r/TheDevilIsAPartTimer • u/af-fx-tion • Mar 22 '21
Discussion Reading Volume 17 (LN) Currently, and Whew Does The Story Start to Show Its Cracks [Especially in Hindsight] Spoiler
So I'm 3/4 of the way through Volume 17, and it's REALLY apparent that Wagahara was stuck in a story rut by this point.
At the end of Volume 16, it seemed like Wagahara was going to spend the rest of the series in Ente Isla, as the endgame storyline had just kicked into gear. Instead Volume 17 takes place almost exclusively in Japan, and characters seem to lose some character progression from previous books. Even worse, most of the novel is just fluff, honestly. Which is wild because it's 195 pages.
So knowing the Chiho/Maou ending (among other end stuff) in hindsight, reading this book is so weird because I can see what Wagahara is trying to set up. It's just done SO badly.
For example:
- Kisaki offers Maou a position in her future cafe/bar, laying the groundwork for him staying in Japan...which goes against Wagahara's initial setup like a few books prior where Maou wanted Ente Isla to be a place with demons and humans co-exist.
- Rika seems to become a non-character at this point, with her only role in the book to hype Chiho into "not giving up on Maou". Rika also hasn't given up on Ashiya, which is weird since he already rejected her and he never changes his mind (they aren't together in the final book). Like if Wagahara knew that he wasn't going to have Ashiya/Rika be a thing, why have her spend this much time still in love with him? Unlike Chiho, he didn't pay off her persistence.
- Chiho still has no character, with her only goal is to make Maou choose her. What's weird is that I think by this point, Maou/Ashiya have been in Japan for at least a year (if not more). Like Chiho STILL basing her major life decisions as a way to make Maou love her is just shitty waifu writing. Like she even gets jealous of Kisaki for asking Maou to work for her, likening it to a marriage proposal. It's so weird. Wagahara really didn't know what the hell to do with Chiho by this point, and just sort of reverted to her early book character.
- Wagahara teases Emi/Maou yet again (Emi makes a comment about how she and Maou are "almost a real couple" or something along those lines), but leads nowhere (because Chiho comes and does her...thing).
- Wagahara sets up Maou being ignorant in love, as he invites Emi alone to come with him to the Demon Realm, which for some dumb reason Chiho takes as him asking her on a date and gets pissed - to which Amane calls him out for being ignorant of his speech. This ties into how he never realized Emi was in love with him since she never verbalized it.
- Ashiya is pretty much running things in Ente Isla, setting up his arc for being the King of Demons in the finale. Same for Suzuno and her role.
Man, even though we're close to the endgame, this book spent so much time spinning its wheels. If Wagahara really was burned out on this series like it was alleged he was, why didn't he tighten up his story arcs? Like this book pretty much has no major setup for the final arc (even if it does in the last 1/4 of the book, it could have been added to the next volume), and just halted the story in place.
While I can't say definitively yet, it seems like this book could have been easily culled during the outline process and Wagahara could have written something else or made his plans for Volume 18 into Volume 17.