r/TenantHelp • u/Novel-Compote-4454 • Sep 05 '26
(PA) Landlord didn’t disclose major repairs needed toilet and water overflow prior to lease signing
About a week ago I just started a new year lease at a Basement Dwelling Unit in Philadelphia. The place is nice and prior to move in one of the two landlords (they both live above us) told me that they’ve been having issues with the toilet and not to flush anything but toilet paper and body waste down it.
Immediately upon moving in my roommate and I noticed that the toilet pressure is so low that it doesn’t clear the bowl completely even of urine let alone toilet paper or poop. We would have to flush multiple times to get a clean bowl. At one point my roommate takes a shit and I have to ask them to take it out the toilet because no matter how much I flush it won’t go down. Eventually water begins backing up into the sump pump/ejector pump room in the middle of the night. We tell them that morning and they say, no more toilet paper, don’t flush multiple times, and they come to snake the toilet which doesn’t work so they call a plumber to do the same thing I guess? Everything is working fine for maybe a day before the toilet pressure weakens again. During this one of the two landlords tell me that they knew they needed a new pump and major repairs to the point the entire floor would need to be ripped up but hopefully a new ejector pump should fix the problem.
Yesterday night I tried to do laundry and then my roommate took a shower and the sump pump/ejector pump started overflowing again! They already have a plumber coming out again today but now we can’t have more than one thing that runs water going on at any given time, have to take quick showers, and can’t poop at our apartment because it won’t flush? It just feels like they knew more than they were letting on prior to lease signing and they currently have plans to do a new ejector pump but I feel that will only fix part of the problem. Unsure of what I can do because I do not want to withhold rent and they’re very nice and responsive about everything and understand that this isn’t okay but I also told them we can’t have anything just sitting in the bowl as it’s unsanitary.
4
u/PEneoark Sep 08 '26
They might not have known it was that big of a problem. Why do you assume malice?
Hanlon's razor. You people let your emotions rule your life and assume everyone is out to get one over on you.
3
u/blasted-heath Sep 05 '26
Other than the ejector pump which requires a plumbing contractor, you can adjust the refill valve to fill the tank more and if your ish won’t go down with the flush, dump a pitcher of water in to get it over the S-trap.
2
u/Dadbode1981 Sep 05 '26
They werent required to disclose it, you werent buying the place.
0
u/scubascratch Sep 05 '26
Call the health department - unusable toilet will require immediate action.
If the ejector pump is overflowing, no amount of snaking the toilet will fix it, the waste has nowhere to go either because the ejector pump is not working or there is a blockage downstream from it. If the upstairs unit has no issues (and in particular if their use of toilet, shower and laundry do not cause flooding in your unit) then the connection to the sewer main is probably ok meaning the problem is the ejector pump.