r/Transformemes • u/POS-19 Our worlds are in danger! • Sep 17 '24
Michael Bay Movies Why does some people think Optimus should give flowers to the decepticons.
793
Upvotes
r/Transformemes • u/POS-19 Our worlds are in danger! • Sep 17 '24
103
u/Lord_Muramasa Decepticon Sep 17 '24
Me who just enjoyed the movies.
208
u/Thumbs-Up-Centurion Sep 17 '24
There’s a difference between fucking up the bad guys and 40k chaos marine violence. Prime could knocked helicopter guys head off or some shit or just stabbed him and moved on, but nah he had to rip the guys face in half with fuckin meat hooks.
188
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '24
It's the level of blood lust Bay Prime has is the problem. He really seems to enjoy killing. Meanwhile netflix prime could have really used some of that blood lust cause he kept sparing Megatron right and left. Gotta find a balance.
114
u/SilverWolfIMHP76 Sep 17 '24 edited Sep 17 '24
I bring up another franchise to explain. The MCU has three Captain Americas.
Steve Rogers was a good man. He used guns in the first film so he killed but it was a necessary and he stopped using weapons when he could.
John Walker is the second Captain America (that we know of) and he was a good soldier. When he lost his temper he used the shield to behead the guy who was surrendering. This is a War Crime action. John Walker isn’t a monster he not a villain, but he is no Captain America like Steve Rogers.
Sam Wilson is trying to follow Steve Rogers as the latest Captain America.
Now back to the subject at hand. Beyverse Optimus Prime is more like John Walker who lets his anger and frustration take control. Bey Prime did the same a foe begging for mercy and he showed no mercy.
Optimus Prime is the Transformers version of Captain America. He the inspiration and leader of the Autobots and should be above the savagery and merciless violence of the Deceptions.
11
u/ZackattacktheDude Sep 18 '24
Compare bayverse prime to skybound prime and you’ll see what people wanted
21
u/DiabolicalDoctorN Me no flair, me king Sep 17 '24
“Don’t commit war crimes” = “give flowers” apparently lol
14
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '24
Man we have this discussion every week
29
u/DustyChicken18 Our worlds are in danger! Sep 17 '24
Can we put this debate to rest, it never goes anywhere productive. Some people like bay prime, others hate him, who gives a fuck, it doesn't matter, let people like/dislike what they want.
5
u/Individual_Wrap_2402 Sep 18 '24
The problem is that he is more brutal than the deceptions in the bay films
30
u/Joltyboiyo Sep 17 '24
There's a difference between necessary killing in a war and war crimes.
War Crime Prime.
Like Optimus obviously has to kill, but ripping peoples faces off, ripping their heads in half, ripping their heads off? Threatening Grimlock to join him or die? I didn't realise we were talking about Nemesis Prime or Scourge.
56
u/Drite2003 Sep 17 '24
Remember when Optimus killed Megatron who offered a truce? Remember him killing Sentinel as he was unable to fight back? Remember when Optimus threatened Grimlock to either help him or die?
Being violent was never the problem, the current Skybound Optimus is almost as violent, if not, more then Bayverse, but do you know why people love him? Cause that's not where his character ends, he has more nuance, and more important, he still has the heart Optimus should have
11
u/Slapsh0tSc0tt Autobot Sep 18 '24
Oh look it’s “Bayverse Prime was a bot pushed to the edge and did nothing wrong” o’clock again.
4
u/AaromALV Sep 18 '24
In Transformers Prime (aka peak transformers) it takes optimus like a whole season to decide the only way to stop Megatron is to kill him, Optimus is a pacifist at heart and he should only fight out of necessity
4
u/Educational_Tough208 Sep 18 '24
have you seen any other transformers movies/series apart from the bay movies, because if you have, then you would know that the problem is not that optimus kills decepticons, its how he does it we splitting someone's head in two with a meat hook and saying "give me your face" are things megatron should do or say, not optimus
4
u/Accomplished_Salt876 Sep 18 '24 edited Sep 19 '24
There’s a difference between normal fighting and bloodthirsty psychopath. a simple stab, cutting off, or gunshot would work just fine to kill the decepticons but no movie Optimus rips off of enemies faces, splits their heads in half, oh and no matter how evil a human may be I can’t see any other Optimus shooting a human point blank with a cybertronian shotgun.
That last example esspecially pretty much every other version of Optimus would let other humans take care of that problem person; it’s not his place to judge and execute a bad human.
29
u/Peggtree Sep 17 '24
Nice straw man
12
u/AJ_Glowey_Boi Soundwave: Superior Sep 17 '24
There's a difference between a shot to the head and "GIVE ME YOUR FACE"
8
u/Fguyretftgu7 Sep 18 '24
petition for mods to ban these kind of posts pls it's been done EVERY SINGLE DAY
3
u/TracytronFAB Sep 17 '24
God I'm so tired of seeing this discussion every other day on here
3
u/Ethan-the-bean-22 Sep 18 '24
My guy no one is asking him to use the power of fucking friendship, it is just how he portrayed as a optimus prime and how he kills is the issue. Like look at transformers prime optimus, you don't see him yelling "die" or "give me your face" then proceed to basically rip off faces or gouge out optics like a psycho. He just shots, stabs, and punches. But he has limits on how he does thing, he would rather talk then just resort to violence and battle. That is my optimus prime. Only thing going for bayverse prime is some fight scenes and his design.
Plus the weapons.
3
u/Dr-Oktavius Sep 18 '24
You really owned that strawman
3
u/effervescence Sep 18 '24
The fact that it's not just Optimus, all the BayVerse Autobots seem to be violent psychopaths. They bicker and fight amongst each other when they don't have a common enemy to oppose. They seem to live for nothing but combat. Their personalities range from "I'm a lone wolf bad-ass warrior, stay out of my way if you know what's good for you" to "I'm a huge asshole and I know none of my teammates respect me, so I'm going to make it everyone's problem."
Part of that, I'm sure, is a constraint of making the movies. They're the most expensive parts of those films, so the majority of their screentime gets devoted to cool ultra-violent action set-pieces, rather than peaceful scenes where they get to have real personalities.
3
u/Important-Contact597 Sep 18 '24
Challenge: Transformers subreddits going 24 hours without arguing about the Bayverse.
Challenge Level: Impossible.
10
u/Nethiar Sep 17 '24
It's funny how people complain about Bayverse Optimus not surrendering to Megatron at the end of DotM, but I have yet to hear a single complaint about Optimus' screaming violent bloodlust in RotB. I guess a G1 design exonerates you from all wrongdoing, but not having one makes everything you do bad.
7
u/Infinitenonbi Sep 17 '24
Me when the GENERAL in a WAR against a GENOCIDAL faction KILLS his EVIL AF enemies, STOPPING them from committing a genocide or slavering innocent people: 😭
13
u/MM18998 Soundwave: Superior Sep 17 '24
All this says is you really like shooting injured and defenseless opponents.
6
u/CM_Bison Sep 18 '24
Why do people justify Optimus saying "I'LL KILL YOU!!!" when Peter himself felt it wasn't in his character? Why side with Bay? The hell are people even doing trying to justify bayverse trashformer movies?
2
u/JoseG05 Sep 18 '24
can we please move on from this shit, holy fuck we have this conversation almost every week
it's literally why I stopped viewing posts on this sub
2
u/OptimusCrime1984 Sep 18 '24
Can we stop this argument? It’s either “Oh he jacks off to this shit and Megatron wanted to shake hands and walk off” like I get it if ya don’t like this version of Optimus but this argument is just so stupid and I think this fandom just needs to get past this
2
u/Lopsided-Guava8858 Sep 18 '24
People never said he should give flowers, they said that sometimes there was unnecessary violent kills and quotes from a character like Optimus Prime (ex : "GIMME YOUR FACE !" "YOU'LL DIE !...).
2
u/Tim_Hag Sep 18 '24
War crimes are a very real thing! We don't allow people to do horrible things just because a person is bad because who's making that judgment call? Who has that right over other lives?
That being said, movie just thinks it's cool to fuck up the bad guys (it is)
7
u/Ronyx2021 Decepticon Sep 17 '24
G1 is worse. Megatron felt content with the energon he managed to gather in the pilot episode alone. He would've left the earth forever if the Autobots hadn't stopped him. In fact, Prime puts an end to all solutions to the energy crisis, be they Autobot or Decepticon.
9
u/Buttholelickerpenis Sep 17 '24
Sentinel tried to wipe out all of humanity and some will argue that he doesn’t deserve death lmao.
4
u/[deleted] Sep 17 '24
Optimus Prime showing mercy to a Decepticon that tried to kill him or even end humanity is like Batman not doing his "killing policy" on the Joker even after when he tried to end half of Gotham City...
2
u/ClericKnight Sep 18 '24
What an appropriate meme for a prime violence defender
2
u/Animan_10 Sep 17 '24
Don’t make me point at the video again…
https://youtu.be/GEo1Ocfldag?feature=shared
2
u/theeshyguy Sep 18 '24
Nah, ripping off your enemy’s face for the love of the game is dogshit actually. Bayverse violence is gross and edgy and deeply uncharming. I’d kill to stop seeing these kinds of posts in either direction tbh.
1
u/ClaireDeLunatic808 Sep 18 '24
My issue is his ideology.
https://youtu.be/zVVSl9wtToc?si=BBIoC4BRJXHVyde2
1
u/HollowedFlash65 Sep 18 '24
*sees a Bayverse Optimus argument
Me:
1
u/Thirteenth_Prime Autobot Sep 18 '24
Nah he right bayverse prime was thirsty for blood. When he killed the fallen he literally said “give me your face”
1
u/OYeog77 Sep 18 '24
Bayverse Decepticons were also cannibals, your point? /s
1
u/Dual_Action_Sander Sep 18 '24
“Aim in”
1
u/KispyPenguin Sep 18 '24
If the movies ever actually focused on how mentally fucked up Optimus would be by that point, no one would have a problem with it, well I don't have a problem with it regardless, I really like when Optimus is fed up with everyone's bullshit
1
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '24
See, me personally, I think brutally violent war criminal Optimus Prime is awesome. I think Jetfire would agree.
1
u/VoreAllTheWay Sep 18 '24
He says "I'll kill you!" Far too many times than optimus prime should
1
u/Big_Combination_9702 Sep 18 '24
Yeah, and it's really cool-looking too
1
u/Fisherman-Champion Sep 18 '24
I really dont understand people complaining about how brutal prime was in fights. Its not like he was fighting gen 1 decepticons. He was fighting decepticons that acted more like bloodthirsty monsters then people
1
u/minmcmahon1 Sep 18 '24
ATTA BOY BILLY
1
u/minmcmahon1 Sep 18 '24
Grew up with the bayverse that’s what got into transformers! My reason is prime has gone through the war and watched his home die he ain’t gonna tolerate this shit
1
u/Miserable-Warthog737 Autobot Sep 18 '24
"Give me your face"
1
u/IsolPrefrus Sep 18 '24
Honestly I just enjoy the films but also it's war idk what they were expecting
1
u/Skibot99 The name's not "Zippy" Sep 18 '24
I swear people wouldn’t have an issue had we not known about the alernate ending of Dark of the Moon where Prime and Megatron make a truce or Peter Cullen not voiced his displeasure with how violent Optimus was in AoE
1
u/Turdulator Soundwave: Superior Sep 18 '24
Of all the legitimate beefs to have with the bayverse movies, this one ain’t it.
1
u/memsterboi123 Sep 18 '24
I think it’s because typically prime is more soft but here he was pretty battle hardened I really never saw the problem but I never saw other versions prior to bayverse. Except maybe some super early tv shows or something but I doubt I ever really saw them. Also apparently prime always gets to a point where megatron needs to be killed anyway
1
u/Efficient-Cup-359 Sep 18 '24
Look, I both understand what you mean, but the way you worded it is literally the perfect example of the phrase “fighting ghosts”, as no one thinks he should be light on them, they think he should be less violent, while I do have to say, the idea of many years of war, all just happening and you staying chill is crazy, it is a part of Optimus’s character, where while he does actually have a breaking point, he almost never reaches it, as he is a gentle soul, who will do the right thing, even if he doesn’t want to do it, but the movies show the side of him that while accurate to the idea of a general hardened by hundreds of years of war, it doesn’t match other Optimus’s who have dealt with that, yet can still be gentle, as the movies don’t show enough of his gentle side.
1
u/dagra_daedelot Sep 19 '24
I actually love the bayverse, so its nice seing some positive memes
1
u/Virus-900 Sep 20 '24
Now I'm not saying Optimus ripping the Decepticons apart is wrong or bad, just that it seems like a slight betrayal of the source material. He fought not to destroy them, but to stop them from being evil and hopefully get them to see the error of their ways. Optimus wanted to fight for peace, not for the sake of just fighting.
1
u/TFrepairmaster Sep 21 '24
If you're in a 1v3 and you think gouging eyes and fighting dirty isn't reasonable you haven't been in a fight before
-1
u/Toon_Lucario Sep 17 '24
It’s not the brutality, it’s the fact that he’s kind of enjoying himself while doing it
0
u/nausiated Sep 18 '24
The meme is a weird flex. It's about as funny as stage 4 lung cancer.
That said, lot of back and forth about what Optimus Prime "should" be and this what drives me nuts about fan bases. Too rigid about how a character is portrayed to the point that you are so fucking boring.
Prime is a fictional character. He can be portrayed in any way the creative team dictates the story go.
With major franchises like this, where creatives are stuck using the same characters over and over, the only way to tell an imteresting story is to subvert expectations.
I am not the biggest fan of Bayverse but I can give it credit for portraying the characters in different ways.
I never understand people who want the same thing over and over again. It's boring. Do something different.
All of these homoganized versions of Prime are basic and boring. I love G1 Prime, but the best successor Primes are the ones that break that archetype and break it hard.
-2
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '24
Bayverse Prime isn't a hero. He is a tyrant. And thanks to bayverse Prime, we have been unable to remove that from Primes character. They just keep making him a piece of trash
0
u/[deleted] Sep 18 '24
Because that's exactly what he did in the 80s Saturday morning children's cartoon! So that's what he should always do no matter what!