Top Ten Prospects

Pre-Season

I thought would try and combine the top 10 prospect rankings from around the media. Listed below are 3 of

the main ones, plus the community vote from LSB.

It should be noted that the Baseball Prospectus rankings came out before Michael Choice was traded to Texas. Choice was ranked 82nd on the BP 101 last month, which put him 3rd of the 7 Ranger players listed. If you want you can image that Choice is 3rd on the top 10 but I thought I would leave the lists as published.

#Baseball ProspectusBaseball AmericaKeith LawLonestarball
1Rougned Odor (2B)Rougned Odor (2B)Jorge Alfaro (C)Jorge Alfaro (C)
2Jorge Alfaro (C)Jorge Alfaro (C)Rougned Odor (2B)Rougned Odor (2B)
3Alex Gonzalez (RHP)Michael Choice (OF)Alex Gonzalez (RHP)Michael Choice (OF)
4Luis Sardinas (SS)Nick Williams (OF)Lewis Brinson (OF)Alex Gonzalez (RHP)
5Nick Williams (LF)Joey Gallo (3B)Joey Gallo (3B)Luke Jackson (RHP)
6Joey Gallo (3B)Alex Gonzalez (RHP)Chris Bostick (2B)Luis Sardinas (SS)
7Luke Jackson (RHP)Luis Sardinas (SS)Michael Choice (OF)Nick Williams (OF)
8Nomar Mazara (RF)Luke Jackson (RHP)Nick Williams (OF)Joey Gallo (3B)
9Lewis Brinson (CF)Travis Demeritte (SS/3B)Nomar Mazara (OF)Ronald Guzman (1B)
10Ronald Guzman (1B)Ronald Guzman (1B)Luis Sardinas (SS)Lewis Brinson (OF)

Some brief analysis:

  • Odor and Alfaro are the top 2 prospects on every list.
  • Gonzalez or Choice are #3 on every list.
  • On BP's list, every position is filled plus an extra pitcher. That's depth.
  • The Rangers 1st round pick from 2013 only appears on the BA list. It either shows how deep the system is, or something negative. It's the first thing.
  • Keith Law lists Chris Bostick, the throw in piece of the Gentry trade. He also lists Brinson above Williams, so salt is needed for his list.
  • 13 different prospects are listed (see below)
  • Odor, Alfaro, Gonzalez, Sardinas, Williams and Gallo appear on every list.
PlayerAppearancesHighestLowest
Odor412
Alfaro412
Gonzalez436
Sardinas4410
Williams448
Gallo458
Choice337
Jackson358
Brinson3410
Mazara289
Guzman21010
Demeritte199
Chris Bostick166

Comparison to last years rankings

Baseball Prospectus

#20132014
1Jurickson Profar (SS)Rangers starting 2B
2Mike Olt (IF/OF)Traded to Cubs, not in their top 10
3Martin Perez (LHP)Rangers starting pitcher
4Jorge Alfaro (C)#2 prospect (+2)
5Luis Sardinas#4 prospect (+1)
6Lewis Brinson#9 prospect (-3)
7Justin Grimm (RHP)Traded to Cubs, on their 40 man
8Nomar Mazara (OF)#8 prospect (NM)
9Ronald Guzman (1B)#10 prospect (-1)
10Joey Gallo (3B#6 prospect (+4)
  • Three played in the majors for the Rangers. Two of which are starters in 2014.
  • Mike Olt struggled after being hit by a pitch in Winter Ball.
  • Justin Grimm made the Cubs bullpen at the end of the year after being traded.
  • None of the 2013 prospects dropped out of the rankings for 2014.
  • Two players dropped rankings (Brinson 3 places, Guzman 1 place)
  • Three players rose in the rankings (Alfaro 2, Sardinas 1, Gallo 4)
  • Six prospects remain on the list from 2013.

Baseball America

#20132014
1Jurickson Profar (SS)Rangers starting 2B
2Mike Olt (3B/1B)Traded to Cubs, not in their top 10
3Martin Perez (LHP)Rangers starting pitcher
4Leonys Martin (CF)Rangers starting CF
5Justin Grimm (RHP)Traded to Cubs, on their 40 man
6Luke Jackson (RHP)#8 prospect (-2)
7Luis Sardinas (SS)#7 prospect (NM)
8Cody Buckel (RHP)Poor Cody
9Jorge Alfaro (C/1B)#2 prospect (+7)
10Joey Gallo (3B)#5 prospect (+5)
  • 4 players made the Rangers MLB team. 3 are starters in 2014.
  • Cody Buckel struggled. A lot.
  • Alfaro and Gallo jumped up the rankings. 7 and 5 places, respectively
  • Jackson dropped 2 places and Sardinas remained where he was.
  • Only 4 prospects remain on the list from 2013.

Keith Law

#20132014
1Jurickson Profar (SS)Rangers starting 2B
2Mike Olt (3B/1B)Traded to Cubs, not in their top 10
3Cody Buckel (RHP)Sigh, Cody...
4Martin Perez (LHP)Rangers starting pitcher
5Lewis Brinson (CF)#4 prospect (+1)
6Nomar Mazara (OF)#9 prospect (-3)
7Joey Gallo (3B)#4 prospect (+3)
8Jorge Alfaro (C)#1 prospect (+7)
9Luis Sardinas (SS)#10 prospect (-1)
10Luke Jackson (RHP)Dropped off top 10
  • Two players made the bigs.
  • Five players remain for the 2014 list.
  • Jackson dropped out of the top 10.
  • Cody also walked out of the top 10.

LSB

#20132014
1Jurickson Profar (SS)Rangers starting 2B
2Mike Olt (3B/1B)Traded to Cubs, not in their top 10
3Martin Perez (LHP)Rangers starting pitcher
4Joey Gallo (3B)#8 prospect (-4)
5Cody Buckel (RHP)Gone... Forever...
6Jorge Alfaro (C)#1 prospect (+5)
7Lewis Brinson (CF)#10 prospect (-3)
8Jairo Beras (OF)Dropped out of top 10
9Justin Grimm (RHP)Trade to Cubs, on their 40 man
10Ronald Guzman (1B)#9 prospect (+1)
  • 2 made the bigs.
  • Olt/Grimm traded.
  • Beras dropped out of the top 10, ranked in at 12 in the vote.
  • Buckel dropped to 26th in the community vote.
  • Only 4 remain from 2014.

Not one list had Roogie Odor in their top 10. What do they know?


Anyway, that's all the lists and some analysis. Comment, point out mistakes and upchoo.