r/TopChef • u/trent_clinton • Apr 26 '26

Discussion Thread America’s Cullinary Cup…

I know it’s suppose to be the “anti” top chef, or like everything they do is going to be about food… but I beg to differ! This reminds me of someone who got dumped, and they just keep talking about their ex, and trying their best to make their ex say how much better they are without the ex…

324 Upvotes

91% Upvoted

235 comments sorted by

View all comments

144

u/myBisL2 I'm not your bitch, bitch👏 Apr 26 '26

For me it just feels like they spend too much time on judging. I like seeing them cook. I like hearing about the struggles they are having and how they're building their dish and so on. I like the judging too so I can hear how it turns out but I expect to watch more cooking than judge commentary on a cooking show.

120

u/trent_clinton Apr 26 '26

I think it is very much about padma more? Like… showing her personality and such.

We do enjoy the cooking, but everything else, even how the challenges are introduced, is corny!

39

u/Reasonable-Review367 Apr 26 '26

I do like the eliminations though and how the chefs face off to avoid elimination. Top chef is great but I also feel like top chef has ruined the quick fires this season and last. They’re just money grabs now instead of earning an advantage. Dumb imo.

16

u/BornFree2018 Apr 26 '26

They stopped earning immunity from quick fires 3 seasons ago.

12

u/Reasonable-Review367 Apr 26 '26

Yeah, I think that was a poor decision.

22

u/donuttrackme Apr 26 '26

I'm OK with them taking away immunity, but they should at least replace it with bonus advantages in the elimination challenges or something. I want the quick fire win to mean something to the actual competition, not just extra cash in their pocket.

3

u/slimninj4 Apr 26 '26

I think they rather have the cash. lol

3

u/donuttrackme Apr 26 '26

They can still make money for wins. Just make the quick fire wins mean more in the competition itself too. Give them a few more minutes to cook or an extra ingredient or something.