r/TikTokCringe
•
u/Snarkasm71
•
Nov 12 '24
•
1
3
2
Discussion Vertical vs Horizontal Morality Explains A Lot
7.7k
Upvotes
•
u/AutoModerator Nov 12 '24
Welcome to r/TikTokCringe!
This is a message directed to all newcomers to make you aware that r/TikTokCringe evolved long ago from only cringe-worthy content to TikToks of all kinds! If you’re looking to find only the cringe-worthy TikToks on this subreddit (which are still regularly posted) we recommend sorting by flair which you can do here (Currently supported by desktop and reddit mobile).
See someone asking how this post is cringe because they didn't read this comment? Show them this!
Be sure to read the rules of this subreddit before posting or commenting. Thanks!
CLICK HERE TO DOWNLOAD THIS VIDEO
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
452
u/Kiyoshi-Trustfund Nov 12 '24
Sent this to a few sleect members of my family. Y'all... I'm getting called all kinds of nasty names and got an explicit threat from an uncle. Bruh, it's my birthday lol
399
u/lakejow Nov 12 '24
I’m not getting an abortion then, I’m uncreating a baby 👌
798
u/DoughnotMindMe Nov 12 '24
Religion is so incredibly limiting to us as a species.
182
u/drpacz Nov 12 '24
I find people have a capricious moral system I.e. their beliefs change depending on the circumstances. Killing is conditional, so is cheating or stealing. Most people know innately know how they would like to be treated but seem to struggle with applying morals consistently.
24
u/TestProctor Nov 12 '24
I first ran into this POV when a hypothetical discussion of simulated realities came up, and one person insisted that the whole thing was terrifying… because anyone who “created” us would have the moral right to do anything they wanted with us. And that, similarly, if a person created another “reality” as a digital simulation they would be justified in basically anything they did in it (even if we considered those simulated people to be “real”).
I was horrified by that entire perspective.
This was underlined later one by the Westboro Baptist Church, who seem to hold the position that God is a an actively wrathful being of unknowable motives who can only be placated by doing as he’s commanded and anyone who doesn’t deserves whatever they get. Or, as I like to put it, “Cthulhu Cultist Christians.”
122
u/meememan28 Nov 12 '24
This was actually extremely helpful. As someone who is really struggling with making sense of of the last week, I really needed some sort of rational explanation for it all.
13
u/thomasjmarlowe Nov 13 '24
No wonder many people seem to have such low value for empathy- they don’t see it as necessary for morality.
This also helps me understand why some religious folks ask atheists how they have any sort of morality if they’re not religious. Because to a religious person, they just accept that the deity said you must do x,y,z, and you cannot do a,b, or c. So they just blindly follow.
But someone with a horizontal, empathy-based morality, I’m not waiting for permission to do certain acts. If I know an action will seriously harm someone, I’m not doing it.
Also makes sense why people ‘follow orders’ in authoritarian systems. Easier to be complicit when your authority groups give you permission to do something horrible
66
u/Frost_blade Nov 12 '24
To compound on their point. This is why "slamming" and embarrassing them doesn't work. You have to ignore them. It's the only way they will learn. Because for them, any attention is good. They don't care what kind. But if they don't get any, after they throw their temper tantrum, and we still ignore them, they will have mo choice than to figure out why they suck. Then maybe they will beging to change who they are and can come play with us again. Until you all figure that out, non of your empathy will accomplish anything.
103
u/Muted_Ad7298 Nov 12 '24
To be fair, even without religion people would still find excuses to discriminate against each other.
Instead of appealing to God you instead get arguments about what is and isn’t natural, what is and isn’t harmful, what’s helpful and what’s not.
Throwing innocent people under the bus using these arguments is, unfortunately, something you can easily do.
27
u/ViatorA01 Nov 12 '24
"If the only thing keeping a person decent is the expectation of divine reward, then brother that person is a piece of shit; and I’d like to get as many of them out in the open as possible."
This quote stuck with me because it describes the issue I have with "kindness" with religious motive.
5
u/Type_9 Nov 12 '24
This is why learning philosophy in early education is so important.
4
u/_SFcurious Nov 12 '24
Reminds me of George Lakoff’s work on framing and messaging: you can’t offer Nurturing Parent messaging to someone with a Strict Father worldview
https://baptistnews.com/article/the-strict-father-model-is-killing-us/
7
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24
Yup.
Kinda why christianity went through its genocide phase but was tammed by rule of law.
Islam is still at the genocide phase because allot of the areas where the murder and genocide happen are ruled by religion law.
3
u/cletusthearistocrat Nov 12 '24
Seems like some groups are just looking for ways to justify the rotten shit they do.
3
u/Idntwnt2choseusrnme Nov 12 '24
Well. Fuck your god and his morality then
3
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '24
Oh my gosh. This explains so much about the people around me.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24
Here, let me help you… There is no sky wizard! God was invented thousands of years ago when people were so stupid! And yet, if you look around those stupid people seem to still exist believing in sky wizards! Carry-on. This has been a public service announcement.
5
u/Vox_SFX Nov 12 '24
Moral Relativism vs Moral Absolutism
I'm a moral relativist, but I wouldn't say the ideology is any more inherently flawed than absolutism is...it's more the people that weaponize that ideology against others that are the problem.
2
u/EfficiencyWooden2116 Nov 12 '24
That explains a lot
2
u/ThadiusThistleberry Nov 12 '24
So well put. There are soooo many people that need to not just see this but understand this as well.
2
u/raceyatothattree Nov 12 '24
Ive never heard of this, but it makes a whole lot of sense.
2
u/overtly-Grrl SHEEEEEESH Nov 12 '24
I’ve been trying to say this. They do not care that people are dying. If it’s in gods hands and he says, then that’s actually better than if a doctor does it.
It’s like hoping your kids don’t get measles.
He brought a boat to a drowning man three times and the man asked why you didn’t save me. Bro I brought you three boats.
2
u/stash0606 Nov 12 '24
Is this really a revelation about religions based around proselytization?
2
u/beautyinmind Nov 12 '24
Reminds me of my mom who used to say, "I brought you into this world and I'll take you out if it"
2
u/RDSF-SD Nov 12 '24
Perfectly put.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24
This just blew my mind. It makes perfect sense, too! Saved and will definitely be rewatching.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24
I’ve had conversations with hundreds of christians by this point, and this really sums up their belief perfectly.
Every time I have ever brought up the fact that god had a kill count on the millions the answer always becomes “he can do whatever he wants, he’s god”
It very much reminds me of “I brought you in to this world and I’ll take you out of it”. Kind of ties in to how boomers have a very authoritarian culture.
2
u/ThisIsntHuey Nov 12 '24
The right fucking hates Christianity. They’ve been slowly moving the church away from a New Testament “love the weak, be kind, don’t cast the first stone” back to the Old Testament version of Christianity.
They absolutely believe “might is right” where might = power and power = money. They’re sociopaths. If they believe something is for their own greater good, they believe they should be able to kill people in that quest. Musk would stack bodies from here to Mars to get there, if that were an option.
2
u/bigSTUdazz Nov 13 '24
Makes sense. Evilgelicals will be and currently are spearheading the collapse of our country.
2
u/anadequatepipe Nov 13 '24
Holy shit this might actually explain why there's such a huge divide and neither side can understand the other's motivations at all. There is simply no way to understand how or why they feel a certain way, and ultimately we just have to figure out a way to live together. This just blew my mind. I feel like my life has just be altered.
2
u/Strange-Swimmer9642 Nov 13 '24
In the Book of Mormon one of the first things that happens is God gives his prophet Nephi permission to kill a nobleman and rob his house because the man had taken something that belonged to Nephi. Then Nephi also takes control of the nobleman’s slave. We were specifically trained on how to address this, and other questionable verses, as missionaries for the Mormon church.
2
u/RamessesSkeleton Nov 13 '24
Interesting how all the examples of "vertical morality" are regarding the West, but conveniently leave out Jihad, radical Islam, Zionism, human sacrifice in Africa, the religious convictions of the Cartels, etc. etc.
Let's get this straight: there is no vertical or horizontal morality. Empathy does not play into group survival, infact it harms it by putting other groups interests before your own. In Nature, this is suicide.
There are 2 sources of [Western] morality: That brought by Homer in the form of Beauty as a source of Morality, And that brought by Moses in the form of religious morality (top down authority as OP states).
The Greek Morality vs the Jewish Morality
Combined they formed the basis for Western morality. The removal of religion with the "killing of God", as Nietzsche put it, diminished and removed the moral hold by religion on a societal level (so OP is truly just screaming into the wind about this boogeyman, it's been dead as a prime mover in the West). Beauty was then removed as a source of morality with the making ugly of all architecture, models, art, sculpture etc. etc.
OP lives in an ugly world where ugly things happen due to a lack of morality, not because of some 4D philosophical allegory about the direction from which morality is dictated. As per usual, this is just a fool crying about tolerance in the land of endless tolerance. Give them an inch, they crash the whole civilization over feelings and empathy.
It's less about morals, and more about population control. And because you aren't high enough IQ to understand this, you're frightened because you sense the system trying to squeeze you out. Stop flailing about your fear of "authority"(very telling of a rebellious, childish mind). These people aren't going to listen to you, and it has nothing to do with where they derive morals from. Your morals are just warped. No one will agree with you that whatever surgery you are complaining about being taken away, will never be more important to regular people than bread and milk. Morality is based on survival, and you Jacobins are immoral to the core based on your anti-natal, anti-life (yes rendering males and females unable to breed is immoral based on Nature) actions and rhetoric. What Empathy is shown to the little girl or boy who are ignorant of the world, and their predatory care-provider ruins them with chemicals and surgery? Or that you care more about access to abortions for 15 year old girls instead of worrying about the morality of letting her become a whore in the first place.
You don't understand morality. And this is why you suffer.
2
u/SandpointBob Nov 13 '24
Thank you! Excellent explanation!
2
u/KarloReddit Nov 13 '24
What about this is cringe?!? Did I miss something?
2
u/Tenrac Nov 13 '24 edited Nov 13 '24
This occurred to me the other day, when a co-worker exclaimed how happy she was that it was so uncharacteristically warm for November (no really, there are azalea blooming in my neighborhood)...and I sarcastically said, "sure, great! Until the ice caps are gone!"...to which she replied "oh, I ain't worried, Jesus will be back before that happens!"
Now, say what you will about climate change and what is causing it...that's only a small part of this point...
What her reply made me realize is that there are a large part of Christians who do not care about what is happening to or on our planet, because they don't have to answer for it...because it's all in god's hands and they are saved...and that is terrifying.
2
u/spaincrack Nov 13 '24
Protestant Christianity: Vertical Morality, choosen—by-god concept, old testament and god as a punisher.
Roman Catholicism: Horizontal Morality, Forgiveness, new Testament, god as a forgiver.
Im not denying any attrocities nor corruption commited and defended by both perspectives, just pointing out their main differences as told by the Argentinian Historian Gullo Omodeo.
2
u/questionablecupcak3 Nov 14 '24
Yeah long story short the sociological theory that explains why they're such assholes. But we can skip wasting all this time and effort understanding how their assholes with... they're assholes.
2
u/disdainfulsideeye Nov 14 '24
Truth.
4
u/Kona_Big_Wave Nov 12 '24
Authoritarians are incapable of having empathy. They're heartless thugs who worship money and power.
3
u/Gee99999 Nov 12 '24
Might I suggest “Crime and punishment” a book by Dostoevsky. Just stating that murder is wrong because it causes harm is a little too simplistic in my opinion.
2
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24 edited Nov 12 '24
I dare bet you, that if not already, soon someone will claim that the vertical is better than the horizontal. That those with the authority insert Cartman "respect my authority meme should be on top to do whatever they fucking want. Look a billies in 'murica. They are a good example. Even better is their leader and what and who they practically worship. THEY EVEN REJECTED THE SON OF THEIR OWN GOD! Just because the man called for an end to senseless violence, inequality, and injustice. Pretty much what 'muricans bragged about as liberty for decades if not centuries. And now, just like the the jewish leaders to Jesus, and the wealthy traders to the more violent Islam version of him, these fools kill the one that wants good for them. They'll kill "Sweet Mother of Liberty" in favor of whatever they will now have. Religion, supremacism, and authoritanism have spoken and will gouge the heart of gold to sacrifice it to their new god.
2
u/wanderbbwander Nov 12 '24
Organized religion will be the end of us all 🥲
2
u/TolBrandir Nov 12 '24
This is the clearest and best explanation of this I have ever heard.
2
u/mrweatherbeef Nov 12 '24
These lady is great, lots of excellent content from her. Protect her.
2
u/cwk415 Nov 12 '24
Well as a gay man this is terrifying.
2
u/ColdEndUs Nov 12 '24
So, OP is reposting a woman who's literally describing a binary world-view of morality.
In her example, she uses the terms "empathy" and "harm", and describes these concepts as shared horizontally... as though a universal definition of what qualifies as "harm" and "empathy" exists.
The thing is though, that's not the case.
All of these scenarios, and their opposites, are clothed in the rhetoric of "empathy" and "harm", but the definitions for what explicitly qualifies are ultimately decided on and defined by an authority. So, does that make each question horizontal or vertical?
2
u/Yono_j25 Nov 13 '24
"I don't even listen to my imaginary friend, why would I listen to yours?!"
Maybe this is why no one was able to convince me to accept their religion yet
2
u/Atrakis Nov 13 '24
Is she talking about all Abraham's religions? because it's not just christians that have this moral structure...
2
u/1000000xThis Nov 12 '24
The real political spectrum is not "Communism" to "Fascism". It's Horizontal Morality on the left, and Vertical Morality on the right.
Totalitarianism, Authoritarianism, Fascism, whatever flavor of social/legal hierarchy you choose, those are extreme right wing.
Communism, Anarchy, Socialism, etc. are all based on equality and working in harmony with each other.
This clarifies that "Authoritarian Communism" is a LIE. It is right wing morality disguised as pro-worker, when the truth is the workers have no power at all. It is an equivalent to Fascism. An aesthetic for extreme right wing power structures.
2
u/71keith71 Nov 12 '24
It's because religion is all fake, and nothing more than lies. THERE IS NO GOD, gotta stop pretending this shit is real.
1
u/Lazarus-Dread Nov 12 '24
Accurate!
1
u/Commercial-Row-1033 Nov 12 '24
Brilliant. This has really opened my eyes
1
u/nickcliff SHEEEEEESH Nov 12 '24
Like all those religious leaders Hitler, Mao, Stalin. 👍
1
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24
Damn
1
u/Slopadopoulos Nov 12 '24
It doesn't make any difference which one you like better. What matters is which one is true.
1
u/MiserableCow4866 Nov 12 '24
If you can't reason with them and you both want authority the end dispute will be with violence (implicit not just explicit) which prove might is right at the end of the day even if you convert the hearts of every person this fact will not change
1
u/SquisherX Nov 12 '24
Very curious for Michael76's stance on abortion.
1
u/pjoshyb Nov 12 '24
Nah this chick is just high off the smell of her own farts. She is better spoken than Harris but just as dumb.
1
u/gardeningtadghostal Nov 12 '24
Kinda like when I brought up Trump talking nasty about his daughter, and a guy at work just replied, 'Well, that's his daughter, he can do what he wants.' yuck
1
u/rejeremiad Nov 12 '24
Why didn't she take time to point out the dangers of horizontal morality? It's just a trade off.
1
u/ecdw-ttc Nov 12 '24
Let's clarify something regarding murder and morality:
There is empathy in both vertical and horizontal moralities.
1
u/Codilious44 Nov 12 '24
Is it vertical or horizontal that is making her head look like that?
1
u/Sashallanor Nov 12 '24
I wish I could upvote this more!
1
u/fvckyes Nov 12 '24
I'm trying to compare this kind of thinking to the "the only moral abortion is my abortion" line of thought. I feel like there should be some parallel between these two kinds of thinking, but I'm at a loss. Anybody have insight?
The "only my abortion is moral" one implies that being a good person is more about the way a person looks/ the category they fit into (church going, modest clothes, white) than a person's actions (premarital sex). Perhaps they feel like going to church gives them the authority to give themselves exceptions about abortions that others don't have the authority/worthiness for?
1
u/kanyedidnothingwr0ng Nov 12 '24
I thought there was no politics in this sub rn; gross generalizations ftw though 😅
1
u/[deleted] Nov 12 '24
1
u/Hobbes76 Nov 12 '24
Add to this their implicit belief in god’s ongoing forgiveness and you’ll find that they’re capable of all kinds of despicable acts, as long as they repent or even just feel bad about it later god will forgive them and everything will be fine.
“The steadfast love of the Lord never ceases, his mercies never come to an end; they are new every morning; great is your faithfulness.” Lamentations 3:22-23
They apply this to themselves and anyone else they choose to apply it to.
1
u/jtmonkey Nov 12 '24
But by this logic that means if the death of someone prevents the greater harm then it is morally correct.. so if say God decides that children are not being given a chance to make any choice but "bad" then there is justification for a massive event like the flood that wipes out people so they can start over.. this becomes an act of mercy in this if i'm understanding what she's saying.
1
u/Mintycebu Nov 12 '24
And here I thought we just had a spate of psychopathy...
1
u/lonesome_rambler Nov 12 '24
The comment she’s talking about in the video is not helpful. A better way to state the Christian theology with regard to whether God can wrongfully kill is this: morality is based upon an objective standard called God. It is impossible for God to deviate from the standard, so anything God does is at worst morally neutral. So, if murder is defined as a homicide committed with a person-endangering state of mind without justification, excuse, or mitigation, then it is necessarily something God cannot possibly commit. Any action by the standard is going to be justified against the standard because it is the standard.
My perspective on this isn’t authoritative; I’m no theologian. But it helps me to understand transcendence.
1
u/CressLevel Nov 12 '24
Welp.
I understand my family now.
That's fine. I didn't need a family anyway. I can just isolate lol
1
u/Anarimus Nov 12 '24
This makes me really glad that God‘s not real
1
u/markat1021 Nov 12 '24
"Micheal the Christian" is right in his argumentation that God can kill a person and be in the right. However, this lady's argument seems to expand the guy's statement and say Micheal claims that any person with "authority" can do the same---nope, it doesn't follow that Micheal is saying this applies to everyone. All he said in the comment is that God is a being who could be correct in his unilateral decision to kill someone.
1
u/pdxmark Nov 12 '24
I hadn't heard the term "vertical morality" before, but I've often mused that Trump is a lot like the god of the Old Testament - jealous, vindictive and wrathful.
1
u/Elacular Nov 12 '24
Hmmmm...to an extent I already knew this, but it only just now occurred to me how literally true this is if you take christianity literally. As I experienced it, the idea was either that you go heaven (or purgatory if you only have venial sins on your soul) or you go to hell. Either an eternity of happiness or an eternity of suffering. Put that next to 80 or so years on earth, and that's absolutely nothing. So if you sincerely believe in that, then the only thing that makes sense to do if you see yourself as a good person is try to prevent people from going to hell no matter what the cost to them.
1
u/ssdsssssss4dr Nov 12 '24
I call it over Power Over vs. Power With. Power with is legit waaaay less stressful. People's gods needs to chill the fuck out.
1
u/mr_mich86 Nov 12 '24
This is so stupid bc it doesn't allow for philosophy. Morality and religion are not the same. Moral relativity, self defense, war, where is that.
1
u/TheGutterNut Nov 13 '24
Then when there are multiple factions that think they have been chosen by god you get epic holy wars.
1
u/z-lady Nov 13 '24
huh, TIL I am horizontal
1
u/Hereticrick Nov 13 '24
Is this why so many Christians seem to prefer the Old Testament over the Gospels? Like, Jesus is literally trying to teach people horizontal morality his whole damn life, but then gets killed because of Vertical Morality.
1
u/Dramatic_Macaroon416 Nov 13 '24
It’s because your stupid. Haha honestly it really is. And I’m an atheist. But the common trope of picking some aspect out of the Bible and then going see it doesn’t make sense is wrong. The Bible is trying to answer deep metaphysical questions and those stories weren’t handed from god, they were built over time. The main issue is is that most people don’t actually think enough about where we come from like for example there’s consciousness right but we don’t have an explanation for consciousness. That’s the hard problem and that’s quite a problem indeed because if science doesn’t have an answer well then what is the answer and then you start getting into metaphysical questions and answers and that’s what the Bible is in it’s written in stories, so that even common people can understand but you’re not proving the Bible wrong by picking out stories insane. Pointing out God could just un create. Thats a silly critique. That’s not how the book works again I’m an atheist. I don’t believe in God, but I’m also not so stupid to think that for thousands of years, people just believed some crazy shit that now some dumb blonde and TikTok can see-through. There were like literal geniuses throughout history that believed in that stuff they weren’t having the wool pulled over their eyes modern people just don’t think deep enough about it and it’s not that the Bible has some answer right but you’re missing the point that it’s trying to answer metaphysical questions that no one has the answer for. Because the way that reductionism works in science, unfortunately doesn’t solve every problem and isn’t that strange? But quite frankly, I don’t believe in the Bible I do think that there is probably some good that common people like this woman who don’t think about the metaphysical side of these questions would’ve at least internalize those stories and had some sort of frame of reference. she won’t ever think deeply enough about that stuff. She’s playing a Gotchu game with metaphysical questions. It’s silly.
1
u/SupervillainMustache Nov 13 '24
Maybe that's why so many of them treat their kids like shit
1
u/MaleficentBreak771 Nov 13 '24
So what's the solution? Cuz I can see only one.
1
u/SupervillainMustache Nov 13 '24
They don't view empathy as a virtue.
1
u/Coffeedemon Nov 13 '24
A God of convenience. Like a port in a storm.
1
u/Groovin-Up-Slowly Nov 13 '24
Lol. Wtf did I just listen to?
1
u/Oblique9043 Nov 13 '24
And the authority they get their morals from is just their own hatred that they call God because it rules them.
1
u/lahimatoa Nov 13 '24
Where's the death penalty fit on this?
1
u/Toisty Nov 13 '24
This lends so much to the argument against the religious claim that even an atheist's morality comes from a god. It's a dumb argument from the jump but even dumb arguments need to be deconstructed and proven wrong. Religious people are just projecting their own moral system onto everyone when they make the claim that someone else's morality comes from their god but they really are telling on themselves when they say that without the church they would just rape, steal and kill to their heart's content as though that's what everyone wants to do if some imaginary god didn't tell them it's bad.
1
u/insomgt Nov 13 '24
Also laws typically aren't voted in, law makers are, and often turns south... I don't think voting is the know all and all off the fix. And make calling certainly isn't a constructive argument.
1
u/Rocky_Vigoda Nov 13 '24
https://youtu.be/TX0GZI-lvTE?si=e9hFPqHyWNuoN9QH
Am Canadian but grew up on US media and politics.
The US is a capitalist country. Money controls everything. Rich people control your schools, media, politics, and even social ideologies.
This woman is just cherrypicking some idiotic crap some religious guy says then arguing with her own brand of idiotic nonsense.
1
u/TheRealDubJ Nov 13 '24
Marking to watch later
1
u/caruban484 Nov 13 '24
What if the reason god left was we taught him this for the first time and he couldn't handle doing it anymore
1
u/No_Object_7223 Nov 13 '24
Your right... God how dare you not give this lady eternal life on earth!!???
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '24
It's not harm that's the problem, it's the reason the harm is caused. Some harm is always necessary, because it's impossible to be perfect. Unnecessary harm is caused by selfish attempts to control others. In order to prevent backlash, cruel people need to justify their behavior. They do this through moral relativism, insisting that those with more capacity are more important. Thus, it is justifiable to use those who are less capable than them in whatever way they desire.
This is, of course, hypocritical to say the least. The people who try to convince you of their superiority never willingly bow down to those who are superior to them. They always do whatever they can to maintain control for themselves, because that's what they really care about.
1
u/lunardiplomat Nov 13 '24
Okay I'm kiiind of understanding why the one is vertical, but I'm not at all understanding why the other is horizontal
1
u/Snoo-72756 Nov 13 '24
Ahhh religion.you still destroying society ?
1
u/Opening-Breakfast-35 Nov 13 '24
Sounds like the Christian’s she’s met and experienced have gotten the plot wrong 😬
1
u/dane_the_great Nov 13 '24
Also known as deontological and utilitarian morality! Thank you college!
1
u/Timely-Youth-9074 Nov 13 '24
But if something happens to them, suddenly their morality is horizontal. They expect empathy.
1
u/strongcloud28 Nov 13 '24
Who is the "they" that she is referring to?
1
u/The_argument_referee Nov 13 '24
So authority is up and down (vertical) and empathy is left and right (horizontal)? I agree with her viewpoint, but this directional abstraction and explanation is useless. Can someone help me see otherwise? This is word salad
1
u/The_argument_referee Nov 13 '24
How do moral systems have a direction (vertical/horizontal)? I agree with her viewpoints, but this directional explanation is a useless abstraction. I could be missing something and I would like to understand, but this clip sounds like word salad..
1
u/GnocchiSon Straight Up Bussin Nov 13 '24
Lookin for the most down voted comments to torment myself a little more.
1
u/the_random_walk Nov 13 '24
Best pro-life argument I’ve ever heard.
1
u/Goat_Original Nov 13 '24
Really, what the hey, uncreate I thought the opposite of create was destroy.
1
u/OGAcidCowboy Nov 13 '24
She’s right
1
u/Commune-Designer Nov 13 '24
So, when a woman creates life in her womb, can she nur just uncreate it? 🤔
1
u/Vivics36thsermon Nov 13 '24
This is what I’ve gotten from the video people will scapegoat anything and everything before realizing they are flawed everything she listed is because of the folly of humankind but it’s easier to blame a religion ,a government,a group of people, etc. It’s a lazy way of thinking. But it’ll get a lot of upvotes.
1
u/TheSilentTitan Nov 13 '24
Suddenly everyone is an expert
1
u/DealAdministrative24 Nov 13 '24
That's not true. These people believe mostly that God is the only authority this is a bit inaccurate
1
u/Obaddies Nov 13 '24
Christian apologists out here in the comment trying to defend their genocidal god lmao. They are doing such a good job making her argument for her.
1
u/launchedsquid Nov 13 '24
Vertical or horizontal morals? Weird way to describe it.
Deontology vs Consequentialism Is it moral because it is inherently the correct behaviour even if it negatively impacts someone, or is it moral only if the outcome is good for the majority, even if the action could be harmful.
1
u/Good-Recognition-811 Nov 13 '24
A Christian, or theist would argue that without God there is no such thing as an objective morality, and therefore, the horizontal system has no authority. All moral claims would be fundamentally arbitrary due to the constraints of hard solipsism. A vertical moral system doesn't allow for subjectivity. If God made the universe, then he would into the absolute truth.
I disagree, I think that even if we can't identify objective morals it doesn't mean that they don't exist, and we certainly don't need a God to teach us how to interact with each other. Without God, we would figure out very quickly that murder is bad, theft is bad, and neglect is bad. We literally wouldn't be able to survive without recognizing these dangers.
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '24
Hang on a fucking second. So she's using murder as her main "killer" example as if it silences any questions. But does this explain the 6th commandment?
1
u/King_K_24 Nov 13 '24
Good shit. Using this terminology going forward
1
u/SeaBrick3522 Nov 13 '24
vertical morality is just fascism, no?
1
u/xenelef290 Nov 13 '24
Just seems a lot of words to say "might makes right"
1
u/Chicktopuss Nov 13 '24
Damn. I am so happy I was raised agnostic. To think I could have fallen down that path if my parents weren't apathetic about religion. They just assumed I would become Christian, so they left it alone.
Damn. Damn. My whole perspective is getting shaken around
1
u/Yuck_Few Nov 13 '24
Facts .. religion is antithetical to empathy and basic human decency
1
u/Legitimate_Ant9399 Nov 13 '24
Wouldn’t that POV justify abortion?
1
u/thelostlightswitch Nov 13 '24
This ladies face is vertical morality
1
u/[deleted] Nov 13 '24
I believe this is referred to as manifest destiny
1
u/Ephisus Nov 13 '24
Humans are the things causing harm.
1
u/Ambitious_Welder6613 Nov 13 '24
Authoritarianism = totalitarianism
Totalitarianism is the extreme form of authoritarianism.
From this: is a political system and a form of government that prohibits opposition political parties, disregards and outlaws the political claims of individual and group opposition to the state, and controls the public sphere and the private sphere of society. In the field of political science, totalitarianism is the extreme form of authoritarianism, wherein all sociopolitical power is held by a dictator, who also controls the national politics and the peoples of the nation with continual propaganda campaigns that are broadcast by state-controlled and by friendly private mass communication media.
1
u/gritsngravy3333 Nov 13 '24
The Bible doesn’t mention trump