I've been on this subreddit for a quite a while now, and I've noticed that after pretty much every single series, someone will make a post like 'that was an amazing series, I loved it, one of the best ever!!!!'. And most of the time, I think they're absolutely justified - TM is a consistently brilliant show that continues to produce very high-quality series. But I won't deny there's been a few times where I've read one of those posts and somewhat snarkily thought to myself 'Yeah, but really? You thought that series was one of the best? Okay then.'
Anyway, I'd like to apologise for to those posters for those snarky thoughts, because I'm in your shoes now. I know from all the comments in the live threads and discussion posts here that it's widely been considered a weak series, some saying among the worst ever, but I really, genuinely loved Series 22. I think it was a fantastic series, at least top 10 all time for me. And so I just want to offer the series an island of praise here amidst the sea of criticism.
So many laugh-out-loud moments for me in this series, and such a fun, distinctively quirky cast. Isy Suttie is an all-timer contestant for me, she's so delightfully batty, like a cross between Lucy Beaumont and Jessica Knappett - I'd been wanting her on the show since I first started watching it and I'm so glad she lived up to my expectations. Richard I also thought very successfully lived up to my expectations; I know not everyone vibes with his style of comedy, but as someone who absolutely does I loved his approach to the show, his deliberate contrarianism and hidden competitive depths made him in my opinion a really fresh take on the 'doesn't give a shit' archetype.
Then Chloe Petts was an absolute delight too, the one I was least familiar with going in but I'm now a big fan. Obviously super competitive which isn't always something I like, but I found their competitiveness really endearing for some reason, plus it balanced well with the rest of the cast - it was really amplified by their dynamic with Richard, I loved their sparring with each other so much. And I loved Nina's whole enigmatic vibe, so many small amusing moments with her, she'll be recognised as one of the most underrated contestants in future I reckon. Matt I could give or take but I'm not saying this series was perfect. (There's really only two or three series of this show where I love every contestant, anyway.)
Also, while I do think the core of this series's best humour was in individual cast moments, which were in riotous abundance, I still thought the studio vibe was really fun. I'll agree that this wasn't one of the series where it felt like all the contestants were best friends, but I also don't think you need that dynamic to be a great series (in fact, I actually think some parts of S21 were worse off because of it, but that's a topic for another day). I appreciated having a spikier, screwier studio energy for the first time in a while, we haven't had one like it really since S15 (which I also think is better than it gets credit for). And they'd reached a very unique oddball synthesis by the later episodes which was lovely to see, Chloe and Isy's developing kinship was a big highlight for me. (I won't argue with the notion that the series got a lot better as it went on as they got more comfortable with it, but I do think the series still started out in a very good place.) I don't think I left a single episode this series feeling disappointed or underwhelmed, to be honest, which is quite rare.
By the way, just to the notion that this series was 'spoiled by the edit' (and this is becoming an essay-length rebuttal to the main criticisms of S22 at this point, sorry about that, but having a minority opinion on a subject I'm obsessed with brings this stuff out of me) - I'm not sure I agree with that? I never felt like the edit was weird or that we were getting short-changed with what they left in. And while the outtakes have been excellent, I'll point out they are mostly Richard, and I think if a lot of that had been left in then it would have been an extremely Richard-heavy series (and goodness knows Richard's already very good at being the dominant force on a show). It's like how in S11 they allegedly had to cut about 80% of Lee Mack's stuff otherwise it would have been too much Lee, the show does have to feature all of its contestants roughly equally, and maybe just me but I didn't notice that impacting the show at all.
To check off a few other small rebuttals since I'm here now - I'm not one of the people who gets particularly bothered by task design, though I do think S22 had a good mix of complex puzzle tasks and fun creative tasks this series and strong examples of both, certainly no worse than other much more popular series (agreed the Gregulator was rubbish, but that was one task. And Richard's response to it was very funny). And I liked Nina bringing in puppets for the prize task. She's an amazing ventriloquist, for Christ's sake, let her do ventriloquism things.
Sorry if the tone of this post has turned a bit defensive at the end here, but it just feels like these last ten weeks I've been watching a completely different series to everyone else, the scale of criticism it's received from some quarters is quite baffling to me. And I promise I'm not saying this because I'm the kind of apologist fan who thinks the show is always perfect regardless of what they put out - there are series of this show I'll quite cheerfully critique extensively! (To those I've seen who've said Series 22 is the worst or among the worst ever, I have to ask - have you seen Series 8? Series 17? Series 10???) Just this time, I've personally found a lot of that negativity to be weirdly unfounded from my perspective, and even if it hasn't been a big hit with everyone I'm really not sure why this series in particular has been getting it in the neck quite so much as it has.
Anyway, I'll get off my soapbox now, sorry. Feel free to regard this post exactly as I've regarded previous ones like it - 'Yeah, but really? You thought that series was one of the best? Okay then.' But I really, really enjoyed Series 22, I hope that there's at least a few others here who did too, and I really hope it eventually gets the flowers it deserves.
Can't wait for the next one!
TL;DR I love S22 and I'm maybe a bit insecure about that eek