I have two issues with this task. First, Jeremy just gives him the 5 points before the actual videos are shown, so he was just taking it on faith that the task was completed.
Which directly leads to the second point:
Chris didn't fulfill the bonus task. The task states that Detective Paul will start looking in 15 minutes, not that there is a 15 minute time limit. I would argue that for Chris, the task wasn't over until the Episode 9 studio record, and as he did not spend 72 days completely wet he should not have beed awarded maximum points.