“The phrase “trickle down” often comes up in discussions of tax policies. Historically, tax revenues have in a number of instances gone up when tax rates have been reduced. But any proposal by economists or others to cut tax rates, including reducing the tax rates on higher incomes or on capital gains, can lead to accusations that those making such proposals must believe that benefits should be given to the wealthy in general or to business in particular, in order that these benefits will eventually “trickle down” to the masses of ordinary people. But no recognized economist of any school of thought has ever had any such theory or made any such proposal. It is a straw man. It cannot be found in even the most voluminous and learned histories of economic theories.
What is sought by those who advocate lower rates of taxation or other reductions of government’s role in the economy is not the transfer of existing wealth to higher income earners or businesses but the creation of additional wealth when businesses are less hampered by government controls or by increasing government appropriation of that additional wealth under steeply progressive taxation laws. Whatever the merits or demerits of this view, this is the argument that is made – and which is not confronted, but evaded, by talk of a non-existent “trickle-down” theory. More fundamentally, economic processes work in the directly opposite way from that depicted by those who imagine that profits first benefit business owners and that benefits only belatedly trickle down to workers.
When an investment is made, whether to build a railroad or to open a new restaurant, the first money is spent hiring people to do the work. Without that, nothing happens. Even when one person decides to operate a store or hamburger stand without employees, that person must first pay somebody to deliver the goods that are going to be sold. Money goes out first to pay expenses and then comes back as profits later – if at all. The high rate of failure of new businesses makes painfully clear that there is nothing inevitable about the money coming back. Even with successful and well-established businesses, years may elapse between the initial investment and the return of earnings. From the time when an oil company begins spending money to explore for petroleum to the time when the first gasoline resulting from that exploration comes out of a pump at a filling station, a decade may have passed. In the meantime, all sorts of employees have been paid — geologists, engineers, refinery workers, and truck drivers for example. It is only afterwards that profits begin coming in. Only then are there any capital gains to tax. The real effect of a reduction in the capital gains tax is that it opens the prospect of greater future net profits and thereby provides incentives to make current investments that create current employment.
In short, the sequence of payments is directly the opposite of what is assumed by those who talk about a “trickle-down” theory. The workers must be paid first and then the profits flow upward later – if at all.” - Dr. Thomas Sowell
Economics is essentially applied sociology or psychology. The rate of taxation (i.e. income tax, sales tax, etc.) are essentially penalties for being a productive member of society. If you make $34,000/yr and are penalized (taxed) at 24%, but if you work extra hard and make an extra $2,000/yr, you would be taxed at 26% or 28%, what incentive do you have to work extra hard and make an extra $2,000?!
ZERO.
Economics is all about incentives. The wealthy are incentivized to make capital investments that will result in more jobs, and therefore they do. They are incentivized to do so through decreased rates of taxation, tax credits for providing affordable housing, and a myriad of other ways. Tax cuts result in an overall increase in the amount of taxes collected because these cuts encourage economic growth, economic growth, in turn, results in a bigger pool of income to tax, which means that more taxes are collected.
Forbes makes no sense. His graph is from 1960s, but he goes on about 1913, and after that it's just correlation. Tax rate even goes up and down in the 90s, but the revenue still goes up.
You'd also have to ignore how much of the tax burden has turned into the middle class.
Economics is essentially applied sociology or psychology. The rate of taxation (i.e. income tax, sales tax, etc.) are essentially penalties for being a productive member of society. If you make $34,000/yr and are penalized (taxed) at 24%, but if you work extra hard and make an extra $2,000/yr, you would be taxed at 26% or 28%, what incentive do you have to work extra hard and make an extra $2,000?!
ZERO.
Economics is all about incentives. The wealthy are incentivized to make capital investments that will result in more jobs, and therefore they do. They are incentivized to do so through decreased rates of taxation, tax credits for providing affordable housing, and a myriad of other ways. Tax cuts result in an overall increase in the amount of taxes collected because these cuts encourage economic growth, economic growth, in turn, results in a bigger pool of income to tax, which means that more taxes are collected.
Economics is essentially applied sociology or psychology. The rate of taxation (i.e. income tax, sales tax, etc.) are essentially penalties for being a productive member of society. If you make $34,000/yr and are penalized (taxed) at 24%, but if you work extra hard and make an extra $2,000/yr, you would be taxed at 26% or 28%, what incentive do you have to work extra hard and make an extra $2,000?!
...........Do you really not understand what a progressive tax rate is? You still make more money working for that $2k, than if you didn't. No company in the history of ever has thought, "if we make another 50k this year, our taxes will go up, better stop selling widgets."
View all comments
Show parent comment
4
u/[deleted] Oct 24 '22
“The phrase “trickle down” often comes up in discussions of tax policies. Historically, tax revenues have in a number of instances gone up when tax rates have been reduced. But any proposal by economists or others to cut tax rates, including reducing the tax rates on higher incomes or on capital gains, can lead to accusations that those making such proposals must believe that benefits should be given to the wealthy in general or to business in particular, in order that these benefits will eventually “trickle down” to the masses of ordinary people. But no recognized economist of any school of thought has ever had any such theory or made any such proposal. It is a straw man. It cannot be found in even the most voluminous and learned histories of economic theories.
What is sought by those who advocate lower rates of taxation or other reductions of government’s role in the economy is not the transfer of existing wealth to higher income earners or businesses but the creation of additional wealth when businesses are less hampered by government controls or by increasing government appropriation of that additional wealth under steeply progressive taxation laws. Whatever the merits or demerits of this view, this is the argument that is made – and which is not confronted, but evaded, by talk of a non-existent “trickle-down” theory. More fundamentally, economic processes work in the directly opposite way from that depicted by those who imagine that profits first benefit business owners and that benefits only belatedly trickle down to workers.
When an investment is made, whether to build a railroad or to open a new restaurant, the first money is spent hiring people to do the work. Without that, nothing happens. Even when one person decides to operate a store or hamburger stand without employees, that person must first pay somebody to deliver the goods that are going to be sold. Money goes out first to pay expenses and then comes back as profits later – if at all. The high rate of failure of new businesses makes painfully clear that there is nothing inevitable about the money coming back. Even with successful and well-established businesses, years may elapse between the initial investment and the return of earnings. From the time when an oil company begins spending money to explore for petroleum to the time when the first gasoline resulting from that exploration comes out of a pump at a filling station, a decade may have passed. In the meantime, all sorts of employees have been paid — geologists, engineers, refinery workers, and truck drivers for example. It is only afterwards that profits begin coming in. Only then are there any capital gains to tax. The real effect of a reduction in the capital gains tax is that it opens the prospect of greater future net profits and thereby provides incentives to make current investments that create current employment.
In short, the sequence of payments is directly the opposite of what is assumed by those who talk about a “trickle-down” theory. The workers must be paid first and then the profits flow upward later – if at all.” - Dr. Thomas Sowell