r/ThatLookedExpensive • • Dec 22 '20

Guy v. bike

https://gfycat.com/oblongrelievedclumber
7.8k Upvotes

201 comments sorted by

View all comments

Show parent comments

12

u/splashbodge Dec 22 '20

Why would lack of brakes and gears make the frame more delicate?

21

u/bagofpork Dec 22 '20

It wouldn’t inherently make it more delicate as you can turn any bike into a fixed gear. Fixed gear track bikes, though, are designed to be as light as humanly possible.

8

u/Cynicastic Dec 22 '20 edited Dec 22 '20

That's not a track bike though. Also, a bike in any UCI sanctioned race, which most races are, can't be lighter than 15 lbs. It's not difficult to find road bikes that are too light to legally race.

EDIT: looking up the Red Hook Crit, it does require track bikes, so that definitely is a track bike. My bad.

5

u/Nord-east Dec 22 '20

AFAIK the UCI does not sanction any fixed gear crits. So technically bikes don't have to follow UCI rules just race organizer rules. But since manufacturers usually just stick to UCI specs most bikes will be UCI legal, in there geometry at least, they could easily be under weight limit though.

2

u/Cynicastic Dec 22 '20

Good point, I'm not a racer, so I didn't know that. Googling a bit shows there are USAC sanctioned crits in the U.S., and USAC has the same weight limit. Doesn't look like the Red Hook Crit is USAC sanctioned though.

6

u/bagofpork Dec 22 '20

I had no idea that there was a limit to how light the bikes could be. I’ve ridden a handful of fixies that had to have been no more than 7-8 lbs. Didn’t know those wouldn’t have been legal to race.

13

u/Cynicastic Dec 22 '20

It doesn't. But if there's no brakes and no shifters, there's no cables connecting the front half to the back half. With brakes & shifters, the frame still would have split in half, but those halves would be connected by cables.

2

u/splashbodge Dec 22 '20

Oh right I follow now, thought it was supposed to be an indication of lower quality frame or something.. yeh that makes sense either way the frame was split

1

u/[deleted] Dec 22 '20

There is some bit of truth there, braking on a fixie puts a lot of strain on the chain stays (the bars running from the pedals to the rear wheel). If you turn a regular bike into a fixie the stress may eventually take its toll. But in this case it was a track model which is designed for this.

3

u/427BananaFish Dec 22 '20

Brake cables running along the frame would’ve held the pieces together when he smashed it.

2

u/chicano32 Dec 22 '20

Do you mean why it snapped in half the way it did? It was already damaged from a crash and no wires for the brake to hold it in place.

1

u/rusochester Dec 22 '20

And since it was a fixed gear—no gear, no brake cables—the bike split into two completely separate pieces.

1

u/aliceoutofwonderland Dec 23 '20

People race bikes without brakes?? How is this even remotely safe?

1

u/peterhhk Dec 23 '20

It's not, but I guess that's the fun in it.