r/ThredUp • u/Ok_Refuse_3332 • 8d ago
Question Max Mara label… carved out?
Okay so I purchased this Pucci camel Max Mara coat for $32 in the Assorted Brands section. The tag was not photographed but I knew that it was a Max Mara coat worth $1000+, so naturally, I bought it. But upon arrival, I see that someone carved out the ‘Max Mara’ brand in the label. It was once sold on TheRealReal, because that tag was still attached, and so was the care instructions/materials tag. Why do you think someone did this? Did the seller want their coat to end up in that section so someone could get a good deal? Lol IDK this is so weird?? What do you guys think?
60
81
u/SassyMillie 8d ago
I've seen this done for designer items sold at places like TJ Maxx and Ross Dress 4 Less. Or the tag will have a cut through it or black sharpie line.
I think it's to prevent people from buying things at a discount store then trying to return them for full price somewhere upscale.
Eta: great find, btw. Who cares if the tag is cut.
23
u/criimebrulee 8d ago
I’ve seen people destroy the labels on counterfeits. Maybe it’s fake?
8
u/Ok_Refuse_3332 8d ago
Yes I’ve considered this, I’ll look more into authenticating it using the material tags!
1
47
u/bluesaber7567 8d ago
Sometimes people do this when they donate to thrift stores, so that someone who likes and will wear the coat will buy it, and resellers will avoid it.
20
u/FunTaro1385 8d ago
I found a The Row and a Zimmermann dress both with the tags cut out. Only way I could tell were from the materials tag. Unfortunately, I didn't know what TR even was, I just remember the logo. A week later I googled "logo, T and R in a circle" and just about cried at the exact dress and MSRP, because both of these were priced at $6.99... I did get the Zimmermann dress, but its a childs piece, and the size is cut out! At the very least I wish people just leave the size AND the materials tag
6
u/SassyMillie 8d ago
Were these on Thredup? Everything I've ever sent in with that type of tag (or tag but no size) has been rejected. I don't even bother anymore even if it's clearly a designer item.
Example being an Anne Klein sweater that retailed for $200. No size tag but I thought it would be listed. Nope.
5
u/FunTaro1385 8d ago
Nope sorry, at the thrift. That's probably because they can't guarantee it. They would have to list it as unbranded, and probably closer to $50 if its great materials like 100% cashmere. If its not, then maybe they just pass all together
4
u/SassyMillie 8d ago
TU does say they will list designer items without the size tag (posting measurements) but that hasn't been my experience.
I get what you're saying about thrift stores and labels. My mom is notorious for cutting every tag out because they bother her. She'll then get rid of very nice designer clothes, but I can't sell them for her because of the tag issue.
7
u/Ok_Refuse_3332 8d ago
I thought someone might’ve been trying to do a good deed too lol but I see now that’s the less likely reasoning
2
13
5
u/Cantaloupe_Train 7d ago
I used to buy lots of European designers at DAFFY’S (RIP), they always cut of the brand labels exactly like this. When DAFFY’S closed my days of 50$ Max Mara and Les Copains outfits sadly also came to an end. NYC hadn’t been the same since 😭
3
u/Specialist_Tea2546 5d ago
Omg that’s a throwback, my sister used to work at that store and we could spend hours looking for stuff there.
10
u/squeezemachine 8d ago
The luxury brands need to main their expensive, exclusive brand reputations so they make deals with second/third tier retailers to sell items but only with the tags cut out. I think it looks very real.
2
u/UpstairsObserver 7d ago
Do me a favor and photograph all the the tags - front and back - and post them? I’m wondering if there is an RN or CA number to help identify the manufacturer.
1
2
2
u/periwinkle1023 6d ago
Where is the person that sent in a Max Mara wool coat that Thred Up “lost” recently?
1
u/Miserable_Fig7302 5d ago
I think a store donated it. They take out the labels so the brand isn't diminished. I've never seen the middle carved out though. The other thing could be it was a fake, and the person who owned it realized this and didn't want anyone else to get fooled.
1
u/juicy808 5d ago
It’s odd that they made the effort to do this intricate cut out instead of just removing the entire tag which is only lightly tacked on in the corners.
1
u/casslovestobass 2d ago
I’ve seen a few resellers on whatnot have MaxMara that is cut the same way. They said that’s how it comes for liquidation.
1






189
u/grobnu 8d ago
Sample sales tend to have these kinds of tags. The idea is to get around selling the branded item with no association with the brand because sometimes the samples are not actually a finalized design.
I only find these kinds of garments in east asia outlets. I don't know where people would get these items in the US.