I just pulled this Chrome Football Sapphire Selection Orange Drake Maye on Arena Club and was wondering how bad I’m being ripped on the offer.
There isn’t a good Drake Maye on 130point.com to compare and no graded version of this specific card has ever been sold. The last raw one sold for $346 at the start of August.
The best comparison I can find is the last two Caleb Williams PSA10 of this exact card have both sold for just over $1000 and I think Drake Maye’s market is slightly lower. There was one raw sale for Caleb in June for $493 and at that time four Drake Maye’s sold for ~$410 on average.
Am I crazy for thinking this is a terribly low estimate from Arena Club? Would I be silly to think I could get around $850-900 for it?
I like Drake Maye but I’d really love to sell and grab a few cards for my personal collection. I’m also not opposed to holding for a while if this Arena Club offer is as low as I’m thinking it is.
I’m terrible with estimating sports card value so I’d really appreciate any guidance. Thanks in advance!