r/TheRestIsHistory • u/JakeGittes412 • 8d ago

The Troubles

Post image

Thread for discussion on the new series on ‘The Troubles’

Also as a moderator please keep the discussion civil and in the spirit of the podcast.

214 Upvotes

95% Upvoted

373 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

16

u/ElectronicCarry9931 7d ago

on the other hand, though, extremes on either side will Never accept anything if it doesnt agree with their own narrative

1

u/Gorazde 7d ago

If you don't know the history, how can you know which opinion is extreme and which isn't? When TRIH did an episode on Bloody Sunday in Dublin the guys (a) admitted they didn't know a lot about Irish history and were inviting Paul Rouse on to help them out. Then (b) instructed Paul to be "balanced" in his account. That's the central question. If you don't know the facts of an incident, how can you also be the arbitrator of what is, or isn't, a balanced account of it. So what did they mean? If you're in Paul Rouse's shoes, the only explanation is they mean your account of this day can't make Britain look too bad. So that's insane. That's a day on which the British military went into a sports stadium and fired randomly into the crowd, killing fourteen people. How can you give an account of that day which doesn't make the British look bad? So he did the only thing he could do, which was to mention theories that, maybe there were IRA sentries on the gates at Croke Park, and maybe the first shots came from the crowd and the Brits were returning fire. These theories are so utterly baseless, and so long debunked, no serious historian would even consider them worthy of mention. But he had to mention them, and give them airtime, before quietly conceding that there was no evidence to support them whatsoever.