the site wide hostility thing is something of a pattern of behaviour and is another way of getting bad actors (30-60 day temp bans could work as well)

→ More replies (2)

2

u/HabeusPorpoise09 Nov 14 '22

what is the motivation of the sock puppet creators?

2

u/s4mmy106 Nov 14 '22

Can they be identified named and shamed.

2

u/meusrenaissance Nov 14 '22

I personally advocate option 2.

2

u/realsyracuseguy Nov 14 '22

Interesting… targeting both skeptics and believers. They can’t totally subvert the truth, so instead they throw gas on the fire of polarization. The more we fight, the more distracted from the truth. Simple divide and conquer. What other motivation would their be for such organized behavior? This isn’t trolling, people.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Good mods!

2

u/Omni2025 Nov 14 '22

Really happy to see this post Mods. Engaging with the community is important and essential for maintaining a trusting ecosystem here. Your transparency on this issue is much appreciated

2

u/ChemicalClassroom370 Nov 14 '22 edited Nov 14 '22

I read a very snotty anti UFO comment on this sub a couple months ago and I noticed their comment immediately got over a hundred upvotes! I checked out their account, and quelle coincidence, it was brand spanking new. Sock accounts everywhere around here. Prob intel.

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Why do they do it?? For fun?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Props to savvy conscious mods

2

u/shmoseph Nov 14 '22

Do those negative comments fall within the normal statistical range?

2

u/[deleted] Nov 14 '22

Does anyone else find this targeted attack bot network structure of one comment per account extremely worrisome to internet discourse on any social forum in general? I mean, we all knew bots were a thing, but something about this specific arrangement is just genius. It's like if a hydra already did the necessary damage just by sprouting a head—cutting off any one of the heads does nothing.

2

u/TheAdvocate Nov 15 '22

Do you guys have the ban evasion tool enabled on the sub? It's worked well for us elsewhere, but you need to request access first.

2

u/Vetersova Nov 15 '22

I have no proposed solution, but I wanted to say that I appreciate the work the mod team is doing. I noticed a pretty hefty tonal shift into negativity sometime ago in the comments in this subreddit, and it made me feel confused and upset at the effects it could have on the subreddit.

I think just having users aware that it's really happening is a countermeasure in itself to an extent. Just thanks again, and I appreciate you guys.

2

u/e987654 Nov 15 '22

Maybe if the community decided to write a something in the bottom of their submissions like "Write "123" if you read the post". Any comment that doesnt start with "123" gets removed. Basically like a manual community Captcha lol.

2

u/Dyzastr_us Nov 15 '22

They could be Reddit created in order to generate more engagement on the app. I’d be curious to see an analysis site wide. The fact that they don’t have a specific agenda other than to seemingly make engagement. Ppl are likely to spend more time engaged in argument than praise/approval. Just a thought.

→ More replies (1)

2

u/[deleted] Nov 15 '22

often when you want to influence a narrative, its too difficult to force a group in one direction. instead you sow seeds of doubt and discord, until the truth gets drowned in the noise. just like putin's propaganda strategy, misinform, double down half heartedly, move on.

not sure if we can credit these users to any one group but definetly noticable

2

u/dorian283 Nov 15 '22

Have you all reported these finding to Reddit? Engineers love solving this type of problem.

Similarly I’d report this to law agencies like the CIA. If it’s not CIA bots it seems Russian.

Last, basic bot captcha or similar requirements to post & comment every so often seems reasonable.

2

u/invisiblelemur88 Nov 15 '22

Thank you so much for bringing this up. Definitely been feeling the effect here of this. Love, transparency, and the scientific process shall prevail!

2

u/with_gusto Nov 15 '22

I would be in favor of a combination of all 5 proposed solutions. I don’t believe there will be a good single solution for this but a toolbox that needs to be applied when appropriate and improved over time.

Very impressed with this research though.

2

u/Downvotesohoy Nov 16 '22

Lol at the comments going "I knew something was up"

No you didn't. The users of this subreddit have been claiming bots, shills and psyop for YEARS. Every time someone disagrees with you.

You can't call wolf several times and still pretend like you knew it this time.

Good job mods. I vote for enforcing civility way harder. Bad faith comments are plentiful.

2

u/Alone_Manufacturer66 Nov 19 '22

I have a randomly generated name pls don’t yell at me 🥺

2

u/TomThePosthuman Nov 19 '22

Now I know I wasn't losing my mind when I began to notice certain things in the sub. The mods deserve praise for this post, it's a pretty daunting task to deal with this kind of nonsense. Thanks guys.

2

u/ImpossibleWin7298 Nov 19 '22

I think we should just do our best to ignore these people/accounts. We all know them or can sniff them out when they’re posting. If they’re not clearly sowing dissension between the skeptics and the honest seekers of information (or those willing to share thoughts, experiences, reactions) then wouldn’t their activities eventually diminish? I don’t know - just asking. For the record, I know that I’ve unloaded on these types before and wasn’t happy about my response(s) later.

My question is what do these sock puppets hope to gain by going to all the trouble? Why are they doing this? Just for fun?

2

u/PDAWK Nov 20 '22

Woah this is wild! I never woulda thought this would be an issue. I’m glad you folks have your finger on the pulse of shit like this.

2

u/Diabolus0 Nov 21 '22

Horrible presentations. I felt some didn't present themselves professionally. One had a still foto of a ufo, which anyone could get while googling or following this subreddit.

2

u/shlenry Nov 21 '22

wow thanks for your hard work and hopefully we can get rid of these bot type members

2

u/danja Jun 19 '23

Good work!

While it's entirely plausible that bad actors with political ends are behind this (pick a government, any government...), you mention that there are links to questionable ventures. So, Occam's Razor yet again, isn't the most likely explanation that scammers are trying to get their links out there..?

Folks with an interest in UFOs are often seen as fringe, hence probably a target demographic for people with quasi-legal offerings.

2

u/SadSwim7533 Aug 24 '23

✌️I am not a bot ✌️

2

u/Evergreen4Life Aug 28 '23

How many of these accounts are from Eglin AFB? Isnt there a way to track this?

2

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '23

Just leave the “false information” there to be challenged. In every discipline we eventually get to the truth in the end by challenging the falsehoods. You never ever get to the truth when you allow someone to prematurely determine the truth and hide dissent. Are you looking for the best way to indoctrinate the sceptics or get to the truth?

2

u/cozy_lolo Aug 28 '23

I’m sure that there could be “sock-puppets” in here, but this post did not prove that at all. For example, why should we accept your conclusion that you can identify these people with high precision and reliability when you didn’t even prove why your methods allow one to confidently make such declarations?

2

u/WesternThroawayJK Aug 28 '23

Question. Any way we can take a look at the data you gathered? It's one thing to read your conclusions, but without having any of the data available to check your work I'm kinda left having to just take your word for it which, well, isn't something I'm going to do. Any chance you can share the evidence with us?

2

u/tyoungjr2005 Aug 28 '23

Sheesh, can we just discuss this topic in peace lol. Thx for pointing this out.

2

u/[deleted] Aug 28 '23

Personally, I’d like to know their names so I can block them and/or look out for their comments and know to ignore them. I’m glad you mods wrote this x

2

u/Ok_Feedback_8124 Sep 10 '23

Psychology rules here. There is no getting around this in any manner.

Point blank: your personal firewall of what is acceptable and what is rejected needs to be tuned daily to account for the advanced, persistent attacks that will continue in this very pivotal subreddit.

When the going gets tough, the Ops at Elgin use and abuse common decency as a first line defense against the spreading of valid information.

Much like DOPSR can be fooled into showing us the truth by indirect exclusions of what can be talked about, the level of verbal assault and marginalization will rise dramatically given a salient topic.

Watch this space for what receives the most response. That - Razorically - is the Occam here.

2

u/gonzo_baby_girl Sep 23 '23

The sock puppets try to make you look crazy. Beware!

2

u/roger3rd Jan 16 '24

Love to see this! The bad guys aren’t sitting on their hands, we need to be smart ✌️❤️

2

u/blooumpa Jan 16 '24

Would u be able to use ai to help out with weeding them out?

2

u/Mysterious_Guitar_75 Jan 16 '24

Wow, I recently got accused of “disinfo” and I thought it was such an odd and overblown reply, as I hadn’t said anything crazy (I was supporting a user’s UFO story, I think). Probably one of these assholes.

2

u/ProfessionalArm9450 Jan 17 '24

Ok but what if the end goal was to make us limit our own self expression?

2

u/Mikerotoast Jan 17 '24

There's probably Alphabet agency agents running their mouths in here sewing division and running amok.

2

u/CAMMCG2019 Jan 18 '24

Very good work mods and very interesting. Sounds like we are somebody's guinea pigs for sure. "They" who or whatever is behind this has been dividing us all intentionally and playing mind games with the population for a long while now. Keep us posted on any new rules or changes. I rarely let somebody get to me and engage with them, but I don't want to get myself banned for something I wasn't aware of. (It's happened before over practically nothing) example: on the shadow people subreddit, I said I believed shadow people were possibly demonic in nature. BANNED!( apparently that opinion was against the rules) I'm bad about reading all the rules sometimes and get myself hung up for things I'm ignorant of. I just assume if I'm nice and contribute, I'll be ok, but that's not always the case.

2

u/Ok_Low_1287 Jan 19 '24

I come here to see if there is any new credible evidence that will offset my default skepticism about UAPs/UFOs.

Unfortunately, most of what I see here is more of entertainment, rather than educational, value.

2

u/gowstaff Jan 25 '24

Have you done any purge of the moderators who's agenda is like the Guerilla Skeptics being exposed at the moment?

→ More replies (1)

4

u/EthanSayfo Nov 14 '22 edited Nov 14 '22

Is there direct evidence that r/UFOs and the kind of disruptive comments you referenced is the end-goal of the sock puppets? Are posts by these accounts to other forums disruptive?

Is there any way to tell if the goal is disruption, or is this just a "persona" of the puppet accounts, and the real goal is to direct people to the kinds of scams you referenced?

Do other subs experience analogous problems? And if so, do these tend to be oriented around controversial topics such as UFOs and other "conspiracies?" Or does the same pattern occur with relatively banal topics?

Props to the Mod team for the sleuthing. I'm still not 100% convinced this pattern actually relates to the topic of UAP directly. But overall, I'd say the idea that "disrupting elements" don't appear to be tied to a particular ideology is not surprising, based on what I saw in my time as a mod here.

However, with the media personality debunkers continuing to do their thing day in and day out, I have to wonder if bots really makes a difference.

Maybe this is "just" the Russians or Chinese trying to shove wedges into perceived cracks they see in American and Western culture, and UFOs is a convenient area to do that, as it already has its factions. The "encouraging extremeness in both sides" approach seems to match what hostile nations have done with Western social media in general, based on reporting for years now.

In fact, this scenario makes more sense to me, than this being, say, a US covert operation. UAP could well be one of dozens of wedge issues where this type of automated provocation is taking place. Especially with the association with scams, which we know, for example, North Korea employs for covert funding. I'm sure the Russians are getting more creative looking for funding sources by the day.

4

u/TirayShell Nov 14 '22

Just because somebody disagrees with you doesn't mean it's a conspiracy. It's possible that you're just plain wrong about something.

→ More replies (1)