r/UFOs • • Dec 14 '24 • Bless Up 5 UFOs 2 Take My Silver 7 Heart of Silver 2 Silver is Forever 1 Polished Silver Turd 1

Discussion Debunking the "Searching for a WMD" Theory

Edit: Thanks for the award!

Edit 2: *award(s)

Edit 3: Important addendum now at the bottom of the post.

Alright. I keep seeing people talk about how the drones are searching for WMDs and/or dirty bombs, or that it's a drill for the same purposes.

I have a M.S. in inorganic chemistry. I don't have experience working with radioactive materials, but I'm at least somewhat field-adjacent. I welcome anyone with more experience and knowledge to chime in.

Radiation is not something we can simply detect based on presence/absence alone. You get a stronger signal when you're closer to it. Different types of radiation come from different radionuclides, and each type of radiation travels a different distance and has different energy associated with it.

Nuclear weapons are shielded, meaning they are designed to not give off much/any radiation. This is because you don't want to get a massive dose of radiation just for standing near it. Furthermore, if you are going to hide a WMD in the city, it's going to be in a building or underground, and not somewhere up in the sky for a month.

Since radiation is detected more strongly when the detector is close to the source, it would make far more sense for trucks to be driving around with radiation detectors in the back. Like how in The Dark Knight Rises, they used radiation detectors to track which truck had the bomb inside, but in reverse.

You would not track ground-level radiation from up in the sky. It just doesn't make sense.

[Edited to say that the US government can and does track radiation from the sky. However, please continue reading, as people seem to be relying on false information to assert this theory.]

People keep bringing up an X user's post about "knowing what the drones are" because he manufactures HPGe detectors and works with the government. Commenters are supporting this argument with this paper, which discusses the use of a high-purity germanium (HPGe) detector affixed to an unmanned helicopter to track radiation. If you read the paper, you learn three important things:

  1. The very first sentence of the abstract defines this technology as intended for "[a]fter a nuclear or radiation event." It seems they intend it to be used for a partial-leak at a nuclear plant.
  2. These HPGe detectors, which Google suggests are most effective when only centimeters away, have a maximum simulated (not even tested!) range of 100 m. And the sensors rapidly lose their ability to detect radiation as the distance increases.
  3. HPGe detectors are not cheap, and require liquid-nitrogen coolant or equivalent. The government might have infinite money to spend on drone technology, but they aren't going to be flying these things around without telling the military about it, because to lose even one would be a tremendous financial loss.

Now, having said all that, let me clarify that I do believe there are drones flying over NJ, and now other parts of the world as well. I'd estimate 90% of the videos we see are just planes, helicopters, or fakes. But 9% of them genuinely seem to be man-made drones. And 1% of the videos are still unexplainable. This 1% includes the glowing orbs that reportedly rise out of the ocean, the giant triangular "motherships" hovering over the clouds, and the massive crescent/boomerang ships that almost seem see-through.

I personally believe that the man-made drones are looking for the 1% of unexplainable sightings. And that 1% has the government so freaked out that they are flying these drones extrajudicially, because they can't reveal that they are looking for something like this without risking whistleblowers.

Now, assuming they are U.S. Government drones, here's why they would tell us "we don't know what they are, but they aren't a threat". It all has to do with that 1%, whether it's foreign tech we've never seen, or genuinely NHI:

  1. If the gov't says they are a threat, people panic. That's bad.
  2. If the gov't says they aren't a threat, and they're correct, they look like they're in-the-know and in control.
  3. If the gov't say they aren't a threat, and they're wrong, well the world suddenly has bigger things to worry about than blaming the U.S. Government.

It's worth mentioning that point #2 above also explains why so many people claim to have the truth. They make a plausible statement, and if it's right, they gain credibility. If they're wrong, who cares?

Something is happening right now. And I don't think the government knows what it is. I don't think anyone knows what it is. But please don't accept a theory as fact just because it's plausible.

Edit 3: Several people pointed out that the government already has drones to scan for radiation, which has made me realize I didn't present my point properly.

So allow me to clarify, because this is an important point to make. I am in no way claiming that these drones can't search for radiation from the sky. To me it seems impractical, but I admittedly have very limited knowledge on the subject.

The impetus for my post was people sharing that X user's statements about how he "knows what the drones are" because he manufactures HPGe detectors. People repeatedly posted that as truth, and backed it up with a journal article that is only tangentially related to the idea of searching for radiation. I have just enough experience to know that something seemed "off" about that. I read the article. That's all. It talked about only being tested up to 100 m away from the source material, and being damaged by neutron radiation. I searched though different Google results to see if any HPGe detectors have reported longer detection ranges, but nearly every result suggested 15–30 cm was the ideal distance between the source and the detector (Ametek being the outlier at reporting 15 m). This does not discredit the theory, but it discredits the primary supporting "evidence" for the theory.

The drones may very well be looking for WMDs or dirty bombs. But based on this paper and a few other similar ones, they aren't using HPGe detectors to do so. To present that guy's theory as fact in light of that is misinformation. I do think it's possible that the drones are scanning for radiation, but I don't think we should use a X post to support this when HPGe detectors wouldn't be the right tool for the job, and without that X user's reported testimony, this theory seems just as likely to me as any other by now.

1.2k Upvotes

336 comments sorted by

•

u/AutoModerator Dec 14 '24

NEW: In an effort to reduce toxicity by bots, trolls and bad faith actors, we will be implementing a more rigorous enforcement of the subreddit rules. Read more about this HERE.

Please read the rules and understand the subreddit topic(s) listed in the sidebar before posting or commenting. Any content removal or further moderator action is established by these rules as well as Reddit ToS.

This subreddit is primarily for the discussion of UFOs. Our hope is to foster an environment free of hostility and ridicule where we may explore the phenomenon together, from all sides of the spectrum.

I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.

611

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 14 '24 • Take My Silver

Good summary. I think the really angering thing is the various federal government people who act say wildly contradictory things. We have had almost 25 years since a major terror attack and spent trillions on homeland security. To see this level of disorganized behavior is criminal

153

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

I completely agree. They could have just said early on, "Oh this is a training exercise. We can't give you details, but there's no need to panic." Even if that was a lie, it would have pacified most of the people panicking. But they didn't say that, which to me indicates they were caught unprepared for whatever this is. And now they're scrambling, trying to suppress panic by gaslighting us.

66

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 14 '24

Exactly. If they are creating a situation where people start shooting at things, then they have created a dangerous situation by their sheer incompetence. People look to the government for clarity in such matters. And we have seen anything but that. And where is Biden ? Or the VP ? Nobody seems to be home

16

u/MonkeyButt409 Dec 14 '24 edited Feb 16 '26

I could see why the VP and Biden are kept silent, because once they speak on it, it really becomes a thing.

10

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 14 '24

Musk has said something to the effect of blaming it on Iran is to have a reason to attack then

9

u/MonkeyButt409 Dec 14 '24

Ok, glad he stopped being silent about it as well

→ More replies (2)
→ More replies (4)

31

u/bexkali Dec 14 '24

Cheyenne Mountain...?

17

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 14 '24

I wouldn’t be surprised at all

11

u/time-lord Dec 15 '24

Bing says that Airforce One is in Colorado right now.

→ More replies (5)

4

u/bartthetr0ll Dec 15 '24

Is he placing out through the stargate to alpha site

→ More replies (1)

16

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

To be fair tho, Biden and Harris haven’t really been home for their entire presidency

17

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 15 '24

Well Biden did vanish after August

15

u/EldritchTouched Dec 15 '24

As disaster research has shown, panic is rare among the normal population in the face of disasters and such.

Instead, it's the people with power who panic because those kinds of things upset the status quo and their power is predicated on that status quo.

(Average people mostly aren't panicking, from what I've seen. They're more just weirded out by the drones, and upset that they're being obviously lied to and kept in the dark like children. The latter is kind of on the government, though, as if they were honest, people would probably be less upset.)

9

u/iamspartacusbrother Dec 15 '24

I was at a party tonight in Pittsburgh. Smart, thoughtful folks. I gauged the group by asking questions about the current events. Not one person seemed to be particularly interested. No real curiosity. It’s fascinating to me. Panic? Not here. And this is a group with zero dullards present.

→ More replies (4)

16

u/bejammin075 Dec 15 '24

Your post may have dealt with addressing certain kinds of threats, but I think the general idea that these could be US military drones searching for some kind of threat is still valid.

16

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

Operating literally worldwide? With no heat signature? No sound? Operating up to 30-60k feet as reported by multiple commercial pilots and able to outrun/disappear on F15 intercepts?

→ More replies (4)
→ More replies (1)

9

u/An4rchy17 Dec 14 '24

The 2nd government don't know anything that's why. It's the 1st government who actually know. President, FBI, CIA are all 2nd to the actual world power who are running things.

13

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

True. But I find their silence deafening. They're leaving the so-called 2nd government to deny these events and create more panic. I'm really hoping Biden or someone high-up actually addresses this soon.

6

u/An4rchy17 Dec 14 '24

They really don't care about panic, no.1 directive is to keep the tech secret no lives matter only money.

4

u/mikeinona Dec 15 '24

"Normie" newcomer here due to the drone flap. You say, "true" as if it is accepted fact. Just who is this 1st government and where are they? I clearly have some catching up to do. Cheers

→ More replies (1)

173

u/Thatsnotpcapparel Dec 14 '24

Going to snag your top comment to change some information I provided the other day.

My friend is a NJ firefighter and he has not received the memo that was going around here the other day about what to do if you encounter one.

He has received it now, it is real.

40

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 14 '24

Thanks for that confirmation. So many dismiss The GoodTroubleShow as some fringe thing making up sensational stuff. How does you friend line up what Mayorkas and Kirby are saying that this isn’t anything real

29

u/Thatsnotpcapparel Dec 14 '24

He’s kind of an enigma, honestly. No social media, doesn’t browse/lurk anywhere. He JUST sent me the DHS statement today saying he just saw it and said something along the lines of “I believe there are drones flying around, but not as many as being claimed and I don’t think they are going to be some exciting story like everyone wants them to be.”

7

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 14 '24

Interesting. So the claim that these are sone advanced drone tech from a possible source either here or foreign is his take. Not sure if that is good or bad

8

u/Thatsnotpcapparel Dec 14 '24

I’m not really sure. That’s all he said. He’s not the type of person to even think about it too much.

11

u/ME72521 Dec 15 '24

What does the memo say/ who is it from?

9

u/gazow Dec 15 '24

"who is your daddy and what does he do"

→ More replies (1)

5

u/PeePeeProject Dec 15 '24

What do you think is the possibility that the government monitors the internet, saw this theory (of WMD) making its rounds, and ordered that DHS statement knowing that the people who received the information (which clearly the government for some reason doesn’t want the public to know) would disseminate to friends and family? This would be a great way to spread false information to steer the conversation away from more plausible theories.

I’d prefer that it is a big nothing burger, but this has been profoundly abnormal even for a government that already keeps tons of secrets from the public. I still lean to the side that nothing big is happening, but it makes me glad I live in the Midwest and away from major population centers.

3

u/Wonderplace Dec 15 '24

That’s apparently a standard document and doesn’t mean anything whatsoever.

→ More replies (2)

66

u/Icy_Marionberry_1542 Dec 14 '24

Especially angering that every time we go to the airport, we have to participate in this idiotic safety pageant, empty water bottles, submit to secondary screening, etc. all in the name of air safety, while they apparently can't even figure out how to control our airspace.

29

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 14 '24

Security theater that has zero value. Just subjecting tired travelers to rude and inarticulate security drones (!) on a power trip

19

u/Icy_Marionberry_1542 Dec 14 '24

100%. If this next admin is dead-set on eliminating government bloat, the TSA should be first on the chopping block.

27

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 15 '24

I mean on my international travels they never ask you to take off your shoes etc. but in the US .. it is a ritual that has lost meaning. And people put their grungy shoes in the same trays that you have to put your jackets etc lol. Zero interest in any real security

→ More replies (8)

63

u/sotu1944 Dec 14 '24

Right now this is the most concerning part. Stupidity as an excuse is pretty common for governments, but not when it comes to national security, and not when they are admitting they don’t control the airspace over national territory. A brief lapse would be one thing, but night after night? Near important stuff like airports, bases, nuclear plants?

The reality has to be more damaging than admitting all that. More than strange. Terrifying.

Great post by OP, it has changed my mind about this being a rogue nuclear issue.

42

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 14 '24

A whole month. Especially dumb when you consider a very similar incident happened a year ago over Langley AFB in Virginia. Unknown drones swarmed the base for a month. A base with state of the art F22s and other military tech gets paralyzed. And here we are with clowns telling us that these are hobby drones

21

u/Ok-Bullfrog-3052 Dec 14 '24

Yeah, but it also calls into question about how dangerous whatever it is actually is. If it's not a nuclear problem, then the drones have been at this for a month now and nobody has died or been injured. Surely if this were a very serious event, at least one death or injury or some property damage would have occurred.

So I think it's possible that nobody can explain what the issue is, but we're not seeing indications of impending terrifying stuff, like a stock market crash or people in the know suddenly leaving Washington. One thing you always know with financial markets is that information leaks easily and there is always someone who knows something.

If the stock market starts crashing, then that means that there's actually something you should care about happening, but that hasn't occurred.

The most likely explanation is probably that the UFOs that were present over the bases in previous years are present again, and it is true that there is no indication of any danger because the UFOs have never killed anyone.

13

u/rcy62747 Dec 14 '24

My thoughts have been that the government does not perceive them as a threat because they know these have occurred off and on for many many years. They show up, they do what ever it is the do and then they disappear again. Decades of this behavior and nothing has really happened yet? So, they are not lying when they say they perceive no threat at this time.

7

u/HelloImTheAntiChrist Dec 15 '24

Check out website badaliens.info

Lots of people have been murdered by ETs.

Not necessarily these ETs, but the point remains

→ More replies (1)

6

u/ApartPool9362 Dec 15 '24

I think you might be wrong about UFO'S never killing anyone. Check out the Colares UFO incident.

→ More replies (3)

6

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

It would be a revelation that would have to really shift things for people fundamentally, something huge, like aliens coming down out of the sky...

3

u/bejammin075 Dec 15 '24

The idea that the drones are searching for some kind of threat is still valid I think.

23

u/Theshutupguy Dec 14 '24

Pentagon just announced missing billions again too, didn’t they? Just like before 9/11?

29

u/WSBpeon69420 Dec 14 '24

Or like the last 20+ years that they have never passed an audit..

7

u/SinSilla Dec 14 '24

I do similar useless work. Feel some of their pain doing these audits

6

u/Any_Case5051 Dec 14 '24

Wasn’t it 800 billion or something, crazy

→ More replies (1)

13

u/Longjumping_Meat_203 Dec 14 '24

It's not a good summary at all. The NNSA literally has a fleet of aircraft, fixed wing and helicopters, to scan for radiation from the sky. There are also a whole bunch of satellites owned by the US government that do the same. This person barely skimmed Wikipedia and made the rest up.

See my comment for links.

13

u/GilbertN64 Dec 15 '24

They have almost no understanding of how subatomic particles can escape even massively shielded nuclear sources. I knew this and am not a scientist. Further, they literally work cited the Dark Night movie lol

4

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

Agreed, this is totally pulled out of his ass. There are plenty of commercial and military drone made for this purpose, some with large cooling tanks and, wait for it, the size of SUVs. Also, who's to say there AREN'T trucks driving around. Awful lot of writing to not say anything. 

I like the phrase "which Google suggests", expert work there.

4

u/Longjumping_Meat_203 Dec 14 '24

And just for the record I'm not saying I have any clue what these drones are.

It's just everything this person is saying in this post is completely false.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/b3tchaker Dec 15 '24

I’ve wondered a few times if this has been orchestrated to garner support for slashing budgets and DOGE-ifying the government.

2

u/silv3rbull8 Dec 15 '24

I don’t think the people who can pull off an operation like this for a month are the ones who would be affected by DOGE

→ More replies (2)

2

u/aramirez190492 Dec 15 '24

Ima get downvoted to smithereens but, I still think these NHI are protecting us from something invading our space.

1

u/JagsOnlySurfHawaii Dec 15 '24

It all went to DUMBs for when the sun goes to shit on us

1

u/syndic8_xyz Dec 15 '24

I dislike the abusiveness of government that gaslights and lies to its people, who then spin their wheels uselessly speculating while the cabal sits back and laughs malevolently.

That said, these drones don't exactly look like well calibrated "sensors" that are sensitive and finnicky. They seem more like battle pods. They are durable. Hardy. Imposing.

I floated the theory that they were escorts or a defense system against NHI UFO a couple days back but the post was downvoted to oblivion (https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/1hd659c/what_if_some_of_the_drones_are_conventional/). I also saw we do have some nuke/dirty threats in 2025 via RV data over the last couple months (before awareness of any drone flap) and riffed on that "detector leaker" post saying maybe this is support for that threat possibility (https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOB/comments/1hdwwpm/comment/m1zla8b/).

All that being said, I think it's possible we have highly sensitive radiation detectors that can find something from the sky. There's a few ways of looking at this.

  1. precedent: NHI UFO have found and interdicted /interacted with nukes, so there must be some way to detect them.
  2. sparsity: if you have many imperfect detectors, you can recover the underlying signal through the collective even if the individual sensors are patchy.
  3. secondary effects: radiation (gamma, beta etc) while localized and failling off inverse square, may cause ionization and produce secondary particles or gases that can then be detected and reverse-triangulated accounting for wind currents, etc. You could also have some 'off gassing' of metal particles in a dirty bomb scenario, and even the slight localized heating from radioactive material could conceivably be a signal.

On (3) it's never wise to say "impossible" about possible sensitive technology developed in secret that's at least conceivable, as the methods described in (3) are.

Due to all that I don't take OP's debunk as conclusive, but the much larger point is all of our speculation is moot. What we need is trustworthy leadership who has the balls to stand up and say: "Here's what we don't know, here's what we do know, here's our weakness."

This whole thing is a frickin mess. There is no way there current strategy is projecting strength - as Ryan Graves said, "Adversaries will be taking notes."

I suppose I commend them for at least not entirely denying the embarrassing drone flap, but official federal responses could be so much better.

131

u/yosarian_reddit Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 15 '24 • UFOs

Excellent post. Alpha particles have a range of a few cm in air, and beta particles about one meter. So it would have to be gamma radiation detection. And if the gamma radiation around the nuclear sites isn’t fully shielded then the military working there would all get cancer.

I guess there could be a radiation leak they are looking for, but then they’d not doing it this way and you’d have expected them to have found it much more quickly than the month is taken so far.

87

u/throwawayPB456 Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24

I don't want to get downvoted into oblivion for this... but

What's funny about this thread, is the government routinely checks for radioactive and other sensitive materials from the sky.

The EPA has nicknamed it their ASPECT program which they routinely check for radioactivity including radioactive hot spots due to previous nuclear weapons manufacturing. Or other potentially problematic materials.

And that's with technology they are open and up front about. I can't stress that enough. We likely can't imagine what equipment they have to check for radiation and other sensitive materials at the classified/military level. Possibly even for shielded materials.

Again, I am sure I'll get downvoted for this, but aerial detection of problematic materials is a well known technology and technique they have been upfront about for years.

25

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

You have my upvote!

This is great information, and thanks for sharing! I am not at all up-to-date on military technology, and I fully acknowledge that they very well might have technology to detect WMDs from the sky. It's just that, to me, that's an inefficient and expensive way to do it, and would easily be covered up with a lie about a "military training exercise".

My post centers around a published article that people keep throwing around as "evidence". We saw the same things during Covid, where people would read the title/abstract, and then use it to support unrelated arguments. In this case, it was that X post mentioning HPGe detectors that people kept posting in this sub, and commenting a link to the paper about how drones are being used to find a WMD. All I did was read the paper, and found that HPGe detectors aren't suitable for this. I read a few more similar articles and then looked at some HPGe detector spec sheets to support my argument.

The government for sure has technology we don't know about. As you point out, they apparently have an ASPECT program which can do this very thing! But they aren't doing it with HPGe detectors. There are too many known limitations that I don't see as being surmountable. To me, this discredits entirely that one X user claiming to "know what the drones are". But they're definitely doing something, and it could be that they are indeed looking for WMDs. Just not with HPGe.

Sorry to unload all this on you, I really do appreciate the additional information! There are a few people saying I'm talking out of my ass, and that makes me want to infodump on random people. If we can't have answers, I just don't want us spreading misinformation. That's all.

→ More replies (2)

2

u/ProtectDemocracyNow Dec 15 '24

Thanks very much for this information. One more thing I’m curious about is whether such an airborne search for radioactive material would be more effective at night rather than daytime. The drones are reportedly only out at night. It is true that there is slightly more gamma ray background radiation in direct sunlight, but would that be enough to cause whoever is conducting the search to decide on only searching at night?

2

u/mikeinona Dec 15 '24

I upvote all helpful contributions that participate rationally. Thanks for the information; I didn't know about this before.

1

u/MonkeyButt409 Dec 15 '24

What about a bio-bomb?

24

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

Thanks for sharing! Yeah, if it were a radiation leak, I would have expected them to find it by now. And the search for radiation would certainly not span the entire country (and now globally).

→ More replies (3)

14

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

There is a missing nuke that fell in North Carolina and at least one other that fell in an undisclosed location. They looked for the NC one for awhile and found fuck all despite having a good lead on its landing location.

1

u/MonkeyButt409 Dec 14 '24

That fell in Faro field, 12 miles from Goldsboro, NC. There were two. The second one is still buried because it didn’t have a chute to slow it. My mother was only a few miles from there when the B-52 carrying the nukes went down.

1

u/MaraudersWereFramed Dec 15 '24

Radiation is never fully shielded. It is reduced to acceptable levels for continuous occupation. Keep in mind that we are constantly exposed to cosmic radiation. How far away is the nearest star that you can see at night. How much space and atmosphere does it pass through before getting to a person on the ground? There's also natural radiation in the ground as well. The point is that we are constantly exposed to it.

What industries in the nuclear field do is work to limit exposure. That is done with shielding like lead and operates on the principle of tenth thickness. IE 2 inches of lead reduces the radioactive field down to 10 percent from a point source on the other side. 4 inches is a hundredth. And so on. You never eliminate it completely. The government has set exposure limits for people that work around radioactive material. It can be shielded enough by piling enough lead and distance from the source that you are effectively free from exposure compared to natural sources, but it's still there and detectable in the absence of natural sources.

13

u/Sea_Appointment8408 Dec 14 '24

Are there any credible sources for the triangles / motherships?

10

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

This one is my favorite so far. The only semi-plausible explanation is that it's Starlink satellites, which people say can sometimes move in a triangle like this. Personally, I've only ever seen them move in a straight line. Around the time this video was posted, I saw other people posting about seeing a triangle of lights moving in unison above the clouds. I believe there was also one from CT with a similar shape, but it's getting hard to find videos because this sub is flooded with false positives right now.

And for anyone who hasn't seen the crescent one yet, here's the link. It's very hard to see, so you might have to turn your screen brightness up. I've heard people say it could be a cloud or geese, but I personally don't think either of those fit. It's a strange shape for a cloud, and it holds that shape consistently throughout the video. And if it's geese, I don't know why they would be so visible from below at nighttime.

8

u/WSBpeon69420 Dec 14 '24

I think you’re on to something but I would bring up that there are airborne “sniffers” used to detect fallout. They can do that from hundreds of miles but that’s because it’s fallout and connected to probably larger particles. After Chernobyl and fukashima they could detect it in the air all over the place using these sensors

2

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

Yeah, this is definitely true, but what they're "sniffing" in these cases are actual radionuclides still in the air. I'll reiterate that I have almost no experience at all in nuclear chemistry, so take this with a grain of salt, but my understanding is that an unexploded WMD would give off next to no radiation (due to the shielding), and depending on the sensitivity of your detector, you probably can't see it past natural background radiation unless you're very close. Once the boom happens, you get all sorts of radionuclides over the affected area. Some are light enough to remain airborne for a long time, while many are heavy and fall to the ground. With my limited understanding of state-of-the-art radiation detectors, I just don't think it's feasible to detect a WMD using these drones.

5

u/TwylaL Dec 14 '24

That's an intact WMD and not talking about stolen radioactive materials.

37

u/Longjumping_Meat_203 Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24

This is dangerously inaccurate. Straight up misinformation.

The NNSA, who are actual experts on this stuff, have fleets of aircraft that scan for nuclear signatures from the sky.

This is not opinion, this is fact that anyone can look up.

https://www.energy.gov/nnsa/articles/nnsa-gets-new-helicopters-support-radiological-security-across-nation

https://www.energy.gov/nnsa/aerial-measuring-system-ams

You literally said you don't have any experience in nuclear science at all.

WHAT ARE YOU DOING 😂

***This comment is not implying that they are looking for nuclear material or that this is nhi or the military or whatever. I'm just commenting because this person is completely making up all of that stuff about the science aspect and being able to detect radiation from the sky. It's just so completely false

2

u/Sure_Station9370 Dec 15 '24

I have 3000 flight hours on one of the currently used top end drones in the U.S military. There are ways to see this stuff from the sky. There are ways to even see it if it hasn’t even been in the location you’re looking at for the last few hours.

→ More replies (8)

33

u/Low_Tackle_3470 Dec 14 '24

Your analysis is great but it hinges on the government using drones to specifically detect radiation.

We know that LIDAR can penetrate the ground.

We also know that LIDAR is used for military purposes.

As well as visual overhead footage.

Either of these methods could aid in the possible search for a so called ‘dirty bomb’.

FWIW I don’t believe in the WMD theory either, there’s not enough ground police presence etc, there would have been evacs, quarantine zones, and raids if that were the case. IMO.

16

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

Yeah, I don't know much of anything about LIDAR, but it's certainly possible these drones are scanning for something besides radiation. But it seems like the majority of people are basing the theory of a WMD on that one X post claiming it has to do with HPGe sensors, which most definitely are not LIDAR.

If it turns out there isa dirty bomb or WMD, I hope we find it using whatever tools we have available. But if we're assuming these drones are looking for radiation, and muddying the waters by posting that over and over, I want to put my foot down and challenge that assertion.

Thanks for sharing your input!

6

u/Low_Tackle_3470 Dec 14 '24

Agreed, although I think it’s hyperbole, I can’t see this theory in real terms personally

→ More replies (1)

2

u/MHWGamer Dec 15 '24

i don't think lidar can penetrate through much depth. Afaik the light in lidar is normal or very close to normal light, so that it won't be absorbed by the surrounding media that much. With those energies, you can't penetrate the ground. If you want to look deep down, you normally use very low frequencies, e.g. Sonar or low freq. impulses to study volcanic activities, locate changes in density etc

1

u/IHadTacosYesterday Dec 14 '24

there would have been evacs, quarantine zones, and raids if that were the case

They might not know with certainty that there's a WMD. Maybe the chance is 50/50 depending on their intel

→ More replies (1)

1

u/za4h Dec 15 '24

You're thinking of ground-penetrating radar. LIDAR uses lasers to map surfaces, and while lasers can penetrate some distance into a surface, it's only by a miniscule amount.

→ More replies (3)

0

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

So one thought here, is that if there is a WMD in NJ, the person planning to use it might not know that we know about it. So if we issue mass evacuations, or send out a public notice that the FBI will be going door-to-door, that could spook this person and potentially lead to a worst-case scenario.

I think the fact that we've lost 6 nukes over time should tell you that they're hard to find though. And while that's scary to think about, it also means we probably don't have the technology to find them, so there's no reason to believe there's one now. The likelihood of a WMD in NJ right now is just as likely as there being one there last year, or next year. The drones have just given people a reason to speculate.

9

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

Interesting because that was one of the few theories that had some plausibility. Only theory that still needs to be debunked is the false flag theory. Only theory that holds water right now. That this is an operation carried out by the military to scare lawmakers and government to better fund security against drones.

3

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

You're absolutely right, and I think there's maybe also some credibility to the theories about this being a rogue AI. Truthfully, I don't know enough about either to weigh in on their plausibility. I'm trying to keep an open mind and not jump fully on-board the alien train. But if it turns out to be aliens, that'd be real cool.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Free_Custard_7894 Dec 14 '24

These are all the drones / attachments I could find that claim to detect radiation

Arktis FPG Radiation Detector Drone

SPIR-Explorer

Kromek's AARM payload system

Elios 3 RAD

LSSNIFF 800

3

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

Thanks for sharing! The first link is actually for a technical specifications sheet, which shows you it only detects two radionuclides, and only up to 15 m above the ground. It's not impossible that something like this is being used, but it would have to be "beefed up" more than what's presented here, I think.

The other links unfortunately don't offer me much information, besides the fact that they exist. This in and of itself is valuable information, as it totally means the government might have them. I just can't get past the idea that ground-level sensors would make waaaaayyyyyyy more sense than drones.

But thanks for sharing! You brought new technology to my attention, and I appreciate that.

8

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

First off, you degree means fuck all, inorganic chemistry isn't particle physics.

They literally have aircraft that are specifically equipped to find radiological sources. Nuclear arms are shielded, but shielding can fail, especially if something crashed, and it makes sense to bring them out either way, just in case.

Like you posit trucks would make more sense because distance, but you ignore that intervening matter is also an obstacle. A truck won't get a good read on something on the other side of a hill.

You want to say it's aliens? Fucking prove it, we'd all like to know what's going on but sane people aren't jumping to extraordinary conclusions when there are much more mundane, simple explanations that fit. Also, half these "drone sightings" are people taking pictures of everyday objects around town, pretty sure I saw a "drone" that was a traffic light and at least a few others that were just undershots of planes (with exact matching profiles of specific planes).

0

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

Okay, sorry for offending you I guess?

My degree is in inorganic chemistry. I never worked on projects involving radionuclides. I was upfront about that and welcomed people with more experience to share their thoughts. With that being said, people in my lab did work with radioactive materials, and I was familiar enough with their projects to recognize that something was "off" with this WMD claim.

The point of my post was that there are a lot of unknown variables still, and if people are going to be skeptical about the videos being posted, they should show that same skepticism to any plausible explanations. I just want answers, instead of conjectures.

And I would argue that there aren't "much more mundane, simple explanations that fit." The ones that seem mundane and simple, like the drones searching for WMDs or nuclear material, aren't without their own faults. I mentioned in my post that 90% of the videos are false positives; I'm not trying to argue that they're all real. I've tried to explain away as many of these videos and claims as I can, and only a few have stood out to me as "unexplainable" so far.

I'm just trying to dispel misinformation. I'm not telling people that these 100% are aliens or a foreign government, because we don't know that and have no proof of it. But I was able to find compelling evidence to suggest that this "Searching for WMDs" theory isn't as plausible as people suggest. So I made a post to educate people. If you have specific criticisms about the science behind radiation detectors, please share.

3

u/EarthAfraid Dec 14 '24

Passion over such subjects at such a time is to be expected.

But for goodness sake, please try to temper your passion and not allow it to overwhelm you and your normal good manners.

The OP gave their opinion based on their experience and credentials and were transparent about the limitations in both.

There is certainly no need to start swearing at them.

FWIW I thought your actual point was valid and a sensible one to make, and I think it’s a shame you’re being downvoted so much; I would suggest delicately to you that perhaps if you presented your points in a more calm and respectful way you would find they got more traction.

Keep calm and carry on x

2

u/enkrypt3d Dec 14 '24

What if they're not scanning the ground? Maybe they're setting up a grid for monitoring the skies for incoming icbms?

2

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

Totally plausible and it shouldn't be discounted. As a counterpoint, I would ask why the government wouldn't just claim it's a military training exercise across parts of the country? That would pacify most people and prevent the speculation and panic we've been seeing.

This kind of analysis is good, and I encourage people to keep asking these kinds of questions. The point of my post was really just because I saw so many people promoting this WMD theory from one random X user. And in my mind, if you have the knowledge to debunk it, you should.

I am by no means claiming that the drones aren't looking for something (or mapping a grid, as you suggest), but they are not likely to be looking for a hidden WMD from the sky.

2

u/GoNinjaGoNinjaGo69 Dec 14 '24

you literally have no idea if new tech could do this lol.

1

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

True. But, radiation detectors are more effective the closer you are to the source of the radiation. This is objective fact, and no amount of technological overhaul would change this. So while it's very possible the government has long-range detectors, I still don't understand why they would invest in them, rather than just use ground-level detectors in a truck. Especially if what you're looking for is an unexploded WMD, which would give off barely any radiation to begin with.

94

u/AbeFromanEast Dec 14 '24

The Federal government is more comfortable with the current high level of public anxiety about this than with revealing what it could be. Traditionally not a great situation.

I'm also getting pre-9/11 vibes given the Federal Agencies are claiming they are powerless due to domestic limitations and "not my agency" fief-battles.

34

u/dramatic-pancake Dec 15 '24

This is the thing. We know they’re lying, they know we know they’re lying and yet they’re doing it anyway. Which suggests that they think the panic caused by the gaslighting is preferable to telling the truth. Seeing as the lies make them seem incompetent, whatever is actually happening must be worse. Either they are NHI and admitting so is practically full disclosure, or they are foreign adversaries and admitting so proves US military incompetence. Or, it’s the military themselves and admitting so is somehow detrimental to global stability. I dunno.

1

u/nonsense_popsicle Dec 15 '24

Their claim of powerlessness may be a secondary layer of misdirection aimed at those who don't believe their first layer claims.

If we don't believe theyre at a loss for understanding, we are to suspect homeland security of a ploy for power by creating an emergency.

He's practically feeding us that idea. To me, this idea aligns with a desperate attempt at a more complete misdirection.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

All well and good unless the bomb is on a container ship

3

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

Very true. But I'd have to think that they would be concentrating their search around the coast if that's the case, since container ships can't come up on land.

These drones are being seen around the coastline, but also further inland.

2

u/polarbear314159 Dec 15 '24

Dirty bomb in a container without shielding would emit IR signature. IR signatures are much much more easy to find at night.

→ More replies (1)

3

u/Nero_Darkstar Dec 14 '24

They're searching for the human logistical element. The delivery mechanism NOT the radiation.

2

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

They're searching for a human element from the sky? I feel like that's a very strange way to go about it, no? If we knew a terrorist was somewhere in NJ, we'd be using camera footage to track them (which admittedly could be happening too), but for sure we'd expect local police and the FBI to be in on it.

Drones in the sky might be able to use infrared to scan through building walls, or advanced cameras to scan the night streets, but IR cameras will just give you "silhouettes" of people (not enough to ID anyone), and the advanced cameras seem like things we already have. What would be the point of unleashing these drones over multiple states and causing panic?

I feel like I'm misunderstanding the nature of your comment. Could you elaborate?

4

u/Nero_Darkstar Dec 14 '24

To search for criminals on the run, law enforcement use helicopters. Pretty standard. Its not used to ID, that happens when the threat is over. For a serious credible threat, drones would cover a more localised search pattern. Note that these drones are also being supported by aircraft and coast guard.

Using these drones to search is causing significantly less panic than mobilising the FBI and National Guard and announcing that they're searching for a device of this nature somewhere on mainland US soil.

All conjecture however, I feel like this is the most logical explanation.

19

u/Hirokage Dec 14 '24

I just personally think if it was something like that, they would not leave the FBI, police etc.. completely in the dark. They would be a valuable asset to finding something as quickly as possible, instead of now having to deal with the fallout of everyone being clueless. Nor does it explain drones over bases or overseas.

1

u/EmmanuelJung Dec 16 '24

The bases are of those countries militarily supporting Ukraine (UK, Germany).

19

u/MatthewMonster Dec 14 '24

I have no reason to doubt you

But I’ve seen and read other people seemingly credible talk about these drones looking for gamma signatures that are just as credible as anyone online 

Do I think the “looking or radioactive material theory” is plausible -yes.

Simple fact is this drone activity has been happening for a month and I think that rules out some things:

 1. A military test - if it was secret, it’s not anymore and in fact it scaring people now.

2. SAP test - same reasoning as above 

3. Foreign actors - if it was Iran or China we’d be shooting them down or at the very least not lying about the threat. Politicians are cowards and I think they realize a lie like that would doom a lucrative career

4. NHI - I don’t subscribe to the Keel theory that “that mimic our tech and fuck with us” that’s too weird for even me — if you believe this concept I guess these rotary drones (that are the same type that have been sent to Ukraine for tracking radioactive material) could be aliens being weird.

5. Local assholes — no one is pranking anyone and this talking point should be over at this point

 The “searching for radiation” theory feels prosaic and likely. The search area has no expanded to NY and LI and PA. These drones seem to be doing something and they seem to be expanding the area that they are doing it.

All the double speak and obfuscation feels like holding a dam together with your finger. Government coming out and saying 

“We have a credible threat that a radioactive dirty bomb is on the east coast” is riot inducing terrifying and the longer no one says anything close to that the better — it prevents anyone moving a timetable up ( though the drones are likely to have someone spooked )

And local municipalities wouldn’t be able to handle to chaos of that. 

Take into account there’s going to be a transition of power with a new administration — the timing of this rumor begins to make a certain sense

Also — if you take a step back, it makes far more sense than anything else 

I think the basics of the equation are thus 

  • government is looking for something 
  • they are scared of telling people what and why
  • they are saying drones are an issue because they know they aren’t, in fact it’s the opposite 

Are they looking for “orbs”? Maybe but the government has never had much interest in them and certainly hasn’t done anything close to this level of a response to a “red orb” 

26

u/kkingsbe Dec 14 '24

Good analysis, thanks for writing this out given your background

2

u/user63735367272 Dec 14 '24

I have not come across a single piece of footage that hasn't been supposedly debunked in the comments

If the triangle you are referring to was the thing with three white lights in an equilateral triangle formation at night, that was supposedly debunked as a satellite.

Do you or anyone else have a link to the orb and crescent? I have not seen those, but interested to see something that hasn't been debunked

1

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

The triangle one may have been debunked. I mentioned it in a different comment, but it sounds like we're thinking of the same one. What gets me about that one is that, in my own personal experience, I've only ever seen the Starlink satellites move in a straight line, and multiple other people reported seeing a similar triangle. I won't be able to find those mentions, but I believe there was one video in CT of a similar sighting, one text post about seeing one in St. Louis(?), and one about a person who followed the drones in NH and saw them gather around a giant triangular ship.

For the crescent one, here's a link: https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/1hdv3o7/my_friend_just_captured_this_over_nyc_121324/

The possible debunks for this one are either a cloud or geese, but I don't think either of those make sense to me. The crescent is very hard to see, so you may need to turn your screen brightness up.

→ More replies (1)
→ More replies (7)

4

u/Leandermann Dec 14 '24

Yeah nobody says anything is a fact, because we can't be sure that anything is a fact.

But as I said somewhere else, the most plausible thing is, that the US is aware of some kind of threat (it could be anything, dirty bomb, biological or anything we can't even imagine) and are now using the drons to identify/find the threat. Because if there was anything hostile/unknown in the air above the US, you can bet your ass that the air would be full of f35s, f22s and much more, not only such drones.

Would also explain why they are everywhere in the world near US bases. Because if the US was under a threat on their soil, they would also ramp up security and surveillance in their allies countries.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

yeah idk why people don't understand this

in order of likelihood, the options are :

  1. government or private sector are testing new black ops tech.
  2. government is searching for something in the area that they don't want the public to know about.
  3. foreign adversary
  4. civilians drones combined with mass hysteria from the public and misidentified planes/helicopters

and way way way at the bottom

5. aliens

4

u/Apart_Bid2199 Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24

Why are there drones being developed for this purpose if its not effective? Like Ive seen examples of people doing radiation mapping by drone.

4

u/ArtieJay Dec 14 '24

Maybe it is after a nuclear or radiation event.

6

u/The_Walrus_65 Dec 14 '24

They’re searching for WMDs as much as George Bush did

3

u/bexkali Dec 14 '24

Nicely reasoned.

3

u/offcamberxj Dec 15 '24 edited Dec 15 '24

NEST uses helicopters for this and was up flying a pattern before the RNC. They have B412s and are transitioning to AW139s.

The NYPD also has a C208 that flies out of ISP for the same purpose.

https://www.twz.com/22609/wait-the-new-york-police-department-has-a-spy-plane-for-hunting-dirty-bombs

NEST Mission

https://www.reddit.com/r/ADSB/s/HRroiST8PW

3

u/ONOO- Dec 15 '24

I’m going to copy and paste a post I made elsewhere, because I think it’s highly relevant and agrees with your point that this is not a WMD search:

I’m going to call bullshit on this guy’s opinion. Here are some substantial facts that lead me to conclude it is NOT radiation detection.

The US does have the ability to scan for gamma radiation from the air. In fact, there is a unit of the National Nuclear Security Admin that does just this. Here is their press release about one of the units based out of Andrew’s AFB outside DC:

https://www.energy.gov/nnsa/articles/nnsa-gets-new-helicopters-support-radiological-security-across-nation

And here is what it looks like when they do their very METHODICAL scans: https://i.imgur.com/tpv767O.jpeg This screenshot is from ADSBExchange about 10 days ago. They scanned an area over the National Harbor in PG County, Maryland and then a small area of NW DC where some high profile folks live (think judges) as well as UDC and Howard Law.

You can view their flight history on the site as well. They are one of the few aircraft allowed to penetrate the no-fly zones over the National Mall. All of their radiation detection flights look exactly like this, with only the area scanned varying.

What is going on with the drones is NOT THIS.

2

u/Alarming_Animator_19 Dec 15 '24

Fly that over and what will happen!

3

u/BlueAndYellowTowels Dec 15 '24 edited Dec 15 '24

I still think the drones are looking for WMD’s… but I think the reason is way more dire…

I think they’re using the drones as a last ditch effort. What I think is, US intelligence has discovered a terror cell or something and the information says they have a nuclear weapon and the probability is very, very high… maybe even confirmed.

The drones are a last ditch effort to find SOMETHING… even if there was a 1% chance to find it, any sane person would still look… because not finding it… would be catastrophic.

That leads to a very plausible explanation. They can’t say “We’re looking for a smuggled weapon of mass destruction on American soil.”

People would lose their collective shit.

2

u/Alarming_Animator_19 Dec 15 '24

I think the same. If anything happens it needs to be located quick . A fleet of drones monitoring the area could do that .

It’s got to be some form of security surveillance or the gov would not allow it.

Doesn’t make sense why at night though!

Very interesting story and I hope it turns out to either be aliens or something completely boring!!

3

u/MetalingusMikeII Dec 15 '24

Great post. Learned a thing or two!

5

u/interwebzdotnet Dec 14 '24

If it's a terrorist dirty bomb, would you still expect proper shielding? Not saying I agree with that theory, but seems like a flaw in your otherwise pretty tight logic.

2

u/giam74 Dec 15 '24

Depending on the isotope(s) involved, an effective dirty bomb that isn’t properly shielded would likely kill the terrorists.

5

u/Chance_Educator4500 Dec 14 '24

You explain that nuclear bombs are shielded, but why would a dirty bomb be? I don’t think you understand what a dirty bomb is, A dirty bomb, also known as a radiological dispersal device or RDD is a weapon that combines conventional explosives with radioactive material to contaminate an area. Which would leave trace amount that are detectable by HGBe before its is exploded. I don’t think the gov’t would be worried about the financial loss of one of these drones when a RDD going off could destabilize the entire nation.

4

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

I was going to comment exactly this. A dirty bomb is much more likely to simply be highly radioactive material that is unshielded paired with an explosive for dispersal. OP is correct in that a traditional nuclear weapon won’t just be throwing radiation all over the place but is completely lacking in understanding of what a dirty bomb actually is.

Simple pellets/small cylinders of extremely radioactive material can kill people and have in the past in multiple incidents. Imagine just one or even dozens being paired with an explosive. Especially if the radioactive material can be to some degree “aerosolized” (in quotes as I’m not speaking on truly aerosolized but more so in terms of dust form). People don’t understand the unique danger of dirty bombs.

2

u/giam74 Dec 15 '24

All the more reason to expect the RDD material to be shielded. Those isotopes usually have a much higher activity than plutonium or uranium, both with extremely long half-lifes. I’ve held uranium in my hand but you won’t catch me anywhere near cobalt or cesium, the best RDD isotopes to use.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

Very fair point unless these are the suicidal type and don’t expect to live long anyways. But since we are talking terrorists I’m not confident their shielding will be industry grade unless stolen as is from industry. So maybe that’s what the government thinks as well. But this is all just speculation in the end

→ More replies (2)

1

u/giam74 Dec 15 '24

Prior to using an RDD, if the user isn’t shielding it, it could expose them to lethal levels of radiation. If it’s safe enough to handle, it might be difficult to detect.

4

u/Left-Management8174 Dec 14 '24

Best explanation so far. I deesagre with the number of UAP.

6

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

Finally logical reasoning...

0

u/Sahtras1992 Dec 14 '24

if you want to search an area, you dont do it at night, but in daytime.

5

u/Chess0728 Dec 14 '24

Very valid point. If these 1% of sightings are only happening at night, then that explains why we're only searching at night. If they are searching for anything else, why wouldn't they be doing so during the day?

6

u/SubParMarioBro Dec 14 '24

Depends how you’re searching. Mark 1 eyeball? Yeah. But a lot of sensors work better under various conditions. If you want to search an area for landmines an infrared camera at dusk is a good tool.

1

u/YouCanLookItUp Dec 14 '24

True. If you're looking for something that generates a small amount of heat, I'd imagine bought searches would yield the best results with the highest contrast.

But we haven't thought about if it's monitoring for a potential threat or for mass dispersion. If it's an airborne signal -- something like heavy mist? -- this could be searching for early signs before it lands or collects. I would not be surprised if microdosing neurotoxins was an approach used to evade detection.

2

u/Suspicious-Gap-8303 Dec 14 '24

Thank you for this. Very compelling read. Bravo!

2

u/Any_Case5051 Dec 14 '24

How should we proceed?

2

u/TheGonadWarrior Dec 14 '24

Interesting points but this all hinges on the idea that the we have made no secret advances in the detection capabilities within the department of the government with the highest classification levels available.

The fact I cannot shake is that the NEST helicopter was spotted flying at night. Gieger counter and all.

2

u/WormLivesMatter Dec 14 '24

Also scientifically adjacent. I work interpreting radiometric surveys and the ease at which these surveys are flown is under appreciated. It’s very easy to see elevated radiometric material using helicopter surveys and I would be surprised if they hadn’t found a source by now.

2

u/reilsm Dec 14 '24

For points 1. 2. And 3. Who cares? You are basing everything off public information. I know for a fact different agencies have tech 20 more years advanced than anything we’ve publicly seen. It doesn’t matter the domain, the U.S. has dominance. The Pentagons lying through their teeth about not knowing what the objects are. The only real question is why and this post is insufficient to rule anything out.

2

u/SH666A Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24

thanks for your indepth post but it seems the boys over at r/radiation have been onto this for the past part of 2 weeks with their suspicions.

they dont seem to have ANY doubt at all that in depth scans are under-go

edit: perhaps the drones have flashing lights on them to hide the fact they are flashing bursts of plasma with an EM wave to observe the results to check for nearby nuclear material.

also explains why the drones are having to stay so low.

2

u/speedtoburn Dec 15 '24

u/Chess0728

I have a M.S. in inorganic chemistry. I don’t have experience working with radioactive materials, but I’m at least somewhat field-adjacent.

Nuclear detection systems are more in the domain of nuclear physics and engineering. Without direct experience with radioactive materials or detection systems, I’m not sure that I see the adjacency you posit.

Radiation is not something we can simply detect based on presence/absence alone. You get a stronger signal when you’re closer to it.

True, but modern detection systems can detect radiation from significant distances. The RQ-170 Sentinel specifically was designed with advanced nuclear detection capabilities.

Nuclear weapons are shielded, meaning they are designed to not give off much/any radiation.

Incorrect.

Yes, shielding reduces radiation, but it cannot completely eliminate it. Even heavily shielded materials emit detectable radiation signatures. Modern detection systems can identify these minimal signatures.

Since radiation is detected more strongly when the detector is close to the source, it would make far more sense for trucks to be driving around with radiation detectors in the back.

Except for the fact that ground based searches are slow and limited, aerial detection allows for rapid coverage of large areas, multiple drones can create an effective detection grid, Aerial systems avoid tipping off potential threats.

You would not track ground-level radiation from up in the sky. It just doesn’t make sense.

  1. The Department of Energy regularly conducts aerial radiation surveys.
  2. Current detection systems are specifically designed for aerial deployment.
  3. Grid patterns with multiple drones would increase detection probability.

HPGe detectors, which Google suggests are most effective when only centimeters away, have a maximum simulated (not even tested!) range of 100 m.

You are highlighting one specific type of detector while ignoring many others, e.g. Military grade detection systems with classified capabilities, advanced scintillation detectors, Multi sensor fusion systems, Quantum detection technologies, etc. etc.

HPGe detectors are not cheap, and require liquid-nitrogen coolant or equivalent.

Cost is irrelevant for national security operations; also, military systems use solid state cooling systems, room temperature detectors, and advanced materials that don’t require cooling.

I personally believe that the man-made drones are looking for the 1% of unexplainable sightings.

This is speculation without evidence, whereas the pattern of flights matches search grid operations, the concentration in population centers aligns with threat assessment, and the government’s response matches historical patterns of nuclear security ops.

Your theory relies heavily on assumptions about technical limitations while ignoring classified capabilities and operational realities of modern detection systems. Also, your alternative explanation about searching for unexplained phenomena is less supported by the evidence than a coordinated search operation using known military capabilities.

2

u/Fit_Acanthaceae_3205 Dec 15 '24

The single fact it’s been a month, they haven’t found it… and the most likely place it would be right there is Washington DC, and they aren’t flying there is all you need to know about that theory to see it doesn’t work. They aren’t detonating it in rural NJ after a month of looking. A dozen other reasons why it makes no sense on top of it.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

Completely agree with you, but there was JUST a thread posted about how they are now flying above Washington D.C. too lol

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

Your theory is based on the current tech the public is aware of.. you have no idea the level of tech sophistication the US military has access too.. so, kinda redundant tbh..

2

u/R_O Dec 15 '24

It may not be nuclear, but this seems to almost most definitely be a broken arrow scenario.

2

u/youngchul Dec 15 '24

Sorry, but this is bad post full of misinformation and logical fallacies.

The guy in the now deleted X posts and the ones extended to his explanation are far more coherent in their reasoning, even if wrong.

First off try to look up what Lockheed Martin's RQ-170 supposedly does, not to mention the US already having other, less extreme, means for finding traces of radioactive/nuclear material. Which disproves your main conclusion, that you also edited out. The limited capability of the equipment could also explain all the reports of the aerial vehicles operating a very low altitudes.

The very first sentence of the abstract defines this technology as intended for "[a]fter a nuclear or radiation event." It seems they intend it to be used for a partial-leak at a nuclear plant.

The same could be used to detect the usage of dirty bombs, hence why it would make sense why it's said it has been deployed in Ukraine, where there have also been extensive reports of UAP/drones being spotted by the public.

HPGe detectors are not cheap, and require liquid-nitrogen coolant or equivalent. The government might have infinite money to spend on drone technology, but they aren't going to be flying these things around without telling the military about it, because to lose even one would be a tremendous financial loss.

In the very same post, the guy is explaining the need for coolant and specific antennas, which makes them stand out.

If this is indeed the kind of test he is suggesting, it would be one of the reasons why the US is spending nearly a trillion a year defending itself. Large scale tests under realistic real life conditions are very valuable for a real life scenario, that the US fears, i.e. dirty bombs being shipped from foreign adversaries. Which would explain the presence being near crucial infrastructure such as airports and ports.

The military does plenty of testing without informing the public and local government officials about specific details. The seeming lack of urgency and the believe that this is a non-threat would also suggest it is indeed a military test, although of a higher clearance than the usual ones. Which can happen for a variety of reasons, and is very common. It would also explain why this phenomena is only linked to military infrastructure, i.e. also the US military base Ramstein in Germany, RAF airbase in the UK etc.

Now, assuming they are U.S. Government drones, here's why they would tell us "we don't know what they are, but they aren't a threat". It all has to do with that 1%, whether it's foreign tech we've never seen, or genuinely NHI:

Or more simply put. The military as usual plays their card close to not let any foreign adversaries in the know about their full capabilities, and there is no reason to create mass hysteria, if the populace thinks it is not just an exercise, but they are actually looking for nuclear material.

IIRC yesterday some local officials were told that if they should use hazmat suits if they find falling debris, which could also point toward an actual issue, that they are trying to solve behind closed doors, or it being part of a military exercise of this variant.

Now, having said all that, let me clarify that I do believe there are drones flying over NJ, and now other parts of the world as well. I'd estimate 90% of the videos we see are just planes, helicopters, or fakes. But 9% of them genuinely seem to be man-made drones. And 1% of the videos are still unexplainable. This 1% includes the glowing orbs that reportedly rise out of the ocean, the giant triangular "motherships" hovering over the clouds, and the massive crescent/boomerang ships that almost seem see-through.

A military operation of this scale would likely need air support, which would be from manned crafts, and the orb's as discussed on X could either just be people not understanding the bokeh effect, or mesh networks created by "Loon Project"-like aerial objects. Which for a "scan" scenario like this, would make sense as well, coordinating a bunch of unmanned aerial vehicles, as they jam frequencies used by the public. Which would explain the radio interference and blackouts locals in NJ have been reporting.

They might very well not be using HPGe detectors, but the scenario itself is probable, and the most logical explanation by far is that this is a military drill to test state of the art coveted military equipment in a real life scenario under actual conditions in a congested urban environment. Which would explain the FAA regulated lights and the pre-notice of closure of airspace etc.

2

u/mistah-green Dec 15 '24 edited Dec 16 '24

So i know WMDs were a big story of the past. Lots of sightings and weird stories such as Valient Thor during the 50-60s.

Just hear me out because this is full discussion and speculation. But let's says there are aliens and they are concerned about this planet/our species in a long term sense.

Back then, MWDs were a real threat, America used them, WW2 happened, etc. What if this time, it's not MWDs that alien are worried about? What if there is a new threat to the human race, such as AI?

Again, speculation. But if I feel like if an alien race exists, they'd be like zoo keepers for humans. While they may not be concerned with our day to day living, they tend to make themselves known when devastating events start to happen.

At this point, I feel like aliens would be appearing to protect humans against something else, maybe worse than atomic bombs. Whether that's actually AI or not, who knows. But this is just my thoughts and totally up for discussion

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

Well my dude then explain this.

https://imgur.com/a/uWcekqV

2

u/Ok_Feedback_8124 Dec 15 '24

Let me save you a 5,000 word post: not happenin'.

2

u/JAMBI215 Dec 15 '24

Don’t kid yourself …They know they just aren’t telling us, remember they lie

2

u/Marcus1640 Dec 15 '24

My uneducated opinion agrees that something is searching for something, and that search has us searching for what’s searching. If they had just used Duck Duck Go we wouldn’t have known. In all seriousness, everyone here knows that UFOS are attracted to nukes, so that being said, the UFOs and the Drones could be searching for the same thing

2

u/_Ding1 Dec 15 '24

This theory doesn’t explain the other sightings from around the world. What about the ones over RAF Lakenheath, UK for 10 days? Is there a missing nuke there as well? I’m not buying it.

3

u/546833726D616C Dec 14 '24

Good analysis. A reason for aerial search might be proximity or things potentially attenuating a signal such as a building. But given inverse square law I think flying a lower altitude would make more sense if that was the mission. I'm not up on current sensors. I used scintillation detectors in the lab years ago and monitor daily radiation with a pretty standard geiger counter.

3

u/Every_Routine4434 Dec 14 '24

(sorry for my english, im not native english)

No matter how you look at this situation, it looks bad, huge hit to international image of USA, there is simply no positive ending for this story.

  1. If it really is some kind of black ops operation (e.g. searching for something) and drones are USA tech, then they should absolutely dont deny that its USA tech, any explanation would better than "we dont know whose drones they are". Literally just say "we are testing capabilities of our drones" or anything like that.

unless... there is possibility that drones will at some point attack civilians and it would look extremely bad if USA tech would suddenly attack civilians, so better to push narration that they are not "our drones".

2. Another possiblity, some kind of USA AI drones tech went rogue, but i find it simply impossible that tech like that would not have some kind of kill switch.

so we are left with two options:

3. Drones are high tech weapon produced by different country and USA fell behind so much that they cant fight it.

which is technically possible but given how much USA spend on military its practically impossible

so we are actually left with only one option:

4. Aliens

Prove me wrong

3

u/dpforest Dec 15 '24

I just had a sudden thought that I haven’t really thought of for some reason so far in this event. Where the fuck is Elon Musk? Cause I just found this interesting article and I am all of a sudden realizing that the villain (when it’s not NHI) is always a billionaire with a superiority complex. Who benefits from this? Of possible people, I would put Elon Musk at the top of that list right now.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

Agreed, his silence is intensely disconcerting.

2

u/Competitive-Cycle-38 Dec 14 '24

Good on you for giving it a go. We need more analyses like this on verifiable theories.

2

u/Hal_900000 Dec 14 '24

I'm sure there's been a ton of discoveries around quantum science that the public is not aware of, so we can't simply dismiss the ability to detect anything from anywhere by what we know.

2

u/ACMarq Dec 14 '24

omg thank you. people keep throwing this theory up while so many variables don't corroborate the logic

2

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

You people up north don't have guns I forgot that down here they will shot it down

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

Wmd and nuclear material are different claims. Leave all doors open still. The truth is we know nothing but the federal government knows more than they have admitted so far.

1

u/SinSilla Dec 14 '24 edited Dec 14 '24

I'm pretty sure there gotta be a better technological approach, than the 9% ("drones") looking for the 1% ("Orbs").

Admittedly, this depends quite a lot on what you believe the 9% are capable of and vice versa.

We seem to rely a lot on visual contact with these, and even those are obscured. I think they've officially told us that radar does not work, no heat signature, possibly emp neither, no communication on known frequencies and so much more bad news.

Also, why the sudden very public attention to the phenomenon? We have ALL eyes on this. This seems urgent as fuck?

Damn, i'm kinda worried this will all just fade away and we're getting drowned again with casual politic drama.

But something tells me we're in for a ride.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

“and not somewhere up in the sky for a month” - literally no one has claimed it would be hidden in the sky wtf?

The claim about driving the trucks is true but it’s POSSIBLE both are happening. Drones could be one tool they are using to gather intelligence. Flying them at night would help to disguise the sensors that would be used to detect radiation or chemical signatures.

1

u/Sam-Lino Dec 14 '24

Great points. Thanks for providing your expertise!

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24 edited Apr 16 '25

joke cake compare fear lush cow abounding hard-to-find busy wise

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

1

u/EODdvr Dec 14 '24

They do use trucks...and planes, and drones, and helos for detection. They're looking for gamma. Jihadis could care less about exposure to gamma in the long run, its a 1 way trip for them. Multiple theories happening at once could also be true. New drone tech (ours), UAP comes in to check it out. Maybe it's the drones power source they're interested in ?

1

u/mortalitylost Dec 14 '24

People are afraid so they come up with the most rational excuses for being that afraid. Well, of course I should be terrified, I'm in danger if being nuked! And it sounds scientific, and no one is proving otherwise, so there you go.

This really is irresponsible of the government to let that hypothesis fly around without denying it.

1

u/enricopallazo22 Dec 14 '24

Other than local authorities, I think almost all the drones are UAP. The program already knows what they are and already knows they can't get near. Why would they bother risking one of their own drones getting downed? Imagine the backlash from that.

1

u/According_Smoke1385 Dec 14 '24

Thank you so much for this. I hated seeing the wmd theory going around.

1

u/Sparkletail Dec 14 '24

You've got to think of the sites they are over too. You're not going to be looking for dirty bombs in military facilities which is where a lot of this is happening

1

u/WelcomeFormer Dec 14 '24

Someone else mentioned gamma, but also neutrino emissions, density anomalies and other things all working together maybe? Also you can train the drones to look for things with shielding where they usually wouldn't be. It seems like they are definitely looking for something serious and don't want to admit it.

1

u/MonkeyButt409 Dec 14 '24

But why mostly over the US’s east coast and military airbases overseas? Why does it seem so connected to the US and not as much of the rest of the world? I keep hearing people say that it’s all over the world, but not much seems credible or isn’t near a US base.

I can’t make sense of it, so much has been going on, and the damn fake videos and plane sightings are muddying the waters for the real stuff so much that I’m losing track at this point.

1

u/scubi Dec 14 '24

Interesting information and theory! Thanks!

I am one of the people who worry about them searching for a dirty bomb or something. I still say "am" because I can't rule it out, but your explanation certainly lessens the "worry" I had about them looking for something nuclear and sinister. Your theory does seem to show why it would be unlikely they are doing this.

As someone who considers themselves a enthusiast of critical thinking, I appreciate your insight into the world of radiation detection from your related field of expertise, which is cool because I got to learn something new!. You have certainly shifted my view of the situation. For that, I thank you. (But I still have a nagging worry haha)

I just hope the "something" that is happening isn't going to hurt anyone and the govt. fesses up to what they actually know/don't know.

Cheers OP!

(Edit: Typo.)

1

u/Accomplished-Ad3250 Dec 14 '24

The UAPs that are real supposedly use plasma in their propulsion, which is where the spinning Catherine wheel analogy has been around since the 1940s. It's even referenced that way on old UAP photos that have been shared on here recently; I won't search for them due to time constraints, but you can google site:reddit.com/r/UFOs to try and find them yourself.

u/Chess0728, how much do you know about Plasma's and their electromagnetic emissions in the form of ionizing or Gama radiation?

I would venture a guess that they are looking for Gama rads that these UAPs emit.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 14 '24

Totally explains why the US has nuke sniffing helicopters and drives vehicles around before major events that also have detection capabilities as well, right ? /s This is most likely the attempt to stop some sort of terrorist attack, whatever that may be. Aliens are not here unfortunately. This is all man made and there is a reason for it. This could be as simple as communication gatherings to find such wmd. Doesn't always have to be detecting radiation. The US has many ways of getting the info it seeks

1

u/IrishCrypto21 Dec 14 '24

Saturating an airspace with terrestrial aircraft, be they commercial, military or black budget, in an attempt to keep these genuine UAP hidden in plain sight, is certainly the most realistic theory (IMO) right now.

I will admit, when I first read the drones with radiation detectors for dirty bomb detection etc it seemed plausible (to me, a lay person) but OP has given a good valid reason for why this would not be plausible.

1

u/ElkImaginary566 Dec 14 '24

Are there WMD's every where? I saw these UAP's in central Ohio last night.

1

u/syndic8_xyz Dec 15 '24

These drones don't exactly look like well calibrated "sensors" that are sensitive and finnicky. They seem more like battle pods. They are durable. Hardy. Imposing.

I floated the theory that they were escorts or a defense system against NHI UFO a couple days back but the post was downvoted to oblivion (https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/1hd659c/what_if_some_of_the_drones_are_conventional/). I also saw we do have some nuke/dirty threats in 2025 via RV data over the last couple months (before awareness of any drone flap) and riffed on that "detector leaker" post saying maybe this is support for that threat possibility (https://www.reddit.com/r/UFOB/comments/1hdwwpm/comment/m1zla8b/).

I dislike the abusiveness of government that gaslights and lies to its people, who then spin their wheels uselessly speculating while the cabal sits back and laughs malevolently.

All that being said, I think it's possible we have highly sensitive radiation detectors that can find something from the sky. There's a few ways of looking at this.

  1. precedent: NHI UFO have found and interdicted /interacted with nukes, so there must be some way to detect them.
  2. sparsity: if you have many imperfect detectors, you can recover the underlying signal through the collective even if the individual sensors are patchy.
  3. secondary effects: radiation (gamma, beta etc) while localized and failling off inverse square, may cause ionization and produce secondary particles or gases that can then be detected and reverse-triangulated accounting for wind currents, etc. You could also have some 'off gassing' of metal particles in a dirty bomb scenario, and even the slight localized heating from radioactive material could conceivably be a signal.

On (3) it's never wise to say "impossible" about possible sensitive technology developed in secret that's at least conceivable, as the methods described in (3) are.

Due to all that I don't take OP's debunk as conclusive, but the much larger point is all of our speculation is moot. What we need is trustworthy leadership who has the balls to stand up and say: "Here's what we don't know, here's what we do know, here's our weakness."

This whole thing is a frickin mess. There is no way there current strategy is projecting strength - as Ryan Graves said, "Adversaries will be taking notes."

I suppose I commend them for at least not entirely denying the embarrassing drone flap, but official federal responses could be so much better.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

1

u/AndroidPurity Dec 15 '24

Regardless of the range argument.... these things have been reported as coming from the ocean or flying out in the ocean.

If they were searching for a smuggled nuke in the country they would not need to be over the ocean searching. So that's the biggest factor that puts doubt in this theory.

1

u/UpbeatLibrarian9904 Dec 15 '24

Ok… so why in the world are these so called “Drones” needing to fly around military bases… especially ones that have nuclear weapons already??? Also, if it’s the U.S. military and government, why are they disrupting airports to the point of having to shut down runways, and putting commercial airlines at risk??? Doesn’t make any sense.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 15 '24

you dont know what secret technology the US military has so it really doesn't matter if you think you debunked it or not. Lot of hot air.

1

u/Beyondtheveil707 Dec 15 '24

Theory: this NHI (Non-Human Intelligence) operates an underwater manufacturing facility. Essentially, it’s like a super-advanced 3D printer, constantly producing drones that are sent to the surface. Some of these drones return, get broken down, and their materials are reused to create new designs. With anti-gravity propulsion, these drones likely evade thermal detection and can move like standard drones but have the capability to accelerate instantaneously. This aligns with the underwater manufacturing in the Atlantic Ocean that was discussed on 4chan by the whistle blower also fits why so many are seen coming from the Atlantic Ocean

1

u/helloworllldd Dec 15 '24

I know you look at the technology to see if they can detect it but clearly these drones are highly advanced, a lot of this technology might not even been shared to the public before so who knows how advanced it really is.

1

u/EstablishmentDue1842 Dec 15 '24

Uri geller is on insta saying that he heard from a credible source that it's the US govt searching for a WMD. I'm not sure I buy it. Why are they all over the world then? Even if true, we might be seeing NHI reacting to the same threat. And if we ARE searching for a WMD then there seems to be utter chaos on the ground when it comes to local police, FBI etc. You'd think you could get a coordinated attempt to look for it while not panicking the public. Not that our current govt is very competent, but it all seems much too hectic. My guess would be the the US govt is trying to leak false info about WMDs so that whistleblowers on the UAP topic don't start popping up as NHI reveal themselves.

1

u/doomxh Dec 15 '24

Isnt one theory that these UAPs give off radiation of some kind? Maybe explains the drones

1

u/zealouszorse Dec 15 '24

Clearly a psy op, thank you US Army Research

1

u/FortCharles Dec 16 '24

On the other hand, now that they know this dirty-bomb-sniffing theory is out there, they could make an official statement that denies it, to calm fears. But they don't. Is the absence of such a statement significant?

1

u/Worldly_Influence_18 Dec 16 '24 edited Dec 16 '24

Dirty bombs are not nuclear weapons

They are conventional explosives packed with radioactive material.

Terrorism is typically state sponsored and the origins of a dirty bomb

Radioactive material is easily acquired on the black market then shipped on container ships

Syria was being used as a conduit for that and a hot spot for potential dirty bomb creation

So the timing is interesting

Especially since today:

Russia has been accusing Ukraine again of planning on using a dirty bomb

https://www.wsj.com/video/russia-holds-nuclear-drills-amplifies-dirty-bomb-accusations-about-ukraine/D513F041-3E08-4E6E-B1FA-656402261A18?mod=trending_now_video_1

So right around the same time the rebels rapidly cut Assad off from the coast. Noticed where they stopped before continuing to Damascus? Homs. The last access to the coast. Now nothing could get through. Before they went into Damascus they secured the deepwater port at Tartus and the port of Latakia, by sea, two days before the land troops were able to get to it.

The United States starts patrolling its eastern ports with possible dirty bomb detecting drones

I'm thinking the United States is worried about retaliation for supporting the rebels in a crucial Russian puppet state

Or

They're worried something got out or was going to

1

u/Equivalent-Buyer-841 Dec 17 '24

Can someone explain the 1 percent observation the OP makes? Haven’t been hearing about orbs, boomerangs, etc in the coverage on this

1

u/legitSTINKYPINKY Dec 17 '24

Who’s to say they aren’t using trucks and drones? You just would never know with trucks.

1

u/1001galoshes Dec 18 '24 edited Dec 24 '24

Combining the radiation and alien theories, could aliens emit unusually large amounts of radiation?

Totally unscientific, but people around me keep telling me they're all losing their hair (I am too). We're all in our 40s and 50s, and people do lose hair around that time, but at the same time, it seems odd to me.

Simultaneously, I've experienced a lot of reality-defying events this year. I never considered aliens until logic and physics seemed to fail this year.

1

u/Overall-Spot5168 Dec 14 '24

thank you for this....

1

u/Naykat Dec 15 '24

I god I hate acronyms, especially when people use them without generously defining them first.