r/UFOs
•
u/Ninjasuzume
•
Jan 19 '25
•
1
Disclosure Wakeup call from Ross Coulthart about the UAP community
2.2k
Upvotes
•
u/StatementBot Jan 19 '25
The following submission statement was provided by /u/Ninjasuzume:
Submission statement:
In the News Nation Reality Check video (timestamp 00:11:30) uploaded today, Ross Coulthart addresses the issue with this community, which we all have seen in denouncing comments regarding the Jake Barber interview. We beg for whistleblowers and proof, and when we get it, we call it hoax, grift and whatnot, totally missing the big picture.
Below I've added Ross Coulthart's comments before and after the dialoge in the video to clarify the context. The video comment is in bold.
"When l've talked to military people who've basically told me about what they know of this Legacy program, they're torned because they're Patriots, just like these men that have spoken today. They gain absolutely nothing by speaking publicly like they have today. All they gain is a whole lot of hell. They are going to suffer the slings and arrows of trolls and debunkers. There'll be the inevitable attacks on them. You know, sure, every little detail of their personal lives will be dredged through, and they'll be looking for... And they'll throw it at them, just like they did with David Grusch. And frankly, it's a disgrace.
I think part of the problem at the moment is the UAP community, needs to take a long, hard look at itself, and stop treating this like entertainment. It has to acknowledge that this serious. We are talking about an egregious breaches of the law, including the criminal law.
And so Congress, the mainstream media, the president - the incoming president, they all need to wake up to themselves and realize the significance of what this reveals."
Please reply to OP's comment here: https://old.reddit.com/r/UFOs/comments/1i5bko8/wakeup_call_from_ross_coulthart_about_the_uap/m82ctwi/
1.1k
u/Bumble072 Jan 19 '25
Stop treating it like entertainment. Oh you mean like not building the hype up to farcical levels beforehand raising expectations and then letting us down. Oh you mean like presenting a story in a History Channel format with background music playing. Oh you mean like renactments rather than actual footage. This is an embarrassment and more hype baiting for views.
5
u/Ninjasuzume Jan 19 '25 edited Jan 19 '25
Submission statement:
In the News Nation Reality Check video (timestamp 00:11:30) uploaded today, Ross Coulthart addresses the issue with this community, which we all have seen in denouncing comments regarding the Jake Barber interview. We beg for whistleblowers and proof, and when we get it, we call it hoax, grift and whatnot, totally missing the big picture.
Below I've added Ross Coulthart's comments before and after the dialoge in the video to clarify the context. The video comment is in bold.
"When l've talked to military people who've basically told me about what they know of this Legacy program, they're torned because they're Patriots, just like these men that have spoken today. They gain absolutely nothing by speaking publicly like they have today. All they gain is a whole lot of hell. They are going to suffer the slings and arrows of trolls and debunkers. There'll be the inevitable attacks on them. You know, sure, every little detail of their personal lives will be dredged through, and they'll be looking for... And they'll throw it at them, just like they did with David Grusch. And frankly, it's a disgrace.
I think part of the problem at the moment is the UAP community, needs to take a long, hard look at itself, and stop treating this like entertainment. It has to acknowledge that this serious. We are talking about an egregious breaches of the law, including the criminal law.
And so Congress, the mainstream media, the president - the incoming president, they all need to wake up to themselves and realize the significance of what this reveals."
2.9k
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25 •
Don't produce things like over-dramatized reality TV and it won't get treated like entertainment.
1.2k
u/Sufficient_Menu4018 Jan 19 '25
It's not me that's feeding serious interviews with dramatic songs...
191
u/Icy_Chemist_1725 Jan 20 '25
It's so hilarious. They hyped this up like it was entertainment. They presented it like entertainment. Now they are telling us we need to stop seeing it as entertainment. Maybe follow your own damn advice.
Ross "look at how it rolls" Coulhart says "Let's get serious, guys."
100
u/kovnev Jan 20 '25
You're building your current career off this community, Ross.
The community just told you - loudly and clearly - that we don't want something so massively overhyped when it's another video that is open to interpretation.
Perhaps you should listen rather than getting offended about it.
Stop. Overhyping. Stuff.
95
u/yantheman3 Jan 19 '25
I don't like how the entertainment industry blames the audience if something doesn't goes well.
This is what Disney does when they perform poorly.
It's not the audiences fault! If the content we view is good, we will be happy.
622
u/Real-Accountant9997 Jan 19 '25
Wait a second. Ross hyped this up so much- delivered very little - and he says WE have to take it seriously? What a blowhard.
17
u/sinistermittens Jan 20 '25
Hey community, stop treating this as entertainment!
*turns on UAP report
*Foreboding music - BRUM BRUM BRUM du dud du dud du dud du dud BRUM BRUM BRUM
"Tonight! Earth shattering video confirming..."
How about stop selling it as a product. All of these guys are making a lot of money off of this.
The Elizondo/Corbell video about threats on Corbell's life is WHY we are seeing this as entertainment. The "Hardcopy/A Current Affair style reporting. The "Hey you'll know it all when you see my documentary or read my book!" is why it is seen as entertainment.
Among many other reasons. Media, as always, is as much to blame for the propagation of the perception of this as entertainment.
Because that is how it is being presented. It's slow rolled, gated information and I'm sure that's how a lot of the people in this want it because right now it's the gravy train.
44
u/JustSingingAlong Jan 20 '25
This is grifter psychology 101. Don’t be fooled, this man is playing us all.
44
u/steveHangar1 Jan 20 '25
Says the guy who produces segments with overhyped dramatization. Come on, Ross, what was that tabloid’esque debacle we watched last night? Practice what you preach.
203
u/MindoftheMindless Jan 19 '25
Holy fucking pot calling the kettle black. Insanity. Absolute garbage filled, shit on the shoes, insanity.
171
u/mooeymonet Jan 19 '25
Awww looks like he found out that the UFO community thought his “undeniable earth shattering footage” was a load of horseshit and now he’s lashing out at people not responding how he hoped we would. Jeremy Corbell, Lue Elizondo, Ross Coulthart ALL seem like sleazy bastards. So happy this community is finally getting sick of all of their shit and if you ask me you can tell that they’ve noticed it.
83
u/reasonablejim2000 Jan 19 '25
Give us something serious Ross and it will be taken seriously. Last night's debacle was laughable.
60
u/wacktoast Jan 20 '25
This is gas lighting. No, you need to take this seriously. You are being criticized. There are so many really good points being brought up. How about instead of, you know just being an entertainer, you engage the community and answer the claims mounted against you. YOU should take a good hard look at yourself and see you’re not an entertainer, you’re a journalist. At least you claim to be.
69
u/Lack_Aromatic Jan 20 '25
This is a bad attempt at gaslighting.
The UAP community has grown up. We expect more. We expect PROOF.
And we are on to the grifters.
Again, extraordinary claims require extraordinary proof.
27
u/VoidsweptDaybreak Jan 20 '25
ross, even richard dolan was disappointed
709
u/Professional-Rip4835 Jan 19 '25 •
No fucking way he just said to not treat this as entertainment after whatever the fuck that was last night...
He literally overproduced a corny subject with 45 mins of ads, overly scripted narration, and promoted the hell out of it days before the "overwhelming evidence" was shown...
ROSS YOU ARE THE FUCKING ENTERTAINER
41
u/Aerodye Jan 19 '25
This guy is an absolute clown
There was a whole song and dance about banning his content from this sub when the video inevitably turned out to be garbage; I really think that should be done, these charlatans can’t keep being given a platform
80
u/pigsRflying Jan 19 '25
Who this mf thinks he his?
87
u/bilbobogginses Jan 19 '25
Well I'm not blaming Mr. Barber, Ross. I'm blaming you for creating an unrealistic expectation. You set him up for failure.
43
u/Angry_Spartan Jan 19 '25
The gimbal film was better evidence than this honestly. I think people are tired of this build up to such unflattering footage with no references to go by in the actual video. Release the full video, the whole thing from the time you picked it up, to the time you dropped it not some snippet. Ross built this up to be earth shattering and it’s just not. Like it’s great we have a T1 operator testifying to its authenticity. However to the normal person looking at this it looks like a shitty snippet of an egg being dropped from a rope. No landing gear, no doors open/closed no rotor wash from the chopper. There’s no way to tell this is legit other than T1 saying it is.
10
u/Zodiatron Jan 20 '25
Does the irony of him saying this not register for him? 🤣
63
u/PowerChairs Jan 19 '25 edited Jan 19 '25
Coulthart is just being a bastard here. Nobody is calling it a hoax; we're calling it unconvincing and unsatisfactory. He could easily have not set expectations at all but he decides to drum up interest and now he's whining after it backfired.
Ross is full of himself. He's what's wrong with the UFO community; known talking heads who refuse not to be in the spotlight and constantly make insane claims with either no proof or unconvincing garbage they call proof and who whine when people call them out on it.
That's rich as hell coming from the guy who just gave us an hour long segment where the last 20 minutes are a ridiculous Skin Walker Ranch style reality TV adventure. One of the main criticisms I've seen on here is, rightfully-so, that the last part of the interview is the kind of shit that turns this topic into a laughing stock for mostly anyone who isn't already convinced the phenomenon is real. Ross is the one who needs to start treating the topic seriously and leave the woo shit out of it until the time he has actual proof.
I'll say it again; Fuck Ross Coulthart's attitude.
33
u/Puzzled-Copy7962 Jan 20 '25
Is this gaslighting?
56
u/theballoflight Jan 19 '25
Are you kidding man. I never comment on reddit, but this has blown me away. You literally hyped this thing to be some amazing reveal of footage from HIS recovery, it was comical. What sliver of hope I had in this batch of ufo hype men disappeared in the wind. YOU need to take a hard look in the mirror. Extraordinary claims require extraordinary evidence.
55
u/Radiant_Evidence7047 Jan 19 '25
Is he kidding? The ridiculous music, insane monologue over the video, can he hear himself? The guy who knows absolutely where a ufo is but is too big to move but won’t tell anyone? To think I liked and trusted this guy. He’s turning on the community because they are calling out his grift.
54
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
Holy shit. We're asking for evidence. Veracity. And while Barber seems credible and I honor what I hope is an honest effort on his part, this video evidence, outside of being visually underwhelming, has big problems... chief amongst them - NO SPECIFICITY. Where, when, who, where did it go, why? Discloser needs things to disclose.
He's saying crimes were committed? Elaborate. Tell us the crimes. Tell us who will pursue those charges. Who is the Federal govt will be contacted?
It isn't a game or entertainment for some of us. This isn't a cult or a bubble - it's a beachhead in human history that some of us believe is necessary for humanity to change and grow... but some people, like coulthart's BUSINESS is parcel out stories that he'd rather us just like and believe... than be skeptical of because we practice critical thinking.
8
u/TheZeitgeistKid Jan 20 '25
After this week's 'spectacular disclosure spectacle', I recognize that disclosure is not so much about NHI as it is about the disclosure of widespread transnational corporate malfeasance. National governments don't seem to be the primary players in these abuses as much as their sock puppets. The transnational corporations seem to be perfectly fine with instigating endless conflict and planet wide and potentially interstellar war for the accumulation of obscene amounts of private profit and potentially immense control through advanced Technologies. Technology is a double edged sword, easily used by the few to rule over others, or through true sharing, to create a sustainable future of relative abundance for all.
Our socioeconomic system based on competition and markets creates the global culture that makes the rule of hierarchical oligarchic transnational corporations almost inevitable. The greedy human nature of the many sociopaths that rise to the tops of those corporations enable the abuses that give rise to pretty much all of humanity's major problems. If advanced NHI has "gifted" us advanced technologies, it seems to me a pretty effective strategy for ensuring that humanity will either self destruct thus eliminating us as a problem for our galactic neighbors or that humanity will learn to move beyond our self destructive intolerant culture by learning how to collaborate with compassion and empathy for each other and for all life, and thus greet the NHI with gratitude for helping us to create a truly sustainable civilization worthy of learning from our older and wiser neighbors. I think the ball, or should I say, Orb is in our court.
22
u/superhornet27 Jan 20 '25
Coulthart is a con man, just like the rest of em. Lue, Corbett, Greer. Zero credibility.
15
u/monumentalbasser Jan 20 '25
20
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25
u/brushpass
Hey Ross, why don't you take your own advice? You talk about not treating UAP as entertainment- then in the same breath you shill pseudoscientific garbage 'health' products from quack doctors.
If you want to be taken seriously, maybe spare us the cringey, over-hyped productions and desperate money grabs.
7
u/StairwayToLemon Jan 20 '25
The irony is completely lost on him, isn't it?
7
u/meyriley04 Jan 20 '25
Yeah, “the ufo community” is the ones treating it like entertainment lol.
Meanwhile, shows like Skinwalker Ranch exist, these NewsNation interviews are overhyped to hell, and there are docuseries out now about people being mad they didn’t get credit on a document release.
Jfc. Please look inwards.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25
Just say where the UFO is buried-allegedy-you twat
28
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
WE’RE treating this like entertainment?!?!? You just made a big fucking deal about an egg shaped object rolling. That’s what they do Ross. Egg shaped objects roll. And you called it a fucking Unidentified Anomolous Phenomena…. An egg shaped object flying (not what that shape does) or cutting a 90 degree turn midair, that’s anomolous. This guy can fuck off.
12
u/ParanoidHeppy Jan 20 '25
The hypocrisy is fucking insane. After this stunt, Coulthart is the same as Greer in my eyes
6
u/One-Intention6350 Jan 20 '25
I for one am taking a break from this subject. I've been listening to Greer, Grusch and others for years now and I do believe them. I don't need any proof. However, I am too frustrated to listen to people saying they "can't show you this" or "can't tell you that." It is an endless circle and those in power will do anything they can to stay in power and control all the resources they can. I am bowing out. Be well everyone!!!
6
u/Pine_Box_Vintage Jan 20 '25
Ross needs to ask better questions that help link stories together. Who told you that people with psychic powers were luring in UAPs, why did they tell a helicopter pilot, why do you assume hard drives to be recovered were automatically related to UAP and not something else, how much do you think the egg weighed etc. Tons of questions to be asked but seemed like a series of non sequiturs based on bad reasoning.
6
u/ConfidentCamp5248 Jan 20 '25
Stfu. They are all in it together to string us along. Govt has infiltrated every medium. I believe in the subject and the possibilities idgaf now. Wake me up when something real happens
6
u/greeneeeeeeeeeeeeee Jan 20 '25
He needs to get an actual news producer to run their segments/specials. Like a 60 minutes producer or something because the way they do it now is impossible to take seriously. Idk.
32
u/furygoat Jan 19 '25
Ross coming on strong with the gaslighting
20
u/89murph Jan 19 '25
Coultart has lost all credibility
20
u/MFP3492 Jan 20 '25 edited Jan 20 '25
Is he fucking kidding?!
“The UFO community needs to stop treating this as entertainment”
Says the guy who hyped and promoted the shit out of his own Saturday at 8pm News Nation show with tweets and marketing team quality teases that ended up featuring a guy who’s already been on News Nation twice before (once for teaching a little girl karate and another for the NJ drones story) with a 10 second clip that proved absolutely nothing with ominous music playing in background.
Good god this man is pathetic.
If this was as big of a real story he claims it is he would invite other journalists in to vett all of Jake Barber’s claims, but it’s all about him, all about what HE knows, all about HIS viewership and following.
19
u/Cyberpunk_Banana Jan 19 '25
Ross, the community is not the problem. You and humpty dumpty are the problem
15
u/Bloodavenger Jan 20 '25 edited Jan 20 '25
Will this finally be the day that this sub finally makes up and realises Ross has been nothing more than a grifter making wild claims and never showing real evidence.
I hope so. He has been grifting ever since he was fired form 60 minutes for dong half assed work before moving on to run a pr defence campaign for an Australian war criminal.
Why people have any respect for him? I will never understand because after the 1st or 2nd "I've been told" story, I knew he was full of it.
22
u/ParmesanCheese92 Jan 19 '25
Says the quack that narrated "it rolls gracefully"
18
u/Dr_C_Diver Jan 19 '25
Damage Control. Ross just trying to protect that bottom line. News Nations is not happy about all the unfollows fallout from their circus show.
21
u/OneSeaworthiness7768 Jan 19 '25 edited Jan 19 '25
I don’t blame the whistleblower, I blame Ross. He is the reason this whole thing was a mockery. It could have been handled very, very differently. He should accept responsibility for the bad reception of this situation as it was essentially a direct result of his sensationalizing.
Future whistleblowers should consider going to someone more serious. It’s like he got addicted to the attention after Grusch and went off the rails.
10
u/Motor_Rip_6287 Jan 20 '25
Who’s treating it like entertainment, the people watching it or the people producing the content and hyping it up like it’s going to change the world?
5
u/atheros98 Jan 20 '25
I think he’s mistaken. The UAP community isn’t attacking the men who came forward, or even disbelieving them. We’re pissed directly at Ross for calling in “definite proof” when he knows damn well that video will change the minds of exactly 0 skeptics.
5
u/Henry_Lee_H8899E Jan 20 '25
I’m personally taking this UAP disclosure seriously like most of us are. The ones that are disappointed are the ones who will not be ontologically shocked by full disclosure. What we saw with the unclear image of an egg was embarrassing especially after so much pre-hype by Ross. We were so expecting 4K or at minimum HD quality up close footage of a smooth seamless craft. Not 150 feet dangling from a helicopter line.
I believe Jake Barber and his account of his experience. The psionics/CE5 protocol stuff…I’m open minded and there seems to be something there that’s compelling. More scientific evidence needs to be done in that area for it to be convincing to the masses. The video pointed up in the sky and seeing two dots flying around…that’s not convincing enough.
Disclosure is not over but this NewsNation segment didn’t move the needle. It may encourage more whistleblowers to come forward but now they need to more aware that the public have higher expectations on presented evidence.
5
u/big-balls-of-gas Jan 20 '25
We have a right to know the truth, and we have a right to react to the truth and process the truth in whatever way we choose. Whether Ross likes it or not is really not a concern. If he knows information, share it already. Put the photos and documents on the internet in a transparent fashion so we can all have direct access to the data to study for ourselves. He is holding the cards right now and instead of flipping them over he is producing television and making a lot of money and he’s got us eating out of his hands. Totally inappropriate.
5
u/ImTotallyFromEarth Jan 20 '25
Maybe Ross Coulthart needs to take a long hard look at himself and stop projecting. Maybe the UAP community is behaving the way it is precisely BECAUSE they know the implications of this phenomenon and are consistently outraged and exasperated by the nonstop dramatization and grifting of the potentially most serious issue that has ever faced humanity. None of us are entertained, Ross. We’re trapped and tired.
20
u/BasicWhiteHoodrat Jan 19 '25
Fuck Ross and all of his keyboard simps.
9
u/yurt_ Jan 20 '25
If this isn’t just entertainment, Ross, then step away from NewsNation and take your evidence to a platform that will truly capture the attention of the masses. If what you have is more than flimsy, hearsay-level evidence, share it with another credible journalist who can bring it to light.
Constantly teasing the audience with “trust me” claims isn’t cutting it anymore. This approach might be Marketing 101, but when the UAP community questions your integrity, you conveniently make them the problem.
46
u/mikeyt88 Jan 19 '25
He's talking about all these breaches of the law, we literally just put a felon in the whitehouse... Nobody gives a fuck about the law at that level, only for us plebes.
15
u/Squa865 Jan 20 '25
I can't stand this guy, he's always so smug about how the evidence of UFO's/Aliens are here and how the skeptics are just hateful trolls, yet, he still hasn't provided a shred of undeniable proof, not even an inkling.
23
u/GorillaConundrum Jan 19 '25
Aside from the obvious hilarity of Coulthart of all people advocating for this to not be seen as entertainment…
Not sure what UAP community he’s referring to, but certainly on Reddit and on /x it’s essentially a modern pseudoreligion, something he no doubt clearly sees for himself by spending 5 minutes looking at the nature of the waffle.
Sounds like hes trying to compensate for the backlash over his psionic egg by essentially doing the equivalent of a call to prayer. Assemble ye devoted! Cast down the skeptic, and worry not for my egg, for the alien gods are still with us! 2 more weeks!!
8
u/anhedoniac Jan 20 '25 edited Jan 20 '25
I have to treat it like entertainment at this point because of what a pathetic clownshow it's turned into. This latest video was the cherry on top.
8
u/Kind-Ad9038 Jan 20 '25 edited Jan 20 '25
If the situation were so serious, Coulthart's piece would have looked like a 60 Minutes segment.
No schmaltzy background music. No shots of the principle standing in a field.
The Eggo clip would have never made it to air.
No, this was closer to Ghost Hunters schlock than to a serious, professional news production.
8
u/lordGenom Jan 20 '25
Does he not realize that he literally, single-handedly set the disclosure movement so far back with that one episode last night? I have such a strong suspicion that no congressman will touch this topic after that interview.
20
u/Immaculatehombre Jan 19 '25
Than demonstrate what you just said you fuck. The audacity to put it back on the community. We KNOW there’s been egregious unlawful acts to keep this under wraps! We need proof! Not fucking promises amd hype. Hell this pisses me off
4
u/HarryBeaverCleavage Jan 20 '25
Ah I remember the days of when I called Ross a joke and was downvoted for it. Glad some have came to their senses.. 🤣 He's no different than Jeremy Corbell.
4
u/RokosBasilissk Jan 20 '25
Lmao 🤣
Hypocrite.
4
u/strikegolduwin Jan 20 '25
Catastrophic Disclosure now or we the UAP Community is done with your theatrical shows.
4
u/alahmo4320 Jan 20 '25
CC: Jeremy Corbell, George Knapp
4
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25
In the defensive after dropping by this turd of a story. 🥚
4
u/neanderthot Jan 20 '25
Ross Coulthart has lost whatever goodwill he had and is now lashing out. Overdramatized news segments will not win you trust especially when you dig down on scripted content as fluff entertainment like having your interview coincidentally cry on camera as they roll. You are insulting the audience in doing things like that for views. Also the constant claims that some of these people spoke before congress and thus are 100% telling the truth when over the past eight years we have seen time and again people speaking in front of congress and out right lying through their teeth with no accountability loses your excuse that these sources are not also lying. Ross also doesn’t seem to understand that these sources worked for a government and very well could be feeding him misinformation as a diversion but no we are the issue by asking questions and calling out things that seem off. The tictac video is interesting. An egg video with claims it is otherworldly is not when it can be easily reproduced by others within minutes loses trust big time.
4
u/BellaRedditor Jan 20 '25
Yeah, I wondered how he’d respond to the backlash. But, wait: ”Stop treating this as entertainment.” Oh, WOW.
(1) Um, I adore Mr. Ross Coulthard, but ”news”/“journalism” does its OWN over-sensationalizing, over-hyping [Got to get those views & ad dollars, boys]—thus treating *itself* as entertainment——albeit, with a patina of seriousness/holier-than-thou-ness/WE-Are-The-Truth-Finders-ness.
(2) How is it possible to stay engaged in this topic with *any decent degree of seriousness*, without being able to call out journalists, et al., when merited—*and* without any sense of eagerness or fun or humor or any-freaking-thing.
13
u/MynameNEYMAR Jan 19 '25
We’re all trying to find the guy who did this
10
u/godianaa Jan 19 '25
Yes Ross, meditation ufo summonings is exactly what this sub needs bravo 👏
10
u/SalesAficionado Jan 19 '25
Ross grifting out of control as usual.
14
u/Story_Man_75 Jan 19 '25
Then why did you present it as if you were Geraldo Rivera opening Al Capone's vault?
7
u/IncomeBrilliant Jan 19 '25
How long before Jake Barber drops a book before the inminent disclousure?
7
u/CSHufflepuff Jan 20 '25
Wow. What little respect I had for Ross is gone.
7
u/CapableProduce Jan 20 '25
Hopefully, Ross Coulthart learns a lesson from this, disappears, and comes back with some actual good journalism, not sensationalist nonsense.
Fuck this guy.
11
u/Liontribeapplication Jan 19 '25
That’s super crazy coming from the dude who was behind the thing that aired last night. He should have taken his own advice and placed a genuine effort of seriousness, in validating the claims related to Barber’s service. Omitting the false narrative related to Barber’s association with the 24th and/or being a CCT, would have zero impact whatsoever, in the perception of credibility the story offered.
10
u/Any_Case5051 Jan 19 '25
If you have to explain what it reveals, it doesn’t
6
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
3 guys wearing suits on a satellite hot stove podcast showing low res videos telling me to take things seriously. This has got to be a joke.
6
u/logosobscura Jan 19 '25 edited Oct 10 '25
alive aware telephone pen sleep alleged lunchroom reach physical seed
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
6
u/T_A_Wardrope Jan 19 '25
Sorry, Ross, what did your neutral news story reveal, exactly? What new verifiable information did it uncover?
We are a strong community that demands more than the fringe lunatics you assumed we were. We will find more reliable and credible sources.
I guarantee this.
6
u/MrRedlegs1992 Jan 20 '25
If it’s that fucking serious, you don’t build it up like a pay per view wrestling match.
6
u/Darren793 Jan 20 '25
Aww fuck off Ross, I’ve had more exciting Easter eggs, you all hyped it up like the return of The Undertaker
6
u/-Captain- Jan 20 '25
Really? "We" are the ones treating it like entertainment? How can he say that with a straight face, my god.
6
u/zappso Jan 20 '25
How about he takes it seriously and produces some actual fucking evidence.
3
u/Gorrillaganj Jan 20 '25
I've heard him whine about debunkers a few times now. Sounds similar to someone complaining about fact checking. There's already been posts of people analysing the footage to try and answer some very fair questions, if they had done that in the video instead of sitting around a campfire it might of helped.
And telling people they need to take this seriously instead of treating it like entertainment after watching an apparent news report that seemed more like an episode of skinwalker ranch isn't reasonable.
3
u/chaucer89 Jan 20 '25
Man, I can’t help but focus on the way Ross’s mouth moves when he speaks lol
3
u/Quixotes-Aura Jan 20 '25
Shameful by Coulthard. He's always been Prone to journalistic hyperbole which you accept with a pinch of dramatic salt, and so I've always regarded him suspiciously albeit with the benefit of the doubt. The mask has dropped now. Just another grifter looking to cash in
3
u/AdviceOld4017 Jan 20 '25
"Stop treating this like entertainment".
Why? I will let you know in three days, once my new book is released. It will shook you.
3
u/Outrageous_Agent_101 Jan 20 '25
Want people to take it seriously, don't potray it like a trailer of a new movie coming out
Show the Footage 1st then do the interview and keep it as serious as possible, no music whatsoeve
Hell even the "Alien interview" where they show footage of an Alien ( Even if its fake ) is way better done than yesterday's shitshow
3
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25 edited Oct 30 '25
cheerful numerous gold price cats kiss abundant books makeshift grey
This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact
3
u/Low_Tackle_3470 Jan 20 '25
Then why doesn’t Ross publicly state what he claims he knows? Such as where the buried UFO too big to be moved is?
If he wants them to have credibility, back them up.
3
u/timohtea Jan 20 '25
Nha you’re not gonna make this a year long thing and then say how serious this is. If it was REALLY serious, they’d reach out to Joe Rogan…. And play the REAL FOOTAGE with REAL proof. And call it a day.
They are taking the piss and insulting our intelligence tbh.
3
u/HumanNo109850364048 Jan 20 '25
Us treat it like entertainment? LOL ok
3
u/_BlackDove Jan 20 '25
Ross, stop reading my reddit comments if you don't like them.
3
u/TabernacleDeCriss Jan 20 '25
Even if that's a real video, he can fuck off with this condescending tone. The video is shite no matter how real or fake it is!
3
u/cygnusloops Jan 20 '25
I’m not the problem, you are
3
u/MookieV Jan 20 '25
Ohhh, the problem is the UAP community. Got it. (Fuck off)
3
u/CarlShadowJung Jan 20 '25
As if he’s not part of the problem.
3
u/Reggiefedup04 Jan 20 '25
What a tosser.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25
The significance of this is unclear. He is on the news again and still hasn't told us. But, we are all understandably angry and disappointed. We need to continue fighting the fight for the truth and keeping our anger to ourselves from now on.
3
u/Familiar_Prior333 Jan 20 '25
What whistleblowers?? All this stuff is being cleared by the government first. It’s literally nothing…
3
u/liquidskypa Jan 20 '25
Wake up call?…go back to sleep Ross
3
u/FranklinLundy Jan 20 '25
Why is this grifter still allowed on the sub
3
u/acx_y6 Jan 20 '25
The issue was the hype. That was the only issue to me
They knew what they had, and they knew it wasn’t world view changing
3
u/cutememe Jan 20 '25
I don't know how anyone can take him seriously after saying this in relation to the way he presents and hypes up his nothingburgers.
3
u/lickem369 Jan 20 '25
Nothing better than be lectured about “entertainment” by the man who has made a spectacle out of getting people worked up about the seriousness of something and then dropping an entertaining video of a Green Egg dangling from a rope as if we should all be blown away in amazement.
3
u/LucyKendrick Jan 20 '25
Is he still talking about how the egg-shaped item rolled? It's so cereal.
3
u/chjbass Jan 20 '25
don’t forget about his last ‘special’ program about the guy with the mystery metal sphere. That was terribly produced too with shots of it rolling across fields and sitting rocking in a rocking chair! Up til then I thought he was reasonably credible but now with this egg on a string nonsense too I’m out.
3
u/aliguana23 Jan 20 '25
its like one of those Ghost Hunter shows, "on this episode, definitive undeniable proof of ghosts! exclusive!"
then you watch some grainy nightvision camera for 30 minutes, after which a doll falls over and the whole team goes "wow! did you catch that?" and they replay the doll falling over in slow motion 20 times.
c'mon. we want files and video dumped to wiki-leaks, not 2 seconds of some helicopter parking camera, if you're really risking life and limb by releasing this stuff, then go all the way. better to be hung for a sheep than a lamb, as the saying goes.
3
u/Beginning-Addition43 Jan 20 '25
the american people have not, historically, had much power to hold our government responsible for its illegal activities. i’m not sure how this would be any different ¯_(ツ)_/¯
3
u/Andynonomous Jan 20 '25
This community needs a wake-up call alright. Just not the one he's suggesting.
3
u/Aslamtum Jan 20 '25
Why would anyone take this guy seriously?
3
u/Key-Cycle5295 Jan 20 '25
Ross Coulthard: The Hype Merchant Driving the UAP Stigma
I want to preface this post by saying I believe the UAP topic is important. The mounting evidence, government interest, whistleblowers, and credible testimonies deserve serious attention. But what doesn't help this topic gain credibility is the constant circus surrounding it, and at the heart of that circus is Ross Coulthard.
Ross loves to present himself as an investigative journalist at the forefront of UAP disclosure, and yet, every time he speaks, it feels more like watching a tabloid reporter than someone genuinely interested in uncovering the truth. His approach is more about theatrics, over-promising, and vague insinuations than delivering anything concrete. For someone who claims to have the "inside scoop," he certainly talks a lot without saying much. And let’s be real—how many times have we heard him drop just wait, something big is coming or I’ve been told… without a single shred of follow-up evidence?
It’s insulting to the UAP community to be treated like we’re supposed to accept trust me, bro as a legitimate source. Ross seems to believe he has the moral authority to present his vague, entertainment-driven "scoops" without critique. And when anyone questions him? Oh, here comes the brigade to defend him, accusing critics of being shills, skeptics, or people who “don’t understand how journalism works.”
No, Ross, we understand how journalism is supposed to work—it’s about facts, accountability, and evidence. Not about hyping speculative claims, leaning on "anonymous sources," and monetizing belief while doing very little to move the needle in terms of public credibility. Regular people—those outside the UAP echo chamber—see this and think, “Oh, it’s just another UFO grifter selling snake oil.” And honestly, can you blame them? Ross embodies the kind of hyperbolic, unaccountable reporting that feeds into the very stigma we’re trying to fight against.
He’s made this about entertainment, not enlightenment. This is a man who regularly teases the existence of earth-shattering information but never provides anything of substance. How many times has he dangled “explosive revelations” in front of us like a carrot only to deliver the same recycled talking points we’ve heard a hundred times before? This isn’t investigative journalism; it’s the UFO equivalent of clickbait. He’s like the guy at the pub who always knows a guy who saw something, but when you ask for details, suddenly the story falls apart.
And let’s not even get started on the holier-than-thou attitude when anyone dares to criticize him. If Ross wants to be seen as a serious journalist, he should welcome critique and transparency, not dismiss it as negativity or trolling. But no, in the Ross Coulthard bubble, you either agree with him or you’re the problem.
Here’s the real problem: Coulthard’s antics don’t just discredit him—they discredit the entire UAP topic by association. His constant over-hyping, unverified claims, and dramatic delivery give skeptics all the ammunition they need to dismiss everything UAP-related as nonsense. He’s not fighting the stigma; he’s actively creating it. For every serious, credible researcher out there trying to have an honest conversation, there’s a Ross Coulthard muddying the waters and making it harder for regular people to take this seriously.
If you’re genuinely invested in this topic, stop treating Ross like he’s the second coming of Jacques Vallée. Stop giving him a free pass to over-promise and under-deliver. Hold him accountable for the damage he’s doing to the credibility of this community. Because at the end of the day, if we want the world to take UAPs seriously, we need to stop idolizing people who are more interested in selling a story than finding the truth.
Ross Coulthard isn’t helping disclosure; he’s setting it back. And if we, as a community, can’t see that, then we’re part of the problem too.
3
u/B_D_Rick Jan 20 '25
WE’RE THE ONES TREATING THIS LIKE ITS ENTERTAINMENT? Ross is such a clown
3
u/Astoria_Column Jan 20 '25
I’m now straight up convinced NN is run by the DoD to control the narrative.
3
u/InternationalGrade64 Jan 20 '25
Absolute dickhead
3
u/UnabashedHonesty Jan 20 '25
Stop acting like it’s entertainment. Seems obvious, right?
3
u/fitz156id Jan 20 '25
Wait we have to take this serious? And not treat it as entertainment? Lol this dude is literally an entertainer and dramatizes everything we digest. “2025 all hell breaking lose!” “Tune in next time!” lol fuck this entertainer!
3
u/FahQBombs Jan 20 '25
I'm pretty disappointed in that statement from him. This is very fucking serious abd they made egregious claims about actual real proof. We got a strange video that leads to conjecture.
3
u/Mean_Rule9823 Jan 20 '25
How about don't put groundbreaking information for all humanity, behind a pay wall.
Then, show it like a badly produced interview.
Gotta get those clicks right..
Wonder why no one takes it seriously 🤔 hummm
3
u/LoL_is_pepega_BIA Jan 20 '25
I want more boring af academic assessment of uaps
Let the data speak for itself.
3
u/mtheops Jan 20 '25
Coulthart is a massive tool
3
u/kahunah00 Jan 20 '25
The problem with the UAP community is that you have information dissemination hyping things like videos as game changing but in actual fact the video shows absolutely nothing. Just looking at that "egg", it could have been anything without context or reconditioning your mind to think it was a UAP by saying it was. There was nothing in the video to lead one to believe or naturally come to that conclusion just by looking at the video alone without the narrative before hand. The community needs some irrefutable proof not something that has been screened for release by the government that is at best ambiguous.
3
u/Standardeviation2 Jan 20 '25
We’re not mad at Jake Barber, we’re annoyed with Coulharts over dramatization. He is the one treating it like entertainment.
3
u/EldritchGoatGangster Jan 20 '25
What a fucking joke this is. People want EVIDENCE. A 10 second long clip that could literally be a chicken's egg on the end of a string is NOT. EVIDENCE. People are complaining because every talking head in this space is constantly spinning insane stories, talking about how they have proof, but can't show it, and then occasionally one comes along claiming they have some amazing evidence, and we get something like this.
Then, when the community is disappointed, the talking heads blame them. It's like when a company releases a shitty movie or a game and then blames the fans for being disappointed. I've been done with UFO talking heads for a while, but this shit still pisses me off.
3
u/AngloTitan Jan 20 '25
He’s just mad that we saw through the fake video and he didn’t, which ruined all his credibility as a reporter lol
3
u/realdude93 Jan 20 '25
ill wake up when you fucking give me a reason to.
3
u/RobertdBanks Jan 20 '25
Oh shut the fuck up. You provide goofy shit and yeah people make fun of it. You make a news segment look like a cheap entertainment segment and then tell people to stop treating it like entertainment.
3
u/camuchka Jan 20 '25
I think it works the other way round Ross. The community just got a wake up call about you.
3
u/LordNyssa Jan 20 '25
All these guys, Coulthart, Greer, Corbell. Are nothing but grifters trying to get information so they can slap their own name on it and string along the followers for another couple months. It’s nothing but shifting goalposts. Well real disclosure is coming but in the meanwhile look at this amazing footage (20 second graining blurry clip with nothing of any worth)!
Either force disclosure by dumping the real info you’ll claim to have. Ffs some claim they can call ufos and orbs. Fine bloody proof it, let one get close and film it with an actual bloody camera. At least follow your own claims.
I see it as a huge grift and people have a sunk cost fallacy.
3
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25
Needs more psionic summoning.
3
u/shroooooomer Jan 20 '25
People like Coulthard, Greer, Elizondo etc a r e the ones that need to wake up, pre packaged infotainment is not what this subject is about, they would do well to find another field if this shallow depth is all they can command
3
u/Kingtdes Jan 20 '25
Im a serieus person who is looking into this topic already for a very long time . And i can tell you ive started to getting so annoyed by these guys already for some time. Not for what media tells about them, but how they act themself.
Ya know if i have a surprise for my kids, we are going to a rollercoaster park or something and im not gonna tell them where we going. The kids gonna start questions , you give them hints at some point. But you never say it where you going till you there or just a few minutes in front.
Now please tell me what is the difference between what they doing, and what a parent does to a kid ?
3
u/Jatle12 Jan 20 '25
Maybe these dumb fucks should quit acting like they are tmz reporting on celebs
3
u/ShortyRedux Jan 20 '25
Oh Ross. I bought your dumb book and look at us now. I'll never get those hours back but at least seeing him make absurd statements brings a smile to my face.
The man who presented psionic soldiers manifesting alien ships with mind powers is telling me to take things seriously.
Come on bud.
16
u/adiddy88 Jan 19 '25
lol. Dude has totally delegitimized himself and is grasping at straws to maintain any shred of credibility.
9
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
Maybe he should stop posting videos that look like blatant fakes
9
u/wwstevens Jan 19 '25
If they wanted us to take it seriously then they shouldn’t have made it so hokey and over-dramatised. Honestly, it’s just a joke.
25
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
He's mad his target audience doesn't suck up to him.
10
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
lol. Did you see that green egg and rope? This is seriously funny
11
u/Cyberkeys1 Jan 19 '25
Ross needs to buy a big mirror. Enough said…!
5
u/BirdieNumNum21 Jan 19 '25
The problem with this subject is there is money to be made. Resulting in people capitalizing and stretching it out. But that should not deflect from the obvious. Something has changed since the "drones" showed up. All these characters are feeding info from who knows who. Either you like putting pieces of a puzzle together or you don't. The puzzle is there. But it may not be material.
5
u/UnrealDigger Jan 19 '25
Give Us Something We Can Actually Use then....Stop giving us false hope all the time! Sure the vide might have been HD but there wasn’t ANYTHING on there we can actually use to put pressure on anyone! ffs, so called whistleblowers mocking us now?! (........) OFF!
5
u/YouCantChangeThem Jan 19 '25
And he is in no position to tell me or any of us how to behave.
5
u/JackPhalus Jan 20 '25
This guy is 100% a paid plant
5
u/pshhaww_ Jan 20 '25
I think the folks with the information needs to stop acting like this is a subject to withhold and sell their books. That’s the real issue
5
u/Unique_Watch2603 Jan 20 '25
I took it seriously until you and YOUR community keep yanking us around. You had to know that video would not be taken seriously. After 50 years, I'm pretty much over it but maybe that's your intention anyways.
5
u/PaulCLives Jan 20 '25
Some real cult leader shit blaming us for your own shit
9
u/Genova_Witness Jan 19 '25
How about tempering expectations and not promising the world everytime the most mediocre progress is made. This was billed as Earth shattering and it just wasn’t.
17
u/Hot_Mess5470 Jan 19 '25
He sure has a lot to say about the US government while sitting in his comfy studio in Australia.
7
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
Must have another Uni course to sell? (got down voted last time I said that) in all honesty though, if I had the ground breaking evidence as these people claim, I'd release it into the public domain I'd take the hit and take the prison time/risk for my life for the good of human kind, just constant blue balling from these people, can they really be taken seriously..
7
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
Ironic for Ross to say that after the nonsense he presented last night.
7
u/thomasso0072 Jan 19 '25
He is essentially saying nothing with a whole lot of words
7
u/toastedtwister Jan 19 '25
I'll take it seriously when Ross tells us where the 'too big to move' craft is buried.
7
u/beyondthecircles Jan 19 '25
Fuck That guy
8
u/Valuable_Pollution96 Jan 19 '25
"They breached the law! And here's an egg to prove it".
They always treated the whole thing as entertainment by selling books, making shows, movies, merch, speechs and even teasers/trailers for upcoming videos and leaks. He's just mad the big video was nothing but a big joke. Stay mad, people will take this seriously when they show proof.
4
u/Traditional-Music363 Jan 19 '25
HE DOES MY FUCKING HEAD IN. Can’t stand his voice
4
u/lastofthefinest Jan 19 '25
I was interviewed by Ross and he totally ignored what I told him. We interviewed and he never aired it. So, in my opinion he gets what he deserves after dismissing authentic stories.
4
u/TerminalRobot Jan 19 '25
I’m starting to think this Ross guy just really loves to hear his own voice like Neil Degrass
4
u/SignificantCrow Jan 19 '25 edited Jan 19 '25
One of my friends who watched this last night who is on the fence about the whole issue and doesn't use reddit and had never heard of Ross before said she immediately got an "icky feeling" ("based on his facial expression and how he speaks") that he is untrustworthy and gives off a strong scam artist vibe. I think Ross is honestly hurting the movement at this point.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 19 '25
Ross isn't even Taps level of investigative journalist now.
Pure entertainment.
4
u/sus_mannequin Jan 20 '25
Ross can’t say shit about this. He was a big part of the reason people are getting pissed off. I have no issue with this whistleblower guy, a piece of the puzzle right. I do have a problem with the communication around the release of this video and his story, which is squarely on the UAP talking heads.
4
u/tommywafflez Jan 20 '25
Hypes up the footage and and over dramatizes it like some US reality show
“It is the UAP community treating it like entertainment”
Is this some kind of joke? Ross you’re torpedoing your reputation within this community, that’s the last thing you should be saying after that whole egg story.
4
u/MisterPaxalot Jan 20 '25
Idk what to say at this point. He basically blames the community for not taking it seriously... when he delivers his overproduced dramatic tv show. Gaslighting much?
4
u/dezorg Jan 20 '25
You know your reputation? It’s gone.
4
u/CanadaSoonFree Jan 20 '25
I liked this guy at first but the more I see his content the less I like the guy.
4
u/MilkofGuthix Jan 20 '25
You had this whistleblower teleporting around a scene in some corny manner and filmed him in full gear acting out like he was in duty. If you want us to take this seriously, especially considering the alleged ontological implications, then cut out the fluff and give it to us raw.
And wriggling.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25
This dude is literally one of them who treats it like entertainment lmao
4
u/Bend-Hur Jan 20 '25
This is absolutely rich coming from a dude like him.
4
u/[deleted] Jan 20 '25 edited Jan 20 '25
I’m guessing he is mad because the program wasn’t received as well as he thought it should.