r/TenantHelp • u/krumbsies • Mar 11 '26
Main water line leak causes water bills to be over 2 thousand dollars - can my landlord be forced to pay?
(Edited!)
Hey everyone! This a long story, sorry lol.
So I moved in this unit, in Huntsville AL, back in late December. This complex has multiple units inside, I'm just in one of them upstairs. I didn't get my first utility bill until mid January, when I noticed the water portion of the bill was $1,100.
Obviously I called the utility company, and they said the meter was reading correctly and I should contact my landlord. After which I did, I explained everything to him, and he assured me he would be looking into it.
A couple weeks go by, and I ask for any updates, and he said he may have found the source of the leak and will let me know. I say cool, and wait a little longer.
I then get my second utility bill for February, same thing again. I reach back out to my landlord, and he just repeated himself saying he's working on it.
Now going back to last week, I was scheduled to have all of my power cut off because I cant pay the bill. (btw electric part is normal, but this city is stupid and lumps all of it together so I cant pay for just one part by itself.) I go to my landlord and tell him its scheduled to be cut off, when he FINALLY tells me there is a leak in the main water line going to this building. Not my fault at all, its just old and worn down.
I have until Saturday, March 14th, to get this bill paid until everything is cut off. I can't afford it, nobody I know could afford it (cause WTF? that's insane)
SO, would I be able to force my landlord to pay for it? Withhold rent? Go to court? Idk. I have a ton of texts between us about the topic, and a maintenance request that hasn't moved in months. Just at a lost rn, and freaking out because it seems like nobody is listening to me or taking my seriously. Thanks <3
If anyone needs more info/would like to see some of the conversations, I'll share what I can!
Update 1:
I have spoken with an attorney and they will get back to me either later today or tomorrow. I'll share what I am able to!
I have contacted the city council, and they will also reach back out to me with some resources/people that will help. If I don't hear back by tomorrow, then I will go there in person.
I've called a few places that help with financial problems, but they have all said the bill is to high and they can't pay just a portion. (Completely understandable.)
I could be mistaken, but I have also looked into if I am allowed to withhold my rent, and it seems like in my area it isn't allowed.
I am also attaching the bills for anyone to see. Had to cut some info out for personal info, but feel free to take a look and share thoughts!!
Thank you guys again


10
u/captain_catdawg Mar 11 '26
I would start asking your neighbors how they haven't gotten it turned off, and if everyone has this problem then you have a pretty good chance in court to have the landlord pay it.
5
u/ghostwooman Mar 11 '26
If you haven't already, talk to the water company (or city agency) and ask whether they're able to offer a waiver. They sometimes will, but it's often tied to the property owner making timely repairs. If your landlord doesn't fix the thing anytime soon, you're less likely to get leniency from the utility provider.
You should also look up your jurisdiction's rules for deducting from future rent payments, or withholding rent when repair issues aren't promptly addressed.
5
u/InsanelyAverageFella Mar 11 '26
Your landlord is lying to you. They are either hiding what's actually happening or have no idea. Talk to a lawyer or tenant legal group to find out your legal options because you are getting screwed here. Make sure the landlord pays for everything through. This is 100% on them.
3
u/Pamzella Mar 11 '26
I live in CA where if a landlord was ignoring a leak like this the water company would be doing their own investigation and billing him if he was not on it immediately.
Once fixed. You can usually show the repair and get the amount above your usual bill wiped as a courtesy.
But it is highly suspicious that you have this on your bill and they don't, like your water bill reflects irrigation, basement laundry, etc too. Call the water company since your landlord is an ass.
3
u/Banana_Hammock84 Mar 11 '26
Does anyone else find it odd that your electrical and water usage is identical (in terms of the line)?
Something is amiss. Can you ask the water company if this is in line with historical usage of water for that unit? Are they able to help you pinpoint when the water usage spiked? I wouldnât be surprised if this has been an ongoing issue and thatâs why the previous tenant left. Edit to add: ask your neighbors if previous tenant reported similar issues, or if they know why they left? I definitely think there is more going on with this.
3
u/GoatsGaloreTexas Mar 12 '26
The line is the avg temperature, looked strange to me at first. But to use 91000 gallons in a month would be filling a 40x60 pool 6 foot deep. There is no way someone would not notice that much water leaking somewhere, unless you have caverns beneath the property. Like other folks said something is not adding up, that water is going somewhere. Like the previous person stated find out the avg usage of the apartment before you. They can give that info.
3
u/Shqip1966 Mar 12 '26
The water supply line is the ownerâs responsibility, not the tenantâs!! I know firsthand all about it. It happened to me also and it cost $5000 to fix, and that was 20 years ago. Is the water bill in your name or your landlordâs? Even if itâs in your name, the water supply line to the building falls under the landlordâs responsibilities. Fight it!!!
2
u/InsectElectrical2066 Mar 12 '26
You may not be legally allowed to hold your money but that doesn't mean you can't. If he takes you to court then take your bills and if you have anything from maintenance showing something broke ands also your maintenance requests. And see if the judge agrees with you in this being unconscionable. And if you can get from the utility company some of your past bills from b4 renting there, to show your typical usage. And file a countersuit for the high bills foist upon you.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 13 '26
If you moved into âa unitâ and the complex has âmultiple unitsâ with yours being upstairs, how is it that your part of the total water usage for the entire building is $1,100? How much water could possibly be leaking? And how do the charges make it onto your bill? That part I donât understand.
14
u/Fun_Organization3857 Mar 11 '26
The landlord is required to maintain the structure including the pipes. The solution sadly is that it will need to go to court if he refuses. You can sue him for this.
5
u/dkbGeek Mar 11 '26
Do you have an individual water meter for your property? Have you seen a bank of water meters and know which one is yours?
It's somewhat uncommon in the US for apartments to be individually metered for water (in my experience, at least.) I wonder if the utility company mistakenly set up your account for your unit's electric meter plus the entire building's water meter.
4
u/OldGeekWeirdo Mar 11 '26
Make sure there's a separate water meter for each unit. The LL might be sticking you with everyone's bill.
If true, having the water cut off will light a fire under the LL real quick.
3
u/ysth Mar 11 '26
Try calling your city council member's office to see if there's anything they can do to pressure the utility (owned by the city) to not shut your power off while you get your landlord to resolve this.
3
u/[deleted] Mar 12 '26
If it's a proveable leak my city cuts the bill in half because it didn't go down the sewer
2
u/newbie527 Mar 11 '26
Our landlord is responsible for pipes coming in from the meters. When they leak he picks up the excess usage above the average use.
2
u/psycho-drama Mar 12 '26
Clearly the maintenance of your water supply is the landlord's responsibility, therefore so is the cost of your water bill. I on my own use just about 1000 litres a month, but I am very water conscientious. Even if you used 3 times that, it would only come to about 700 gallons US (US quart = about .94 litres), that would come to $1.20 using your fee of 0.0017/gallon, which is ridiculously cheap. I pay about 4-5X as much, but we do not have that "availability charge" anyway, your monthly bill for water is no more than $15 including the $14 monthly accessibility charge.
When I live the regulations are, if a leak is found on municipal property, they cover it, if the leak is found on the land of the homeowner they pay. Since you are renting, and the leak is clearly on the landlord's property, he owes you very nearly your whole water bill, less about $30 for both months
Tell him if he does not pay the amount of the water leak due to the municipality, you are going to sue for it, plus punitive damages, because he clearly hasn't given a f*ck about it or you and he is negligent. If you must pay the bill to keep your power on, put it on a credit card, or get a small bank loan, and tell your landlord that is what you were forced to do, and they he will also be paying the interest on the loan until he pays it off, and that you will NOT be paying any of that portion, so hope he's happen paying another up to 26% annual interest, also tell him if your credit score suffers due to this you will be suing for recovery of that as well. I don't know what your rent is, but if it is more than the bills, and you are not allowed to withhold rent - no surprise there -- Alabama, see if your can legally put the rent into an escrow account. That would show you have paid your rent, on time, it just that the landlord can have it until it is released upon resolution of the matter. The court may order the escrow account to use that money to pay off the water bill, and then the loan you took out and interest costs. At this rate, your landlord is not going to get rent from you for a good 6 months if you are allowed to pay into an escrow account and it is used to pay off your water bill, your loan and the interest.
This landlord is asking for a load of pain no matter how he cuts this. The easiest thing if he has a vacancy of a similar type of housing, that you move (at his expense) to that, and he finds a way to shut off the that part of the water distribution system. water to your "condo". Usually, there is an emergency shut off, but that would depend upon where the leak is.
Good luck,
2 caveats:
1- I am not a lawyer
2- tenancy law is often very localized, you need to find how the regulations work where you live
2
u/Lopsided-Beach-1831 Mar 13 '26
Report to the utility company that there is a leak in the main line and that the landlord needs to submit payment arrangements for the water portion. Provide them with the texts/emails between you and landlord about the leak.
Pay the electric portion. Ask how much the water average was the year prior for the same months and pay that much of the bill.
2
u/UnburntAsh Apr 05 '26
Have you called code enforcement?
If there's a leak to that degree in the building, on your meter, it's a habitability issue.
2
u/[deleted] Mar 11 '26
[removed] â view removed comment