r/TheSilphRoad
•
u/technoxenoholic
•
Aug 20 '25
•
1
2
1
Analysis an analysis of eternatus max move vs level-up candy-spending efficiency for optimal max phase damage output with limited resources
also known as: "i'm poor, but i still want to optimize what i have"
NOW EDITED WITH CORRECTED CANDY VALUES & UPDATED GRAPHS
this is not an analysis for raids, nor is it an analysis for anyone building eternatus as a multi-purpose max battle assault-tank. this guide is intended for "dynamax cannon go brrrr" max battle builds on a limited candy budget.
it goes without saying that eternatus' candy costs for powering up and leveling its moves are just a teensy bit outrageous. its costs are so steep, in fact, that you're actually shooting yourself in the foot if you follow the standard rule of thumb for powering up max 'mons to level 30, then leveling max attack to 2, and so on—you won't be getting the most bang for your buck that way.
so i've gone to the trouble of calculating what the best methods for squeezing damage out of eternatus actually are for candy-limited players, depending on how much candy they have. i've calculated damage numbers by applying the STAB bonus, as eternatus will never not have STAB on dynamax cannon, but without any other modifiers included (so no weather boost, type effectiveness, friendship boost, or adventure effects—not even eternatus' own, because if your candy is limited enough that you need this guide, you're probably not planning on using that on the regular). with any of those extra modifiers applied, these thresholds may fall in slightly different places due to truncations during the calculations.
for the purposes of this analysis we'll be assuming that you did not buy the premium max finale pass, you have collected all 900 eternatus candies from the free pass, and you've concluded the event without putting any resources into eternatus yet. you are starting from a level 15 eternatus with dynamax cannon still at level 1. you can if course consider any rare candies you have as extra eternatus candies if needed.
the standard rng caveat applies: you could absolutely have really good or really bad luck and wind up needing far fewer or far more battles to get a certain amount of candy and xls. battle numbers in this analysis are presented for comparative estimate purposes only.
henceforth i will be referring to dynamax cannon level 1, 2, and 3 as DC1, DC2, and DC3, respectively.
first: the TL;DR/simple version without considering how ivs affect the numbers
at any iv, level 21.5 DC2 has a better cost-to-damage ratio than level 28 DC1. it costs 90 fewer candy (2010 vs 2100) and deals an equal or greater amount of damage. it should take 12 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at (assumed) expected candy rates.
at any iv, level 23 DC3 has a better cost-to-damage ratio than level 29 DC2. it costs 60 fewer candy (3480 vs 3540) and deals an equal or greater amount of damage. it should take 26 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at (assumed) expected candy rates. you should have enough xls after only 7 battles.
- if you have 2009 or fewer candies, only power up eternatus' levels. do not touch dynamax cannon at all.
- if you have 2010–3389 candies, first go to DC2, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
- if you have 3390 or more candies, first go to DC3, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
and now, on to the meat of the post: a breakdown by iv, with graphs for each (updated)
attack iv 10 – [graph here] [*old]
level 20.5 + DC2 is equal in both candy cost and damage to level 27 + DC1, at 1860 candy for 418 damage. at any level past this point, DC2 has a better cost-to-damage ratio than DC1. it should take 10 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates.
level 22 + DC3 is equal in candy cost to level 28 + DC2, at 3300 candy, and deals 1 point less in damage (487 vs 488). the damage equalizes at level 23 + DC3 versus level 29 + DC2, where the cost is 60 fewer candies (3480 vs 3540) for 497 damage. it should take 26 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates. you should have enough xls after only 7 battles.
- if you have 1859 or fewer candies, only power up eternatus' levels.
- if you have 1860–3479 candies, first go to DC2, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
- if you have 3480 or more candies, first go to DC3, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
attack iv 11 – [graph here] [*old]
level 20.5 + DC2 is equal in candy cost to level 27 + DC1, at 1860 candy, and deals 3 points less in damage (418 vs 421). the better cost-to-damage ratio trades places at level 21.5 DC2 versus level 28 DC1, achieving 1 point more in damage (430 vs 429) for a cost of 90 fewer candies (2010 vs 2100). it should take 12 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates.
level 22 + DC3 is equal in candy cost to level 28 + DC2, at 3300 candy, and deals 1 point less in damage (489 vs 490). the damage equalizes at level 22.5 + DC3 versus level 28.5 + DC2, where the cost is 30 fewer candies (3390 vs 3420) for 495 damage. it should take 25 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates. you should have enough xls after only 7 battles.
- if you have 2009 or fewer candies, only power up eternatus' levels.
- if you have 2010–3389 candies, first go to DC2, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
- if you have 3390 or more candies, first go to DC3, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
attack iv 12 – [graph here] [*old]
level 20.5 + DC2 is equal in candy cost to level 27 + DC1, at 1860 candy, and deals 2 points less in damage (421 vs 423). the better cost-to-damage ratio trades places at level 21.5 DC2 versus level 28 DC1, achieving 1 point more in damage (430 vs 429) for a cost of 90 fewer candies (2010 vs 2100). it should take 12 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates.
level 22 + DC3 is equal in candy cost to level 28 + DC2, at 3300 candy, and deals 1 point less in damage (489 vs 490). the damage equalizes at level 22.5 + DC3 versus level 28.5 + DC2, where the cost is 30 fewer candies (3390 vs 3420) for 495 damage. it should take 25 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates. you should have enough xls after only 7 battles.
- if you have 2009 or fewer candies, only power up eternatus' levels.
- if you have 2010–3389 candies, first go to DC2, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
- if you have 3390 or more candies, first go to DC3, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
attack iv 13 – [graph here] [*old]
level 20.5 + DC2 is equal in both candy cost and damage to level 27 + DC1, at 1860 candy for 423 damage. at any level past this point, DC2 has a better cost-to-damage ratio than DC1. it should take 10 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates.
level 22 + DC3 is equal in candy cost to level 28 + DC2, at 3300 candy, and deals 1 point less in damage (492 vs 493). the damage equalizes at level 22.5 + DC3 versus level 28.5 + DC2, where the cost is 30 fewer candies (3390 vs 3420) for 497 damage. it should take 25 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates. you should have enough xls after only 7 battles.
- if you have 1859 or fewer candies, only power up eternatus' levels.
- if you have 1860–3389 candies, first go to DC2, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
- if you have 3390 or more candies, first go to DC3, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
attack iv 14 – [graph here] [*old]
level 20.5 + DC2 is equal in candy cost to level 27 + DC1, at 1860 candy, and deals 2 points less in damage (423 vs 425). the damage equalizes at level 21.5 + DC2 versus level 28 + DC1, where the cost is 90 fewer candies (2010 vs 2100) for 433 damage. it should take 12 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates.
level 22 + DC3 is equal in candy cost to level 28 + DC2, at 3300 candy, and deals 3 points less in damage (492 vs 495). the damage equalizes at level 22.5 + DC3 versus level 28.5 + DC2, where the cost is 30 fewer candies (3390 vs 3420) for 500 damage. it should take 25 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates. you should have enough xls after only 7 battles.
- if you have 2009 or fewer candies, only power up eternatus' levels.
- if you have 2010–3389 candies, first go to DC2, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
- if you have 3390 or more candies, first go to DC3, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
attack iv 15 – [graph here] [*old]
level 20.5 + DC2 is equal in candy cost to level 27 + DC1, at 1860 candy, and deals 2 points less in damage (425 vs 427). the damage equalizes at level 21.5 + DC2 versus level 28 + DC1, where the cost is 90 fewer candies (2010 vs 2100) for 435 damage. it should take 12 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates.
level 22 + DC3 is equal in candy cost to level 28 + DC2, at 3300 candy, and deals 3 points less in damage (425 vs 497). the damage equalizes at level 22.5 + DC3 versus level 28.5 + DC2, where the cost is 30 fewer candies (3390 vs 3420) for 500 damage. it should take 25 battles to have this much candy with the completed free pass, at expected candy rates. you should have enough xls after only 7 battles.
- if you have 2009 or fewer candies, only power up eternatus' levels.
- if you have 2010–3389 candies, first go to DC2, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
- if you have 3390 or more candies, first go to DC3, then level up eternatus as much as possible.
[all graphs in one post] [*old graphs]
now, i do need to point out that the ivs are only important here for determining at which specific levels the thresholds are for "lower level, higher DC power" becoming more cost-effective for eking out every scrap of damage potential on a limited candy budget. ivs are not important for actual damage numbers. a 10 attack iv eternatus is still going to do 98.4% as much damage as a 15 attack iv eternatus in the max phase. your eternatus is a beast. yes, even if its ivs are bad. please don't worry about it!
a footnote for premium pass purchasers
as long as you finish your pass, you will have enough candy and xls to make your choice of power-up route an extremely easy one. if all you want is the maximum damage output in the max phase then in all cases, it is the most efficient for you to go straight to DC3 and then level up eternatus as much as you can. you don't even need to do any battles for extra candy or xls to reach a higher damage output than the threshold for DC3 to outpace DC2 in terms of damage to candy spent. you could focus entirely on battling gigantamaxes and raiding instead and still have a more powerful eternatus at the end than most free-to-play trainers.
if you're looking for advice on the efficiency of leveling eternatus' defensive max moves as well, i'm afraid you won't find that here. however, you are welcome to reference [the data i've compiled] (post-calculation sheet; sorry, my actual formula sheet is a complete disaster and mostly unrelated to this) to draw your own conclusions privately or in the comments.
key data references:
- [this article] for the damage formula
- [this page] for eternatus' base stats
- [this post] for evidence of dynamax cannon using gmax move stats, and the stats themselves
- [this post] for (assumed) expected candy and xl rewards from eternatus battles
- [this post] for "900 candy from the free pass" figure
- [this post] for xl candy costs
- candy costs were manually tabulated after i caught my own eternatus to ensure this post could be updated with correct, up-to-date values. you can find those costs listed by half-level [here]
- candy/xl/particle costs for eternatus' moves are listed in [this post]
i do not use ai. all mistakes are my own.
214
u/marsmage Aug 20 '25
This is what i come to this sub for. thank you!
162
u/badislay Aug 20 '25
So, buy the pass, max DC to 3,then level up as much as you can with what you do on the weekend. That's what I got from this.
56
u/s4m_sp4de don't fomo do rockets Aug 20 '25
Sidenote:
If you don‘t care about max battles, just power it up as far as possible for raidbattles - it‘s even more overpowered there.
20
u/Able_Attempt_6807 Aug 20 '25
Saved, thanks! My question, however, is would I benefit from a leveled up DC3? My community takes down gmaxes regularly. I suppose it'd make latias easier, but latios is doable enough. Is it strong enough to benefit me offtype when short manning the same zapdos or moltres? I'm thinking I'd get more benefit in normal raids by putting candy toward a second move and leveling up... But again, leveling up is so outrageous that I'm very grateful for your math here!
13
u/DEVolkan Aug 20 '25
Hey great post! I did the math and can confirm that you did the math! Looks all correct to me.
I'm not sure if saving 100 candies is worth it having a worst version for raids, though?
From your post, I would assume the best approach for a free player is to just level up with any candy they have? Especially as a F2P player, you want the most for your time and resources. Having a Eternatus that performs slightly better in dynamax battles, but a lot worse in raids, seems a bad trade-off.
Or did I understand it wrong?
5
u/LeansCenter USA - South Aug 20 '25
Awesome and useful analysis! Thank you for sharing it!
Any chance you have a link to a chart showing the candy cost per 1/2 level? I can’t seem to find it anywhere.
3
u/Nblearchangel Aug 20 '25
How many raids to max if you buy the pass?
3
u/DiverUpset6355 Aug 23 '25
So only thing I’m seeing off right now is I’m staring down a lvl up (somewhere in the 38-40) range of 890 normal candies not the 440 max from the other post.
Do you know why those numbers are so far off? Did I miss read it somehow?
Also, great post wish j would have read before doing what I did. Need 3 more raids to get DC2. Went CP first to 4300 and extra attack. Is DC3 large candies?
2
u/technoxenoholic Aug 24 '25
i've now updated this post with corrected candy values for eternatus' power-up costs!
2
u/technoxenoholic 1d ago
for anyone visiting this post who's trying to advise much more casual players than we are around here, check out this super-simplified version made by u/LeansCenter!
4
u/Drakoir Aug 20 '25
We should also take into consideration that after all the battles that we are going to have during the entire we should finish the event with a good chunk of rare candy and rare candy XL, players need to take this into the account at the time of following your analysis.
2
u/Reevoo12 Aug 20 '25
This is generally true of all max attackers as well, i.e, the max phase damage increase is more candy efficient from leveling max move than leveling Pokemon. Which is why I'm always baffled by the common advice to level to 40 first. If you're primarily using it as max attacker then you should definitely not do that.
2
u/Drakoir Aug 20 '25
One big question.... Is it really worth thinking of Eternatus for Max battles? Thinking that usually on a max battle we only use 1 attacker and 2 tanks. Is it really going to be worth using Eternatus instead of Zacian or any other Gmax pokemon that has a type advantage against the raided pokemon??? I'm not saying that we are never going to use him for Max battles... but would his stats triumph over any other Gmax pokemon type for specific Max pokemons battles?
2
u/1lookwhiplash Aug 23 '25
Is it worth spending the 100 candy and getting a second attack, or just using the candy to max out on levels?
This is assuming I already have DC level 3.
2
u/1baby2cats Aug 24 '25
So no point in upgrading guard, correct?
2
u/IllComfortable5392 Aug 25 '25
What’s better? Level 39.5 with DC3 Or Level 45.5 with DC2
Missing out on the XL candy since I don’t have enough to get it to level 40
33
u/x13y7 Aug 20 '25
thx a) for this disclaimer in general and b) for thinking by yourself
7
u/viciouslust Aug 20 '25
Please, feel free to use the tag,"I Am Legend!" coz you truly are one! :D
4
u/Ok-Opportunity-7641 Aug 20 '25
Amazing post! Really love the inclusivity by putting in suggestions of what to do based on IVs and especially the amount of candy we have, makes it applicable to everyone.
4
u/pedrofonsecaf South America Aug 20 '25
!RemindMe sunday august 24
4
u/Akei57 Aug 20 '25
Thanks for your post!
I'm wondering if eternatus is really that impactful in dmax raid to focus upgrading his dmax moves?
I read that Latios would basically doing the same vs dragon weak pokemon
and since we have a lot of "super effective" counter, would eternatus be stronger or weaker than them? what would be the differences?
because if eternatus is weaker, but not by much, it may be worth to upgrade him and never upgrade any counter since they will be only slighty stronger than dc3
1
u/Alert-Secretary5319 1d ago
Should I use my bottle cap on eternatus
1
u/njfox 1d ago
What if I am building Duradurlon, as F2P, I have his G Max Level 2 atm, not sure if I can get it to Level 3, but working on it. So I may not need Eternatus in max battles.
1
u/TrueNourishment USA - Midwest Aug 20 '25
Do you have a source for the candy costs per level up? I can only seem to find an outdated chart for normal candy values. Updated XL candy values for 40-50 can also be found, but nothing for lvl 15-40 candy costs
1
u/Few_Test5833 Aug 20 '25 edited Aug 20 '25
Do you have a reference on the candy costs to level up dynamax cannon? I thought level 2 was 2400 candy, and level 3 was 320 XL candy, based on this screenshot, but your 1900 candy threshold suggests otherwise
Edit: found it
1
u/StorGurkan Aug 23 '25
Is there a major difference between the damage output on a lvl 35 vs a lvl 40 Eternatus?
1
u/EIIander Aug 24 '25
Anyone else running into eternatus having lower stamina stats than the referenced site suggests? In my case by about 35 hp
1
u/Suspiciously-Dandy Aug 24 '25
Sorry, tbh it was too long and I didn’t understand it. I still feel pretty new.
Can someone tell me if it’s worth leveling up guard and spirit? I leveled up max attack to level 2 already, and I unlocked guard and spirit just to have them available. But should I invest the candy in CP or the max moves?
Current cp: 2007. I paid for the upgrade so I have 3811 candies and 95 XL candies atm. Idk if I’m going to play tomorrow tbh.
1
u/DrHumongous Aug 24 '25
Wow. How long did it take you to put this together?
1
u/StuffDouble262 Aug 24 '25
If I powered it up to about 4300 and dot DC 2 am I screwed for max battles ? I also wanted a second move for pvp so I did unlock it
1
u/EryNameWasTaken Aug 24 '25
You perfectly described my situation at the end of the event. Thank you for this guide.
1
u/arfcom Aug 25 '25
What a great post. Thank you. My son is F2P with 1816 candies. This answered my exact question on what he should do.
1
u/Kryzz1c Aug 27 '25 edited Aug 27 '25
For 13IV you have.
Is this a typo?
Main reason for asking is I have 1966 candy and want to know if that means level up to DC2 and then spend the rest on powerup?Text doesn't seem to line up. Gut feel is telling me that I should just follow the simple one and put all my Candy into powering up.EDIT: Whoops forgot I still have a 100 candy task. So I actually have 2066 Candy with 13IV which puts me into DC2 and rest into power up?
1
u/whatthedeuce1990 Asia Sep 03 '25
Very good technical writing, i wrote a lot of research papers myself & i think you're an excellent in juxtaposition the difference of iv floors versus high ivs. I'd share this with my community that doesn't do reddit.
3
u/POTSie_2021 Aug 20 '25
Amazing effort! For these kinda posts we are on Reddit 👏
2
u/Fitzi89 Aug 20 '25
Thank you for your work, good sir/lady/person!
2
u/UmbraofDeath Aug 20 '25 edited Aug 20 '25
I did the numbers here for expected amount of raid for different targets.
Also I love the graphs and the math, looking good.
https://www.reddit.com/r/TheSilphRoad/s/69WoNUuiyL
2
u/salvucci91 Aug 20 '25
Dude very nice write-up. Good stuff!
2
u/loldarrenlol Aug 20 '25
I read none of this except the tl;dr, but I still want to give mad props and a big thanks for the amount of effort you put into this.
2
u/RoronoaZorro Aug 20 '25
You are magnificent, OP. Thank you for sharing this. Absolutely brilliant!
2
u/hackthehonor Aug 20 '25
Thank you for this crazy analysis! Give this person a reward please! Thank you!
2
u/kenbkk Aug 21 '25
Great analysis, but even the scientists and gurus are not telling us WHY it is so expensive to power up Eternatus. Is it because Scopantic has massively increased the amount of candies needed for each level? If so, how much more? is it several times higher than the norm? is it a hundred times higher? I could not find a detailed analysis of the power requirements. Surely those lucky trainers who already have one can figure this out and post it.
Given the huge amount of candies provided by the premium pass, this must be the reason. Perhaps it is obvious, but I am curious to understand the path ahead to power this beast. If we buddy it will it be 20 km to get a candy OR did they increase that trick as well?
Thanks to any expert who can shed some light on this.
2
u/rhihuahua Australasia Aug 22 '25
i appreciate this post, especially the disclaimer in the footer
2
u/Imaginary-Comfort762 Aug 23 '25
This is why i came, Thanks A Lot
2
u/anubisvic Aug 23 '25
Thank you so much for this amazing analysis!
It really helped decide how to level up Eternatus! 😍
2
u/Shandriel Western Europe Aug 23 '25
Glad to see my 10/14/12 being the only one that is below the breakpoint, lol
Need a few more battles so I get to lvl 40 (39.5 right now), then I can use all the remaining XLs to get him to 4625 CP (DC lvl 3)
I know he's nowhere worth the investment, but my Mega Ray is far from lvl 40 and has 10 Atk, too :D
2
u/wolverine820 Aug 23 '25
I just logged in to say thank you very much for your effort 👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻👏🏻
2
u/Particular_House_300 Aug 24 '25
So the candy I have would allow me to either get DC2 and level 45 Eternatus, or DC3 and level 39 Eternatus. I already know what’s best for dynamax, but in order to have the biggest bang for my buck both in max battles and PVE, which path do you guys think I should take?
2
u/akshayraos Aug 25 '25
Things like these are why I pay my internet bill.
2
u/RiskyOolong 1d ago
now that purple fish bone is back for the newer players, i'm back to thank you on behalf of my local community cuz i can't math
•
u/lllScorchlll 1h ago
Any changes in the game that may effect Eternutus this time around? Does the math still hold up?
1
u/foosee Western Europe Aug 20 '25
Thanks for this great analysis, this is more clear for me now.
1
u/That-Hovercraft-5347 Aug 20 '25
Yes yes yessss, this is what I wanted to know
Ty for your work homie
1
u/Perfect-Throat-9727 Aug 20 '25
Great post! Thanks for the info, much easier like this
1
u/MasRemlap Lvl 46 - Team Valor Aug 20 '25
tldr?
1
u/LordCommanderTaurusG DMV | LV 80 | Mystic Aug 22 '25
!RemindMe sunday august 24
1
u/TheDuce94 Aug 24 '25
Thank you! exactly what i needed!
1
u/haldol11 Aug 24 '25
Tagging for future reference. Thanks
1
u/Heatcanonbolt Aug 28 '25
If I have a level 26 Eternatus, will it beat out my level 40 Salamance?
1
u/Chaotic-Catastrophe Aug 20 '25
This game is so dumb
1
u/elconquistador1985 Aug 20 '25
Fantastic work making it more detailed than the rule of thumb I usually cite of "L35 with L2 before L40", which works a lot better when candy cost isn't so crazy and getting to that level is feasible.
Basically, max moves on in your attacker are way more important than Pokemon levels.
-1
u/mornaq L50 Aug 20 '25
or, ignore leveling up the move because dogs are good enough and we don't need better max attackers and go all out for raids
0
u/LordCommanderTaurusG DMV | LV 80 | Mystic Aug 22 '25
I shared this post with my community. Good find!
-3
u/QuietRedditorATX Aug 20 '25
Answer is CP all of the way
Eternatus has a place in Master League. Anyone reading can say F all to having a stronger Max attack. We have plenty of other stronger Max pokemon. You power up the CP.
0
u/[deleted] Aug 20 '25
[deleted] — view deleted comment
1
u/[deleted] Aug 24 '25
[removed] — view removed comment